Brad Pitt: 5 Awesome Performances and 5 That Sucked

A common concern amongst the acting fraternity is that they might be typecast. To a B-list abundant with character actors, this can be a blessing- it€™s a source of steady work they might not otherwise get. However, the further you get up the acting pyramid, the more generally disliked the idea of typecasting is. Yet it still occurs; Adam Sandler plays €˜lovable€™ idiots, Judi Dench is often stuck portraying upper-class types, and Brad Pitt plays glamorous, albeit empty parts. Or does he? Brad Pitt is a beautiful man. This much is plain. Oftentimes, directors will want to make good use of the fact he€™s really-really-really good looking. The Ocean€™s series was seemingly built around the premise that Pitt and company all lived impossibly glamorous lives. Troy descended into a shirtless, homoerotic farce. In Interview With The Vampire, he appeared to be little more than a clothes horse. But underneath those Zoolander-esque qualities, everyone seems to forget just how good an actor Brad Pitt can be- he€™s been nominated for four Academy Awards and five Golden Globes and yet has only won one, a supporting actor nod for his role in Twelve Monkeys. I think that€™s surprising; he€™s been doing sterling work for years now. Though when asked about Brad Pitt, most people will envisage his looks first and his acting second. That€™s a bit of an injustice. But as they say, there's no smoke without fire. He really has made a couple of turkeys along the way, and they don't help his case at all. So, without further ado and to celebrate the recent release of Killing Them Softly, here is a list of Brad Pitt€™s best and worst performances.

5 Awesome Performances

5. Kalifornia - Early Grayce

Kalifornia itself was a bit of a flop. With a budget of around $9 million, it was never expected to rip up any trees, and it duly lived down to this expectation. But buried beneath this minor-leaguer was a revelation; Brad Pitt could act. So whilst Kalifornia is probably his most little known film on this list, it€™s undoubtedly one of the most important. I€™ll clarify. Pre-Kalifornia, Brad Pitt was often perceived (probably fairly at this point) as a sort of Robert Redford-lite; good at looking impossibly hunky or glamorous in a role, but little else. His turns in Thelma and Louise and Johnny Suede were probably the most notably examples of this. Essentially, he was playing fluff. Often well-acted, well-directed fluff, but fluff nonetheless. Kalifornia really shook this up with a novel idea; they would take that clean-cut good guy and grunge the shit out of him. Gone was Pitt€™s easy, charming persona, replaced with the leering visage of an unwashed sadist. He utterly dominates the film with his shocking behaviour and harrowing amorality. You actually share the other character€™s fear of him and his malevolent presence. Usually when an actor makes a concerted effort to play against type, you roll your eyes and expect the worst. But what was so truly shocking about this film was that not only could he actually do it, he could smash it out the park. And think, if it wasn€™t for this film, crazy, violent roles/films would€™ve been off-limits to Pitt. There would be no compellingly unbalanced performance in Twelve Monkeys, nor a deliriously entertaining turn in the ultraviolent Inglorious Basterds. What a shame that would€™ve been.


4. Meet Joe Black- Joe Black/The Guy in the Coffee Shop

If I€™m going to cop any flak for this list, it€™ll probably be over this one. But screw it, I€™m going to go for it anyway. Though Meet Joe Black is overlong and in need of a good editor, I€™d still argue that there were excellent performances smattered throughout. Anthony Hopkins was excellent as Elliot Parish (if only for his vocal work when €˜Joe€™ takes on his guise) and was well complimented by Jeffrey Tambor, Marcia Gay Harden and Claire Forlani. However, the film rides on its titular character, and it€™s a difficult burden for Pitt to shoulder. After all, he€™s playing Death- an unstoppable, immortal force- through a human host after he suddenly (and hilariously) cops it. Though Pitt came in for a lot of stick for not looking convincing as an omnipotent figure, I€™d argue that was kind of the point. Joe is supposed to look youthful and fresh-faced, thus highlighting the paradox between his outward appearance and the omniscience that inhabits it. When we consider this, it€™s possible to argue that this is one of Pitt€™s greatest dramatic performances. He exudes a coldness and stillness belying his movie-star looks and obvious charm. It€™s made all the better due to his original portrayal of the cocky young guy in a coffee shop who Joe takes on as a shell. It starts out as a €˜Brad Pitt performance€™ before turning into something else entirely. Joe is magnificently brought to life, his obvious lack of humanity shown by marrying a child-like naiveté (he loves peanut butter) to a penchant for selfishness and blithely reeling out threats of impossible magnitude. In fact, his very presence in the film is utterly insidious; he€™s literally a walking reminder for Anthony Hopkins that his death is imminent. But he isn€™t evil. After all, he€™s not even human, and Pitt conveys this maelstrom of nuance brilliantly. It€™s actually quite a feat to makes this incorporeal shade of amorality at all sympathetic, but Pitt really does manage it. He makes something that isn€™t even human grow as a character, and that€™s quite an accomplishment.

