After Earth: 5 Possible Twists For M. Night Shyamalan
One of this Summer's most secretive blockbusters of this year is none other than the Will/Jaden Smith Sci-Fi/Action vehicle, After Earth. However, it's secretive in a way that is at once surprising and clearly logical. After Earth's secret, at least when it comes to how the movie is being sold, is that it's directed by none other than Crap Auteur Extraordinaire M. Night Shyamalan. That's right kids, just when you thought it was safe to go back to the Multiplex, everyone's (least) favorite Hitchcock wanna-be is gracing our screens once more. And what Shyamalan film wouldn't be complete without...THE TWIST! Go ahead and watch the trailers again with that knowledge, and try to refute the possibility that somewhere in the trailer is "clever" misdirection leading us all to think one thing, only to twist it into something else by the end of the film.... So taking a page from Douglas Reynholm's movie watching playbook, let's guess the twist to the predestined Razzie Award nominee, After Earth!
5. Kitai Is Dreaming The Whole Thing
The Theory: We'll start with the most obvious twist theory, one that is so engrained in the moviegoer's mind that it's practically a joke when its mentioned. But let's think this through: Kitai engages in a life or death quest on the harsh planet of Earth, with creatures that have evolved to kill...US! Ultimately (most likely) he'll be saving the day and reuniting with his father. Or will he? Supporting Evidence: Judging by how harsh that crash landing was, and the fact that Oxygen masks were required for safe passage, it's a decent bet that this whole thing could be a Jacob's Ladder scenario. A harrowing crash, crossed with lack of oxygen and probably a healthy dose of shock, could lead to Kitai lingering on the knowledge he happens to have of Earth. This fuels his delusion, and in the end we find that he's merely been out of commission the whole adventure, ready to be saved by Cypher. He has a realization that he has what it takes to survive, but he'll need his training to hone those skills, blah blah blah. Roll credits and throw you drink at the screen.
4 . It's A Simulated Mission, Designed To Test Kitai's Skills
The Theory: Kitai is a brash, bold, and cocky cadet; gunning for a spot among the Rangers. In the trailer, it's noted that he won't be advanced in his ambitions. (And here you thought you'd gotten enough of the "cocky ladder climber" trope from Star Trek Into Darkness.) His father, believing in his abilities but recognizing his hubris as a disability, decides to trick him into a realistic simulation of a mission filled with factors he can't control. What's more, the alien terrain and higher stakes of death just might help knock some sense into his head. Supporting Evidence: Not much to go on here, besides the fact that his father knows all of the conditions of the planet word for word and could easily manufacture a situation he can control. Not to mention, out of all of the planets in the Universe, they happen to crash land on Earth? What are the odds? Everything that can go wrong seems to in these trailers, and there's undoubtedly stuff missing from the plot that'll be in the film. This would also explain why his father is left behind on the ship, considering a crash like that means you're either "meant" to survive or you're dead.
3. It's An Historical Documentary
The Theory: So here's an unorthodox twist to take that'd legitimize the events we're watching, but would explain things a little better. So say Kitai and Cypher areon Earth, and the threat is real. They fight to survive and win, return home, and make a historical record of what they've done in order to chronicle their journey's peril and warn others who may try to make the same journey. Kitai learns through this that his selfishness helps no one, and that to be a Ranger he must not only face mortal peril, he must learn how to help others avoid it. Supporting Evidence: This might be the weakest theory, in the respect that there's not a lot to support the film will take this route. However, at the same time it's more plausible in the sense that Shyamalan (at least, to my knowing ledge) hasn't tried to pull this one over on us yet. He knows the world is sick of his "twist" film-making reputation that he decides to twist expectations in a more feasible, traditionally Sci Fi way.
2. Cypher's Been Dead The Whole Time
The Theory: Yes, it's been done. Yes, it's been done by M. Night. Yes, it's lame. But...the trailer and concept of the film have some compelling pieces of evidence that show this theory culd be an inconvenient truth for Mr. Shyamalan's latest film. So the theory goes as follows: after a rather turbulent journey that leaves the ship crash landed on Earth, Kitai starts hallucinating/fabricating his father's existence in order to make it through the journey. He faces great odds with the guidance of his father, and manifests his wisdom and knowledge in a presence that remains in the ship (which will never be recovered) in order to retrieve the emergency beacon. Cut to the end of the film, and Kitai is rescued. As he's being lifted off of the planet, the spirit of his father looks up at him, and he looks right back. Father and Son say a silent goodbye, as Kitai leaves Earth ready to become the man his family always knew he could be. Supporting Evidence: So towards the beginning of the trailer, we see Cypher and Kitai breathing through Oxygen masks, followed by Cypher being thrown across the cabin. After some quick cuts, we learn that not only one, but both ends of the ship have some off in the accident. Supposedly injured, Cypher stays on board the remains of the ship and guides Kitai through his journey. Yet, if you were injured AND on a planet of dangerous creatures that could kill you, wouldn't you want to hide somewhere a little more secure than the wreckage of a ship? Doesn't make sense, unless of course you're a spirit/fabrication that can't leave the last point it was living in. It's a twist that Shyamalan has used before, and with the trend of filmmakers returning to old formulas and spinning them into sometimes slightly newer stories, don't expect M. Night to be immune to a quick story-making shortcut.
1. There Is No Twist
The Theory: Exactly as it says in the headline. No surprises lie ahead, just a good old fashioned trek through an alien land that makes a boy a man, earns him the respect of his father, and the chagrin of the audience for sitting through it all at $11 a pop. (Audience, please adjust accordingly for IMAX screenings and international markets. Your outrage may vary.) Out of all the hunches, I've saved this one for last. It packs the most punch, because the biggest twist you could find in an M. Night Shyamalan film is that there is NO twist. The film plays as is, without any trickery, and an ultimately happy ending. Supporting Evidence: M. Night Shyamalan might have given up twist endings for good in his career. His last two films, The Happening and The Last Airbender, didn't contain a twist ending in either of their structures. Two films in a row...this could be the third that could set the pattern of non-twist reliant storytelling becoming the new normal for Shyamalan. Who knows? After Earth could be the hit making combo that takes Shyamalan out of the dregs of his career as the nadir of filmmaking and Will Smith might have a hit on his hands where his son isn't a liability. I mean, it's not bloody likely, but still...wouldn't THAT be a twist to remember? Are you planning on seeing After Earth this weekend? Did you see it already, and want to complain about the ending (or even pick an ending you like better from our stash)? Head down to the Comments section below and blow some smoke!