A Quiet Place Part II Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs

A solid, if flawed, sequel.

A Quiet Place Part II Emily Blunt
Paramount

A year after it was originally due to release in cinemas, A Quiet Place Part II is finally here, and with its early U.S. box office smashing pandemic-era records, there's hope that it will help usher in a more prosperous second half for 2021 at the movies.

On its own merits John Krasinski's hotly anticipated horror sequel is a rock solid if perhaps slightly underwhelming sequel - beautifully crafted, well-acted, and yet a little empty. An efficient, technically sharp follow-up that ultimately feels like a fairly unimaginative retread.

That said, the film has largely racked up positive reviews from critics, and while it doesn't get close to replicating the gut-wrenching ingenuity of the original, it's likely to leave most fans of the first film satisfied, as long as their expectations are set appropriately.

Is it a masterful sequel for the ages? Not a chance, but it does just enough to expand the world of the original while effectively giving fans more of what they liked the first time.

Above all else, director Krasinski proves he's sure to be a majorly in-demand genre filmmaker when his work on this series is over - because, yes, A Quiet Place Part III is inevitably already in the works...


Downs...

4. It's A Surprisingly Unadventurous Sequel

A Quiet Place Part II Emily Blunt
Paramount

Despite being given a budget more than three-times the original's $17 million, it's a little disappointing just how much A Quiet Place Part II is simply a "more of the same" sequel.

Yes, the scale is given a modest expansion and it's a more technically proficient film overall, but it refuses to do what truly great sequels do, and that's flip the script or change the game in a way that's both surprising and serves the characters.

This is basically another 90 minutes of the Abbotts being put through the wringer as they try to silently fend off an impossibly powerful enemy, complete with the requisite questionable character decisions.

To that end it feels more like an unassuming addendum to the original than an outright sequel.

Not every sequel needs to be bigger, but given the resources afforded to Krasinski, it's surprising how inessential and low-key this one feels despite its many strengths.


3. Djimon Hounsou & Scoot McNairy Are Totally Wasted

A Quiet Place Part II Djimon Hounsou
Paramount

As refreshing as the film's breathless runtime is, the flipside is that it doesn't allow much room for the film's peripheral characters to be developed or, well, do much at all.

By far the biggest casualty is Djimon Hounsou, who plays an unnamed survivor that ends up crossing paths with Cillian Murphy's Emmett.

Hounsou is an actor of such gravitas that his presence implied a beefy supporting role, but his character is mostly just around to exposit in what's really more of an extended cameo.

Scoot McNairy also shows up for a single, brief scene in a role that shan't be spoiled, but considering the actor's talents, it's frustrating to see him come and go without really doing much of anything at all.

There's little doubt that Krasinski had actors falling over themselves wanting to appear in the sequel, but it might've been worth adding a few more minutes to the runtime in order to make these two performers actually feel well utilised.


2. The Disappointingly Thin Script

A Quiet Place Part II Emily Blunt
Paramount

By far the single biggest disappointment is the film's strangely piecemeal script, which reduces plot and character to mere bullet points while giving preference to a relentless string of suspense set-pieces, which while well-crafted aren't often informed by anything interesting below the surface.

It doesn't help that, like the first film, character logic is flaky at best, and you'll likely often find yourself questioning why these characters, even the children, are doing the things they're doing.

Suspension of disbelief is a given, though there are a few dubious plot points which feel excessively contrived in order to nudge the characters along to the next action sequence.

While Krasinski co-wrote the original film with Bryan Woods and Scott Beck, this time he went solo, and the excess of signposted setups and payoffs throughout suggest a writer who benefits from having another voice in the room.


1. Not Enough Emily Blunt

A Quiet Place Part II Emily Blunt.jpg
Paramount

After John Krasinski's Lee Abbott met an untimely fate at the end of the first film, it seemed natural that the sequel would see Emily Blunt's Evelyn become the focal point, as a mother fiercely fighting to protect her children.

And while this is true for the movie's opening passages, Blunt ends up a strangely lacking presence in her own movie.

This isn't the spoiler you might think it is, but Blunt ultimately sits out a massive chunk of the second half, kept off-screen while the focus shifts to other characters.

This speaks to the wider frustrations of the film's fragmented storytelling structure, separating Evelyn from her daughter Regan (Millicent Simmonds) and son Marcus (Noah Jupe) for so much of the story, such that for large chunks of it Evelyn's got very little to do.

In the end Emmett feels as much of a protagonist as Evelyn does, which may disappoint those understandably expecting the story to focus tightly on Evelyn's journey.

These gripes aside, though, A Quiet Place Part II does enough to please most fans of the original. Here's everything it gets right...


Ups...

