Black Panther: Wakanda Forever Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs

An impressive and emotional - if flawed - follow-up to its classic predecessor.

Black Panther Wakanda Forever Shuri
Marvel Studios

Without question one of the most anticipated superhero movie sequels of recent years is now finally in cinemas around the world - Black Panther: Wakanda Forever.

Ryan Coogler's original 2018 film was a pop-culture phenomenon far beyond anyone's expectations, yet Wakanda Forever inevitably rolls into cinemas accompanied by a cloud of melancholy, given the absence of the late Chadwick Boseman.

Coogler and company were faced with an incredibly challenging task, of paying tribute to Boseman in a new film while moving the story forward in a way that made sense, and for the most part they've pulled it off in affecting and satisfying fashion.

While it's fair to say that Wakanda Forever doesn't reach the fist-pumping highs of its predecessor and is hobbled by several common MCU issues, that such a robust sequel has been produced barely two years after Boseman's untimely death is quite the impressive feat indeed.

As a conclusion to the MCU's rather uneven fourth phase, it's certainly one of the franchise's stronger cinematic offerings in recent times, if also very far from perfect.

With that in mind, first here's what doesn't work in Black Panther: Wakanda Forever...


Downs...

3. The Bloated Runtime & Overstuffed Storytelling

Black Panther Wakanda Forever Shuri
Marvel Studios

With an epic 161-minute runtime, Wakanda Forever is one of the longest MCU movies to date, and while that extended runtime allows director Coogler to let the big emotional scenes breathe, it ultimately also lends far too much latitude to an overstuffed canvas of subplots and characters.

Given that the film's two major storylines - Wakanda grieving T'Challa's death and the emergence of Namor (Tenoch Huerta) - provide more than enough dramatic juice for a superhero sequel, it's rather baffling that Coogler and co-writer Joe Robert Cole decided to bloat it out with so much "added value."

The two most egregious offenders are a subplot involving Everett Ross (Martin Freeman) and the rather unnecessary inclusion of Riri Williams aka Ironheart (Dominique Thorne) - though more on the latter later.

Overall there's just a lack of propulsiveness to the film's pacing, especially in the saggy second act, which suggests that Coogler desperately needed to take another pass in the editing room and cut those leaden scenes that don't enhance the two central storylines.

Simply, there's a lot here that feels like cutting room floor material, ensuring Wakanda Forever's runtime gets unwieldy to the point that it undermines one's enthusiasm to revisit it anytime soon.


2. The Underwhelming Action Sequences

Black Panther Wakanda Forever
Marvel Studios

Perhaps the single biggest disappointment in Wakanda Forever is the generally pedestrian quality of the film's action sequences, which while hardly bad feel so incredibly ordinary for the standards of the MCU.

Given that Coogler delivered one of the MCU's finest set-pieces with the original film's thrilling Busan sequence, it's a shame that the majority of the action here feels perfunctory and unenthusiastic, like Coogler knew he had to include it but really wanted to focus on the superior dramatic material.

This lack of inspiration is especially apparent during the final battle between the Wakandans and Namor's Talokanil: a listless, CGI-slathered clash in a dull location that doesn't do anything particularly creative or interesting.

There are brief moments of tenacious action - Okoye (Danai Gurira) using her spear to decimate a police car during a high-speed chase - but for the most part the action design is seriously underwhelming coming from a filmmaker as talented as Coogler.

It never gets as visually unappealing as the infamous climax to the original Black Panther, though some of the suit designs that show up in Wakanda Forever's third act might make you wince a little.


1. Riri's Forced Inclusion

Black Panther Wakanda Forever Riri
Marvel Studios

Many fans were excited to learn that Riri Williams/Ironheart was announced to appear in Wakanda Forever, and though actress Dominique Thorne does an absolutely solid job with what she's given, it has to be said that her inclusion here feels incredibly forced.

The manner in which she's integrated into the central story doesn't feel organic in the slightest, making it clear that she was seemingly written into the script to accommodate the upcoming Ironheart Disney+ series, which can't help but make her presence seem like a cynical calculation.

In a film that already has so much to work through, introducing a significant new superhero probably isn't the smartest idea, and given that Riri feels like a thin sketch of a character at best, she probably should've been saved for a future movie with less weighty dramatic baggage.

One can't shake the feeling that Riri plays like she's in another movie entirely, as though she was a remnant from the original Wakanda Forever script written prior to Boseman's death, and so comes off as a shoehorned component in this new version of the story.

These gripes aside, though, there's a lot to enjoy in the film, and so here's what it gets absolutely right...


Ups...

7. T'Challa's Death Is Emotional & Tasteful

Black Panther Wakanda Forever
Marvel Studios

There were so, so many ways to screw up contextualising Chadwick Boseman's tragic death within the MCU, but Coogler has done a generally excellent job of pulling it off in a way that makes dramatic sense.

Rather than overcomplicate T'Challa's death, Coogler has opted to borrow liberally from reality and in turn ensures that we, the audience, are basically on the same emotional page as the film's characters.

There are several delineated tributes to Boseman and T'Challa throughout the film, all of which clearly come from a deeply affectionate and heartbroken place, as viewers are likely to find incredibly moving and gratifying.

