Black Mirror: Bandersnatch Review - 7 Ups & 2 Downs

An innovative, unsettling interactive film.

Black Mirror Bandersnatch
Netflix

Netflix's much-hyped Choose Your Own Adventure Black Mirror film Bandersnatch is available now on the streaming platform, arriving amid a mysterious marketing campaign and the release of a trailer just a day before the film dropped online.

The early response from both critics and fans alike seems to be generally positive, albeit with a few qualifiers.

Though it's clear that Bandersnatch is a demo for a concept which could be much more intricate and complex in the future, it is nevertheless an entertaining, gloriously meta tech-centric horror-show.

Does it sit up there with the best Black Mirror episodes? Surely not, but in blurring the line between film and video games, it presents a unique opportunity for Netflix, who with their 140+ million subscribers, are capable of bringing these envelope-pushing experiences to an unprecedented number of viewers.

If nothing else, it's a bold attempt to do something different, and though flawed, more often than not it's another deliciously dark offering from Charlie Brooker...


Downs...

2. The Superficial Story Choices

Black Mirror Bandersnatch Will Poulter
Netflix

It was claimed ahead of the film's release that Bandersnatch offered over five hours of play-time and "trillions" of story permutations, though it's worth knowing that only about half of the available video is actually original content.

In fact, it's entirely possible to unlock all five of the film's main endings within about two hours, which is a tad disappointing.

As much as Bandersnatch has been hyped up as a labyrinthine, layered spin on CYOA stories, the core is revealed to be quite simple once you've played through it a few times.

Now granted, the idea of limited player agency is a theme the film itself touches on, but if you were hoping for the differing options to open up wildly divergent paths and story choices, you might end up feeling a little disappointed.

The film is extremely generous with allowing "players" to correct themselves in the event of a mistake, which while respectful of players' time, also helps highlight the limitations of the branching paths.

What's there is certainly well executed, but ultimately if you've spent 90 minutes tinkering your way to the end credits, you've already seen the majority of the prime material the film has to offer.


1. It Lacks The Satirical Bite Of Traditional Black Mirror

Black Mirror Bandersnatch
Netflix

If Bandersnatch was presented as an ordinary episode of Black Mirror, it would probably be on the middle-to-lower tier, because it's lacking the satirical punchiness of the show's better episodes, and feels undeniably compromised by its CYOA presentation.

That's not to say it's not clever, just that it feels a tad Black Mirror-lite, with Brooker clearly toning down his usual incisiveness for the sake of a broader and more accessible game-like experience.

Aside from one hilariously meta sequence, few are likely to be left gob-smacked by much of what happens here, which after four seasons of the show, feels almost ordinary compared to some of Black Mirror's most ferociously clever episodes.

These flaws aside, though, there's plenty to savour, and here's what Bandersnatch got right...


Ups...

7. Fionn Whitehead's Terrific Performance

Black Mirror Bandersnatch Fionn Whitehead
Netflix

Dunkirk's Fionn Whitehead stars as protagonist Stefan Butler, a 19-year-old computer programmer with dreams of adapting a cult fantasy novel, Bandersnatch, into a video game.

Whitehead is terrifically cast here as Stefan, proving instantly believable as an unsociable, mumbly young computer whizz with aspirations towards a career in the gaming industry.

Whether working through an awkward chat with his father or having one of his many possible freakouts, Whitehead does a stand-up job as both quietly contemplative and explosively angry.

Given the unique nature of the role and the difficulty of keeping in character with the various story paths, he effortlessly rises to the challenge.

Casting has of course always been one of Black Mirror's strong suits, and despite the film's flaws, Whitehead is perfectly cast as Stefan.


6. The Seamless Branching Narrative

Black Mirror Bandersnatch Fionn Whitehead
Netflix

Though the actual storytelling freedom available to the player is somewhat underwhelming, you have to give Netflix credit for producing perhaps the most slickly intuitive interactive movie ever made.

Whenever a choice emerges, there's no judder or stuttering as the pipeline loads up the user interface, and once you've selected an option, it's seamlessly inserted into the story thanks to some meticulous editing.

