Batman: 10 Reasons Why Tim Burton's Was The Best
Everyone loves a good superhero movie. Movies based on our favourite characters from DC and Marvel Comics have been gaining plenty of popularity over the last few years - and the passion is only getting stronger. DC's recent Batman trilogy (starring Christian Bale) has been wildly popular throughout the world since 2005 when Batman Begins premiered. Today, however, I'm here to talk about a couple of classics. These two films created by my favourite director, Tim Burton, have always been at the top of my list - Batman (1989) and Batman Returns (1992). The differences between these two films, Joel Schumacher's continuation and Christopher Nolan's modern representation are actually quite massive. If you are one who enjoys the fun, comic-book style of Tim Burton's Batman films then please read on as I express 10 reasons (in no particular order) why I believe they are the best!
10. Bruce Wayne Is Not Cocky
Or at least not to an overwhelming extent. Let's face it - we'd all have a little bit of an ego if we were that wealthy too. I always found in the Tim Burton adaptations, Michael Keaton did not portray Bruce Wane as a particularly conceited man. Yes, he has money. Yes, he lives in a beautiful mansion and is taken care of by his butler, Alfred Pennyworth (aka the sweetest man on the planet), portrayed by the late Michael Gough. However, his parents were also murdered right in front of his eyes when he was only a child. I'm going to go out on a limb and say that an event like that can scar someone for life - and certainly keep them humble. After seeing Christian Bale's egotistical representation of Bruce Wayne in the new trilogy I personally consider it rather refreshing to see a more withdrawn version of him in these older films. It allows him to come across as a real person and someone that people can sympathize with for all that he's been through.
9. Catwoman: The Way She Should Be
Who didn't adore Michelle Pfeiffer's Catwoman and Selina Kyle? This is everything Catwoman is and should always be - sneaky, clever, mysterious and tremendously sexy. Not to mention the excellent chemistry between Pfeiffer and Keaton as they were dating at the time Batman Returns was being filmed. Everything from the skin-tight costume, the makeup and even the feline behaviours were spot on. I never could have imagined a better Catwoman/Selina. Her level of sarcasm is impeccable ("Honey, I'm home! Oh, I forgot I'm not married") and she adds plenty of sex appeal to the film. The tragic story of becoming Catwoman and the love affair between her and Bruce Wayne is what makes this character so appealing to audiences. Although she's a villain we can still sympathize and root for her just as we would the hero.
8. Michael Keaton's Chin
Many of you will find this completely absurd. "How can Michael Keaton's chin have anything to do with Tim Burton's adaptation being the best?" I'll tell you why! The chin and lower half of the face in general are the only parts of the body (besides the eyes) that are visible when the Batsuit is being worn so it should really make an impact. Michael Keaton's chin is the best I've seen in comparison to Val Kilmer, George Clooney and even Christian Bale. Batman needs to have an impeccable jaw-line, an attractive mouth and a chin that is not too small, too large or too perfect looking. Every Batman possesses their good and bad qualities in terms of their lower faces. Michael Keaton's face has excellent proportions, beautiful lips and a jaw-line that could cut through glass. Tim Burton's decision to cast Michael Keaton as the beloved Batman likely had little to do with his chin but can we deny that he set the bar rather high for all future Batmen?
7. The Comic-Book Style
We all know that Tim Burton is a visionary. A brilliant one, at that. Many films that he does are re-imaginings of books or films that already exist. In this case however, he is creating a film out of a comic book superhero. Now I'm not going to ramble on and pretend I actually have comic book knowledge - I truly don't. Though I do indeed know what they look like and the general style of them. Of course Batman and Batman Returns do not look identical to a comic book yet they do carry certain elements that make it feel like some scenes have jumped right out of one. Tim Burton has managed to capture the ambiance of Gotham City that we know and love in such a way that pays tribute to the original format of the stories. Dark, gloomy colours set the mood and make us believe that Gotham is really the crime-ridden city from the comic books. Rich, bright colours occasionally seen in costumes and makeup cause the characters to really stand out from the setting and aid in bringing this dreamlike world created by DC comics to life. In these two films, Tim Burton creates an astounding combination of reality and surrealism, which makes for a couple of very entertaining and interesting films to watch. Everything appears dull and dreary until a villain or Batman himself arrives on-screen and Gotham City becomes this fantastical world that we thought could only exist in the pages of our favourite comic books.
6. Michael Gough As Alfred Pennyworth
The late Michael Gough acted as the beloved Alfred Pennyworth for both of Tim Burton's Batman films and the two Joel Schumacher films that followed. This character is one that has always been around to take care of Bruce following the death of his parents. Alfred is trustworthy (he does keep Bruce's biggest secret, after all), very helpful and provides some of the best advice. Gough presents himself as the perfect Alfred. It's almost as if he isn't acting at all - he just is Alfred Pennyworth. A butler and a parental figure that Bruce missed out on - this character is vital to every Batman story. His thorough knowledge of Bruce and his regular behaviours add comedy to a predominantly dark story. Many Batman fans hold a very high regard for Michael Caine's portrayal (which of course is also magnificent), however Michael Gough's sweet and sentimental Alfred gives even the best of actors a run for their money.
5. "Why So Serious?"
