American Sniper: 9 Things The Film Lied About

Set your sights on the truth behind Hollywood's most controversial soldier

It's the film that everybody's, well, sniping about. Clint Eastwood's intensely personal journey down the scope of America's most celebrated soldier has attracted controversy almost as quickly as Academy Award nominations - some say it's the frankest insight into the personal cost of war we've seen in a generation, others that it's glorifying what amounts to little more than mass murder. Based on the best-selling memoirs of Chris Kyle, American Sniper takes you through the Navy SEAL's recruitment into the military, before showing you the grim reality of his four tours of the Iraq War, the effect it had on his relationships with his wife and family, and how it haunted him on his return home. In the wake of Kyle's death at the hands of an ex-serviceman suffering from PTSD, his legendary feats now seem destined to become enshrined in American folklore, with Eastwood's film acting as a monument to his bravery, sacrifice, and character. Like all directors though, Eastwood's first duty is to entertaining an audience, not to accurately document a man, and, under scrutiny against Kyle's own words, American Sniper leaps from the embellished to the down-right made up very quickly. Now being posthumously exalted across the world for his feats of heroism in this film, few are stopping to ask themselves how much of American Sniper represents the real experiences of Chris Kyle, and how much is simply a film studio trying to add in some excitement.

9. He Didn't Quit Bull Riding Because A Girl Broke His Heart

In the film's opening 30 minutes, Eastwood opts to whisk the audience away from the opening rooftop scene where Kyle is staring down his sights at a woman and a small boy, and tries to show instead how he ended up there. At the heart of this apparently is the break up with his girlfriend, which leads to him quitting the burgeoning bull riding career he loved so much. There's some element of truth in that Chris Kyle was, for a while at least, quite a good bull rider and his book does include numerous accounts of the trips he took in pursuit of the sport. Growing up on a farm with upwards of 100 cattle, he and his brother began to rodeo in their teens, but neither considered it as anything more than a hobby. However his decision to dismount had nothing to do with an ex-girlfriend or heartbreak, and came as the result of Kyle being thrown off a bronco and being dragged under. When he awoke some hours later with a sore head, a shattered wrist and numerous other injuries he decided to end his time in the saddle to pursue other avenues.

8. He Didn't Enlist Because He Saw The 1998 Embassy Attack

Not long after the end of his rodeo days, the film depicts Chris Kyle witnessing the horrific attacks on the United States embassies in Kenya and Tanzania. Seeing the carnage and the wreckage unfold on television, he's suitably moved to enlist in the Navy SEALs. Whilst this is chronologically accurate with the time Kyle decided to serve his country, the events of 1998 had nothing to do with his desire to do so. Kyle writes in his book that he'd always planned to one day join the military and become a soldier. After originally being turned down in 1996 because of his rodeo injuries, he was approached by a Navy recruiter who told him they'd now be willing to accept him into the program. The film at this point has Kyle as a grizzly and well-prepared 30 year old when, in reality, Kyle would only have been 24-25 at the time he enlisted.

7. He Didn't Actually Shoot A Boy Carrying A Grenade

After setting up the backstory, Eastwood then takes you back to the rooftop in the Middle East where Kyle is still fixated on the young woman and the boy carrying a grenade towards a group of American soldiers. After some deliberation and back and forth between his superiors, he eventually shoots both the woman and the child. Arguably the film's most iconic moment. Except it didn't actually happen. At least not the way it's portrayed in the film. In an interview he gave prior to his death, Kyle recounts an almost identical situation with a woman and a grenade, but there's no child involved. Staring down his sights as she approached US Marines, Kyle was forced to shoot and, as the film suggests, this was his first kill. There was another situation later in his tour when a small boy was sent out to retrieve a grenade and Kyle, watching above, tracked him for a number of minutes. However he didn't fire, and strongly maintained in his book that under no circumstances would he have fired on a child.

6. Chris Kyle Wasn't Conflicted About Killing

As well as the film picking up an Oscar nomination for Best Picture, Bradley Cooper also finds himself up for an award for his portrayal of Chris Kyle. This is largely down to the inner turmoil that rages throughout the protagonist from start to finish and how Cooper highlights the tremendous psychological effect war is having on him. The real Chris Kyle certainly wasn't, on the surface at least, as remotely traumatised by his role in the conflict as you see in the movie though. In his book, Kyle actually uses the words €œI love war€ and even goes on to explain that he saw his killings as €œfun€. It's hard to believe that someone is making sacrifices for his country when, by his own admission, he's actually enjoying them. Most troubling of all though, and most directly in conflict with Cooper's portrayal of his personal strife, is that Kyle claimed that he "couldn€™t give a flying f**k about the Iraqis€. When questioned by an army investigator over the death of a civilian, Kyle responded "I don€™t shoot people with Korans", before going on to add "I€™d like to, but I don€™t".

