Benedict Cumberbatch: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked
Tinker, Tailor, Sherlock, Strange...

Benedict Cumberbatch is one of the most intriguing character actors currently working, which is precisely why Hollywood is deeply in love with him. He carries an almost regal majesty - an "odd duck" spirit, it's been called elsewhere - that particularly suits strange characters, or even Strange ones, if you're a fan of puns. And he combines that with a classical, RSC approach to characterisation and presence that means he's an utterly irresistible watch.
This week, the Englishman debuts in the Marvel cinematic universe as Doctor Stephen Strange, opening the doors on the cosmic arm of the MCU and heralding a whole new era for the studio. Rather wonderfully, the film is an utter success, and that is tied very closely to the man leading it. The fact that the future of Marvel movies rests on his shoulders is a very good thing.
And while his star is in the ascendancy, his work in the best bore the marks of a man learning his craft quickly, and as such there are uneven moments and flat out bad performances. It just so happens that they tend to be balanced by some incredible ones. So in honour of Doctor Strange's release, we're looking at both.
First, the great performances...
5 Awesome Performances
5. Alan Turing - The Imitation Game (2014)

Putting aside all empty accusations of Oscar-baiting, The Imitation Game is a quite stunning achievement because of how reluctant it is to cow to any politicised agenda, despite the urge - nay, the near obligation - to focus on one element of the story more.
The film, which is as grim and heart-breaking at times as it is uplifting and affirmative at others, is not a grotesque rake through the Tragedy Of Alan Turing's life - how he was failed, how he was abused and how he was singularly let down by everyone his work managed to save - it is a celebration of his genius.
As such, it consciously withholds part of itself, allowing it to bubble more under the surface and encouraging the audience to fill in the gaps - and it is a narrative device mirrored entirely in the central performance. Cumberbatch is subtle, restrained and extraordinary - detached somewhat in that regal/alien way he works so well and yet he is uncomfortably, devastatingly sympathetic.
4. Richard III - The Hollow Crown (2016)

For many fans, Benedict Cumberbatch's finest performance wasn't one captured on screen at all (albeit apart from beam-backs into cinemas) - in the exceptional Frankenstein. He was incredible as both monster and maker, and it was merely a confirmation of his ability as a stage actor.
His second most purely theatrical performance comes in Richard III, the finale of the second run of the exceptional The Hollow Crown (a series which also made the best of Ben Whishaw back in 2012). There is something about his profile and presence that lends itself rather perfectly to Shakespeare: the Bard was the master of monstrous, dominant performance writing - soloquies that burst forth from stages to be the most memorable elements of grand productions and distilled entire characters in comparatively small, pregnant speeches.
That is exactly the sort of dynamic that suits Cumberbatch so well in Richard III, in which he plays both monster and man again - this time wrapped in the same body - and there is a passion and a subtlety that is as complex as it is impressive.
3. Alexander Masters - Stuart: A Life Backwards (2007)

Long before he and Tom Hardy were household names, they starred together in the supremely affecting BBC drama Stuart: A Life Backwards, which is far from the appreciated gem it deserves to be. It seems now to only be discovered by fans purely accidentally having been made for TV (though having the twin titans of the BBC and HBO pushing it should count for me).
The film is all about Hardy's performance on the surface: it is far showier and far more of a construction, but Cumberbatch's understated, subtle balance. He plays Alexander Masters - the author of the stunning book the film is based on - complete with a disarmingly authentic Scottish accent and he's brilliant.
It's through his eyes we watch Stuart's story unfold, and his empathy and sympathy and disgust that we feel rawest as the tragic figure's life unravels its mysteries. It was quite the announcement performance for both men.
2. Stephen Strange - Doctor Strange (2016)

There's a good reason Kevin Feige was so keen to get his first choice into Doctor Strange's cape, and it is perfectly sold in his performance as the talisman of the cosmic arm of the MCU. He is the perfect blend of aloof, arrogant and exotic, and there is a brilliant sort of otherness to him that has been so successful in his other most famous role to date (more of which soon).
Cumberbatch's Strange is the heir apparent to Robert Downey Jr's crown as the leader of the MCU, and he has clearly been asked to unblur the distinction between the characters on purpose. His Strange is a posturing, detached playboy with a penchant for fast cars and worldly commodities, and difficulty forming relationships, just like Stark. In this early stage, he is almost unlikeable BUT he pulls it back as RDJ did with a cheeky, disarming charm and a pleasant quirkiness that kept even his worst moments crossing the line too far.
And then as he changes over the course of his arc, the transformation is entirely sympathetic - we believe his reluctance to drop his egotism just as much as his final revelation, and his final emergence from that progressive cocoon marks the introduction of one of the MCU's immediately most compelling characters.
1. Sherlock Holmes - Sherlock (2010-)