3. The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford - Jesse James

As Pitt became older, his roles have progressed from the young buck and into alpha male territory. He€™s proved very capable too, whether playing professional furniture-flipper Billy Beane in Moneyball, the gleefully psychotic Aldo Raine in Inglourious Basterds or the always-eating Rusty Ryan in the Oceans series. He€™s very comfortable in own his skin, and though these roles are all undoubtedly awesome, I would argue that he€™s not really stretching himself. But then there€™s The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford. Apart from having a bewilderingly long title, it features a compelling subversion of the alpha male persona by Pitt. He plays the eponymous Jesse James, and is never anything less than skin-crawlingly watchable as the infamous outlaw. Though Casey Affleck waltzed off with most of the plaudits for this film, I truly believe that Pitt€™s performance matches, if not surpasses it. He€™s basically playing a tortured caricature of himself, if you trade out the acting for bank robbing. James is a character consistently in anguish, always keeping a dominating air even when all authority has been stripped from him by an ever-enclosing world. This unsettling performance proves to be the rudder guiding the film, with Pitt constantly keeping a bullying demeanour of forced joviality at odds with his increasingly parlous situation. He does a great job of it, portraying a man who behind every forced smile and over-friendly manner is becoming increasingly desperate- he€™s lived far too high for far too long and has started to doubt his own not-inconsiderable hype. The audience simultaneously feels both pity and disgust for him, and this is an incredibly hard trick to pull off. Effectively, Pitt€™s entire role embodies the films musings on the cult of celebrity; that a man who was clearly capable of great deeds can quite easily succumb to egomania. He puts across this concept extremely well, wringing out most of the film€™s drama before his own inevitable and tragic conclusion. To find the pathos in a monster meandering towards their own doom is very hard feat, and it€™s a credit to Pitt€™s considerable abilities that he manages it. There€™s a reason he won the Volpi Cup for this one.

2. Tree of Life- Mr. O'Brien

Another key trait of an archetypal €˜Pitt performance€™ is that his characters are quite easy to fathom. Though often entertaining, subtle, they ain€™t. You could probably write down Rusty Ryan€™s and Aldo Raine€™s motivations on the back of a fag packet. It€™s by virtue of his status as an A-lister that Pitt doesn€™t necessarily have to affiliate himself with the more out there, auteur cinema and the sometimes unnecessarily complex, pensive characters of that universe. Really then, it would€™ve been entirely possible that Brad Pitt and Terence Malick would never cross paths. Malick is a famous recluse who shuns the limelight; Pitt recently picked up the largest sum ever for celebrity pictures- $14 million from Hello! and People- for pictures of his new-born children. Different universes, is what I€™m saying. But cross paths they did, and Tree of Life was the result. Pitt really does swing for the fences here, but in a way we haven€™t seen before. As I said earlier, his characters are usually easy to pin down in their motivations. Yet Mr. O€™Brien is anything but. He€™s sympathetic and callous, understandable and irrational. Simply put, he€™s human, not a character. His motivation seems to be entirely based around his family, a noble effort that drags him through the mud. But unlike most films, it's not in a blatant manner. There's no obvious fall from grace here, no grand epiphanies. The drama is-whisper it-human. It's not overt, like in most films. Mr. O'Brien is a disciplinarian, not a psychopath. Though his methods seem draconian, he sees them as necessary, not in the style of the Nuremburg defence, but in a manner similar to 50s parents. Hell, even your parents committed some necessary evils raising you. He's not a film character, he's a person. And that's the point. Despite being Captain A-lister, Pitt has never seemed so...normal. Granted, wife-beating is not a normal state of affairs, but this was a portrayal of a man pushed to his limits, and this exacerbated his inherent (although not obvious) flaws. He was quick to fly off the handle- a very human flaw with which most of us could sympathise, even though we didn't condone the extent of his actions. Moral quandaries aside, the point is that these actions happen; 'normal' people are too tough on their kids, everyday people can be forced into terrible actions. Yet despite Pitt's obvious status at the zenith of the celebrity tree, he sold the hell out being a regular person, leading to a gripping performance. He's not a hero, he's not a villain. He's simply human, with all the light and shade that comes part and parcel of that. In the acting world, there's humanising your character, which often involves a shallow conceit (you want to make your action hero sympathetic? Get him a dog!), and then there's making your character human. This can't be done with cheap tricks- it's a very hard trick to pull off, and Pitt does it with aplomb.

