Aladdin Review: 4 Ups & 5 Downs

Will Smith saves Aladdin from disaster.

Aladdin Genie
Disney

Guy Ritchie's Aladdin hits cinemas worldwide this week, and if the film's rather dubious set of trailers weren't discouraging enough, Disney opted to hold all reviews until the very day it was released in the UK.

To the surprise of few, this live-action adaptation of Disney's classic 1992 animation is quite the mess, with most early reviews sitting in the mixed-to-positive range so far.

It's fair to say that Ritchie's film isn't close to the catastrophic disaster that fans expected from its earlier trailers, but it's also not a particularly persuasive argument for Disney remaking all of their animated classics in live-action form.

Some solid central performances combine with an undeniable nostalgia factor to paper over some of this Aladdin's conceptual flaws, but you'll need a strong love for the source material to make it to the end with your patience in tact.

With both Dumbo and Aladdin scoring mixed notices from critics and fans alike, hopefully Jon Favreau's The Lion King might break the rule of threes later this summer...


Downs...

5. Marwan Kenzari's Jafar Is TERRIBLE

Aladdin Jafar
Disney

Easily fans' biggest complaint about Aladdin's marketing was how utterly flat and unremarkable the live-action version of villain Jafar (Marwan Kenzari) appeared to be.

And sadly, it's a shame to report that Jafar is indeed the film's single biggest failing, largely due to Kenzari being so thoroughly miscast in this role.

Though the film admirably attempts to make Jafar a more suave, handsome and even charming character - compared to being both a literal and figurative cartoon in the animated film - Kenzari's lack of screen presence and wooden line readings fail to do justice to the iconic Disney baddie.

The part desperately needed an actor with actual bass in their voice, not to mention a prevailing charisma, both of which Kenzari simply lacks.

It's more a criticism of him being cast in this role in the first place than the actor himself, but either way, this Jafar is a total misfire.


4. It's Brutally Paced

Aladdin Blue Genie
Disney

Much like 2017's live-action Beauty and the Beast, this new Aladdin touts a significantly beefed-up runtime compared to its animated predecessor, clocking in at 128 minutes and therefore almost 40 minutes longer than the original.

While this could've allowed Ritchie to amp-up the set-pieces and deepen the characterisation, much like Beauty and the Beast it simply leadens the film's pacing and makes the journey to the end credits ultimately feel like a bit of a slog.

The biggest issue is clearly the bloated first act, which takes over 40 minutes to introduce audiences to the Genie (Will Smith), and clearly could've been trimmed down some.

The distended runtime isn't ever really justified, and though live-action by its sheer nature isn't as lithe as animation, there's absolutely no way this thing needed to run past the two-hour mark.


3. The Painfully Lazy Script

Aladdin Jasmine
Disney

Guy Ritchie has always been a majorly mixed bag as a writer-director, so it's little surprise that his script here - co-written with John August (Charlie's Angels, Dark Shadows) - is all over the place.

It's no exaggeration to say that a solid two-thirds of the script is comprised of ham-fisted exposition, forcing the poor cast to try and rattle off the robotic spoon-feeding of plot with some sense of naturalism.

The audience is never given the benefit of the doubt and allowed to observe events for themselves - everything is cynically spoken aloud, and even basic, obvious character beats are needlessly verbalised to cater to the very lowest common denominator.

There are so few memorable lines in this movie, but an utter avalanche of scribbled-by-committee placeholder dialogue.


2. Guy Ritchie's Direction...Isn't Great

Aladdin 2019
Disney

If Aladdin makes anything abundantly clear, it's that Guy Ritchie is absolutely a director better-suited to lower-budget filmmaking.

Between this and his previous film, King Arthur: Legend of the Sword, he clearly struggles to have his voice heard over the machinery of a blockbuster production, making for an awkward end product.

The first act in particular feels extremely messy editing-wise, with choppily-cut action sequences and messy dialogue scenes that were blatantly cobbled together from numerous ill-fitting takes.

Much like the writing, there's really nothing memorable here direction-wise: everything gives off an extremely rote and soulless vibe, while the hit-and-miss production values occasionally evoke the feeling of an expensive panto.


