Baywatch Review: 2 Ups & 8 Downs

Even The Rock can't save it.

Baywatch Dwayne Johnson Zac Efron Kelly Rhorbach Jon Bass Alexandra Daddario Ilfenesh Hadera
Paramount

The dubiously-anticipated big-screen Baywatch reboot is almost here, and...critics have had a good time bashing it so far, in what's likely to end up one of the summer's most disappointing movies.

Despite the promise of the Dwayne Johnson-led action comedy being a spirited, R-rated reinvention of the admittedly rather lame TV source material, the end product is ultimately an incredibly inconsistent affair that fails to exploit its talented cast for all they're worth.

Though Baywatch is likely to be pretty critic-proof in the long run and perform decently at the box office regardless, it doesn't exactly leave one eager for the sequel that it so blatantly begs for as the credits roll...

Downs...

8. It's Not Sexy Enough

Baywatch Dwayne Johnson Alexandra Daddario.png
Paramount Pictures

The original TV show was unavoidably tethered to the constraints of network TV, and so it's not at all surprising that it was a pretty mild affair despite its reputation for being raunchy.

This Hollywood reboot, however, is blessed with an R-rating, which naturally caused fans to expect a major uptick in the amount of skin on show. As it turns out though, rather than baring boobs and butts left and right, the most nudity audiences will see is a dead man's penis. Really.

Considering that Zac Efron and Dwayne Johnson have bared their behinds before and Daddario has stripped off for True Detective, it's pretty surprising that they all keep themselves in swimsuits throughout...and The Rock even wears shirts in scenes when he really doesn't have to.

Considering the potential to massively up the raunch factor for the late-teen crowd, it feels like a wasted opportunity to blow it merely on profanity, drug use, occasional gore and that aforementioned dead dick.


7. The Awful Visual Effects

Baywatch Dwayne Johnson
Paramount

This is what you get when you make a two-hour action movie starring The Rock and Zac Efron and budget it at around $40 million.

Something's gotta give somewhere, and it ends up being the visual effects, resulting in the film's numerous aquatic action sequences looking like hot garbage.

The most egregious sequence occurs early on, when the Baywatch team are saving several women from a burning boat. It's clear that the heroes have simply been composited in via green screen, and the CGI fire in particular looks like something that wouldn't pass muster in a PS2 game.

To make matters worse, the film's gag reel shows numerous dialogue-driven scenes filmed entirely against a green screen, which is just embarrassing.


6. Priyanka Chopra's Incredibly Boring Villain

Baywatch Priyanka Chopra
Paramount Pictures

Nobody expects a world-class plot from Baywatch, and to that end the movie does live down to the TV show's lame standards, but would it have killed writers Damian Shannon and Mark Swift to put just a little more effort in?

The central villain plot is your garden variety crime kingpin drug territory nonsense, and though the lovely Priyanka Chopra is plenty nice to look at, her baddie is incredibly boring outside of the fact that she's a woman (hilariously, when Johnson calls her crazy, she retorts, "If I was a man, you'd call me driven").

She's otherwise totally humourless and just a thoroughly bland character. It's not really Chopra's fault because the character is written as such, but overall the crime plot just detracts from the movie's sense of fun.


5. There Are Several Forced Romances

Baywatch Alexandra Daddario Zac Efron
Paramount

You know what this movie didn't need? A love story. There are in fact two focal romances, both of them utterly absurd, though one a lot less believable than the other.

The first is Zac Efron's attempts to woo Alexandra Daddario, which looks set to subvert expectations, but nope, it actually goes the whole earnest hog by film's end in rather head-scratching fashion.

Then there's the decidedly less plausible love-in between Kelly Rohrbach's stunner C.J. and Jon Bass' schlub lifeguard Ronnie. She's just way too hot for it to be remotely believable, and while it could've had some satirical potential, the romance is actually played totally straight, making the final payoff that much more bizarre.


4. The Cast Is Frequently Wasted

Baywatch 2017
Paramount

Johnson and Efron proudly take center stage and Daddario has her moments, but most everyone else is thoroughly mis-utilised here.

