Batman vs. Superman: 8 Actors Who Could Play The Riddler

Riddle us this: who could play Batman's iconic villain?

After looking at 10 possible actors who could make killer new Jokers if given a chance in the upcoming Batman Vs. Superman movie, it's time to turn our obsession on another possible supervillain we're dying to see. Even if major casting announcements have fizzled out as production has officially begun, who's to say there aren't any surprises left in store? At least we can feed our anxious anticipation with some fun by letting our imaginations run wild, and ask the big Question: who would be the best Edward Nygma today? The greatest thing that ever happened to The Riddler (as far as his film feature depictions go) is that Heath Ledger never portrayed him. Instead of the rather daunting prospect of replacing him, the next actor will have to fill only the clownish shoes left almost 20 years ago by Jim Carrey, which is hardly a leap. Watching Carrey's over-the-top performance today could be a pulpy joy, but does anyone really watch it anymore? DC has gone much darker since Christopher Nolan decided to take Batman back to the best of his source again, pretty much leaving all previous Batman adaptations eating his dust. And following Nolan's success, it's hard not to think that The Riddler desperately needs a much darker shade of green. The Riddler has loads of untapped potential for reinvention: obsessed with torturing his victims with insanely convoluted puzzles, traps and sickening clues, a contemporary Riddler could be a mix of Jigsaw and Zodiac Killer, with interior decor sensibilities of someone like Errol from True Detective, just with a little more green. He's the wildest card next to The Joker and as the enigmatic personification of intellectual, ambiguous evil, he's not interested in breaking banks or backs, only minds. Plus, his CV pretty much guarantees cynical sarcasm and entertaining wit, which would be a nice addition to Snyder's notoriously humorless world. So who would do justice to a more contemporary version of The Riddler?

8. Garret Dillahunt

Having a relative unknown take on such an iconic role would make the character rather than the actor stand out, and a role like The Riddler demands to stand out. With that in mind, Garret Dillahunt is the first somewhat obscure actor on this list. Rarely given a chance to show just how good he is because the spotlight keeps getting fixated on the more famous; the more he acts, the more it feels like Dillahunt's big break must be around the corner. Moving away from Carrey's over-the-top farcical Riddler, Dillahunt would bring a slick and unnervingly psychotic demeanour to the man who is obsessed with outsmarting Batman. If you've seen No Country For Old Men you might remember Dillahunt as Tommy Lee Jones' bumbling, soft-hearted deputy. But take that character and compare it to his unhinged gang leader in Last House On The Left and you'll have someone who can turn from compassionate to callous in a blink of an eye. And if his TV work on Raising Hope tells you anything, it's that he's got a knack for adding great flavour to his line delivery. With the kind of sinister ambiguity Dillahunt brings to his villainous roles, he'd have to stretch his range the most from anyone on this list but the dedication he shows towards his work proves that he'd be up for the challenge.

7. Scoot McNairy

Another enigmatic supporting actor whose comparatively unrecognizable face would disappear behind the Riddler's mask to accentuate character; if the dice rolled in Scoot McNairy's favour, he'd add a certain kind of manic entertainment to the role that would make him completely own it. McNairy has been cropping up in huge movies like Best Picture winners Argo and 12 Years A Slave and blending in perfectly; another quality that would suit the role of the mysterious puzzler. McNairy deserves to wear the green and get drunk on brain-teasers primarily because of his delectably scene-chewing role in Killing Them Softly. Alongside Brad Pitt and Ben Mendelson, McNairy plays an untrustworthy junkie who seems ready to snap at any second. Delirious in his paranoia, hilarious in his delivery and ostentatious with his eye movement; McNairy as Nygma is beginning is sounding more and more appropriate. If that wasn't enough, watch the short Verge movie where he involves himself in a paradox of etiquette - he might as well dial Batman right after he finishes eating and ask him to name three things a man loves but never begs for as his victim screams in the basement below.

6. James Badge Dale

Sure, you might be asking yourself "Does his role in Iron Man 3 place him outside of this equation?" Or even perhaps, "James Badge Who?" (though the latter is much less likely following some break out supporting roles in the past few years). But being in a previous comic book film can actually work in the actor's favour because it never hurts to have comic book film experience on the CV (see Chris Evans,) and it is the more obscure but brilliant actors like James Badge Dale who can pull off Riddler's genius deductive reasoning out of nowhere and with one glare. While he commanded every single scene of his in Iron Man 3 (a mandatory qualification for any potential Riddler), Dale isn't here because of that role specifically. He played the no-bullsh*tting action badass quite well in stuff like World War Z and TV's 24, but it's his film-stealing scene as a cancer patient (literally, Gaunt Young Man) in Flight that shows exactly why he would translate perfectly into a chilling and super intense Edward Nygma, the likes of which we've never seen before on film. When he says "People are either drawn to me, or they pretend like they can't see me... it's a trip" just change "trip" with "trick", give the man a green suit and it would be like two pieces of the same jigsaw puzzle, fitting perfectly and sending chills down your spine.

