Batman vs Superman Movie: 10 Replacements If Ben Affleck Pulls Out

With Affleck threatening to walk away from the now delayed production, just who could Zack Snyder turn to if he loses his controversial lead?

Nearly everyone in the world has had something to say about Ben Affleck taking on the coveted role of Bruce Wayne for the upcoming Batman Vs Superman: just have a quick Google. It's been very rare though that anyone's had anything nice to say; Christian Bale did such a fantastically immersive job with this icon: what on Earth is the Daredevil himself going to do with it? After the huge backlash however, the naysayers may have their wish granted. Affleck is threatening to walk away from the project, apparently due to his concerns over David S. Goyer's screenplay, but reports suggest that the delays rumoured to push the movie back a year - also threatening Affleck's involvement with his Live By Night adaptation - are also a big concern to the star. So what if Ben Affleck pulls out? Warner Bros. would be back to square one in casting Batman. It should be mentioned that this rumour is extremely dubious; no one even close to the movie has so much as mentioned it, and let's face it, it's probably snowballed due to Affleck's almost unanimous unpopularity. If there was a shred of truth in the whispers though, it would prompt the question: who else is capable of playing Bruce Wayne now? Let's have a look at ten candidates, and remember to add your choices to the comments below!

10. Bradley Cooper

The hugely popular Hangover star is one name that has to play a superhero sooner rather than later. He'd no doubt ooze charm and magnetism as a millionaire, and as he's proved in the likes of The A-Team, he has the physique to kick ass. Though questions remain on whether he could handle the darkness of the part, his chemistry with Henry Cavill would be fascinating; he's a big screen presence, he's hugely talented, and he's due a role like this, isn't he? It would be a chance for Cooper to show the world that's he's not just a pretty face, competent at the comedy. He's probably not many fans' top choice, but there's no doubt he'd put a unique spin on the Caped Crusader.

9. Michael C. Hall

One actor who is used to darkness however, Michael C. Hall is perhaps best known for his work as serial-killing Dexter. Dexter is a hero with a troubled past, taking the law into his own hands, but always adhering to a moral code: Hall plays the double-life with exquisite balance, and though he's not the most glamourous actor on this list, he's certainly one who's due a big break, rather like Cavill was in Man of Steel. He's finished Dexter for good now it would seem, and what better role to leap into? Though he's largely inexperienced in Hollywood, that could work in his favour; if Affleck does pull out, Warner Bros. will likely want to avoid such a backlash again. Going for someone not quite so well known might be a shrewd move, and Hall would definitely be a good option.

8. Tom Hiddleston

Having starred in both the Avengers and Thor as Loki, Hiddleston's not only used to playing a superhero, but a dark one at that. And while he might not be as strong or commanding as the great Christian Bale, he can certainly crank up the ferocity and snarl like a demon. Hiddleston might not be the obvious choice for Batman - he's not a traditional choice, at all - but casting someone more as a psychological opponent for Superman, a character who has strong in mind as well as in body, might put a spin on the role that differentiates it from Bale's performance. It's unlikely that Tom Hiddleston would find himself in two huge superhero roles, but wouldn't Tumblr go mad if he did? It would provide a unique opportunity to the Brit, and not one that would likely come around again any time soon.

7. Milo Ventimiglia

Like Michael C. Hall, Milo Ventimiglia is another lesser-known name, most famous for his stint on Heroes, as the lovely Peter Petrelli. As Ventimiglia proved on that show, he's a captivating actor with both likeability and a vicious side. Like Hiddleston, he's not particularly well-built, but he's someone who feels like a superhero already; he'd provide an interesting contrast to Cavill and would relish the opportunity of such a huge break. Whether he's macho enough to take on the role is perhaps the biggest question facing him; but having declared that he's a huge fan of the character, and of the Nolan films, he's not an actor who'd turn it down if the part fell to him.