Weirdly, the other three Baywatch members actually disappear from the movie for about 20-or-so minutes at the midway point for no discernible reason, and later Johnson himself is even briefly sidelined, which is never a good thing.

That's to say nothing of comic genius Hannibal Buress, who gets one or two punchy one-liners before disappointingly exiting the film, and the cameos from David Hasselhoff and Pamela Anderson are pretty perfunctory, one-note affairs.

Speaking of Pamela Anderson...


3. Kelly Rohrbach Is No Pamela Anderson

Baywatch CJ
Paramount

The most iconic thing about the original show is, of course, Pamela Anderson as C.J. Parker, and the new movie attempts to replicate that appeal by recasting the character with model-turned-actress Kelly Rohrbach.

Though Rohrbach certainly meets the physical requirements of the part and the camera loves her, she lacks the confident sexuality of Anderson and ends up coming across more as blandly ditzy than powerful in all of her beauty.

She's not terrible by any means, but Anderson's role is a tough one to fill, and she doesn't remotely hit the mark.


2. The Gags Are Incredibly Hit-And-Miss

Baywatch Dwayne Johnson
Paramount

Unsurprisingly, the script is all over the place, resulting in a gag-rate that's incredibly inconsistent. There are laughs to be had, sure, but they're sandwiched between joke after joke that falls horrendously flat, reeking of first draft material that desperately needed another pass.

There's a clear effort made to copy the successful Jump Street formula, but it's not as smart or as weird as those movies, the tone is much more jumbled, and simply, the laugh count is depressingly low at times.

There are entire sections of this movie which pass without a joke because the film gets way too invested in its preposterous crime thriller plot, and it suffers tremendously as a result.


1. It's Way, Way Too Long

Baywatch Dwayne Johnson Zac Efron
Paramount

Arguably the movie's biggest issue is its excessive length, clocking in at a thoroughly unreasonable 116 minutes, which is surely at least 20 minutes longer than it needed to be.

Bloated out with leaden crime caper subplots and countless scenes that service neither the laughs nor the characters, it's surprising director Seth Gordon wasn't forced to make more cuts in post-production, and this might be a rare case where some added studio intervention might've resulted in a more enjoyable end product.

Considering that several scenes from the trailers don't even appear in the final film (such as Johnson and Efron riding a moped together), it's clear that Baywatch was thoroughly over-written from the outset.

Bad though it is, Baywatch isn't without a redeeming feature or two, though...


Ups

2. The Rock & Zac Efron's Awesome Chemistry

Baywatch Dwayne Johnson Zac Efron
Paramount

Yes, all the film's flaws considered, The Rock and Zac Efron sure ain't phoning it in here, and they do deliver genuinely entertaining performances even though they're working from thoroughly mediocre material.

Johnson is a mountain of charisma as usual and makes for a far more likeable Mitch Buchannon than David Hasselhoff ever was, and his frequent run-ins with Efron's arrogant Olympian Matt Brody do make for a sometimes-compelling sit.

Efron meanwhile continues to prove himself a natural comic talent, and though he's still waiting for that big breakout role, he turns in some great work here. It's just a shame they're both struggling throughout to elevate such a lousy script.


1. It's Incredibly Easy Viewing

Baywatch Alexandra Daddario Ilfenesh Hadera
Paramount

All in all, Baywatch is an incredibly easy sit. It's a typical brainless comedy people tend to watch on boozy Friday nights or bored Sundays when they want something undemanding starring charming, attractive people.

It's not aggressively annoying for the most part and delivers some basic joys, even if the film quickly falls apart under any real scrutiny. Still, for many, the simplicity of its cheesy homages to the original show and a cast kitted out in swimsuits will deliver all that they want and expect.

It's low-effort enough that there's not much incentive to actually pay good money to see it now, but if streamed at home in a few months, it's easy to see the appeal.

What are your expectations for Baywatch? Shout them out in the comments!


In this post: 
Baywatch
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.