1. Fight Club- Tyler Durden

Come on, could it have been anything else? It's simply Pitt's defining role. Back in the halcyon days of 1999, he was in the best possible condition for it, balancing of the physicality of youth with the gravitas of age. Such a balance would prove integral to the character of Tyler Durden. He's an impossibility- the manner of a charismatic preacher, the mind of a sly, dominating ubermensch and the body of a fighting Calvin Klein model. You wish you were this man. In fact, that's kind of the point. He's an ideal. He's everything you want to be- confident, talented, attractive, ferociously intelligent and I'm pretty sure he could whip you into next week. But shock horror, you realise that he isn't actually real. Again, he's an ideal, a fantasy- the fevered daydream of Ed Norton's Jack/Tyler Durden gone too far.But whilst Tyler the character is most definitely imaginary, it doesn't mean that Pitt's performance is illusory too. The mantle of such a dominating character needs an excellent actor to actually fill it. If an actor is not up to scratch, you could end up with something similar to every Nic Cage film ever. For every individual who can live up to the promise of the vivid characters screenwriters can put on screen, there are any number of bear-suited, women-punching, bee-screaming eejits. So it's very much a credit to Pitt that he can rein in something as obviously phantasmal as Tyler, whilst still keeping him with that consistently believable edge. This Tyler dances on the edge of what a person can be, clearly emanating an air of otherworldliness and sheer impressiveness, but still seeming, well... human. Whether asking you the age-old question of the ass or the crotch, doing unspeakable things in family cinemas or orchestrating a grand, anarchist/luddite conspiracy in order to regain a lost sense of manliness, it is clear that he is capable of great things, and can deliver upon them. Such a premise makes Pitt's performance the jolt that drives the film. This is in contrast to all the other male characters, who appear to have had the motor ripped out of them by modern life. Thanks to Pitt, you believe that this man can inspire others, and he does it without being at all hammy. In fact, he's quite the opposite. He's actually quite calm. The scaled back, wry persona Pitt cultivates makes Tyler seem all the more threatening, and the actor all the more impressive. Tyler's calm reflections upon the eroding of male masculinity (the duvet point being a particular highlight) are lent an even greater power when married to his occasional flair for the theatrical, but when he explains his ideology (...an entire generation pumping gas, waiting tables, slaves with white collars) he never engages in polemics, instead forcing you see the emotive logic behind his lunatic plans thanks to his clear, logical delivery. He's rather understated and insidious, and it's all down to Pitt. His ability to establish in Tyler an unsettling air of authority often seen in cult leaders is mesmerising, and proves to be the film's animus, something the film's all too aware of; they even splice him into the film before his formal introduction, if only to make it clear that the film badly needs this spark. It takes an actor of special talent to be able to shoulder such a responsibility and Pitt pulls it off, making what could've easily been a caricature into a character that whilst not relatable (that's not really the point of him) is certainly believable. Thus he becomes even more compellingly watchable; witness when he burns Jack's hand with lye. He's never anything less than utterly calm whilst logically getting his point across as the situation/burn escalates. Again, whilst this is partly due to the character being a fantasy, at this point we aren't actually supposed to know that, and it is a credit to Pitt's performance that he can make you simultaneously believe in and be in awe of Tyler. That is how you create an immortal performance. Bravo, Brad Pitt.

