Avengers: Infinity War - 8 Compelling Hints Iron Man Will Die (& 4 He Won't)

Genius. Billionaire. Philanthropist. Dead guy.

Iron Man Helmet Fire Thanos
Marvel Studios

If you've missed the fact that Marvel Studios want us all to know that people are going to die in Avengers: Infinity War, you haven't been paying much attention to the marketing campaign.

Far away from the provocation of the Captain America: Civil War teasing, there's been a shift in the way the directors, producers and actors have spoken about the threat of Thanos' invasion and the changes the film is going to have on the entire MCU.

The question that's endlessly playing out in fans' minds is who those deaths will be in the ensemble. Some candidates look more obvious than others at this stage, with an ominous cloud definitely hanging over Captain America, but there's a distinct possibility that the shocking fatalities won't end with him.

What if Iron Man - the man on whose shoulders the entire MCU was initially built - will be killed off too? What if there's a double sting in the tail? And though that might sound like too much pessimism for a Disney movie, there certainly is enough evidence and hints out there suggesting that it might be the case. Basically, the writing may well be on the wall for the Avengers' most valuable single character and it definitely deserves an investigation...


Why He'll Die

8. It Suits His Story Arc

Captain America Civil War Iron Man Sad
Marvel Studios

From the very start of Tony Stark's arc as Iron Man back in 2008, he's had a lot of things to atone for. He was a conceited, selfish weapons-dealer whose behaviour for the first three quarters of his life had been mostly deplorable, with his skills mostly wasted and his vast wealth ploughed more into self-destruction than philanthropy or in service of the world.

Ultimately, he was basically guilt-tripped into becoming Iron Man (even if he did it in a particularly Tony Stark-like way) and since then he's had more reasons to feel like he needs to atone heaped onto him. His weapons killed the twins' parents, his anxiety and PTSD led to the creation of Ultron, he was partly responsible for the Sokovian incident and then he turned on his friends and led to the paralysis of his best friend, Rhodey. He doesn't seem to care about endangering a teenager in Spider-Man, but that will probably come full-circle too.

He HAS had opportunities to make up for it and he has appointed himself Earth's chief protector (for better or worse), but he hasn't had what an arc like his usually demands: a real heroic sacrifice. He tried in The Avengers, but was foiled and since then he's spiraled further.

In short, the idea of him ultimately laying down his life in a purely altruistic fashion absolutely suits the way he's been developed as a character.


7. He Might Be Linked To The Soul Stone

Soul Stone Infinity War
Marvel Studios

Now, this is a slightly outlandish theory, but there could well be something to the idea that Tony Stark is somehow linekd to the Soul Stone, given the fact that some official artwork (which linked each Soul Stone to the Avenger most closely associated with it) seemed to imply a link to him. Specifically, that image seems to suggest that it's his arc reactor that will play a key part in the discovery of the Soul Stone - which could perhaps be explained by looking back to Stark's development of the "new" element he engineered for his power source.

It'd take some creative writing to make it work, but it's not like the other Stones aren't also entirely fantastical... And there are other theories out there suggesting that other characters could somehow be the Stone personified. So why not Tony?

If that's the case, he's unlikely to be allowed to live with Thanos on the trail of the Stone. And a heroic sacrifice (or, really, just a plain old death) as the key would suit what we know of the Soul Stone.


6. It's More Surprising Than Any Other Death

Avengers Infinity War Captain America Thanos
Marvel Studios

From almost the moment Captain America: Civil War was announced, Captain America has had a target on his forehead because of the way the comic story played out. His death is inevitable, just as Vision's fate is likely to be the same, given that he has an Infinity Stone in the middle of his forehead, and the other "major deaths" look pretty obvious too - the likes of War Machine, Falcon, The Collector, Loki and even Black Widow are all looking decidedly under threat.

But since when was the MCU this obvious? The first Avengers set up Iron Man's death only for him to survive, Avengers: Age Of Ultron made Hawkeye look like dead-meat only to kill someone else and Civil War was DEFINITELY going to kill Cap until it didn't. For all of the accusations of paint-by-numbers film-making from cynics, the franchise simply isn't that predictable and throwing in a spanner to the works like Iron Man's death instead of someone more obvious would be very fitting.

And just look at the way the marketing is being shaped currently, with the Russos doing their level best to warn us of surprises and devastating shocks. They WANT us to know this isn't going to go the way we all expect, and that could easily spell disaster for Tony.


5. There Won't Be An Iron Man 4

Iron Man 4
Marvel

No matter how much you might want to see another stand-alone follow-up to Iron Man 3 - and God knows Marvel probably would given the over-$1bn box office return - it's just not that likely.