5. "The Butcher" Never Actually Existed

One of American Sniper's more dramatic plot lines is that of Kyle's mission to stop an insurgent nicknamed "The Butcher". Wearing a sinister black coat and dispensing of his victims with the aid of power tools, he's about as close to a cliched movie bad guy as you're likely to find, and seems almost too sinister to be real. Which of course he isn't. It's likely that the filmmakers have based him on the infamous Iraqi warlord Abu Derra who, taking credit for thousands of deaths in the Iraq War, bears a number of strikingly similar characteristics with "The Butcher", but he and Kyle had no interaction during the conflict whatsoever. In fact he's still alive today. Chris Kyle was good, but not even he could have tracked down and killed a man who doesn't even exist. There's no mention of any event like this anywhere in Kyle's writings and the whole arc in the story was added simply to give a more acceptably evil face to the enemy.

4. There Was No Special Bounty On His Head

With Kyle's legend growing in the film, it's revealed that the insurgents have placed an eye-watering $180,000 bounty on his head, and are using his tattoo to help identify him to any would-be assassin assassins. It wouldn't be quite right to say that this didn't happen entirely, as for the majority of his tours there would have been a cash reward for anyone able to prove they'd killed Chris Kyle, but this was simply the standard bounty that was placed on any American sharpshooters in the war. Whilst the figures did vary, and Kyle's tattoo was known to his enemies, he wasn't singled out by them. In an interview with talkshow host Conan O'Brien, Kyle even joked that if it had been anywhere near that high his wife would have probably claimed it straight away.

3. He Didn't Kill The Sniper Mustafa (In Fact They Probably Never Even Crossed Paths)

One consistent theme running throughout the film is the sniper vs. sniper face-off Kyle has with a man named Mustafa, culminating in him and his elusive nemesis finally battling to the death across a mile distance, with Kyle emerging as the sole survivor. Mustafa was real, that's long since been established and his legend and influence during the war was comparable that that of Kyle's. As the film correctly depicts he was a Syrian, believed to be a former Olympic marksman, and responsible for the deaths of countless marines until his own death at the hands of US snipers. However, his interaction with Kyle consists of one passing sentence in his book. Nothing more. Many legends became attributed to Mustafa over the course of the war, with almost any impossible shot from the insurgents eventually being attributed to him. Such is the nature of sniper warfare that even if the two did have their sights trained on one another at some point there's no way either of them would have known for sure.

2. He Didn't Actually Call His Wife During A Battle

One of the defining moments toward the end of the film is a phone call Bradley Cooper makes to his wife in the aftermath of his duel with Mustafa to tell her that simply can't deal with the trauma of war anymore and that he's going to come home to be with her and his children. All in the middle of a battle. While Kyle did frequently make use of a satellite phone to keep in touch his family, occasionally during active duty when things had taken a lull, this call never took place. Twice however, fighting broke out while was in the midst of a call and on one occasion his failure to disconnect before putting the phone down led to his wife listening to almost the entire firefight until the battery eventually died - a scene that is depicted in the film. Electrical sockets are a little harder to come by in the middle of a warzone though, and it was a number of days later before Kyle could call again and let his wife know that he was still alive.

1. He Doesn't Have 160 Confirmed Kills

In reality, there isn't any such thing as a "confirmed kill". Official US policy is not to keep records of this sort of thing and, even though all snipers have to file reports about every instance of them discharging their weapon, no statistics are kept of how many combatants they kill. Instead, sniper folklore varies between numbers being verified by spotters and kills needing to be verified up close, and Kyle himself has spoken of his number coming from him personally keeping track of the amount of soldiers he killed. Although since his death a number of fellow marines have stated that, given the length of his tours and hours in the field, they'd estimate his true figure to be upwards of 250. Whatever the total figure though, he comfortably holds the record, albeit it an unofficial one, for most sniper kills in the American military. The previous holder of this dubious honour was Carlos Hathcock, who recorded 93 during the Vietnam war. What did you make of American Sniper? Do the factual discrepancies change your opinion on it? Discuss the movie in comments below.

Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine