Batman Animated Films - Ranked Worst To Best

Batman's got a celebrated history in animation, but which is his best film?

Midway between the mediums of print comics €“ where Batman began €“ and modern live-action films €“ where Batman has reached the widest audience €“ are the animated films and television series centering around Bruce Wayne and the legend of the Dark Knight. Animation is the logical jumping-off point from the comics, and advances in the field have led to some of the most loved comic books of all time being brought to the screen in awesome fashion. Batman: The Animated Series is generally agreed to be the best of the televised offerings, but the animated films are a bit harder to rank. There have been eight films, so far, that are judged here under the criteria of being a "true" Batman film - some adapt famous comic book arcs and some pit Bruce Wayne against fresh, original adversaries, and all of them attempt to create a vision of Gotham unlike any we've seen before. Obviously, the Dark Knight has appeared in more than eight animated movies. Any Justice League animated films have been excluded, although Batman does appear in several (2012's Justice League: Doom), as well as any team-ups (2010's Superman/Batman: Apocalypse) or the like €“ basically, any film where Batman isn€™t the main character. Gotham Knights (2008), while it does indeed focus on Bruce Wayne, is more of a series of short films than one feature, so that's been excluded as well. The latest animated feature, Son of Batman, is set to be released on May 6, 2014, followed later in the year by Assault on Arkham. Before that €“ and with a mild spoiler alert €“ let€™s run down all of the Batman animated films from worst to best.

8. The Batman Vs. Dracula (2005)

While Batman: The Animated Series (rightfully) hogs all of the TV glory, the later small-screen incarnation The Batman really wasn€™t that bad at times. The feature film spinoff, though, 2005€™s The Batman vs. Dracula, is that bad. Gravely disjointed in terms of plot but also animation style, the weak and meandering narrative can€™t seem to just sit still and be a straight story, for Alfred€™s sake. Parts of the overall aesthetic are modernized, like the dreadlocked Joker and the batarangs that glow blue (why do they glow blue?), but meanwhile Gotham City itself looks more like Victorian London. The Penguin, who has no business being in the movie at all, looks like he stepped out of the pages of the Elseworlds tale Gotham by Gaslight. A major qualm €“ speaking of Elseworlds tales €“ is that there is a phenomenal Batman vs. Dracula comic called Red Rain, which spawned two sequels due to commercial and critical success. This comic is probably far too dark for an animated feature adaptation, but surely there would be some element of the original comic incorporated? No? No. In fact, it€™s pretty clear that whoever made this felt no need to look to the comics for inspiration at all. That would be fine, except that the originality at play here is hardly enough to make up for a lack of a comic book muse. Vampire Joker is pretty cool, Vicki Vale gets a big role, and the climax of the film isn€™t complete trash (why does everything glow blue?)€but overall The Batman vs. Dracula is the one animated Batman feature that you can skip.

7. Batman: Mystery Of The Batwoman (2003)

Battling for the distinction of Worst Batman Animated Film is the 2003 feature Mystery of the Batwoman, the third in a trio of films spun out from Batman: The Animated Series. Where The Batman vs. Dracula takes the cake for jarring indifference and sheer ridiculousness, Mystery of the Batwoman has another problem: it is impossibly, inescapably, unbearably, unbelievably boring. There are very few episodes of The Animated Series that are a chore to sit through €“ Mystery of the Batwoman feels like a script written to be a weekly episode, one only meant to fill twenty minutes, and then someone decided to stretch it out into a feature-length tedium-fest. The revealing of the identity of the €œmysterious€ Batwoman is weak, and most viewers will see it coming from the first ten minutes. This serves to render Bruce Wayne as Incompetent Sap rather than World€™s Greatest Detective. Ninety minutes later, most will be wishing they€™d used the time just watching old TAS episodes. The animation style in Mystery of the Batwoman is very much in keeping with that original series, but that€™s really where the favorable points begin and end.

