Batman: 8 Reasons Affleck Must Make Arkham Asylum (& 3 He Shouldn't)
All your favourite villains, under one terrifying roof...

It seems you can't go more than a couple of days without a major rumour attaching itself to an upcoming DC movie: if it's not the alleged production issues on Justice League, it's directors leaving or the promise that Aquaman is going to be darker than Batman v Superman.
The most exciting, without a shadow of a doubt, is the suggestion from Birth Movies Death that the stand-alone Batman film is "going to be crammed with Bat villains, which means that just about every major bad guy you've ever wanted to see in a movie will be in this movie."
Inevitably, that rumour immediately inspires further possibilities, and it's hard to resist the idea that Affleck and Warner Bros might be about to adapt something as villain heavy and as iconic as Arkham Asylum: A Serious House On Serious Earth.
Beyond a mere whimsical suggestion, the appeal of that seminal arc being adapted by someone as talented as Affleck is incredibly hard to deny. And it would be a hell of a way to announce a new solo Batman franchise in the wake of Batman v Superman's well-publicised problems. In that respect, it's not only a good idea for Affleck to tackle that story, it's almost his duty to the fans...
8. The Scope For Lots Of Villains

As a Batman fan, the idea that we might get to see a massive injection of characters from the comics into the Batman screen world is one of those irresistible prospects that don't come up very often. With the way Arkham Asylum is set up, the characters wouldn't even necessarily need to be on screen for a long time - somewhat negating the issue of over-crowding - and you'd get the fan-baiting reaction Warner Bros probably need after Zack Snyder seemingly failed to understand why Batman is popular.
As well as The Joker, Two Face, and KIller Croc, the story would also allow for screen debuts for Clayface, Mad Hatter and Maxie Zeus and basically any villain from the entire Rogue's Gallery, giving some spotlight to previously overlooked characters who may have been deemed unviable for movies.
Cutting the right balance would obviously be a big issue, but having 6 or 7 big names and some lower level mooks would ensure incredible potential for set-pieces and action without it getting too crowded (particularly as the Joker and Two Face would be removed from combat anyway).
7. It's Incredibly Clever

Despite the billing, Arkham Asylum isn't just an opportunity to drop a muscle-bound hero into a swarm of baddies and watch him fight his way out of it: it is a story loaded with subtext that explores the symbolism and pyschology of Batman's villains.
For all the fighting and the potential for numb-skulled, muscle-bound action, it is the book's ideas that really shine through in the end. The story is a deconstruction of the genre too, which should fit with what Zack Snyder has already built: he has been very vocal about his approach to what should perhaps be considered the "post-superhero movie" and deconstruction has been front and centre.
That's not to say Affleck should be taking notes from Snyder (who knows if he'll even still be involved in the DC universe by the time this comes out), but anything that encourages a deeper engagement with the content that also has the potential for fun should be welcomed whole-heartedly.
6. The Graphic Novel Is Incredible

Just as Zack Snyder's attempt to adapt The Dark Knight Returns came from a good place, the idea of using a truly great source comic as a foundation for Affleck's Batman makes perfect sense.
Arkham Asylum isn't just ones of the finest Batman arcs, or Grant Morrison's best work, it's also easily among the finest superhero publications there has ever been. It is as recognisable to fans as titles like The Killing and The Dark Knight Returns, and Warner Bros will be able to count on established brand appeal already should they choose to adapt it.
There are some slight story issues (Batman navigates some of the perils within the Asylum a little too easily), but this dizzying, brilliant journey through the psyche of Batman is as close to flawless as the exalted company it is usually ranked alongside.
5. Might We Get To See Some Actual Detective Work?

Even Tim Burton's Batman movies notoriously neglected one major aspect of Batman as a character - the fact that he is The World's Greatest Detective - and it's high time we got to see some of that in a Batman movie.
While Arkham Asylum obviously has action at the forefront, the fact that it is a story-lead arc that explores psychology as much as it does fisticuffs, means there's scope to bring out Bruce Wayne's investigative side.
Arkham is also underpinned by a mystery - of who is actually behind the riots and trying to get Batman killed - and that would allow for the right balance between action (which gets fans on seats) and intrigue (which keeps them talking when they get back out of them). And the idea of Affleck's Bruce Wayne attempting to follow threads around Arkham's creepy interior is a hell of a thing.
4. There's Threat & Darkness (Without Having To Jump Any Sharks)

We all know that DC and Warner Bros have a certain manifesto for dark, grown up comic book movies. Warner Bros. film chief has already explained why they're darker than the Marvel films, and even with the critical backlash to Zack Snyder's work, it's unlikely they're going to abandon the entire approach now. That would surely represent an embarrassing about turn?
"There is intensity and a seriousness of purpose to some of these characters. The filmmakers who are tackling these properties are making great movies about superheroes; they aren't making superhero movies. And when you are trying to make a good movie, you tackle interesting philosophies and character development."
Considering Silverman's manifesto, Arkahm Asylum fits the brief for seriousness, interesting philosophies and character development, and crucially, it's a clasutrophobic enough story so that Affleck wouldn't be forced into a dramatic escalation that required a Doomsday or Darkseid MacGuffin to sell the final act.
That jumping the shark style escalation in Batman v Superman has already backed Snyder into a corner, which he's going to have to throw bigger and bigger plot contrivances at, and Affleck should already have identified the risk for his own film. It should be a smaller, tighter story (that doesn't mean a smaller cast of characters, obviously), and Arkham fits that requirement perfectly.
3. It Pushes The Joker Logically