Putting aside the fact that Phase 4 is being positioned as a new beginning (well, not entirely, because there'll be continuity for newer properties) and the fact that there's enough story left in the Ten Rings arc to warrant a fourth outing, the simple fact remains: Iron Man 4 would be too expensive to justify.

Thanks to Civil War, there'd be expectations of another mini-Avengers movie among fans, Robert Downey Jr would be able to write himself any pay-check and you really have to think that it would have been announced by now. You could say that's merely Infinity Saga spoiler protection, but there are already Phase 4 sequels announced and it's not like there isn't more evidence that it won't happen.

Previously, Downey Jr was open about the possibility, but Civil War changed his tune as it became the next natural step in his personal arc and he was quite adamant that there wasn't a fourth movie in the pipeline back in 2015. Little has changed since (though he has flirted with the idea of one more), and if anything, the arrival of Black Panther to the MCU makes him a slightly redundant character (other than perhaps as a replacement for Nick Fury as the over-seer - though even then, his death makes more sense).


4. Any Death Is Reversible

Doctor Strange
Marvel Studios

The fact that his heart might stop in Infinity War doesn't necessarily mean this is the last we've seen of Robert Downey Jr's Tony Stark, because Marvel have now introduced the perfect means to undo even the most serious of events: time travel (or at least the capacity to do it).

Obviously, the rules that the Sorceror Supreme must uphold as a guardian against multiverse threats means that frivolously using time travel wouldn't be encouraged (and that's probably how they'll make sure Strange can't just travel back in time and thwart Thanos simply), but certain key things will transcend paradox concerns.

In short, this is the perfect time to kill someone like Tony Stark (or indeed any huge character for effect), because you'd get the immediate emotional impact without any of the long-term ramifications. And that would allow Tony to live out his natural arc but also fly off into the sunset with Pepper (which fans will want just as much).


3. Robert Downey Jr "Can't Do It Forever"

Tony Stark Iron Man 3
Walt Disney Studios

Permanently killing a huge character in a franchise like this is one of the easiest means of manipulating a huge response from the fandom, but the simple fact is that it diminishes in potency as the actor stays in the role because of a simple fact of existence. Just as everyone dies, the life-span of an actor in any role - even one as lucrative as a masthead MCU character - is subject to the rules of mortality. In short, no character can live forever (or at least not with the same actor behind it).

And it's not like RDJ has been shy about talking about his retirement from the character. He's gone more quiet on that front recently - probably to throw us all of the spoiler scent - but back on the set of Civil War, Downey, he talked about his advancing years:

"I also recognise that I€™ll be turning 50 by the time I promote this movie. The clock is ticking down on the amount of memories and participation that I would allow myself and not embarrass the medium with."

Doesn't that sound like someone committed to going out with a bang, rather than a whimper?

And before anyone says Tony Stark could be replaced with another actor... No, he absolutely couldn't. Without Downey Jr, there would be no MCU Stark and the character's arc in the films has been increasingly invested in his fears of mortality and how suitable he is to remain as an active superhero. Making him have a change of heart just to suit the change of face would be a huge disservice.


2. Phase 4 NEEDS To Be Different

Marvel Phase 4
Marvel Studios

It's no accident that a huge part of the Infinity War marketing campaign has been dedicated to what comes after Avengers 4. It's been a means by which Marvel can sell the huge, unprecedented stakes at play in the double-header and selling the idea of a "wholly different" Phase 4 is a good way of hyping the next chapters of the MCU without making it seem like they have to directly compete with Phases 1-3.

But if Marvel were to hype so much difference, new worlds and new time-settings and the role James Gunn will be playing in expanding the cosmic MCU and then simply fill in the available release slots with sequels for Spider-Man, Black Panther, Doctor Strange, Guardians Of The Galaxy, probably Ant-Man, Iron Man and a Black Widow prequel they'll be making themselves liars.

If they want difference, they need to make it different in a big way, and there's no bigger way of leaving the past behind than by killing the original pillar of the entire franchise.


1. The Trailers Make Him Look Doomed

Avengers Infinity War Tony Stark
Marvel Studios

You might not want to believe that any trailer would spoil something as obviously as the way Tony Stark is presented in the Infinity War trailers, but it's pretty hard to ignore the message that he looks entirely screwed in those teasers.

Everything in the Titan-set scenes make it look like Iron Man, his fellow Avengers and most of the Guardians are defeated in their encounter with Thanos, who not only drops a whole bloody moon on them but also does enough damage to Stark to ruin his new nano-tech armour. And without that protection, he's no more than a genius, billionaire, playboy philanthropist on a strange planet trying to stand up to a monstrous alien with the power of at least TWO Infinity Stones in his locker.

