Bill Paxton: 5 Awesome Performances (And Five That Sucked)

The only man in history to be killed by a Predator, a Terminator and a Xenomorph.

Chet Weird Science Bill Paxton
Universal Pictures

Just when everything seemed to be looking rosy, and just when all the bad news seemed to have ceased - after a 2016 that saw us lose Alan Rickman, David Bowie, Gene Wilder and Carrie Fisher - the movie industry has lost another of its shining talents.

With the great Bill Paxton recently passing away at the far-too-young age of 61 due to "complications from surgery", we're left with a diverse, colourful and impactful legacy, a career that spans decades and includes appearances in some of the finest sci-fi, drama and action pictures ever made.

Acting wasn't the only contribution he made to the film scene, either; Paxton directed both Frailty and The Greatest Game Ever Played, two solid efforts that could have led to something even bigger if he had eventually decided to step behind the camera permanently.

Directing aside, this list will look at some of his greatest onscreen performances - and some of his not-so-great ones. With such a vast filmography, a handful of duds were inevitable, from roles that just weren't meant for him to films that were doomed to be terrible from the start.

However, it's testament to the man's ability that he is nearly always watchable, no matter the character, story or film.

First up - the five awesome performances...


5 Awesome Performances

5. Chet - Weird Science (1985)

Weird Science Chet Bill Paxton
Universal Pictures

Though he's ludicrously funny in a handful of films, you never really hear people talk about Paxton as a comedic talent.

That's probably due to the fact that his two most famous roles, or the roles the general public will know him for - Twister and Titanic - are light on laughs, but dig a little deeper into his catalogue of films and you'll find that humour is one of his more underappreciated traits.

Possibly his funniest role came in John Hughes' Weird Science. As Chet Donnelly - protagonist Wyatt's older brother - he slipped into the role of 'douchebag elder sibling' perfectly, delivering quotable insult after quotable insult, managing to transform into a complete jerk while still remaining likable.

Perhaps out of fear of being typecast, Paxton stepped away from roles like this in the future, but it was Weird Science that helped him refine those comedic chops that he'd put to good use as his career progressed.


4. Simon - True Lies (1994)

True Lies Bill Paxton
Universal Pictures

Let's be honest - as is the case for a lot of us, True Lies will mainly be remembered for Jame Lee Curtis' seductive striptease, but aside from that, its standout moments are easily provided by Bill Paxton's Simon.

An immoral, cowardly car salesman who regularly lies to women in an attempt to get them into bed, Paxton again delivers quotable line after quotable line ("the 'Vette gets 'em wet"), and despite his character being a sleazy piece of work, you can't help but laugh at him and you'll probably end up loving him to death.

Everything about the character, from his scruffy, 80s pornstar moustache to his excessive confidence, is pitch perfect, played with complete self-awareness by a Paxton who's clearly having the time of his life.

And that makes it incredibly easy for us to enjoy ourselves too. If Paxton had played the character a little less outlandish and a little more straight he would've come across as irritating, but the actor knew that the only way to make Simon work was to embrace the fact that he was a scumbag and make the best of it.


3. Hudson - Aliens (1986)

Bill Paxton Aliens
20th Century Fox

After a small role in 1984's The Terminator, Paxton quickly re-teamed with director James Cameron for sci-fi epic Aliens, starring as the "ultimate badass" Private Hudson.

While Hudson will, like the two Paxton roles we just discussed, be fondly remembered for his funnier moments and lines, the level of realism and depth the actor brought to the fledgling marine cannot be understated.

Initially cocky and arrogant, Hudson transforms into a nervous wreck when the situation takes a turn for the worse and everyone's lives are in danger. He reacts exactly how we'd all react in his shoes, and when compared to his relentlessly calm, unshakable teammates, he feels like the most human character in the movie.

And then, yes, there are all the amusing moments - "game over, man, game over!" and "Vasquez, have you ever been mistaken for a man?" among them - and when you combine these with the character's relatability, it's easy to understand why Hudson will go down as one of Paxton's most enduring roles.


2. Dad Meiks - Frailty (2001)

Frailty Bill Paxton
Lionsgate

Paxton's feature directorial debut, 2001's Frailty also saw the actor take the lead as a father-of-two who believes he must commit a series of murders in order to destroy demons disguised as human beings.

Though Dad Meiks is, inherently, a bad person (he is a murderer, after all), Paxton is able to make the character one you'll feel sympathetic towards, playing him in such a way that you can't help but feel sorry for the man.

All he wants to do is look after and protect his children - that's why he's killing "demons" - and although he's being manipulated by his religious beliefs (he's visited by an angel, who compels him to begin his demon-hunting quest), he's only doing what he thinks is right, and Paxton smartly focuses on this aspect of the character.

It's a dark tale that's not as easy to watch as the other awesome performances on this list, but it packs a fantastic third-act twist and a strong performance from a pre-Oscar-winning Matthew McConaughey.


1. Bill Harding - Twister (1996)

Twister Bill Paxton
Universal Pictures

Arguably Paxton's most famous role - since you've probably seen it on ITV2 3,683 times since its release - Twister stars the actor as Bill Harding, a former tornado-hunter who re-enters the game in order to help create a more advanced weather warning system.

Though Twister is an effects-laden, fun-filled blockbuster, Paxton keeps his performance quietly restrained. This could have been viewed as an odd choice - after all, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Alan Ruck and most of the other storm-chasers are anything but restrained - but it works incredibly well, Paxton's measured delivery supporting the film's central emotional backbone.

Twister is just solid all around; the love triangle between Bill, his ex-wife and his fiance makes for some compelling viewing, and the tornado action is as exciting as you'd hope. It's Paxton who makes the movie what it is though, and without him, it simply wouldn't be as successful as it turned out to be.

