Avengers: Infinity War Review - 9 Ups & 3 Downs

You are not ready for this film.

Thanos Infinity War Five Stars
Marvel Studios

There is one statement most fans reading this review will want to read: Avengers: Infinity War is a five star film. For the most part, anyway. It is the best experience of any MCU film - even when it isn't the best put-together story (Civil War, Guardians and The Winter Soldier are more nuanced and well-rounded) it is a spectacle like no other in this franchise or any other.

It ebbs and flows at times and the interest curve is definitely not always at the top of the graph for its entire (very long) run-time, but taken as a whole picture, it is a breathtaking, impactful experience that deserves to be watched a lot more than once. What the Russos have achieved in balance, power and spectacle is nothing short of profoundly brilliant.

After ten years of building characters, seeding one over-arching narrative and bridging an almighty 18 movies together into one cohesive narrative, the MCU has arrived at one hell of a climax. Or at least, one part of one hell of a climax. The fact that we get to see more of this in just a year feels like a treat that only loses some lustre for the fact that we have to wait that long. Then again, given what it takes from the audience by the end, maybe a little period of respite is sensible.

Even with that top rating, the film is not flawless - somewhat inevitably - and it's only because of how great it is that the areas for possible development stick out. And ignoring them would be disingenuous, so that's the best place to start with this review. There are no spoilers within, of course, because Thanos demanded as much.

First those negatives...


Downs

3. It Really Requires Homework

Thanos Infinity Stones
Marvel Studios

Though the film does admirably to bring in some exposition in the first act, thanks to this being ten years in the making, there is a lot going on that requires a fair bit of knowledge of the MCU's lore. For fans - and particularly those who have just done an extensive rewatch in preparation of Infinity War's release - that won't be a problem, but this is a mainstream audience film, and it might feel a little like hard work in the first act to really keep up.

In the end, that partly comes down to a problem with the exposition, which feels like it was treated somewhat like an obligation to be gotten out of the way before the big show really kicked off. It isn't at all fatal, but it just feels slightly non-committal.


2. The Comedy Is A Little Too Relentless

Avengers Infinity War Doctor Strange Tony Stark Bruce Banner Wong
Marvel Studios/EW

For the first half of the movie, the gags come at an absolutely relentless pace, and while a lot of them really do land and audiences will love them, some are a little too much and don't entirely suit the gravitas of the situation.

In a way, it feels like the Russos paid a little too much attention to Thor: Ragnarok in terms of the gag frequency and after a while it feels a little like you're being made to endure too much shtick. And really, some more restraint would have served the agenda to make us laugh a little more, which is very much the message of the second half, where the gags calm down because of the need to focus on more break-neck action and it all works a lot better.

Still, there are gags in there that will absolutely be remembered long after the film is dust in the memory.


1. It's SLIGHTLY Too Long

Avengers: Infinity War Thanos
Marvel Studios

There's a very definite shift of pace at the mid-point of Infinity War that rather unfortunately makes some of the scenes up that point feel a little long.

The difficulty, of course, is that there is so much story in there that the Russos would have been faced with some pretty major decisions (and at least one sequence we know was filmed didn't make it in to the final film). But you still come away feeling like it could probably have been about 15 minutes shorter without losing anything.

That said, there is absolutely zero fat to trim on the second half and the Russos would have had to kill some real darlings to get the run-time down. Strictly speaking, the negatives here are meagre compared to the soaring heights.

Now to the positives...


Ups

9. The Fight Choreography Is Astonishing

Avengers Infinity War Wakanda
Marvel Studios

If you thought the spectacle of Civil War, Ant-Man, The Avengers or any of the more adventurous MCU movies to date was impressive, you have seen absolutely nothing like the incredible battle scenes in Infinity War.

It's almost impossible to go back through the best of them, but the climactic Wakandan and Titan sequences are absolutely astonishing and unlike anything we've seen in the MCU so far. And it's not just about huge scale: like the best battle sequences in the Lord Of The Rings, it's as much about the interplay of characters as it is about satiating a bloodlust with huge World Of Warcraft action.

And even when the action is more personal and there are smaller pods of heroes and villains clashing, it's just as good and just as heart-pounding. A lot of that comes down to the choreography too, which the Russos really need to be commended for.


8. The Story Progression

Infinity War Star-Lord
Marvel Studios

The important thing to remember going into Infinity War is that the build-up for the last decade doesn't only matter when it was dealing directly with the Infinity Stones. Each of the characters has gone through something important and taken them to this point and everything they've done impacts the story direction of Infinity War.

The whole MCU is about the individual choices and mistakes of heroes given the responsibility of guarding the Earth and the galaxy, the cost of that - both to them and to the world - and their accountability. Infinity War deals with all of that - in terms of the themes of PTSD, belonging, control, accountability, passion that leads to mistakes - in such an organic way that it's honestly incredible that the script-writers and the Russos have managed it.

Even with 90 minutes plus of solid action, the character pay-offs are some of the biggest and boldest moments in the entire piece.


