Batman V Superman: 10 Characters Scoot McNairy Could Be Playing

Fans V Rumours: Dawn Of Speculation

Nearly one year ago, an anonymous source reported that Scoot McNairy had joined Batman V Superman. Warner Bros wouldn€™t confirm he was in the film and certainly weren't going to say who he was playing if he was. His involvement was discussed only in whispers and rumours until months later when he was spotted on set, seemingly confirming his involvement. But then the plot thickened.

Spy photos taken of him on set showed McNairy sporting giant green socks, presumably there to digitally alter his legs somehow. The speculation on his role immediately grew to a fever pitch. With a library of characters as vast as DC€™s and an actor versatile enough to pull off both superhero and villain, the possibilities seemed almost endless. Superman has hordes of allies and foes, and that€™s before getting into the world of Batman or the expanded DC Universe as a whole.

The Batman side of things is particularly interesting since Scoot, real name John, has recently collaborated with Ben Affleck on both Argo and Gone Girl - could the Bruce Wayne actor put in a good word for his co-star? Maybe, although that's not the real mystery here, is it?

The hushed involvement of a major actor as a mysterious role in a superhero blockbuster is nothing new. But in the age of the internet, unanswered questions like who Scoot€™s playing only lead to a fevered speculation. As such, these are the 10 most likely characters Scoot McNairy could be playing in Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice.


10. Doomsday

There have been rumours that Callan Mulvey is playing Doomsday. There have been rumours that Michael Shannon is playing Doomsday. Even if neither of those are true, it certainly sounds like Doomsday may be in the film. So we have Scoot McNairy without a role and a role without an actor...

The role really is a doozy. In the comics, Doomsday is a genetically-engineered Kyptonian monster, whose most famous exploit involved beating Superman to death. He€™s a giant presence in Superman€™s world, a huge threat to him and very much an unstoppable force of nature.

Despite all of that, unless Doomsday has a civilian alter-ego like in Smallville, it would seem unlikely that McNairy is playing him. And if he was playing the giant rocky monster, he would likely be in a full motion capture suit as opposed to a pair of socks. A role this brutish almost seems like a waste of McNairy€™s talents, and wouldn€™t give him much space to return down the line, but seeing the paltry McNairy portray an eight-foot tall beast could be a sight to behold.


9. Ted Kord

Billionaire by day, under-appreciated crimefighter by night, as Blue Beetle Ted Kord is essentially the more likeable, B-list Batman. Blue Beetle is very much a fan favourite due to his embracing of the fact that he€™s not the top tier guy but can still get the job done.

While we might not expect the costumed counterpart, the civilian identity of Ted Kord absolutely fits into the BvS world, far more than most heroes€™s would. As a businessman and inventor, Kord rubs shoulders with the likes of Lex Luthor and Bruce Wayne, and that professional relationship is likely to play a role in Batman€™s journey to Metropolis.

If that weren€™t enough, in Season 3 of Arrow, Ray Palmer€™s role was originally supposed to be Ted Kord, but the producers were told he wasn€™t available as he was part of their film plans. Scoot McNairy embodying the quirky and affable billionaire businessman? It seems almost too obvious that he would nail the role.


8. Maxwell Lord

Originally a slimy businessman, Lord spent most of his early years in comics running the Justice League International. Over time, he became more of a government agent who was shady without being outright evil. Finally, he was revealed as a criminal mastermind who shot the aforementioned Ted Kordw when he discovered his secret.

Like his role, Lord€™s abilities have fluctuated over time, though in recent years he€™s generally been portrayed as a standard government operative with some mild degree of telepathic powers. In other words, he€™s a threat with both brains and brawn, has connections to the two titular heroes, and would likely be portrayed as villainous.

McNairy has convincingly played villains before and the government agent angle could offer him a new avenue to explore. If anything, it could set Lord up as a major player for Justice League where McNairy could throw down with his pal Ben.


7. Will Magnus

Scoot McNairy€™s current day job is as an outcast genius computer developer on AMC€™s Halt And Catch Fire. Though he might prefer to veer a bit from the same type of role, there€™s no denying that character€™s similarities with Dr. Will Magnus.

Magnus is a brilliant inventor and father to the Metal Men, a heroic team of robots resembling metallic alloys. He€™s also majorly connected to Cyborg, a hero who€™s sure to play a massive role in the DC world going forward. Somewhat like a more pleasant Dr. Frankenstein, Magnus is one of the smartest men in the DCU.

Speaking of the DCU, there€™s always need for developmental scientists and roboticists at places like LexCorp and Wayne Enterprises. This role could be perfect, allowing McNairy to go toe-to-toe with Jesse Eisenberg and Ben Affleck, all the while potentially setting up Cyborg€™s inclusion at the end of the film.


6. Jack Ryder

By day, Jack Ryder is a famous reporter, but he is better known for his bizarre, yet well-intentioned, alter-ego The Creeper. Transformed by an experimental formula of drugs, he€™s given physical enhancements and healing powers at the cost of a crazy alternate personality.

