Alien 3: What Really Happened?
It was one of the most troubled productions of all time. But what really happened to Alien 3?

Alien 3 might just be the most scrutinised film in movie history.
In the decades since the ill-fated sequel arrived in cinemas in May 1992, fans have found themselves pouring over every detail surrounding its production.
That is of course down to the fact that the film came as something of an anticlimax after 1986's Aliens, but there are a number of other factors that have contributed to Alien 3's mystique - for instance, the fact that it was one of the first films to really be picked apart on the burgeoning days of the internet and online fandom.
Whether it was creators or actors publicly airing their grievances with the project (James Cameron famously called the film a "slap in the face" to his work on Aliens), or a number of unproduced scripts making their way online, Alien 3 became a frequent topic of conversation amongst online circles in the early days of the internet, with the prospect of what could have been proving too delectable a topic for many to ignore.
In recent years, the topic has also proven irresistible to creators and publishing companies.
One early version of Alien 3, written by cyberpunk author William Gibson, was adapted into a comic and then an audiobook just the other year, with actors Michael Biehn and Lance Henriksen even reprising their roles as Corporal Hicks and the android Bishop in the latter. And, although not to the same degree, Ripley actor Sigourney Weaver also went on the record to praise a version of Alien 3 developed by Vincent Ward, which Fox of course opted not to go with.
Ultimately, what sparked all these years of discussion and reinterpretation was the fact that, in 1992, Fox released what would eventually prove to be the first of many disappointing Aliens follow-ups. Both Ridley Scott's 1979 original and James Cameron's '86 follow-up are revered as sci-fi classics, and while the franchise has failed to live up to those original two offerings since, Alien 3 was the first to kickstart that trend.
There's also the fact that it was one David Fincher's directorial debut. Fincher, who has since helmed repeat successes in the likes of Se7en, Fight Club and Zodiac, had only directed music videos when he signed on to helm Alien 3. Production on the film was notoriously tumultuous - notably chronicled in the documentary Wreckage and Rage: The Making of Alien 3 - and Fincher has since disowned the project in interviews altogether.
All these factors coalesce to create a uniquely fascinating story. But what really happened to derail the then imperious Alien franchise? And what makes those unfinished versions so much better than the film that released in 1992?
4. Alien After Aliens - Why Alien 3 Entered Development Hell

To figure out what went wrong with Alien 3 you have to go back to 1986, and the release of Aliens. Jim Cameron's 1986 sequel was a critical and box-office success, and Fox were keen to capitalise on the positive buzz surrounding the film by approaching Brandywine Productions (the other studio behind the Alien franchise) to pitch further sequels.
The initial idea was that Alien 3 and 4 would be almost like a two-parter, and that both films would shoot back-to-back, with Michael Biehn's Corporal Hicks being the main protagonist of the third film, leaving Sigourney Weaver's Ripley to return as the hero in the fourth.
But here's where things start to get a bit messy. You see, Weaver herself wasn't too excited about returning to the Alien franchise. Although Alien 3 takes the cake for studio interference, Fox were similarly invested in Aliens and reportedly removed key scenes that would've revealed more of Ripley's past. This in mind, Weaver only initially signed on for a follow-up on the condition that her role would be kept to a minimum, which later evolved into her demanding that Ripley die if she was to come back and make a third film (via Entertainment Weekly).
During this time, the studio had also attempted to lure Ridley Scott back to the franchise. But he was unable to return.
Meanwhile, Fox and Brandywine got to work on finding writers to pen the screenplay. In 1987, they approached William Gibson, whose aforementioned script went on to attain cult status.
Gibson's idea for a third Alien film was rooted in Cold War politics, and built upon the concept first thought up by Brandywine heads Walter Hill and Gordon Carroll, which aimed to reveal why the sinister Weyland-Yutani Corporation was so invested in the Xenomorphs, and would've seen the group face off against an isolated human colony governed by a Soviet-style ideology.
Fox eventually passed on Gibson's script, but not before exploring other options. A number of other treatments were written, with one penned by Eric Red pitting the Xenomorphs against space-colonists in their own town.
After Red came a script from David Twohy, who built off of Gibson's work. By this point however, Fox felt as though the end of the Cold War had made the initial pitch outdated and irrelevant, and so Twohy opted to pursue another angle, which involved a prison planet - much to the disappointment of then director Renny Harlin, who departed the project shortly after.
The next script, written by Vincent Ward, differed massively from the previous versions.The film would've seen Ripley crash land on a partially wooden satellite inhabited by monks who had all but shunned technology. Ward disembarked the project due to creative differences, but his version provided the skeleton of the plot seen in the finalised Alien 3, with Fox swapping the monastery out for a prison, and the monks for prisoners.
With Ward's departure, Hill and Carroll decided to take control of the project and fashion a new script, one that combined elements of Ward's film with Twohy's. David Fincher then came onboard, with filming commencing at the beginning of 1991 - a whopping four years after the first script had been completed - without a finished draft.
3. Production Begins... Without A Finished Script