As alluded to in the Strange point, Cumberbatch has a certain, tangible strangeness and theatricality that works perfectly for characters on the oddness spectrum, and they don't come more well-suited than Sherlock Holmes.
His strangeness in this case is timeless: Holmes' aloofness transformed into something almost medical, but still tinged with charm and empathy and the classical build of the character. It is almost definitive, which is ridiculous considering how many actors have played the part in the past, and it's certainly the most layered of all of the modern iterations.
Alongside Martin Freeman, Cumberbatch has built a warming chemistry that is comforting and charming in equal measure, with dark shards cutting across it that add complexity and intrigue. It's a complete performance, eminently watchable and infectious and the final testament to its success is how much clamour there always is to see more of it.
And now on to the poorer performances...
5 That Sucked
5. Dormammu - Doctor Strange (2016)

Say what you want about Doctor Strange, and how excellent the scene between the dread demon Dormammu and the good doctor Strange is at the climax of the film, there's a pretty major issue with it: Dormammu himself.
It is instantly regrettable that Marvel chose not to go with the more traditional fiery head design of the comics and instead went with a sort of giant fluid energy ghost with corduroy face. It has since emerged after the European release that Cumberbatch is the face behind the ripples, following on from his mo-cap work on the Hobbit movies.
The performance is almost entirely swallowed by the design, and the odd narrative speed that makes what is supposed to be an eternal time loop into a five minute montage with Dormammu losing his mind like a giant toddler. The emotion is all well and good, but this is literally an immortal, thousands of years old creature who would have the patience of a glacier, but who loses patience with Strange's antics after literally minutes. It's pretty ruinous of the scene.
4. Julian Assange - The Fifth Estate (2013)

The general consensus seems to be that Cumberbatch is excellent in the poorly received adaptation of the Wikileaks story, which was something of a critical bust, but the performance and the film are one and the same thing.
The direction is poor at worst and utterly misguided at best, and while there is some pleasure to be had watching the actor's performance as Assange - or a cliched vision of idiosyncratic geniuses in general - the film is so relentlessly bland that it's hard to raise any sort of enthusiasm for Cumberbatch.
The result, then, is a sort of weird living museum piece - notable for its similarity, but almost completely devoid of charisma or impressive ornamentation. It's not so much a performance as an impression, and that's in no way as rewarding.
3. James - Third Star (2010)

Back in 2010, Cumberbatch was still an emerging star, and he wasn't quite as efficient at picking his roles.
Third Star isn't quite the right fit, it's a typical debut feature but without making the kind of statements directors make later in their work when they're more assured. There are nice little moments, and a loving fascination with the countryside, but it's a little soppy and a little meagre to really last in the memory.
The problem is that a lot of it is directionless and it almost wouldn't matter how good Cumberbatch is, it's just an utterly forgettable frame and a forgettable performance. And rather unfortunately, he's not at all likeable (and neither are his cohorts, for that matter), even if their relationships are the only thing that really ring true in the film.
2. Smaug - The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug (2013)

His Smaug is far from the worst part of The Hobbit (that accolade goes to the directing), but it feels like an exercise in trick casting: an under-directed performance built mostly on Cumberbatch's profile rather than an actual performance of the character. It's almost like they've told him to go and have fun and haven't dared try and restrain him.
The whole Hobbit trilogy feels like a smug, self-congratulatory masturbation fest, attempting to take what made the Lord Of The Rings work and distilling it, bafflingly, down to "well, it was long, so let's do that again". There's nothing in Smaug of Cumberbatch on the same level as Andy Serkis' deeply personal Gollum performance.
And the worst thing you can say about it is that it really doesn't feel like he's behind the mo-cap, which is fatal for a character actor like him.
1. All - Zoolanders 2 (2016)

Why Benedict, WHY?!
In a film populated by numb-headed cameos designed to distract from the fact that the film is utterly terrible, Cumberbatch's cameo as All - a deeply offensive androgynous uber-model is one of the cherries on top of the sundae. It's pointless - a cheap shot - and not even remotely funny or particularly insightful. It's not like there are a load of weird alien-like models defining the modern industry.
The performance itself suits the material, but that doesn't make it any more forgivable. Which it might have been had the comedy worked or been particularly clever. It didn't and it wasn't.
Which are your favourite and least favourite Benedict Cumberbatch performances? Share your favourites below in the comments thread.