The 5 That Sucked

5. Ocean's Twelve

When you look at it, Brad Pitt is a perfect fit for the Ocean€™s franchise. He€™s glamorous, impossibly good looking, capable of portraying a sense of slick purpose and easy charm. Plus, he looks ridiculously awesome in a suit. But much like the franchise itself, Pitt''s performances as Rusty Ryan can be described as a series of peaks and troughs. Ocean€™s Eleven was excellent, positively dripping with that old Vegas glamour and possessing a plot that was extremely tight, given the amount of actors the screenwriters had to accommodate for. Pitt was probably on stand-by mode; all he had to do was stand there, look pretty and emanate endless cool. Pitt could do this in his sleep, and given the added boost of standing next to George Clooney, it becomes even easier than that. However, come the time of the second film, the audience had a revelation; there's a fine line between cool and smug, and these fellows had just crossed it. It was cool to have an extensive, complex plan to rob a ruthless Casino mogul, and to have this plan succeed. It's smug to throw all this complex planning out the window and effectively have the entire film amount to a simple bag-swap on a continental train, then ask your audience to marvel at just how brilliant this slight of hand was. But we didn't marvel. We were pissed. Arguably, as one of the main leads, it's Pitt's character that suffers most from this deception. Whilst one could make a case to blame Clooney's Danny Ocean, Danny is still the heart of the film, has obvious depth and has shown himself to be quite charming over a collection of scenes with his wife Tess (who looks like Julia Roberts, y'know). Yet Rusty is played as the epitome of cool. Whilst he is routinely given the run-around by Catherine Zeta-Jones' character, this does his reputation no harm- it merely enhances hers by showing that she can outsmart even Rusty, a man so slick he can get away with eating in every scene, without breaking his charming, debonair aura. Yet Pitt's portrayal of this impossibly cool character has an obvious weakness. He's utterly one dimensional- Rusty is completely defined by how cool he is, and granted, when put in the correct situation, he can be very cool indeed. Yet in the wrong situation, this coolness evaporates faster than the audience goodwill come Twelve's credit sequence, and this leads to a problem- when we knock away this defining feature (like the events of Twelve did), we're left with a non-entity of a character. When the wry canniness of Eleven morphed instead into blatant smart-assery, you really have no reason left at all to root for Rusty. This problem is caused by Pitt's performance; it really is quite vacuous, entirely because this type of role isn't really a challenge for him. When you're already a glamorous, good-looking man, playing a glamorous, good-looking character is hardly a stretch. It certainly wasn't in Eleven, but he got away with it then. This time around, Pitt is so blatantly on autopilot that there's a discreet air of complacency- whether intentional or not- that defines the performance. There's just no effort made beyond the assumption that the character will be cool no matter his actions, and when this assumption falls flat on in it's face, Rusty Ryan is left without a dramatic leg to stand on, and that's entirely Pitt's fault. But if the role is such a non-entity, why have I given it such condemnation? That's simple. The problem is that Pitt is ostensibly playing up to his own stereotype with this role; that he's a good looking man first, an actor second. Whilst the entire Rusty role is hardly the most challenging fare for any actor, Pitt's playing of the character opens up these old criticisms of him, obscuring the fact that deep down he is a decent actor, when he stays away from easy tripe like this.