6. Batman & Mr. Freeze: SubZero (1998)

Legend has it that they actually delayed the release of 1998€™s SubZero because the animated movie was way better than Joel Schumacher€™s live-action Batman & Robin. There isn€™t a whole lot more that needs to be said about Clooney€™s Batman and Schwarzenegger€™s Mr. Freeze, and SubZero is indeed a superior story. Acting as a follow-up to the introduction of Victor Fries in the TAS episode "Heart of Ice", SubZero shows a more maniacal Mr. Freeze take desperate measures when the possibility of finally reviving his cryogenically frozen wife is threatened. Nora Fries is the only thing Victor cares about, and he wouldn't blink to take an innocent life to save her. This alone makes him a better villain - and a better character - than anything Joel Schumacher churned out around that time. And yet, in a similar way to Mystery of the Batwoman, SubZero feels at times like a stretched script for a half-hour of television rather than a necessary feature-length endeavor. Conceived, allegedly, as a standalone sequel to 1993's Mask of the Phantasm, the movie has plenty of substance but almost none of the original's charm, and that stretched feeling unfortunately leaves you waiting for the end. There are, however, no "ice" puns, which is a major plus.

5. The Dark Knight Returns, Parts 1 & 2 (2012)

A faithful adaptation of Frank Miller€™s epic 1986 book of the same name, The Dark Knight Returns came out a little over a year ago to much fanfare. It didn€™t disappoint, either €“ by splitting the story into two features, The Dark Knight Returns managed to stay faithful to nearly every panel of Miller€™s book. As far as standalone Batman graphic novels go, there are few that can hold a candle to The Dark Knight Returns. Because of that, a direct adaptation was simultaneously exciting and somewhat limiting. The famous Tunnel of Love scene, the vocal work from Peter Weller and Michael Emerson, that super final battle €“ all of these were fantastic, and for a fan of the graphic novel they were nothing short of awesome to experience in motion. Frankly, the only reason this epic two-parter doesn€™t rank higher is because most of the work was done by Miller a couple decades before. I hate to fault it for that, as the animation work, pacing, and overall aesthetic are superb. Make no mistake - TDKR Parts 1 & 2 are spot-on and form an epic ride, featuring characters new and old from both sides of Crime Alley.

4. Year One (2010)

Three words: Bryan Freakin€™ Cranston. The guy is clearly at the top of his game, coming off a five-year stint as one of the greatest television characters ever created, and he could probably be in any movie he wants from now on. Sure, he€™s bit at the prospect of some high-paying, big-budget Hollywood remakes, including the horrific Total Recall and next year€™s promising Godzilla remake. If you€™re telling me you wouldn€™t do the same, you€™re lying. But Cranston makes time for smaller projects too: he€™s currently playing LBJ on Broadway, and in 2010 he lent his gravelly voice to Detective James Gordon for the animated adaptation of Miller€™s Year One. Why, when he could be a part of nearly anything, did Cranston choose to play Gordon? Does the fact that he€™s a complete badass have anything to do with it, perhaps? Like the animated adaptation of The Dark Knight Returns, Year One is extremely faithful to the original Frank Miller yarn. And again, this is simultaneously great and limiting. I prefer TDKR to Year One (if I had to pick one comic), but Cranston is just perfect for Gordon. All the talk of him taking on the role of Lex Luthor in the Man of Steel sequel made little sense to me, having seen how perfect Cranston would be as Gordon. Both adaptations are great, but Year One makes better use of vocal talent and, by extension, makes for a better film.