7. The Character Dynamics

Avengers Infinity War Rocket
Marvel Studios

As soon as it was revealed that Infinity War was going to bring characters together for the first time - especially the Guardians Of The Galaxy (who are definitely the MVPs as a group, along with Thor) and the Avengers meeting - it immediately became very exciting to think of the new dynamics and partnerships we'd get to see.

And it's definitely the interplay of characters that stands out in Infinity War as some of the best fan-baiting moments. Thor and Rocket Raccoon deserve their own movie together, Thor and Star-Lord have a great dynamic, the alliance of Stark and Strange and Parker is brilliant and generally speaking, the meetings of some of the characters are really joyful moments.

It's a shame that there are missing figures (you'll see), but there's more than enough in there to justify it.


6. The Surprises

game of thrones peter dinklage
HBO

Even though Marvel Studios have done a LOT of spoiling with the avalanche of TV spots that have come out since the Russos released their message about spoilers and Thanos demanding silence, it's really very impressive how many surprises there are in Infinity War.

There have been some spot-on leaks, unfortunately for Marvel (which may have prompted the spoiler anxiety, in fact), but if you've avoided them (and most seem to have missed the most accurate), there are some truly jaw-dropping revelations, cameos, emotional beats...

Things you've been led to believe would definitely happen are avoided, there are huge swerves in the story and there are spoilers that are so valuable that it's no wonder the Russos want them protected at all costs.


5. The Black Order Are Great

Avengers Infinity War Black Order Children Of Thanos Ebony Maw
Marvel Studios

Traditionally in MCU films, if the big bad brings sidekicks, they're either cannon fodder or glorified set dressings who serve a vague purpose until they're killed off rather unceremoniously. But that isn't the case with the Black Order.

They're helped somewhat by the fact that Thanos actually brings an army of cannon fodder for the Wakandan scene - in the shape of Outriders - but each of the Order have the personality (or the presence in the case of the non-talker) and they could have been villains in their own right.

Ebony Maw is particularly brilliant with an amazing vocal performance by Tom Vaughan-Lawlor, and it's a bit of a shame that there's not even more of him in there. But that's only because he's so great.


4. The Post-Credit Stinger

Avengers Infinity War
Marvel Studios

Though there's only one post-credits scene, it's well worth the wait to go through the entire credits for.

Without spoiling it, it follows on from the stunning ending sequence organically but also sets up one of the forthcoming movies between the two Avengers movies in a very clever sort of way.

There's also a great fan-baiting gag in there that just about changes the tone enough to alleviate what the film has just put you through. Well, almost, anyway.

In short, do NOT leave the cinema early.


3. The Last Hour Is Pure, Incredible Blockbuster Film-Making

Nebula Infinity War
Marvel Studios

There is absolutely no way you have experienced anything in a cinema like the final hour of Infinity War. It manages to balance THREE action-heavy sequences in a perfectly balanced way, with almost all of the main MCU characters in one way or another and lots of emotional complexity behind the action.

This is the kind of blockbuster spectacle that we should be absolutely thankful to the MCU for. Thanks to the ten years of success we've had, the Russos were handed a mighty budget and they have squeezed every last penny out of it in that breathless, blistering hour of action, emotional devastation and stunning shocks.

It is absolutely stunning and it would be way too easy to stray into platitudes and hyperbole, but it's fair to say that even when the film strays below a 5 star rating, that entire triptych sequence drags it right back up there.


2. Thanos

Avengers Infinity War Thanos
Marvel Studios

Considering the problems that certain other comic book movies have had with fully rendered villains, you would have thought that Marvel and the Russos would have avoided the potential for the those pitfalls.

But it's great that they didn't, because Thanos is the single best character in the entire film. The effects work that has gone into him is the crown jewel on top of a film that has truly great effects all the way through and it's matched for quality by Josh Brolin's powerhouse performance.

There is no emotion lost for the motion capture nor the fact that he is a great big purple monster. And crucially, the script-writers have taken everything that worked with Zemo in Captain America: Civil War and Killmonger in Black Panther and applied it to his story. He is complex, sympathetic and deeply impressive (not least because his threat is absolutely delivered on in the first ten minutes of his appearance) and he's definitely the best villain the MCU has ever seen.


1. That Ending (And The Emotional Heft)

Avengers Infinity War Tony Stark
Marvel Studios

If the final hour of the movie is great, the very end of Infinity War is simply astonishing. What the Russos have done and what it will do to the audience is hard to put into words. It comes down to feelings and you're going to struggle not to be overcome with a whole rainbow of them.

And that's very much the case for the whole film. Even when it's deeply invested in massive spectacle, it always comes back to small, personal moments - of chest-beating glory, devastating heartbreak, warm charm - and it will absolutely leave a mark. Let's be honest, it will leave a LOT of marks.

Considering the accusations Marvel and Disney have faced in the past for not delivering on adult themes, this is an absolute tour-de-force.

What did you think of Avengers: Infinity War? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.