6. The EXCELLENT Prologue Sequence

A Quiet Place Part II John Krasinski.jpg
Paramount

By far the strongest part of the movie is its chilling prologue sequence, which depicts the events of "day one" when the alien invasion suddenly kicked off without warning.

Though we know what's coming, the scene is a mini-masterpiece of filmmaking craft - a deliriously thrilling short film which compellingly conveys the chaos of that day while still retaining a sense of mystery.

This is the single sequence in the film that feels like it truly benefits from the expanded budget, with its horrifying depiction of a small town being violently savaged by the monstrous creatures.

The scene alone confirms Krasinski's confidence behind the camera as an action director, and it's a shame the film never gets close to this level of pulse-racing kineticism again - even though, as a "prequel" scene, we know that the central characters are all safe.


5. The Intricate, Immersive Sound Design

A Quiet Place Part II Millicent Simmonds
Paramount

A Quiet Place Part II is certainly a worthy film for those planning their first visit back to the cinema in many months, if only for its expert sound design.

Much like the Oscar-nominated sound work on the original film, the sequel's aural landscape is ingeniously engineered, making the most of even the faintest sound to generate tension.

The sound mix truly comes alive, though, during the thunderous attack sequences, with the monsters' ear-splitting screeches sure to leave audiences with sweaty palms.

Though the theatrical window is shrinking, and Paramount has already announced that A Quiet Place Part II will be available on their Paramount+ streaming service within 45 days of its theatrical release, this is definitely a film worth watching with the biggest, bassiest sound system you can find.


4. Cillian Murphy & Millicent Simmonds' Strong Performances

A Quiet Place Part II Cillian Murphy
Paramount

Though the entire ensemble delivers solid work here, the easy highlights are the performances of Cillian Murphy and Millicent Simmonds.

As rugged, world-weary survivor Emmett, Murphy is an outstanding addition to the franchise, a sympathetic and yet ambiguous man who effectively becomes the stand-in for Krasinski's Lee - enough that you can almost suspect Krasinski regrets killing his own character off.

Murphy ends up carrying at least as much of the movie as Blunt, and he benefits from often playing opposite the again-brilliant Simmonds, whose deaf daughter character Regan remains the soul of the series.

Without their fine work the relatively thin premise wouldn't be nearly as engrossing.


3. John Krasinski's Tight, Tense Direction

A Quiet Place Part II Emily Blunt
Paramount

Even in the film's least-interesting moments, it's tough to argue with John Krasinski's work behind the camera.

Aided by skilled cinematographer Polly Morgan, Krasinski wrings every drop of suspense from the various perilous scenarios he envisions for the characters, confirming his genre debut was no fluke at all.

Beyond that, Krasinski also confirms himself a fine actors' director, particularly with how skillfully he directs Murphy and Simmonds during scenes of downtime away from the action.

It's fair to assume that Krasinski will be back to helm A Quiet Place Part III, after which it'll be interesting to see the further direction of his career.

It wouldn't be surprising at all if the Marvel Cinematic Universe came a-knocking in the near-future, because he's proven beyond any doubt that he can handle the pressures of a mid-budget project.


2. The Sharp Pacing & Snappy Editing

A Quiet Place Part II Emily Blunt
Paramount

At just 97 minutes in length, this is a film that moves fast and doesn't let up for its entirety. While this does mean that the film occasionally feels a little too hurried for its own good, it mostly means that the film retains a lean form and gets to the point with maximum efficiency.

Aided by Ryan Coogler's regular editor Michael P. Shawver, Krasinski cleaves almost all excess fat away to ensure that his sequel is a snappy ride from start to finish.

Though it's a reasonable complaint that A Quiet Place Part II doesn't really expand the series' scale much despite its far larger budget, the flip-side is that it also doesn't saddle itself with the baggage that so many ambitious, expansive sequels also do. It's swings and roundabouts.

The ending may feel slightly abrupt when it speedily arrives, but that's only because Krasinski always keeps things moving from one point to the next throughout, never sticking in one spot for too long or making the audience notice the passage of time.


1. It Sets Up An Intriguing Sequel

Quiet Place 2
Paramount Pictures

It isn't much of a spoiler at all to say that the film lays the groundwork for an inevitable threequel, which per the film's already-spectacular box office haul is now-guaranteed.

While A Quiet Place II doesn't substantially shake up the formula in any major way, it does point to an interesting throughline for the third film, ensuring it can hit the ground running with a clear purpose and hopefully wrap up a solid trilogy of movies.

There are of course no guarantees as to what Krasinski will do with the sequel, but the implication here seems self-evident - there's a clear dramatic goal moving forward, and one which should be achievable within a tight, 90-minute, trilogy-capping sequel.

While there's no date set for A Quiet Place Part III yet, given how quickly this film materialised - even with pandemic-related delays - 2023 or 2024 seems incredibly likely. Bring it on.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.