4. Interview With the Vampire

Interview with the Vampire is a remarkable story of human nature set across several centuries, albeit with homoerotic undertones so blatant you probably could have played Soft Cell in the background and nobody would've batted an eyelid. With it's lavish storytelling and excellent production values (it was Oscar-nominated for both best original score and best costume design) it could've been one of the best films of recent films. As it is, it's sort of alright- a bit long-winded but nonetheless functional as a tale of gothic macabre. So why the decline? I reckon it's Pitt. The fact is that he's just boring in the role. I understand that Louis de Point Du Lac is meant to be a very closed off individual, but for a character that's supposed to be full of internal anguish about his situation, he's surprising buttoned-up and stilted. Even when he eventually completely loses it in some Paris catacombs, you still get the impression that whilst he's read about emotions, he's never actually experienced one properly. Amongst all the Oscar-nominated aesthetics, his performance just slides into the background as the least interesting thing of all. Consequently, putting such a character as the leading narrator in a film can only invite trouble. His deadpan delivery proves to be a weight on the film, detracting away from the varied and interesting plot. Such a performance would be understandable if Louis was supposed to be the straight man (figuratively speaking, wink, wink, nudge, nudge), but he quite patently isn't; that's the job of Christian Slater's interviewer. Louis is meant to show us what it's like to be a vampire; he may not like it, but at least show us that properly, for god's sake. All that comes across instead is a charisma vacuum of the highest order. Pitt may have been aiming for ethereal, but Louis just comes across as boring. With this blank slate in place the film ends up being utterly dominated by Tom Cruise's Lestat. He's interesting in all the ways Louis isn't; he has his own struggles and his own opinions, and most importantly of all, he actively shows them to the audience. It also certainly helps that he's nothing short of outrageously flamboyant all the way through the film, addressing Lestat's selfishness with the devil-may-care attitude that serves to drive on an already egomaniacal character to even greater heights. Louis on the other hand, despite wearing all the decadent frippery of the era, looks dull- he's positively cowed by Cruise. It's one thing to be out-acted by Tom Cruise; at that moment in time, he was one of the most talented working actors in Hollywood. However, when you're being upstaged by a 12-year-old Kirsten Dunst (who admittedly is terrifying as Claudia), it's probably time to revisit the parameters of your role and ask yourself the question; should I emote a bit? If that means you wouldn't find yourself embarrassed by the girl who would later help inflict Spider-Man 3 onto an unwitting world, then the answer is probably yes. Out-acted by the cast and dwarfed by the production, this all just proves to be one abominably average misfire for an actor just about hitting his A-lister stride. He just looks like a pretty face who's wandered over from an Armani advert, and seems slightly confused as to why he's dressed up as a French nobleman.

3. Mr. & Mrs. Smith

Mr. and Mrs. Smith was about a couple living a life of domestic boredom, whilst hilariously unaware that they were both world-class assassins. As the premise for a film goes, this is undoubtedly a good one. But if this is true, why does it all feel so...cold? I'll tell you why; it's the actors. As I've just mentioned, this premise had the potential to be comedy gold. Arguably, Mr. and Mrs. Smith shake a good amount of fun out of it, but the problem is that this genius idea takes a back seat to the pretty people, or Brangelina, as they came to be (irritatingly) known. Selling your film as a star vehicle has it's own rewards (truck -loads of guaranteed money, for one) but also it's fair share of traps. Fundamentally, it shines an even bigger spotlight on the protagonists, so they have to be on top of their game. But more importantly, it's probably a good thing to lay out what game they should be playing. Mr. and Mrs. Smith bungled this horribly. This whole film had all the potential in the world as a comedy, and was certainly sold as such by the actually-pretty-funny trailers. The idea was to juxtapose the inescapable humdrum of everyday living with the fantastical life of a top-of-the-line hitman, and for the the first couple of minutes, the film did this rather well. Through some clever vignettes, such as Angelina Jolie doing the dusting whilst balancing on just one leg of a chair, before getting back onto all four when she hears her husband coming in, we were able to laugh along with the film. However, as the runtime dragged on, you could tell more and more than the very presence of Pitt and Jolie were changing things somewhat. Simply put, their megastar status took the quirky vibe away from the film, as it endeavoured to give them more screentime at the risk of diluting the premise. I'll explain. Basically, much like Ocean's Twelve, this was Pitt on his cool-as-all-hell autopilot. You got the feeling that he turned up on set, played himself for a bit, and then went home. This would be fine in a film like the Oceans franchise, where everybody (barring the electronics expert) is a thoroughly urbane and charismatic. However, this isn't a film with this sort of people. It's about everyday life, and it's dullness, made all the more pertinent by the character's job as an assassin. But Pitt still carries on as his regular, glamorous self, seemingly unable to help himself. I haven't met many insurance people with the good looks and droll wit that Pitt's John Smith seems to have, never mind an office drone who's built like a fighting machine. He's just too remarkable to ever convince. His obvious A-lister quality sticks out like a sore thumb amongst the hedgerows of suburbia, so the film feels obligated to make up ways to further use such star power. This causes a stripping back of a once-clever plot in favour of an asinine shoot-em-up, and this is a shame, because it didn't have to be this way. Whilst Pitt was later able to show that he can do comedy in Burn After Reading,the writers seem to think it incomprehensible that a bonafide mega-star would be capable of lampooning himself unless he looks cool whilst doing it. Sadly, Pitt appeared to have been all too happy to go along with the charade; he foregoes the obvious plot goldmine in favour of a series of empty action set-pieces designed to make the protagonists look as good as possible, and that's disappointing, to say the least. Couple this with the clear sexual chemistry between (groan) Brangelina, and you've got a film that just abandoned everything clever in order to focus on encouraging a cult of personality around it's two leading actors, who frankly could've played backgammon for two hours and still found an audience willing to watch. The point is that there was no challenge, no need for Pitt to exert himself, and without that drive, he easily fell back into old habits, squandering any potential this film may have had. This distinct misunderstanding of the role and consequent lack of acting effort causes the film to lose all emotional depth. Why should we care about this couple, when they're quite easily capable of obliterating a small private military company all by themselves? I'd rather ask a different question; whatever happened to the argument about the curtains? I can't help but feel that answering the second question would've been more interesting- I've seen thousands of movie explosions in my time, but never something as intriguing as a trained killer's arguments on home decor. It's unfortunate that Pitt's very presence on this film denied me this.