One Stone was enough to empower the twins, bring Vision (an actual robo-Jesus) to life and mind-control Hawkeye and Dr Selvig. One Stone evaporated Red Skull. One Stone blew up the Collector's entire collection. One Stone can turn back actual time. One Stone could alter the fabric of reality. AND HE HAS TWO.

In short, without his suit and with his allies otherwise occupied dodging moon parts, there's no way Stark can survive a direct encounter with Thanos.

And now to the hints that he won't die...


Why He Won't Die

4. He Needs His Reunion With Captain America

Captain America Tony Stark
Marvel Studios

Though they shared a loaded moment at the end of Captain America: Civil War in which some of their wounds seemed to be mended by the truth of Bucky's condition, neither Iron Man nor Cap can be allowed to leave their MCU roles behind without having a proper reunion.

Right now, it feels like the Avengers are still torn apart by the schism formed in Civil War and the only way to defeat Thanos is to work together. It wasn't accidental that the first trailer for Infinity War started with a reiteration of the value of the team, nor was it that the characters working alone makes them look more vulnerable. Marvel WANT us to yearn for them all to be back together, because it's the only answer to ending Thanos' conquest.

And seeing the two poles of the MCU coming back together will be the final resolution to that idea, which definitely isn't happening in Infinity War. By the look of it, the pair don't even meet, which means it has to happen in Avengers 4 and with Cap likely dead by then, it makes no sense for them both to be (even with the time travel element).


3. He's In Avengers 4

Avengers 4 Tony Stark
Marvel Studios/Instagram

It's a fairly straight-forward point, but unless Marvel have cunningly gone to extreme lengths to set up entirely fake shooting days with Robert Downey Jr, he's definitely in Avengers 4.

Quite what he's up to remains to be seen, but he definitely seems to be involved in the mooted time travel element (mostly because his hair suggests he's still the older version of the character rather than the clearly Battle Of New York era Cap). So, in other words, killing him off would create some almighty problems on that front.

Now, obviously there are other ways (like more travel) of undoing his death, but using it twice in the space of a single movie would fit the "frivolous overuse" concerns already brought up and would devalue using it as a mechanism to go back for Cap (or whatever the real reason turns out to be).


2. He Might Have Some ACTUAL Avenging To Do

Avengers Infinity War Trailer Tony Holding Hand
Marvel Studios

There's another reading of those scenes from the trailer on Titan that seem to show Tony Stark giving up hope of survival: he's actually mourning. It could be that word of Cap's death comes to him at this point, or that he witnesses someone else in his new alliance die (hell, it might even be Spider-Man if everyone is protected by time travel anyway).

The point is, if Thanos breaks Tony's heart, he's in for exactly the same response that Cap and Bucky were on the end of in Civil War. That the Mandarin provoked in Iron Man 3. That the Ten Rings terrorists inspired in the first Iron Man... Fundamentally, he's a very emotional character (hence his occasionally wayward impulsiveness) who is ruled by his heart (again, the symbolism of his arc reactor is not unintentional) and it would be rather fitting that he'd be compelled to make Avengers 4 a revenge flick by something devastating.

Plus, isn't it about time we got to see the Avengers actually avenging? Infinity War's marketing campaign KNOWS this: after all, the trailer includes the line "If we can't protect the Earth, you can be damn well sure we'll avenge it." So what if that's pointing directly towards Tony's arc into Avengers 4?


1. He's WAY Too Valuable To Marvel Studios

Tony Stark Money, cash
Marvel Studios

While you could suggest that the $1.3bn haul of Iron Man 3 and Robert Downey Jr's increasingly outrageous pay are reasons why it would be better for Marvel to cut their losses and allow RDJ's contract to lapse lest they're forced to pay him a cool billion per appearance (or thereabouts), there's a reason Marvel are happy to pay.

When it comes to the chance to negotiate a new Marvel contract, it won't be the studio that pull out. By now, because of Downey Jr's impact on box office - not only in his own movies but with two Avengers movies, Civil War and Spider-Man: Homecoming all feathering his (and their) nest - he's the kind of brand you do not let go. Regardless of cost.

So even if we don't get an Iron Man 4, Marvel would be idiotic to pass up the chance to extend his presence in the MCU, even if it means only using him in a sort of consultancy capacity until they require him to suit up. Then they can use a stunt performer for the leg work and RDJ for the close-ups and nobody has to be concerned about his advancing age.

Sure, it can't last forever, but there is more than enough life in him and the character yet.

What do you think? Will Iron Man be killed off in Avengers: Infinity War? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.