Bill Murray: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

"Human sacrifice! Dogs and cats living together! Mass hysteria!"

Reportedly cantankerous, resistent for way too long over the Ghostbusters threequel (probably because he's the only person to acknowledge the sequel was poor) and as creatively diverse as a pick'n'mix, Bill Murray is an indie actor who doesn't really make indie movies. He flits from one genre to another, as comfortable in and as curious about making a war ensemble as a Grumpy Old Men surrogate (like this week's release St Vincent) and his name is the only advertising some fans need to see any film. As every story of Murray tending bar, or turning up at house parties appears, you get the feeling that he's now beyond the stage where he cares what anyone thinks of him (did he ever?) though there's the very real threat that he could become too much of a parody of himself. His life right now already reads like the sequel to Joaquin Phoenix's I'm Still Here. But it's Murray, so it's utterly forgivable. Not that he cares either way. With St Vincent now hitting cinemas, it's time to look back on the career of a truly cherished actor: the way he's beloved now you'd think he hadn't made any missteps on is way to the special level of fame he enjoys. He has, and in some style. Were there licence to celebrate an actor being himself, Murray would inevitably qualify for Zombieland (and perhaps even Space Jam), but given the calibre of most of his work it's inevitable that moments when he's just playing around as himself will be squeezed out.

5 Awesome Performances

5. Frank Cross - Scrooged (1988)

Not universally loved, or indeed critically acclaimed, Murray's take on A Christmas Carol is one of the greatest modern Christmas films without a shadow of a doubt. Quite what that means in real terms is somewhat up for debate: "modern Christmas films" after all isn't exactly a bountiful genre. But all semantics aside, Murray's snarky, snake-like Frank Cross is the perfect modern day Scrooge; a soulless yuppy with distinct sociopathic tendencies and a keen eye for money. Perhaps because Murray wasn't really interested in being serious, Cross is manic as he unravels, striding gleefully into pantomime villains - a reimagining of American Psycho's Patrick Bateman without the killing, but with the same obvious lack of self-awareness. There is of course the suggestion that Murray turned up full of contempt for the material and basically showed his disdain by disrespecting it with a petulant, irritated performance, but the prickliness (and prickishness) were well suited to the character. Cross isn't even likeable when he's "redeemed", and you get the sense that he probably hasn't genuinely learned anything, but at least it was watching him dragged through some nastiness for a while.

4. Ernie McCracken - Kingpin (1996)

It's been a while, but the Farrelly brothers used to make genuinely entertaining movies before "gross-out" became licence to do just that with the pillars of film-making and not just the content. And between Dumb & Dumber and There's Something About Mary, the outrageous duo lost money, but gained a near-cult following for Kingpin, thanks in no small part to a scene-stealing performance by Murray. McCracken is easily the Farrellys' best villain creation; he's a cartoonish rogue, vain to a fault and all too invested in the fallacy of his own little bubble of importance. He's a self-made, self-imagined celebrity; his idea that he is "famous" in the Farrelly-created ludicrous universe where bowling is the pinnacle of fame and fortune is as laughable as his hairstyle, but gloriously nobody seems to notice. Again Murray plays unlikeable without the hangover: he's despicable but utterly charming and there's just enough suggestion that he's nothing more than a fool trying to hide his true form with bluster. As a mark of how well Murray got into the role, he actually made the three strikes in a row at the film's climax. Method.

3. Bob Harris - Lost In Translation (2003)

It's something of a disservice to Lost In Translation that most of what remains in the memory concerns what Bill Murray whispered to Scarlett Johansson at the end: in creating something that was supposed to not matter, Sofia Coppola unwittingly built a cult around a moment that distracts somewhat from the rest of the film. There's something quite wonderful in imagining that Murray's Bob Harris is the closest thing audiences have seen to how he genuinely feels about the film industry: world-weary, abused for gimmicks and content to just do interesting things between actually having to work. Perhaps that's why the role is so believable; why the sadness that's never explained or even really brought up is so palpable and why his loneliness is so perfectly sold? Having built a career on caricatures, Lost In Translation was Murray's confirmation that he could be hilarious without artifice or massive silliness and the pleasure of his cultural odyssey is entirely irresistible.

2. Peter Venkman - Ghostbusters (1984)

Peter Venkman is arguably the most generous character creation of Murray's career: while the rest of the cast play varying degrees of straight men (Dan Aykroyd is something of both sides of the coin, but not really intentionally), he was allowed to get away with sabotaging everything and taking the lion's share of the laughs. He's pretty much the least believable scholar possible; a probably sociopath and definitely an arch manipulator, and while he suffers the most in terms of being slimed and having to see his "girlfriend" possessed, he's also afforded the best jokes and the most enjoyable dialogue. He's an anti-hero rather than a bumbling geek; a jerk rather than a dork, and it's almost impossible to imagine anyone else playing the character any other way. It's frustrating that Murray has always seemed so intent not to bring the character back, but perhaps he's aware of the laws of diminishing returns: there's only so much Venkman can get away with before he's completely irredeemable, and that was always a big part of his appeal.

