Andy Serkis: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
Five roles to rule them all and five which weren't so precious.

5 Awesome Performances...
5. John D'Auban - Topsy-Turvy (1999)

4. Ian Dury - Sex & Drugs & Rock & Roll (2010)

3. Martin Hannett - 24 Hour Party People (2002)

2. Kong - King Kong (2005)

1. Gollum - The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (2001-03) & The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012)

And 5 That Sucked...
5. Spike - Flushed Away (2006)

4. Richard Kneeland - 13 Going On 30 (2004)

3. Hoodwink - Sugarhouse (2007)
Few things are more depressing than a formulaic British gangster film. Where once the genre produced the likes of Get Carter and Gangster No. 1 (featuring career-best work from Paul Bettany), nowadays it's nothing more than a collection of meat-headed cliches, supplying the same old levels of violence and nudity but without the substance to justify them. Serkis found himself in one such film when he made Sugarhouse, a thankfully little-seen and thoroughly derivative offering. Sugarhouse is an urban thriller based loosely on the stage play Collision. It follows the middle-class Tom (Steven Macintosh), who is down on his luck and feeling suicidal. He attempts to buy a gun from homeless crack addict D (Ashley Walters), who attempts to extort Tom for more money to pay off his debt to local gangster Hoodwink (Serkis). Upon discovering that the gun actually belongs to Hoodwink, Tom and D become embroiled in a cat-and-mouse chase that could be lethal for them both. There's nothing in Sugarhouse that you haven't seen a hundred times before, and while it lacks the pretentiousness of Guy Ritchie's output, it's still pretty insufferable to watch. Serkis is one of its biggest problems: he brings no subtlety to the part of Hoodwink, playing him as a ruthless, angry hooligan with no redeeming features and nothing interesting about him. It's all well and good having a villain who is enigmatic and mysterious, but Serkis treats the character like a blunt instrument, bashing us repeatedly over the head until we've lost all patience.
2. David - The Cottage (2008)

1. Father Carlo - Blessed (2004)
Horror filmmakers have been exploring the fear of children and pregnancy for decades. This trend of 'paedo-phobic' horror reached its peak in the 1960s and 1970s, with films like Village of the Damned, Rosemary's Baby, The Exorcist, The Omen and even Alien to some extent. Since then, horror films have struggled to bring anything new to the table on the subject of scary children. But few have failed quite so blatantly as Blessed, another film which thankfully few people have seen. Blessed is a British-Romanian co-production directed by Simon Fellows, who later helmed the Danny Dyer vehicle Malice in Wonderland. James Purefoy and Heather Graham play a couple who are desperately trying for a baby, but their hopes are dashed when Graham's character is diagnosed as being infertile. They are given hope by a new treatment available at the Spiritus Research Clinic, and the couple soon find themselves expecting twins. What follows is an increasingly stupid story involving priests, secret pacts and the Devil's DNA (I've lost you already). Blessed is essentially what you would get if you took Rosemary's Baby and stripped out all the subtext and atmosphere. It's a rubbish horror movie that's riddled with cliches, and unlike Drag Me To Hell it doesn't gain the audience's trust by poking fun at its own shortcomings. Serkis takes the cake, though, phoning in his performance as Father Carlo with a lack of commitment bordering on contempt for the material. He seems genuinely embarrassed to be there, barely making eye-contact with Graham in their scenes together. Serkis' best work has always come from total commitment to a role, making this a shoe-in for the worst performance of his career. Disagree with my choices? Drop me a comment below or visit Mumby at the Movies for more reviews.