6. Idris Elba

One of the names constantly mentioned in relation to both James Bond and Doctor Who, Idris Elba would be fascinating as Bruce Wayne too. Not only would Elba bring a raging brutality to the character, he'd be skilled at the quieter, introspective moments of the man as well. At over six foot and 215 pounds, he'd be a very physical force, but would Warner Bros. really cast a black Batman? There was enough controversy when he landed the part of Heimdall in Thor, and this is a monumental role. That's something that Elba himself would probably want to avoid, given that he's fed up with being touted as "a possible black Bond" and not just "a possible Bond". Elba's a fantastic actor though, and would give an intriguing performance as Batman, regardless of the colour of his skin.

5. Jon Hamm

Mad Men star Jon Hamm is another name who's been touted for the role of Batman, despite being great friends with Ben Affleck. There's no doubting that he specialises in cutthroat, no-nonsense characters, but Hamm's also capable of tragedy and soul-searching; he's extremely versatile, a huge authority figure, and would be a massive contrast to Christian Bale. Hamm may have called the franchise "a young man's game", but that's even more reason to watch him opposite Cavill; there would be a gripping contradiction between the young farmboy struggling with his gifts, and the wiser city playboy. Hamm would be perfect in that respect. He's a favourite with many fans, and has in the past, even been mentioned in relation to playing an older Superman. Cast him in the film one way or another: he would be excellent.

4. Armie Hammer

Armie Hammer Batman The 6' 5 Social Network star is also someone perma-linked with the role of Batman, perhaps due to the fact he was cast in the cancelled 2007 Justice League flick. He's imposing, handsome and like Cavill, a young rising star, who was also considered for Clark in Man in Steel; he apparently ruled himself out of the running to play Batman, claiming he wasn't a fan of superhero movies - "If you have a guy who is supposed to be invulnerable, then what's the point?" - but would he really turn down such a huge role? This is the kind of part that would propel him to superstardom. If Affleck does leave the project though, would the 27-year-old mature enough to fill his shoes? That's another question entirely. He may have the presence and the look, but is he capable of playing a ruthless anti-hero?

3. Karl Urban

Karlurban Karl Urban is another actor who would thrive in such a huge leading role; he even has comic book experience, having played Judge Dredd in 2012. And if his role as Bones in Star Trek is anything to go by, Urban would meticulously study the finer details in Bruce Wayne's characterisation. He's charming enough for sure, engaging, with a fantastic voice, and a frightening streak; the New Zealander would certainly be a different kind of Wayne from Bale's portrayal, but he'd keep some of the facets that made Nolan's Batman so engrossing. Would Urban have time for such a big film though? There's his commitment to Star Trek, the possibility of more Almost Human, and anyway, who says he'd want a role similar to Dredd?

2. Michael Fassbender

A name that arose the other day in the comments section of WhatCulture when discussing future James Bonds, Michael Fassbender is a much sought-after and hugely respected name who would play a spellbinding Bruce Wayne. The Irish-German star is famous for his effortless portrayal of tormented personalities; that and a hypnotising screen presence would make him a great choice alone, but just look at his versatility, and the mind just boggles on what unknown qualities he could bring to the role. He's certainly play more of an intellectual Batman to a physical one, but he's an actor who, like Bale, would totally immerse himself in the part. Whether he fancies playing two superhero goliaths - he's Magneto in the X-Men films - is another matter. But there's no denying he'd be a mouthwatering replacement for Affleck.

1. Ryan Gosling

And finally, perhaps the fans' number one choice, should Ben Affleck pull out of the film. Ryan Gosling apparently turned the role down, due to his concern over sequels, but should he change his mind, he'd no doubt be excellent in the role. He's only 33, and though producers reportedly want an older Batman, he'd be mercurial and chilling, as simmering as Cavill, and hugely different to the multi-faceted Bale version of the character. As seen in Drive, he's fantastically believable as a moonlighting hero, and in Only God Forgives, he's as entrancing as the character of Batman would demand; he has an understated darkness to many of his characters, and he'd be what many see as the perfect anti-hero of this franchise. Who would you like to see in the role though? Do you hope that Ben Affleck walks away from the film? Do you think he'll make a good Batman after all? Comment below!

Contributor
Contributor

Mark White hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.