3. The Return Of The Joker (2000)

I€™m not the biggest fan of Batman Beyond, especially where the TV show is concerned. While not necessarily €œbad€ in too many direct instances, the overall show was a pale shade of the original animated series. The villains left me pining for the old rogues gallery, Terry left me pining for Bruce, and my discomfort, quite frankly, was just that this isn€™t really Batman. But The Return of the Joker, the 2000 Batman Beyond film, more than makes up for all of that discomfort. It starts in much the same way as your typical Beyond yarn €“ villains are stealing stuff, Terry swoops in and stops them, and we move on to the next. But what follows is a surprisingly complex story that involves Bruce, Terry, and €“ somehow, even though he is supposedly dead €“ the Joker himself. The Return of the Joker recalls the past in an important way, which is something Batman Beyond should have been doing all along. Appearances by the likes of Tim Drake and Harley Quinn (€œSweetie, get mommy€™s bazooka€) further serve to color the story, but Bruce, Terry, and the Joker are front and center. Mark Hamill and Kevin O€™Conner are in top form as usual, and even Will Friedle lends some heart to the usually whiny Terry. Batman Beyond has more than its fair share of absurd, pseudo-futuristic gimmicks employed as plot points, and The Return of the Joker nearly succumbs to a similar absurdity. By grounding that absurdity in the Batman mythos, rather than blindly forging a path that all but ignores everything but the €œBeyond€ part, this film remains one of the best Batman animated features ever made.

2. Under The Red Hood (2010)

Under the Red Hood is unique in many ways. Bruce Greenwood and Jensen Ackles turn in some great vocal work, as does John DiMaggio as Joker, and peripheral characters like Black Mask and Nightwing are likewise treated and voiced with care. This is a story that hustles along like a freight train, and the 75 minute runtime breezes by in an instant. And while Under the Red Hood is based on a comic book arc, it distances itself from the adaptations of Year One and The Dark Knight Returns by occasionally straying from the source material to add new pieces or subtract superfluous ones. Granted, the Red Hood arc is nowhere near as good a comic as anything from Frank Miller, so one could argue that straying from the source material for Year One or TDKR would only worsen things. Still, there€™s no doubt that there€™s bold originality at play here. In fact, the Red Hood film manages to include a famous event from another Batman storyline, A Death in the Family, which is necessary for viewers unfamiliar with the comics and the Red Hood lore. This addendum isn't just tacked on or shoehorned in, though, and A Death in the Family is recalled frequently and, like the main comic arc, changed to better fit the film. This kind of writing makes for an exciting movie, whether you're familiar with the original comics or not.

1. Mask Of The Phantasm (1993)

Did you expect something different? The greatest animated Batman feature, with little doubt, is 1993€™s Mask of the Phantasm. This is the movie that spun directly out from Batman: The Animated Series, and it retained every spire and shadow of that €œDark Deco€ Gotham noir feel. Most importantly, though, unlike the sequels SubZero and Mystery of the Batwoman, Mask of the Phantasm actually has enough story to support a feature-length runtime. All the usual suspects are here and in fine form: Kevin O€™Connor and Mark Hamill as Batman and Joker, superhuman manchild Paul Dini on the writing team, and the creative production team that made The Animated Series so great is operating on all cylinders. While it€™s great to have the old familiar faces around, the new characters are what separates Mask of the Phantasm from nearly every other film on this list. The whole movie feels like a comic from the old Batman heyday, from even before the campy Adam West revival years, due to the fact that the story being told is truly a new one. This is a hero that has enjoyed decades of continuous publication, and fresh stuff is getting harder and harder to come by. There are other things about Mask of the Phantasm that deserve laudation. The theme, like that from from the original series, is near-perfect €“ I€™m a big Hans Zimmer fan, and I like the music in Burton€™s Batman films, but when I picture Gotham City I hear the Phantasm theme in my head. And when Bruce dons the cape and cowl and turns to Alfred, leaving the butler stunned and aghast, Mask of the Phantasm solidifies itself as the quintessential Batman animated film. What are your favorite Batman animated films? Are you looking forward to Son of Batman? Let us know in the comments below!

In this post: 
Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Matt is a writer and musician living in Boston. Read his film reviews at http://motionstatereview.wordpress.com.