Boseman's death unavoidably casts a shadow over the entire movie, but rather than detail T'Challa's death and then attempt to immediately move away from it, Coogler instead boldly leans into it.

As such it's little surprise that many of the film's best scenes are moments of quiet reflection as characters process their grief.

We'll probably never know what Wakanda Forever would've looked like were Boseman still alive, but there's not a whiff of cynicism in how Marvel Studios has written T'Challa out of the franchise.


6. Letitia Wright Steals The Show As Shuri

Black Panther Wakanda Forever Shuri
Marvel Studios

Though Letitia Wright is something of a controversial figure for obvious reasons, there's no arguing with the brilliance of her performance in this film.

Wright, who of course played a supporting role in the original Black Panther, has been unexpectedly passed the protagonist baton for this sequel, and more than rises to the occasion.

From the film's very first scene, Wright powerfully conveys Shuri's anguish at her brother's death and her struggle to move on from it.

It is a highly potent portrayal of grief, especially for the standards of a splashy tentpole film, in large part because Wright gives such a magnetic performance.

Sure, she may not be nearly as charismatic as her late screen brother, but given what Shuri is dealing with throughout the movie, that's hardly expected. This is an often shockingly introspective superhero character study, and Wright knocks it out of the park.


5. Namor Is One Of The Better Recent MCU Villains

Black Panther Wakanda Forever Namor Ramonda
Marvel Studios

If the fourth phase of the MCU has offered up a relatively mixed bag of villains, it's at least a pleasure to report that Wakanda Forever's primary antagonist, Namor, is one of the best in recent years.

Tenoch Huerta Mejía gives terrifically terrifying presence to the villain, who has an immediately compelling motivation for coming into conflict with the Wakandans, and even if not every aspect of his arc is totally convincing, he basically ends up stealing every single scene he's in.

Aided by a fascinating backstory and some worthwhile changes made to the character's presentation from the comics, Namor is an incredibly memorable character and sits just a little below Shang Chi's Wenwu (Tony Leung) as one of Phase 4's very best.


4. Angela Bassett's Terrific Supporting Performance

Black Panther Wakanda Forever Ramonda
Marvel Studios

As won't surprise anyone who's seen the trailer - or anyone who's seen her act before - Angela Bassett gives an amazing supporting performance as Ramonda.

Bassett carries herself with such ferocious power in every single scene, proving immediately captivating whether she's quietly ruminating on her son's loss or, in her finest scene, loudly espousing her grief.

Bassett's so fantastic in the film that it wouldn't be remotely surprising if she received a Best Supporting Actress Oscar nomination for her work here.

She does exactly what great supporting players usually do: enhance the lead character's arc in a truly meaningful way.

Bassett makes us feel Ramonda's devastation basically every time she's on screen, but in all of her power and forthrightness she's certainly far from a pitiable figure.


3. It Has Real Dramatic Weight

Black Panther Wakanda Forever Shuri
Marvel Studios

Wakanda Forever is surely the single heaviest MCU movie to date, given the parallels it draws between Chadwick Boseman's death and the passing of T'Challa.

But it also never feels excessively miserable for no reason: Coogler has quite ingeniously utilised the grief he and his cast and crew presumably felt to craft an ode to loss that feels more real and honest than the typical heightened MCU drama.

Beyond that, there's also a majorly compelling series of parallels between Wakanda and Namor's home nation of Talokan, which fuels Namor's desire to keep his home hidden and causes him to exert significant pressure on Shuri to help him preserve that secrecy.

Even with its storytelling excess, the emotions at the core of the characters feel totally grounded and genuine, ensuring its flaws are considerably easier to forgive.


2. Ludwig Göransson's Fantastic Musical Score

Black Panther Wakanda Forever
Marvel Studios

Composer Ludwig Göransson won a well-earned Best Original Score for his work on the original Black Panther, and while he might struggle to repeat such an accolade this time, it won't be for lack of trying because he provides another stellar soundscape for the sequel.

What's immediately striking about Wakanda Forever's score is just how diverse it is, utilising distinct instruments to score the Wakandan and Talokanil tribes respectively.

Göransson particularly outdoes himself when it comes to the Talokanil's skin-crawlingly creepy chant which they use to hypnotise their enemies several times throughout the film.

All in all the score boasts all the operatic bombast you'd expect from an MCU movie yet also feels appropriately culturally distinct, ensuring it doesn't blend into the more workmanlike bevy of scores in recent MCU films.


1. It Ends Phase 4 On A (Mostly) Strong Note

Black Panther Wakanda Forever
Marvel Studios

Phase 4 of the MCU has certainly been a bit of a bumpy ride for fans, with many feeling that the franchise has lost a little of the consistent magic that made it such a hit in the first place.

But Wakanda Forever thankfully feels like a bit of a return to form, its flaws accepted, in both functioning as a dramatically striking piece of character-driven drama and a superhero epic that looks forward to the future direction of the IP.

While Phase 4's ending isn't particularly momentous given that we're only now starting to build towards the two-part Avengers climax in 2025 and 2026, Wakanda Forever nevertheless feels like a palate cleanser, both for those exhausted by underwhelming recent MCU films and those nervous for how Black Panther will continue without Chadwick Boseman.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.