5. Jackie Earle Haley

Riddle us this: which three names appeared as one in the form of a nightmare, played by the voice of the greatest Riddler of all? You live to see another day if you answered Jackie Earle Haley, who stepped into Robert Englund's iconic Freddie Kruger role €“ having already shown in The Watchmen that he could play delightfully dark, even grotesque anti-hero types. As Rorshach, Haley proved how seamlessly he is able to get under the skin of complex fan-favourite comic book characters, and the mask that played so much of a role in that character will also protect him from the over-familiarity that can make fans baulk at the suggestion of reusing comic book movie actors for other roles. And of course, if he can bring his best for Snyder once, he probably can do again. Bringing back this idea of darkness which a movie version of The Riddler is begging for, Haley's performances in Little Children, Watchmen and Shutter Island should make any casting director seriously consider his name, but check out his interviews on Rorshach's "complexity of the grey area" as well, or how he talks about his character Guerrero in Human Target for further indication of his worthiness. For the latter, he literally says "when he kinda tells you something, and it's threatening, you're wondering whether he's bluffing. There's something about this guy, you just don't wanna call him on his bluff". Now tell us that doesn't sound like the perfect brief for The Riddler...

4. Ben Foster

Adding to the list of underrated talents who could breathe new life into a character like The Riddler is Ben Foster, who is another talent who tends to find himself in more sidelined roles, and yet who has shown that he has the capability to offer a juicy villainous role in some dark and delighting roles in the past. He's got the charm, the image of cunning and most importantly that intangible look of darkness, and imbalance that tends to mean his more villainous, or morally ambiguous roles are his best. And while he's known for mostly playing hotheads, Foster has shown that he's got the talent for much more dimension. His Charlie Prince in 3:10 To Yuma is the indication you should need to see that Foster would have all sorts of fun toying with Batman, seeking with singular focus to outsmart him while concocting all kinds of dangers for innocent Gothamites as pawns in his game. In The Messenger Foster also proves that he is more than capable of the acting chops necessary to give the Riddler more substance, and the kind of charisma that would work to establishing the necessary spark of sympathy audiences must feel for even the most evil of villains. And if you want to see The Riddler get physical? Check out Foster's pitbull energy in Alpha Dog for indication that he is more than capable of such an added dimension to his performances.

3. Adam Driver

At the age of 30 Adam Driver is the exact same age as Jesse Eisenberg who has just been cast Lex Luthor, so if Snyder and co. decide to stick with youthful villains, they would need to look no further than the largely untapped potential of this young man. Driver is currently one of the most exciting actors to burst out of television and he has certain intangible geek credentials that would make him a strong option - which is perhaps why he was deemed such a strong candidate for Star Wars Episode VII. The scene where his Adam fights with Hannah on the street in Girls (check it here) is filled with major raw emotion that showcases the kind of passion Driver would bring to a sinister role like a modern Riddler, and there's something delightfully appealing to his on screen demeanour, and specifically his nerdy intellect that would work well in a new version of the Riddler, who would be the perfect antithesis to Carrey's caricature. He's certainly charismatic enough to fill the considerable green shoes of the character, and though he is perhaps taller than you might expect of a Riddler, that too might stand as a benefit to distinguishing him from the last on-screen version of the character.

2. John Hawkes

John Hawkes' chief virtue that makes him stand out in this fantasy casting race is that he would look incredible in the Riddler's iconic outfit, but that would perhaps ignore the fact that he is easily one of the most accomplished and critically lauded actors on this list. He has the pedigree to pull off the kind of villainous part that stays with audiences, burrowing under the skin the same way that Ledger's Joker and Willem Dafoe's Green Goblin memorably did: his Oscar-nominated Winter's Bone performance proves that succinctly, and there is a lot in his performance as the sinfully ethereal cult leader in Martha Marcy May Marlene that suggests his appropriateness for the role. Since the added attention afforded him in the wake of Winter's Bone, Hawkes' career has been building with greater speed than before that watershed moment, culminating in another critically beloved turn in The Sessions, and it would be great to see him tackle a completely different, and far more animated role in the shape of the Riddler. If his facial expressions and the emotion of his The Sessions performance are enough to warrant an Oscar nomination, you have to wonder what he would do with something as colourful as that character.

1. Walton Goggins

Walton Goggins, whose underused charisma has been slowly building a fanbase from his TV work on The Shield and Justified ever since 2002, and he also proved that nonchalant sadism can come as second nature in his portrayal of Billy Crash in Django Unchained. He's disappeared behind flamboyant drag in Sons Of Anarchy and shared the role of "El Camaleon" in Machette Kills with Lady Gaga and Antonio Banderas, and he certainly has the credentials to make for a memorable Riddler. As no stranger to the wild side of cinema, and the perfect balance of comical darkness and unhinged ethics, Goggins would be a fantastic addition to the cast. Aside from the fact that his look (with his beady eyes and sinister smile) would make for an irresistible version of Edward Nygma, he has the kind of on-screen presence that begs for a role as considerable and villainous as the contemporary Riddler's deserves to be. The way he talks about coke and rape like he's reading the morning papers in Predators or how he dances around while preaching in Justified are only a couple of examples of why he'd be perfect. While all the other guys are appropriately suited to play a variety of modern Riddler versions, it feels like Goggins has a bit of all of the above and could tackle any version thrown at him: be it mass murderer, genius schemer or psychotic obsessive. For added incentive, they could make The Riddler's background from the South and Goggins would snarl his way into becoming one of the most memorable Batman villains ever. Like these choices? Got better ones? Let us know!

Contributor
Contributor

Nik's passions reside in writing, discussing and watching movies of all sorts. He also loves dogs, tennis, comics and stuff. He lives irresponsibly in Montreal and tweets random movie things @NikGrape.