1. The Wildly Inconsistent CGI

Aladdin Iago
Disney

Despite Aladdin clearly touting a colossal budget, the quality of the visual effects are ludicrously inconsistent throughout the film.

To be fair, there are moments of pure digital splendour, with the Genie's cave proving particularly impressive, but even in the middle of scenes, the fidelity of the VFX can switch from good to awful at a moment's notice.

This is no more apparent than with the Genie himself, who sometimes looks terrific, yet moments later might resemble an offputting uncanny valley Will Smith stapled to a CGI rig.

But the film's biggest offence in the effects department is unquestionably the finale, which offers up a repulsive magic carpet chase sequence full of blurry, garish effects more likely to rouse unintended laughs than genuine wonder.

And that's not to ignore a final showdown with Jafar that throws everything at the wall effects-wise, but clearly needed either more time or money to fully realise its vision.

So, Aladdin isn't great or even really that good, but it's certainly not awful - and here's everything it actually gets right...


Ups...

4. Will Smith's Genie Steals The Show

Aladdin Will Smith
Disney

Though there was plenty of pre-release hand-wringing about Will Smith's Genie, it was all pretty much for nothing, as Smith is easily the most entertaining aspect of the entire movie.

While he certainly takes a little too long to show up and he's absent from long stretches of the third act, the Genie is a charismatic force-of-nature every time he's on-screen, allowing Smith to give perhaps the most Will Smith performance that he has ever given.

Whether he's singing his heart out or frantically wise-cracking, Smith is clearly having a blast, and his enjoyment is infectious enough to make the second act of the film dangerously close to very good.

The effects could be better, for sure, but given that Smith's not exactly been cranking out the prime roles in recent years, it's great to see him pulling off some worthy, crowd-pleasing work.

And above all else, he has the good sense not to try and imitate or out-do Robin Williams' beloved Genie: his version is a very different and equally valid beast.


3. It (Mostly) Nails The Songs

Aladdin A Whole New World
Disney

For all of the film's scripted flaws, it does at least generally nail the heart and soul of the original animation's songs.

The aggressive auto-tune present in Beauty and the Beast is employed far more scarcely here, ensuring that fans can soak in the elaborate set-pieces without being distracted.

The classics are all wrought with a clear affection for the material, especially the marquee tunes "Friend Like Me" and "A Whole New World", which sprinkle just enough contemporary flavour while staying largely reverent to the originals.

Arguably the most startling musical moment here, however, is an entirely new song, the stirring solo tune "Speechless", a rip-roaring empowerment track for Princess Jasmine (Naomi Scott).

The visuals for these sequences may suffer from feeling over-produced at times, but for the most part, the signature belters retain most of their fist-pumping power.


2. Naomi Scott & Mena Massoud's Solid Lead Performances

Aladdin Jasmine
Disney

Will Smith may be the easy MVP here, but in Naomi Scott and Mena Massoud the film also finds a rock solid Jasmine and Aladdin.

Scott in particular makes for a charismatic and strong-headed Jasmine, and delivers easily the most consistently impressive vocal performance across the board.

Massoud isn't quite as assured as Aladdin, but nevertheless proves to be a convincing live-action adaptation of the animated hero, both as a fleet-footed thief and a more awkward romantic interest for Jasmine.

Admirably, the film doesn't layer on the romantic entanglement too thickly, allowing Scott and Massoud's natural chemistry to win out above a potentially contrived love story.

They certainly deserved better material, but both performers work well enough with what they've got.


1. The Modern Feminist Revisions

Aladdin Jasmine
Disney

Though Ritchie's film clings pretty closely to the animated source material, it does include one welcome tonal update for contemporary audiences.

The character of Jasmine has been afforded far more opportunities to assert her independence throughout, frequently expressing exasperation with the attention paid to her beauty rather than her intellect.

She also has more multi-faceted goals than in the animation, keen to succeed her father (Navid Negahban) as the new Sultan, a role which tradition dictates cannot be assumed by a woman.

This pays off predictably but satisfyingly at the film's climax, providing a neat, modern addendum to a near-30-year-old story.

Between these moments and Jasmine's aforementioned new solo tune - which sees her passionately pleading for her voice to be heard - the film does a fitting job of revising the character's journey for a new generation.


In this post: 
Aladdin
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.