Annihilation Review: 8 Ups & 2 Downs

An ambitious cult classic in the making.

Annihilation Natalie Portman
Netflix

After getting a limited release in the U.S. and Canada late last month, the second feature from Ex Machina director Alex Garland is available now on Netflix throughout the rest of the world (except China).

Though the recent state of Netflix's Originals line-up might give you low expectations - what with The Cloverfield Paradox and Mute making an especially dodgy case for sci-fi fare - rest assured that critics have been tripping over themselves to praise Garland's film as a challenging, superbly crafted entry into the genre.

And they're not wrong. Though you might decry your inability to see the film in cinemas, you're still getting arguably the best movie of the year so far streamed straight to your home, and that shouldn't be sniffed at.

For those prepared to pay attention, immerse themselves in the mystery and go along for the barmy ride, Annihilation represents sci-fi cinema at some of its most uncompromising. A worthy follow-up to Garland's incredible debut indeed...


Downs

2. The Totally Pointless Frame Narrative

Annihilation Natalie Portman
Netflix

Alex Garland makes a bold and not entirely successful creative decision right at the start of the movie by presenting the film's events within a frame narrative.

Biologist and former soldier Lena's (Natalie Portman) journey into the bubble-like alien construct known as the Shimmer has already taken place when the film starts, readily spoiling the fates of herself and her team as scientist Lomax (Benedict Wong) debriefs Lena about what took place.

This immediately strips a decent portion of the movie's tension away, and considering how little the frame narrative impacts the overall plot, it could've easily been done away with entirely.

Whether Garland employed this technique himself as a means to make the story more accessible or it was mandated by original distributor Paramount, it's a jarringly conventional flourish in a film that absolutely doesn't need it.


1. The Wildly Inconsistent CGI Quality

Annihilation Deer
Netflix

Annihilation is an incredibly ambitious film both thematically and aesthetically, and Alex Garland should absolutely be praised for delivering such a stylish and visually bold project on a rather moderate $55 million budget.

However, there are clearly sequences - especially in the movie's third act - where the budgetary restrictions have obviously impacted the fidelity of the visual effects, resulting in some CGI creatures and phenomena not quite looking up to par with the rest.

It's certainly a case of Garland's vision exceeding the utility of the tools at his disposal - there are many worse drawbacks for a movie to have, for sure - but the overall inventiveness is strong enough that most audiences shouldn't care all that much.

And now these minor complaints are dealt with, here's everything that really works in Annihilation...


Ups

8. Natalie Portman's Terrific Performance

Annihilation Natalie Portman
Netflix

Natalie Portman gives one of the strongest performances of her career in this film, playing a complex, expectation-defying heroine who manages to be both incredibly smart and believably capable in combat scenarios.

Portman's Lena has a lot to juggle here, pondering on her wobbly relationship with her critically ill husband Kane (Oscar Isaac), while also dealing with the visceral existential threat of the Shimmer itself.

The actress is fantastic in the quieter, more typically emotive scenes, the brief moments of shoot 'em up action and also as the awe-struck explorer desperate to reach the lighthouse at the centre of the Shimmer.

Don't expect any Oscar nominations or anything, but it's some her most inspired work to date and surely the strongest lead performance in just about any film this year so far.


7. The Smart, Thought-Provoking Script

Annihilation Natalie Portman Oscar Isaac
Netflix

As you'd expect and hope for from Alex Garland, Annihilation is an intelligent and provocative film which asks fascinating questions about the nature of existence and the future of humanity.

It is, in many ways, what Ridley Scott's Prometheus and Alien: Covenant really should've been: a tense, character-driven sci-fi thriller that prods and pokes at the nature of creation in a wildly unexpected way.

Through and through, the film eagerly subverts sci-fi tropes, from the typical gender dynamics being inverted - here the woman quests to save the man, and the mission's crew are all women - to the nature of the Shimmer itself (but the less said about that, the better).

It is a film that wants to challenge audiences by eschewing genre convention, and for those up to the task, it's an incredibly rewarding sit.