Up next - five performances you won't remember quite as fondly...


5 That Sucked

5. Mason - The Colony (2013)

The Colony 2013 Film Bill Paxton
Entertainment One/Image Entertainment

Paxton's recent work has been nowhere near as memorable as the performances he delivered in his earlier days, and his role in The Colony is a fine example of this.

Perhaps it's because he plays an out-and-out villain (of sorts) and his character possesses few, if any, redeeming qualities. We're not used to seeing Paxton like this, and it felt rather jarring and unusual to watch him play against type to such a severe degree.

The material didn't exactly serve him well, with a predictable script and by-the-numbers execution, so it's hard to say if Paxton could have added another dimension to the character or not.

As it stands though, Mason is paper-thin, and the disgruntled expression he wears for much of the movie's runtime is probably indicative of how the actor felt when he saw the finished product.


4. Jim Reston - Brain Dead (1990)

Brain Dead 1990 Bill Paxton Bill Pullman
Concorde Pictures

Not to be confused with Peter Jackson's superior 1992 horror-comedy of the same name, 1990's Brain Dead will, if nothing else, be remembered as the movie that would forever ensure audiences got confused between Bill Pullman, and Bill Paxton.

They both star here, with Paxton taking on the role of Jim Reston, a billionaire who enlists the help of Pullman's Dr. Rex Martin, a neurosurgeon Reston hopes will be able to unlock the secrets held within the mind of a genius mathematician.

If that sounds confusing, it's because it is. Brain Dead tries to be deep and thought-provoking but instead comes across as dumb, and at times, unintentionally hilarious.

Paxton is completely wasted in a dry, humourless role too, with some bafflingly weird dialogue thrown in for good measure ("the universe is just a wet dream" is a particular standout).

And this is one of those rare occasions where he doesn't even seem to be trying. Even when the film is bad you can tell that, at the very least, he's putting in some effort, but throughout Brain Dead Paxton just looks... well, brain dead.

The film would probably have been better as an out-and-out horror-comedy. Its low budget and uninspired, stationary camera work make it seem funnier than it should be, and at least then Paxton would be able to bring more of his signature levity to proceedings.


3. Joe Keenan - Term Life (2016)

Term Life Bill Paxton
Focus World

Another example of Paxton playing an out-and-out villain with no redeeming qualities and zero charm came in 2016's trope-ridden thriller Term Life.

It's usually impossible to not like the actor, no matter how bad the movie or questionable the performance, but here, everything was lifeless.

Keenan is one-note, bad for the sake of being bad, and Paxton doesn't bring anything else to the table. Maybe he was tired or just plain bored, but it seems like he didn't even attempt to make the character more three-dimensional, content with keeping things straightforward and easy.

To be fair to Paxton, he was completely miscast as the uber-serious dirty cop. He's often at his best when he's playing roles that are more light-hearted - even in serious fare like Aliens, he's still supremely enjoyable to watch, and seems like he's having a lot of fun himself - but Term Life affords him no such opportunity.

The film made many mistakes (like casting Vince Vaughn as an action hero... really?) but one of its biggest was failing to use its incredibly talented cast in the right way, causing them to suffer for it.


2. Dinky Winks - Spy Kids 2 & Spy Kids 3-D (2002 - 2003)

Dinky Winks Spy Kids Bill Paxton
Dimension Films

Every actor does a paycheck movie or two at some point in their careers - even the greats - and Paxton was no different.

In fact, the pay was so good, he went back for a second round. We can only assume the money was the main draw of Spy Kids 2: The Island Of Lost Dreams and Spy Kids 3-D: Game Over, because we can't imagine a performer as talented and respected as Paxton read the script and thought, "you know what... that's pretty damn good!"

Dinky Winks first appeared in Spy Kids 2, and Paxton plays the part as though the director just told him to be a stereotypical Texan businessman, with emphasis on the stereotypical. It's just plain bad, more groan-inducing than funny, and you'll be wanting his scenes to be over as soon as they've begun.

It's sad to see such a legend stoop this low, and although he appears to be having fun, you'll be silently wishing they'd just cast some unknown actor in this bit-part instead.


1. Ray O'Malley - Boxing Helena (1993)

Boxing Helena 1993 Film Bill Paxton
Orion Pictures

If there's one thing Bill Paxton usually always does, it's stick to his guns. His performance in Spy Kids was bad, but at least it was consistently bad, the actor choosing a direction and sticking to it firmly.

Well, here's one example where that's not the case.

Boxing Helena is a sombre, horrific tale about a woman who has all her limbs amputated by a surgeon who holds her captive in his house, and yet, Paxton does a parody of every self-centred, pretentious jock from every high-school movie ever, the actor seemingly caught between going full-on funny, and full on a-hole.

The result is a performance you're neither laughing at or feeling threatened by. If Paxton had fully committed to either angle, things may have worked out a bit better - at least then his intent would have been clear - but as it stands, we don't have a clue what on Earth he was trying to pull off here.

What are your favourite and least favourite Bill Paxton performances? Leave your picks in the comments section!


Contributor
Contributor

Danny has been with WhatCulture for over ten years, and is currently Doctor Who Editor and WhoCulture Channel Manager, overseeing all of WhatCulture's Whoniverse coverage. In 2022, he took charge of WhoCulture and has grown it into the biggest Doctor Who channel on YouTube, and one of the biggest Doctor Who communities on the web full-stop. He has been writing and video editing since his early teens, and first got a taste for content creation after making his own Doctor Who trailers, off the back of a burning obsession with the Matt Smith era of the show. Like many his age, he first got into Doctor Who with the 2005 revival, but has since gone back and fallen in love with the classic years too. If you need someone to recite every Doctor Who episode in order, or to give you a random factoid about the making of Gridlock, Danny is the person to ask!