Clearly the Creeper doesn€™t fit into the ultra-serious DCCU, but with Clark working in the news industry, it stands to reason that Ryder could be one of his co-workers at the Daily Planet. Better yet, his presence as an outspoken talk-show host lends itself well to a film where public debate on superheroes seems to be a focal point. Whether advocating for or against Superman, the public needs a singular voice to represent their interests.

Ryder was almost name-dropped in Man Of Steel, and it would make sense if the higher-ups were waiting for an actor like Scoot McNairy to bring him to life. McNairy is not know for his charismatic, outgoing performances, but playing against type could make the character all the more fascinating. The look certainly isn't far off, anyway.


5. Jay Garrick

After seeing green on McNairy€™s legs (and only his legs), many thoughts turned to super-speedster The Flash. Even with Barry Allen now cast, there€™s been multiple Flashes over the years, including the original, Jay Garrick. The current incarnation of Garrick is a resident of the alternate Earth-2. Traditionally an older man, this new version is much younger and received his powers from the dying Roman god Mercury.

With McNairy not being an old man, he falls in line with this new version of Garrick. The character could take on a mentor role to Ezra Miller€™s Flash, while still being nimble enough to join the fight himself. The idea of Scoot as Garrick appeals on two fronts: it allows a skilled actor to explore new territory while also introducing a character with strong ties to the expanded DC mythology.

And don€™t fret about The Flash TV show; if they can live with two Barry Allens, anything can happen.


4. An Injured Civilian

A new character entirely, imagine that! Coupling the climax of Man Of Steel with Scoot€™s enhanced legs and one logical conclusion suggests that he was injured in some way during Superman's climactic Battle of Metropolis against Zod.

As a result, McNairy€™s character could blame Superman for his injury and lead a public crusade, or thank Superman for saving him from a potentially worse fate. Either way, Scoot's character could tie the sequel back to the first film and provide a clear POV to represent the views of the general population towards the Man of Steel.

Frankly, McNairy could be anyone from a government agent, another reporter, or an employee of either Bruce Wayne or Lex Luthor. However, with so many established characters from the comics, why not just use one of their identities, even in name only, and create something new with their characterization? It€™s not as if McNairy isn€™t talented enough to put a fresh spin on something.


3. Jimmy Olsen

Speaking of characters being injured in the Battle of Metropolis, the most substantive rumour concerning McNairy€™s role directly links his character€™s green legs to an injury sustained in the rubble. On top of that, the purported character that was injured is sidekick/photographer/Superman's pal Jimmy Olsen. The rumour goes on to suggest that Jimmy is grateful for Superman saving his life and becomes an advocate of his heroism.

Jimmy€™s an essential character to the Superman mythos, rounding out Clark€™s life at the Daily Planet while reminding the viewers of the good Superman is doing. Furthermore, Jimmy would also function as the likeable, comic relief role, a feature desperately needed in what€™s sure to be another very bleak affair.

McNairy is not know for his comedic chops, so it could be extra hilarious to see an actor known for his dramatic roles embodying the lighthearted naïveté of Jimmy Olsen. Both the actor and the character have a bumbling quality about them and could contrast excitingly with Amy Adams€™s fierce Lois Lane.


2. Dick Grayson

He was the first Robin, the solo vigilante Nightwing, and, for a time, even Batman. Dick Grayson is one of the most essential players in Batman€™s life and the DC Universe as a whole, and it would be very unsurprising to see him show up with his mentor.

Likewise, it would be very unsurprising to see Scoot show up with his Affleck. The two have a natural chemistry together and a dynamic like theirs lends itself perfectly to the long and complicated relationship between Dick and Bruce.

There are knocks against this dynamic duo, however, like the gravestones spotted with Grayson€™s name on it (likely a red herring) or Jena€™s Malone potential presence as the current Robin, but it€™s almost unconscionable to not have McNairy next to Affleck at every turn. Batman should have a Robin and Scoot McNairy should play him.


1. Metallo

The assumption is that, though he may don his famous warsuit, Lex Luthor is not much of a physical threat to Superman or Batman and needs some help in the muscle department, at least for the sake of the film€™s action set pieces and the viewers€™ interest levels.

Enter Metallo, the formerly human soldier John Corben, who€™s suffered an experimental procedure to have his mind transferred into a robotic body powered by a kryptonite heart. His ties to the military fit him seamlessly into Superman€™s world and he could be their answer to how to combat Superman; an answer potentially developed by the aforementioned Lex Luthor.

From a creative standpoint, McNairy said he would have to get his €œhead around emotionally€ for the character, which seems to imply a villain. Scoot€™s villainous side could be perfect to bring Metallo to life as his work in Non-Stop showed he could work as a tormented soldier with a penchant for destruction

Hero, villain, bureaucrat? Who do you think Scoot is playing? Let us know in the comments.


Contributor

Connor loves movies, comics, and TV, and is trying to write for people who feel the same way. When he's not sitting on the couch with his laptop, you might find him lying in his bed with his laptop.