6. The Jaw-Dropping Visuals

Annihilation Natalie Portman
Netflix

Though there are the aforementioned CGI issues, more often than not this is an utterly ravishing film to look at, from Rob Hardy's lush cinematography, through to the immaculate, thoroughly convincing production design, and the imaginative nature of the increasingly trippy visual effects.

To that end it's a shame that most of the world won't get to experience Annihilation in an actual cinema to soak in the full impact of the impeccable production, but it is nevertheless a remarkably imaginative achievement that persuasively distinguishes itself from the aesthetics of other similarly-themed sci-fi offerings.


5. It's An Atmospheric, Suspenseful Slow Burn

Annihilation Natalie Portman
Netflix

Even with the fates of the central characters being revealed at the very beginning of the movie, there's still a lot here to get your pulse and mind racing.

Garland expertly doles out the slow-burn mystery at the film's core, progressively ramping up the weirdness ahead of a gonzo third act that's quite like nothing else out there (but more on that in a moment).

The action sequences are also well-wrought enough that it's easy to forget about the business of who lives and who dies, and just get wrapped up in the sheer horror of what's happening to these people.

Though the pace is deliberate, it's certainly not too slow for its own good, and at just 115 minutes in length, the film carries itself along with a healthy dose of intrigue in practically every single scene.


4. The Excellent Supporting Cast

Annihilation Natalie Portman
Netflix

Natalie Portman leads an accomplished, capable and primarily female cast who also contribute hugely to the film's success. Of particular mention are Tuva Novotny, Gina Rodriguez and Jennifer Jason Leigh as the more fleshed-out members of Lena's unit, while Tessa Thompson's rather forgettable physicist character conversely feels disappointing underdeveloped.

Rodriguez is especially good as the hot-headed, fiery-tempered medic Anya, and Leigh brings every bit of skill to the table you'd reasonably expect.

Garland's prior collaborator Oscar Isaac isn't in the movie too much, but he certainly makes his scenes count, and ably helps form the story's emotional core.

It's Portman's show, but everyone around her clearly appreciates how special the material here truly is.


3. The Fantastic Musical Score

Annihilation Natalie Portman
Paramount

Ex Machina composers Ben Salisbury and Geoff Barrow return to provide the musical score here, and once again, they've delivered a score that fleets between hauntingly beautiful and pulsingly surreal.

From the various stripped-down, acoustic guitar-led tracks peppered throughout the film to some infrequent, discordant uses of synths, there's a real diversity to the music on offer, which suits the mood and tone of the visuals perfectly.

Though the film would be incredibly atmospheric even if there was no music to speak of, Salisbury and Barrow's contributions help boost it to that next level.


2. It's Brilliantly, Intensely Disturbing

Annihilation Bear Natalie Portman
Netflix

There are some incredibly unpleasant and unsettling scenes in this film, from literally revolting body horror sequences to more restrained, even artful and beautiful depictions of the Shimmer's effect on the human body.

There's one scene in particular in this film that's going to linger in the mind of just about everyone who watches it, a sequence so stomach-knottingly intense and superbly executed that it'll be talked about for months, if not years from now.

Though it would've been easy for a lot of these disturbing moments to simply settle for delivering schlocky genre thrills, the fact they stem from such an intriguing concept and involve so many compelling characters ensures there's always something thoughtful going on.

But seriously, there are quite a few moments in this movie that'll have you wincing and cringing at what you're seeing.


1. The Totally Insane Third Act

Annihilation Natalie Portman
Netflix

No spoilers here, but Annihilation's third act is an absolute all-timer in terms of ambitious sci-fi spectacle, a visually outlandish, unsettling and beautiful sequence that's nothing if not a brave attempt to tell a totally unique spin on typical alien invasion narratives.

This is clearly the section of the film that Paramount was most concerned about before Netflix snapped up the international rights, and indeed, it's easy to see how more causal audiences might be left more dumbfounded than entertained or satisfied by what happens.

If you're prepared not to get all the answers you crave and go down the rabbit-hole with Garland, though, this is a visionary finale like nothing else out there right now.

What did you think of Annihilation? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.