1. Phil Connors - Groundhog Day (1993)

The real genius of Groundhog Day is that it does the same thing a million different ways and at no point loses anything in the telling. The reason it works, even despite a typically stoney performance by Andie McDowell and a frankly ludicrous central premise is that Bill Murray is Phil Connors, and he sells the emotional journey perfectly. Having already played one version of Scrooge five years previously, Murray was at it again, this time without the guiding influence of anything as blatant as ghosts of past, present and future. This Scrooge was trapped in the perpetual Hell of his own life, being forced to live, die, repeat without anything as spectacular to target as thwarting an alien invasion: he just had to stop being himself. Typically, Connors cruises the line between unlikeable and charming that most of Murray's best performances do, and it is the actor's sell of the various stages of grief - reimagined as denial, madness, suicide, acceptance and growth - that propels the film forward to classic status.

5 That Sucked

5. Mayor Cole - City Of Ember (2008)

City Of Ember always felt like someone was trying to make a Guillermo Del Toro movie for kids, but had only ever seen images and a colour palette and didn't really understand the Mexican auteur beyond that. It was a dystopian portrait of an underground world characterised by classification and corporate greed: managing to be both anti-communist and anti-capitalist at the same time in a rare achievement. For all of those interesting points, it was also as bland as tap water. It's well crafted, but it just feels like a retread - albeit a pretty one - and the moralising is as annoying as it is confused. Murray plays the villain of the piece: a pantomimey power-crazed supreme leader who hoards canned food and makes sure everyone is in their place. He seems to have risen to power based on charisma alone, but rather oddly this is a performance lacking in that usually abundant Murray raw material. He's an idiot, and this is just too far into the unlikeable territory to really convince of why he'd ever make it to the Mayor's office, largely because Murray never really feels all that interested.

4. Jack Corcoran - Larger Than Life (1996)

Larger Than Life is one of those movies where Disney used to look at who was popular at the time, ignore precisely why and threw money at turning them into a family comedy movie star. In this case, they ignored the fact that Murray was appealing because of his pitch black humour, flirtation with anti-hero status and downright roguish charm and relegated him to an unfunny sidekick to a bored elephant in a mirthless "comedy" about finding yourself down an elephant's trunk or something. There is something of the trademark Murray Jerk school here, but it's so badly written that there's no laughs or charm to redeem him. He's just a bit of a jerk on a Planes, Trains And Pachyderms journey across America that is so hard to invest in that the end goal becomes entirely redundant.

3. Frank Detorri - Osmosis Jones (2001)

How could a gross-out comedy animation from the Farrelly brothers focussing mostly on the chance of emissions from Bill Murray's various orifices not work?! That seems to have been the sales pitch for this curiosity, along with the promise to have Murray literally fart William Shatner out of his body. Seemingly based entirely on the Ten Second Rule (Murray eats an eat that has been fondled and dropped by a chimpanzee because he's that kind of idiot), Osmosis Jones was an odd experiment that somehow cost $70m and made just $12m back. Ot's frankly disheartening to see Murray - a comedy character actor usually so invested in wit and charm being reduced to playing a slob, whose bodily functions are literally the star of the show, and you have to wonder whether a good deal of that $70m was used to convince him to temporarily drop all self respect.

2. Happy Shannon - Passion Play (2011)

Never heard of it? There's a good reason for that. In 1993, Murray made Mad Dog & Glory, playing against type to commit one of the oddest, but not the least successful gangster performances imaginable. Frank Milo worked because he was a reasonable exaggeration of Murray's accepted persona, even if the threat of physical violence was a little hard to accept. Clearly buoyed by the experience, Murray went back to the gangster genre in 2011 to play Roy Orbison-alike Happy Shannon in a movie that attempted to pair Mickey Rourke and Megan Fox up as a believable couple. That wasn't its only fault of course - Rourke actually admitted it was "a terrible movie" if you need further endorsement - and you have to wonder first why Murray agreed to do it, and second why he didn't put as much effort into his performance as the make-up team did into his hairpiece. The film took its attempts to be cool rather than good way too seriously, and that seems to have infected Murray's piecemeal performance. It could have been great, and watching many people attempt to kill Rourke for seemingly very little reason should have been entertaining. As it is, it's just a perverse, sad footnote on Murray's recent career.

1. Garfield - Garfield (2004) & Garfield: A Tail Of Two Kitties (2006)

So bad that it suffered the ignominy of being mocked by the actor himself in a beautifully throwaway jibe in Zombieland. Perhaps it's cruel to say that Bill Murray's performance in either of the Garfield movies was bad, but then the actor physically chose to make them. He agreed to be associated with the lethargic orange cat the same way Dan Aykroyd agreed to murder Yogi Bear for the regrettable recent movie, and he should be held accountable. And when you really drill down to it, the performance isn't all that great either; there's no personality in the voice, there's no attempt to change it to sound more Garfield-like - the entire thing is based on the knowing self-indulgence of having Bill Murray as the voice. That's literally the only way it's sold, and it's no surprise that Murray put so little into it: when a film seeks only to further actor mythology (as Only God Forgives did with Ryan Gosling) the results are inevitably poor. Which are your favourite and least favourite Bill Murray performances? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.