The brief story summaries which play out following a fail state must've been a headache for the production team to assemble, and some of the smaller details - like picking a cereal and seeing a TV advert for that cereal later on - result in a cute paying-off of even the most insignificant choices.

The system is smooth and robust, so it's easy to be confident that with a bolder approach to choice next time, another Netflix CYOA project could be incredibly special indeed.


5. It's Jam-Packed With Easter Eggs

Black Mirror Bandersnatch Metalhead
Netflix

Bandersnatch is absolutely jam-packed with Easter eggs, from neat little details of the mid-80s period, to hilariously on-the-nose nods to previous Black Mirror episodes - namely San Junipero, White Bear and Metalhead, the latter also being helmed by Bandersnatch's director, David Slade.

Video game fanatics may also notice a brief appearance from legendary game designer Jeff Minter, who appears fleetingly as a demented game designer driven to violent lengths by his obsession to create a sprawling, labyrinthine CYOA game.

Though there's inevitably still plenty of hidden nods and references for fans to discover, it's certainly another incentive to cycle back through the various story paths and seek out every last one.


4. The Stellar Supporting Cast

Black Mirror Bandersnatch Alice Lowe
Netflix

True to form, Bandersnatch is spectacularly cast across the board, and Fionn Whitehead is backed up by a terrific roster of acclaimed character actors.

For starters, Will Poulter is bizarrely cool and charming as famed video game designer Colin Ritman, while Alice Lowe is perfect as Stefan's concerned psychiatrist Dr. Haynes, and Asim Chaudhry is wonderfully slimy as Mohan Thakur, the enterprising head of games company Tuckersoft.

Everyone commits to their roles splendidly, ensuring that this is without question the best-acted CYOA film/FMV game ever made.

Fingers crossed its instant success could invite some A-list names to the table if Netflix decides to proceed with a follow-up.


3. It's Gorgeously Shot

Black Mirror Bandersnatch
Netflix

If you were worried that the larger scale and greater volume of video content required for the episode would result in a watered-down visual experience, fear not.

Cinematography has always been a high-point for Black Mirror, and that was certainly the case with director David Slade's monochromatic Black Mirror episode last year, Metalhead.

Having worked through the various story paths, it's clear that Bandersnatch is richly, evocatively shot throughout, and no technical corners have been cut or expense spared in putting together a seamlessly cinematic story with stylistic uniformity across the board.

Given that most CYOA films end up looking a bit cheap and visually flat, this is without question the most stylistically formidable effort the medium has ever seen.


2. The Awesome Soundtrack

Black Mirror Bandersnatch Fionn Whitehead
Netflix

Music has also been another consistent strong suit for Black Mirror, and yet again, Bandersnatch is no exception.

Though Frankie Goes to Hollywood's iconic "Relax" is a recurrent motif throughout the episode, players will occasionally be given options to choose the episode's soundtrack, such as picking between Thompson Twins and a Now 2 compilation, and then between Tangerine Dreams' record "Phaedra" and Isao Tomita's "The Bermuda Triangle."

Elsewhere the likes of Eurythmics, Kajagoogoo and Depeche Mode can be heard throughout the episode, ensuring that not only does Bandersnatch sound quintessentially 80s, its synth-based focus perfectly accentuates the episode's exploration of video game development.


1. It's An Ambitious Storytelling Experiment

Black Mirror Bandersnatch
Netflix

Bandersnatch sure isn't perfect and certainly could've done more with its concept, but it's hard not to respect the ambition in even attempting something so headache-inducingly complex from a technical perspective.

Given that most prior attempts at CYOA stories and FMV games have turned out cheesy and unconvincing, it's impressive just how persuasive the storytelling and overall production quality is.

It's a major step up, creating a space with plenty of room for improvement, yet possibly being the start of an incredibly rewarding trend for audiences (and a lucrative one for Netflix, no doubt).

If this was just a one-off experiment, it'd be a massive shame, but considering the strong reviews and feverish social media engagement so far, it seems likely we'll see another in the near-future.

What did you think of Black Mirror: Bandersnatch? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Black Mirror
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.