Before Alien 3, David Fincher had no experience directing feature-length films, let alone a blockbluster sequel to one of the most iconic sci-fi franchises of all time. What he did have were a number of commercials and music videos, and he had previously worked for ILM on films such as Return of the Jedi and Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom. A clear talent, then, but one who was at that time still a relatively unknown quantity.
Fincher's skills spoke for themselves, but one does have to wonder if the reason why Fox hired the then newcomer was because they thought he'd be easy to control. After all, Fox were said to have interfered with the production of Aliens and it would stand to reason that they were willing to exercise that control yet again. Fincher, who was used to working on tight deadlines to fulfil contracts on music videos and commercials, could've been seen as the perfect candidate to abide the studio's meddling.
Of course, that never happened. Fincher came on board to a film production already in disarray. Hill and Carrol's script was incomplete, which led Fincher to re-write large swathes of the draft while the film was shooting. Indeed, there is no overstating just how large a task Fincher faced while on set, with the director having to help build everything from the sets, to the actual design of the Alien itself.
By the time filming had commenced at Pinewood in 1991, production costs on Alien 3 had already spiralled way over budget. It was the kind of climate that, when taken with Fincher's unwavering pursuit of perfection, made for the perfect storm.
Fincher wanted Alien 3 to be perfect, and that instantly put him at loggerheads with the film's producers. Vox, referencing the documentary Wreckage and Rage, which detailed Alien 3's troubled production, pointed out one particular anecdote of Fincher exploring the possibility of shooting a "thousand" takes of an exploding head, just to get the right shot. Producer Ezra Swerdlow also states in the same documentary that the studio set out to "break" Fincher in response to his opposition.
This all culminated in the studio's rejection of Fincher's three-hour cut, and even to this day, the director hasn't returned to see his original vision released.
2. "A Slap In The Face" - The Alien 3 Backlash

And thus, we come to the finished product. Alien 3 released in 1992 to a tepid response from critics, and a sizeable backlash from fans. Its reputation has only grown more divisive as the years have rolled on, with director James Cameron calling the film a "slap in the face" (via The Playlist), while others involved in the franchise have also spoken less than enthusiastically about the threequel.
In truth, for all that Alien 3 has benefitted from a burgeoning eagerness amongst fans to reappraise it in the years since its release, it could never recover from its opening sequence, which elected to not only kill off Hicks, but also the 12-year-old Newt. Yes, the Alien series had gone to dark territory before, but it felt like an especially cruel move - one that robbed Ripley and her allies of the happy ending they sorely deserved.
It mattered not that Alien 3 possessed some frankly brilliant visuals, or even that the film took the franchise in some interesting directions. That opening scene killed most of the enthusiasm from fans and laid bare the inadequacies of the film's production.
Of course, Alien 3's inability to satisfy large swathes of moviegoers, is best typified by Fincher himself. The director all but disowned the film after its release, confessing to The Guardian in 2009 that "no one hated it more" than himself.
More importantly, the effect of having so many people involved in the franchise come out and criticise the film has only encouraged the fascination regarding the lost versions of Alien 3. It would be one thing for just the fans to come out and despise it, but when you have creatives who worked on the series airing those same grievances, that anger is almost legitimised - hence the attention being paid to William Gibson's original script.
1. The Alien Sequels We DIDN'T Get - And Why We're Still Talking About Them

Of course, Alien 3 wasn't the be-all and end-all of the Alien franchise. Another frankly diabolical sequel came in 1997 with Alien: Resurrection, which was then followed up by two other dismal offerings in Alien vs Predator and its sequel, Requiem.
Things haven't been so dire for the series as of late. Prometheus, while divisive, isn't short of admirers, while 2017's Alien: Covenant was a lyrical if not occasionally frustrating prequel that further fleshed out the series' mythos. Even so, though, the scrutiny surrounding Alien 3 refuses to abet - mostly because no sequel since has managed to match Ridley Scott and James Cameron's first two respective efforts.
Those first two films have captivated audiences for decades now, and have spawned a massive multi-media franchise comprising films, comics and video games. Countless stories have been told away from the camera, and have garnered strong reviews, including James Stokoe's Aliens: Dead Orbit comic, and Alien: Isolation, which was made by Creative Assembly in 2014. All are worthy follow-ups to the original two films, and the same can be said of William Gibson's Alien 3 script, which - as I've already established - has since been adapted into a comic and an audio book.
Alien and Aliens are two of the finest sci-fi films ever released, so anything that followed them was always going to have a tough task. However, the fact remains that, because no film has equalled the 1979 classic or its sequel, Alien fans will keep pondering what could've been. And Alien 3, as the first franchise entry to break critical consensus, will continue to bear the brunt of fan frustration.
--
What are your thoughts on Alien 3? Have you listened to the William Gibson audio book? Let us know in the comments below!
Watch Next
Alien Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Franchise?