Avengers: Endgame's Most Confusing Plot Holes EXPLAINED

A definitive explanation for the MCU's most mind-breaking film.

Avengers Endgame
Marvel

--MAJOR AVENGERS: ENDGAME SPOILERS WITHIN--

They did it.

After 11 years and 22 films, the first major arc of the MCU is complete. Minus Kevin Feige stating that Spider-Man: Far From Home will actually be the "true ending" to everything in July, comprising a decade's worth of superhero flicks, Endgame wraps the vast majority of plot points, arcs and character moments into one hell of a sendoff.

Existing as one sprawling, impressively detailed three hour epic, directors Anthony and Joe Russo essentially created a Lord of the Rings-sized heist movie. The sense of scale is unprecedented as The Avengers duck and weave through time itself, plucking older versions of the Infinity Stones out of specific past Marvel movies - the plan being to emerge with a complete Infinity Gauntlet's worth of life-saving power on the other side.

Now, as with almost every movie that deals with time travel, there are a BUNCH of head-scratching "... what?" moments when all's said and done, and from Captain America "replacing" his original self, to Thanos invalidating his own 2018 Snap my making it never happen, you'll likely be in need of an explainer.

--MAJOR AVENGERS: ENDGAME SPOILERS WITHIN--


5. Forget Multiple Timelines, There Is Only One

Endgame 1
MCU

It seems that every other website/author has a different take on precisely what the Avengers were doing across the film. Either every time they were delving into the past and doing anything, it created a splintered new timeline/reality, OR they were remixing the established MAIN timeline, and everything stays locked into one "core" progression.

Personally I think the latter makes the most sense, and it's backed up by comments from Bruce Banner and The Ancient One.

First up, during the scene where each character is mentioning the "rules of time travel" based on Hollywood's most popular examples (Back to the Future, Timecop, Terminator etc.), Banner wipes all these off the table, leading to them being called "bullsh*t". Where all these movies go down the route of "X thing changes in the past, therefore Y is affected in the present/future", Bruce states that the only perspective that matters is that of our characters.

Banner clarifies that "your past becomes your present", and as we're following THIS group of Avengers throughout, that's all that matters in understanding Endgame.

This is doubled down on by The Ancient One when Banner visits her, who shows us a visual diagram of the "main" timeline (highlighted in bright orange as a larger stream) holding together because all six infinity stones are present and correct. She notes that removing one to serve the present/future will fracture the core timeline, and reiterates the need for the stones to remain, so they can be used to defend Earth.

With both these pieces of evidence, it's safe to say that all the events we've seen across the last 21 movies are set in stone. You can travel back and pick up objects or characters to bring them forward, with the time in between essentially being Schrödinger's cat (existing and not existing simultaneously, until witnessed).

It's worth noting here that these black tendril "split realities" do start to exist (Loki escaping, for example), but the whole point of Endgame is to EVENTUALLY reduce everything back to one solid timeline.

At least, that's the only explanation I've found that works.

Onto the good stuff.


4. Captain America's "Plot Hole"

Avengers Endgame Captain America
Marvel Studios

Plenty of people are claiming Cap's final resting place in the canon doesn't add up, based on the idea that time travel creates multiple realities, and him going back to marry Peggy would negate the future he's then sat in as an old man. If changing the past fractures the timeline, he couldn't then be in the same spot as our Bucky and our Falcon.

However, going off the one timeline theory, Cap's life played out as follows:

After being given the serum in 1941, going into the ice circa 1941-43 and getting thawed out in 2011, he continued to lead and help The Avengers until 2019. After helping defeat Thanos, he decides to go back in time to 1941-1943, meeting back up with Peggy and living the life his other self lost in the plane crash.

We now have a main timeline where there are TWO Captain Americas, with OUR Steve Rogers living with Peggy, under the radar; his "younger self" remaining stuck in the ice. See how his timeline is more a timeloop-and-keep-going?

Cap only has one progression, but his timeline loops back before continuing. It carries forward from the 1940s to 2019, only to loop back around as he finally ages through the years he first spent in the ice. The twist, again, is that his "iced self" hasn't gone anywhere - he's just waiting to enact the events that will lead him back to the past.

Old Cap (our Steve) stays away from the spotlight this entire time, sadly losing Peggy to the same mental degradation she suffers in Winter Soldier/Civil War, but managing to make it to the bench for that all-important reunion with Bucky and Falcon.