After he inevitably steals Suicide Squad (and isn't killed off, because OBVIOUSLY), Warner Bros are probably going to want to further cash in on the popularity of Jared Leto's Joker. It would take something serious for the villain not to be a big focal point in the stand-alone, given that his dynamic with Batman has already been seeded in two films already.
And crucially, Arkham Asylum offers a picture of the Joker that seems already to fit with the way Leto is portraying him. This is a Joker who kills an innocent guard to get Batman's attention, who stacks a game of hide and seek in his own favour so Batman has to fight, who taunts and haunts and creeps. In other words, he's exactly the kind of raw nerve enegry that we've seen ahead of Suicide Squad.
This would be the next logical step for Leto's Joker. Even if he ends up locked away at the end of Suicide Squad, having him seem to orchestrate the inmates taking over the Asylum, torturing a few innocents and looking to ruin Batman's day would be a nice progression to that arc.
2. It Has A Ready Made Legacy

It might be a little premature to start looking too far into the future beyond the stand-alone Batman film that doesn't even have a name yet, but that's precisely what Warner Bros should already be doing.
While this Batman is already an established figure in a "lived-in" world, that doesn't mean he's at the end of his character arc, and if Affleck's first solo movie does well, there's no reason the studio won't be keen to get him back again. The alternative, in fact, would be ludicrous.
The appeal of Arkham Asylum in that respect is that it works as a sort of soft-reset for the Batman universe. Affleck's Batman could well have cleaned Gotham up entirely before moving into semi-retirement, so having him drawn to Arkham to face every single one of those figures would make sense. And as the end of Arkham Asylum sees every villain subsequently freed, the franchise beyond that immediately gets a host of villains who have already been seeded and who are once again at large to commit crimes in their own arcs.
1. It's Basically Die Hard: Batman

At the end of the day, the single most compelling reason for adapting Arkham Asylum is how well it fits in with the image of Batman we've already seen built in Batman v Superman. This hulking, muscular brute is very much an aged action hero drawn back into the rat's maze of criminals, wizened by his experiences, tenacious and not afraid of using extreme methods.
In other words, he couldn't be more like John McClane if he tried.
There's something irresistibly magic about the idea of flipping expectations of a Batman movie and having the star of the show trapped like a rat up a drainpipe and pursued by the people he's locked away over the years. There could even be some scope for a switch towards the horror genre if Killer Croc and Clayface or even Man-Bat are introduced as traditional movie monsters.
It's just a gloriously rewarding idea, that makes Arkham Asylum stand head and shoulders above the other possibilities for adaptation.
But then again, is this really a cut and dry issue? Not exactly, there are also reasons why Affleck might be better suited to another story entire.y And here's why...
3. Under The Red Hood Fits Better

There has never been a better opportunity to adapt Under The Red Hood than right now. We have a Joker on the loose (or presumably on the loose after Suicide Squad), a mystery surrounding a supposedly dead Robin and the most haunted Batman we've yet seen on screen.
When it was initially rumoured that Affleck would be adapting the iconic story, and filling in the gaps in the dead Robin saga, it seemed to fit. There was surely no way they'd go to such lengths to set up the Jason Todd switcheroo in Batman v Superman and then just abandon it, right?
If Affleck does indeed adapt an entirely different story, it's just going to look like Warner Bros dumped their longer term plans (unless of course this isn't a linear movie). Either way, it would be a fairly big missed opportunity.
2. The Ending Is A Bit Silly

For all of the great work that goes into setting up the pay-off that Arkham's administator Dr Chares Cavendish is behind the riots rather than just The Joker, the actual finale itself is a little on the bizarre side.
Channelling Psycho, Morrison has Batman discover Cavendish dressed in a bridal gown in the higher reaches of Arkham, where he reveals he's carrying on the work of Amadeus Arkham, who killed his traumatized mother and then lost his mind when his wife and daughter were raped and murdered.
In light of the haunting backstory, having the Psycho like wedding dress element is flat-out silliness, and you'd have to be concerned how that would translate on the big screen.
1. Too Many Villains Spoil The Broth

If there's one thing Spider-Man 3 and The Amazing Spider-Man 2 have taught us one over-riding lesson, it's that adding too many villains for the sake of falsely escalated drama is a bad idea.
Whether those films struggled because of poor directing decisions or because trying to convince fans to split their hatred across too many villains is a fundamentally flawed approach remains to be seen. But it's a dangerous precedent to try and second guess in a film that needs to be a home-run.
As much as the fanboy in me wants to see all of Batman's rogues' gallery at once, you have to wonder whether cameos would really be satisfying enough. And then there's the concern that spreading too many characters too thin in a limited run-time would do little beyond compromising the impact of the more important pillars of the story.