Films about superheroes should never take themselves too seriously. In such a surreal world there must be an element of comedy and light-heartedness. Even Marvel's The Avenger's and supporting films have not become lost in a cloud of gloom and dread. Superheroes are extraordinary people (or aliens - I'm looking at you, Superman!) that use the exceptional aspects about themselves to save the world from the most psychotic criminal minds to ever grace the planet. These things don't happen in real life, so why bother trying to fit them into our world? Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy became quite dark and sinister which turns them into those films that you have to really be in the right mood to watch. He tried to make the films as close to reality as he could, but that takes much of the fun out of it. The point of a superhero film should be to transport the viewers into an alternate reality - a different version of the world we really live in. This is never forgotten while watching Tim Burton's rendition - he doesn't try to make us think that this could ever be real. It's a fantasy world for our minds to escape to and that's why they're so entertaining. Batman and Batman Returns contain plenty of seriousness along with many elements of comedy to break the ice, interesting love stories, great characters and an exceptional number of action sequences. Tending to practically every emotion and interest - these are films that anyone could enjoy.
4. The Batsuit
The Batsuit is an absolutely vital part of a Batman film. Acting as Bruce Wayne's disguise, protection and also decked out in all of the latest gadgets - this is how Batman does his work. Everyone knows about Val Kilmer and George Clooney's batsuits with all the usual gear, sculpted muscles for a toned appearance - and some nipples thrown in there as well. It's probably fair to eliminate these right off the bat, wouldn't you agree? A little too over-the-top, even for a superhero film. Christian Bale's suit on the other hand is rather marvelous. It's technologically up-to-date, extremely protective and does not include decorative nipples. Very good. However, the batsuit in Tim Burton's films worn by Michael Keaton just looks classic. It is also up-to-date technologically (for the year the film was made), does not include nipples, and does include the Batman logo! I realize not every superhero wears their logo on their chests but it's such a great addition nonetheless. This suit fits the ambiance of the film and with the yellow logo and belt it looks like it could have popped right out of a comic book.
3. Danny Elfman: Musical Genius
The score is brilliant in these films. Just like the plot, the music is mysterious and exciting with melancholic undertones to suit the characters and action as necessary. Tim Burton has Danny Elfman do the music for nearly every single one of his films and there is a very good reason for that! He does an incredible job of capturing the essence of what it is right to the very core. He assists the audience to feel everything that Tim Burton wants us to feel in terms of characters, plot, or action at all of the right moments. Elfman's music is very dramatic and theatrical, only furthering the intensity of these fantastical films.
2. The Voice
The importance of this one is on a similar level to the chin. Once again, many of you may disagree but I know that I'm not the only person on the planet who considers Batman's voice to be vital to the films! Bruce Wayne of course uses his own natural voice while speaking and therefore must disguise it at least slightly while in Batman uniform. Michael Keaton only subtly deepens his voice while suited up. It is just different enough that even if someone suspected Bruce Wayne, they might second-guess themselves because it's not quite his voice. It may not work in the real world but for a film it certainly suffices. It is most important for audiences to understand what's being said. A voice that is so dramatically disguised will often have its downfalls. Exhibit A: There is nothing that irritates me more than Christian Bale's Batman voice. I find it fundamentally cringe-worthy every single time he speaks. Not to mention that I almost never know what he's saying anyway. He is the most aggravating Batman to listen to while he tries very hard (too hard) not to reveal his identity. It's important to have a change in tone between Bruce Wayne and Batman, however it's far more important for an audience to understand what's being said!
1. Choice of Villains
A good superhero story needs a few exceptional villains to be a true success. The Joker is of course a classic and a fan-favourite in terms of Batman villains. There's a brilliant balance between creepy and funny with a character like this. Completely psychotic and full of puns and sick schemes. The perfect villain! Jack Nicholson found this balance and acted it out beautifully. The best part about Catwoman is that she and Batman are working against each other even though they have an incredible amount of chemistry and a love affair in their regular lives. This is the sort of baddie that we can sympathize with more-so than many others. She's only bad because she was thrown out of a window, after all. Perfectly sound reason for revenge. No need to babble on about her though since she's so great that she has her own section (see #9)! Danny DeVito certainly made one disgusting and disturbing Penguin. A sob story about being left in the sewers due to a deformity and then growing up with penguins - this is one very messed up man! The Penguin is a truly terrifying villain that children may find in their nightmares. He also adds an incredible amount of comedy and certainly an element of the ridiculous with his appearance and completely inappropriate behaviour. Such fun! Any film that contains even one brief moment with Christopher Walken is bound to be a success. Luckily, Batman Returns has plenty of him as the sociopathic Max Shrek. He's that kind of baddie who is already wealthy but is finding ways to become even more so and will do absolutely anything to get there, including making a deal with The Penguin and throwing Selina Kyle out of a window (accidentally creating Catwoman). Having a character whose only villainous quality is his own personality, standing alongside a man who has the appearance of a Penguin and a woman who behaves like a cat adds a fascinating dynamic to the entire story. A brilliant addition to the over-the-top villains in either film. There you have it! 10 reasons why Tim Burton's Batman films really make an impression. I know some will disagree, as the Christopher Nolan films have an incredible fan-base but please remember even when critiquing to keep the conversation respectful in the comments.I appreciate everyone's feedback and can't wait to hear your thoughts!