3. Does Thanos Time-Travelling Negate His Own Snap?

Avengers Infinity War Thanos
Marvel Studios

Next up: How does Thanos getting beamed from 2014 to 2019 NOT negate the Snap? If in 2014, Thanos never collected the Stones and instead leapt straight into the final fight, the Snap doesn't happen, and that future doesn't exist, right?

Wrong.

At least, "wrong" inasmuch as the only explanation is the version of time I'm going with.

With this "Schrodinger's time" explanation, Thanos being plucked from 2014 doesn't change reality, because it CAN'T. The timeline we're dealing with fundamentally has a version of Thanos that used the Infinity Gauntlet to snap away half of existence, only to get beheaded. Those events cannot be changed, either through a younger version of him being killed (which Banner confirms wouldn't do anything and Nebula surviving shooting herself proves too), or destroying the stones.

Endgame is about forward momentum, so we can assume Stark's dying request was one of two things:

1. He wished to destroy Thanos and all his followers right there and then. The surrounding environment doesn't reset, so his decision definitely centres on population control, rather than reshaping the damage done.

2. He wipes them from the present and sends Thanos back to 2014, with no memory of his failure. This way, all the events of the main timeline happen as expected, and it all (eventually) leads back to Stark's snap saving the universe.

Also note that Gamora goes missing and Quill is seen running a search program for her. If situation 2 had happened, Gamora would have died by Thanos' hand and Quill wouldn't have any vital signs to search for.

It's more likely then, that reality is set, and 2014 Thanos just got wiped out in the present, with everything that's happened still being mapped out in one chronological direction.


2. Wait... Loki Escaped Again?

Loki The Avengers
Marvel Studios

Here's where the movie gets a little too carried away with experimental time fractures, and it's likely because Tom Hiddleston's Loki TV show was being put in place during its production. Still, I have an explanation, but it's also tied to the next point, too.

In the scene itself, Captain America, Tony Stark and Ant-Man attempt to dive back in to the Battle of New York in 2012, only to get knocked down by original Hulk, right at the point they were about to escape with the Space Stone (the Tesseract). This leads to Loki picking up the Tesseract and teleporting away, only for us to continue watching Cap, Stark and Lang erect a Plan B.

The natural thought process is that Loki escaped, creating a time fracture; an alternate reality where he escapes back into New York, or does whatever else comes to mind with his newfound freedom.

As we need this theorised timeline to work as one though, this could easily be where Loki's "What If?"-themed TV show comes into play. Doing so makes perfect sense as there could be a gap where Loki possesses the Tesseract for a time, only to return it to Odin's vault for Thor: Dark World.

This contradicts Banner's claims that "you can't change your past", but there's also the idea that he was eventually stopped by Captain America.

"Wait... what?!" you scream. Well...


1. Cap Finally Makes Everything Okay

Avengers Endgame Trailer
Marvel Studios

Endgame goes to great lengths spelling out that there are only so many chances to get everything right ("one round trip each and two practice runs" using the time machine), but Cap picks up more Pym Particle phials when he's back in the 1970s' SHIELD/Hydra base.

We see Cap pick up 4 phials in a set (and these are used to keep the main mission going), but there are two more sets that he could've also nabbed, for his final mission to restore the Stones.

Using the same theory we've had this whole time (that only the Avengers we're watching matter), Cap isn't visiting a number of realities to restore order, but points along the "main" timeline instead. By dropping in at key points in the established canon, he either prevents Loki from escaping by restoring the Space Stone's original position in the 70s, or Loki still escapes into his own TV show, only for events we haven't seen yet to return the Tesseract before Thor: The Dark World.

Either way, Cap is all about making a life for himself and Peggy, in the background of every other movie's events.

Cap is the only character who manages to loop back on his own timeline, and that's likely down to setting the last Infinity Stone in place, then remaining in the physical space he was left in, opting to miss his "window" to return to the present. The Tesseract is the "oldest" Infinity Stone we saw in the MCU, and it makes sense Cap would place it back into Howard Stark's storage last, back in the early 1940s.

There was always one main timeline; our MCU movie timeline, with all these events as they always were.

Cap needed to restore order by placing the stones back in the right place, and once that was done, he could live a long, happy life with Peggy.


Watch Next


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.