2. Troy

Troy represents one of Brad Pitt€™s highest-grossing films. However, the sad truth of modern Hollywood is that just because something makes a lot of money, it doesn€™t necessarily mean that it€™s a good film. But Troy isn€™t a bad film, it€™s just€ mediocre, much like the actor himself in this. Sadly, it could've been so much better. We€™ve already established that Pitt has a natural affinity with alpha male characters. So, at first glance, his decision to portray the nigh-on invincible classical hero Achilles was something of a perfect fit. Pitt is capable of exuding a sense of natural authority and can be a commanding presence. Couple this with his bulked-up physical appearance, and you have somebody who could easily evoke both the physicality and mindset of a demigod. Unfortunately, he only pulls off half of the demands of this role. He€™s excellent in the physical aspects, managing to nail the god-like fighting style of a man who is clearly beyond mere humans. However, it€™s in the dramatic conveyance of Achilles where Pitt falls down. Whilst there is a memorable performance by a tragic soldier-character in Troy, it€™s Eric Bana who takes these plaudits. Pitt€™s performance is forgettable at best. Granted, Achilles is supposed to be a wholly un-likeable character, albeit with the caveat that he is a fundamentally good one. However, whilst this inner conflict is meant to inspire something in the audience, we doesn't really see it like this. Whilst Pitt is trying to convey something akin to a level of burden and aloofness common in demigods, he doesn€™t work the gears hard enough. Instead of portraying world-weariness and inner torment, he just ends up looking hung over. Thus, all dramatic power is lost- instead of making the audience question what's wrong with the world, we end up wondering what's wrong with the actor. They must've been serving good scotch on those Turkish sets. But this is only one part of the problem of a much larger problem; the fundamental misinterpretation over how to portray the character. Arguably, if you're going to play a Greek classical hero, I don't think being introspective is the way to go- you should probably attempt some bombast and give yourself an effusive personality to mesh with the obvious physicality and grandiose plots on show. These guys aren't regular human beings, they're supposed to be caricatures. By not realising this, Pitt makes a massive mistake. Perhaps he over-thought it- he wants to make the character seem nuanced by giving him a brooding edge, but this sits so uneasily with this mighty character that it actually alienates the audience. The rest of the cast resemble archetypes; the foppish Paris, the battle-hardened Hector, the dickish Agamemnon. We know what they are, so we know how to react to them, and they inform the story accordingly. However, Achilles is much harder to fathom, and therefore much harder to relate to. Unfortunately, the blame for this has to be laid at Pitt's feet. The true, disastrous scope of creating an introvert-Achilles becomes even more apparent when he's put in scenes that require him to display outward emotion. Consider the scene where his elite unit have to break the news to a departing Achilles that his cousin Patroclus has been killed. Everybody else is working really quite hard to mark out that this is a heart-rending, dramatic scene. It€™s arguably the pivot upon which the plot of the film is turned. It€™s at this moment where you need your actor to really chew some scenery. Yet Pitt just can€™t rise to this challenge. Rather than acting in the grand, dramatic way the Iliad was clearly set out for, he retreats back into himself, and attempts to brood again. Except this time, the misinterpretation of the situation leads to a complete and utter dramatic fumble. Pitt's lack of gravitas makes him look like he's visibly doubting what he should do, to the point where it becomes actually hilarious. He ends up looking like a shell of himself, being operated by a tiny Derek Zoolander. He's trying so hard, he actually pouts. If that's the best emotion that your lead actor can summon, we might as well all go home. Something's clearly gone wrong.

1. Cool World

When you compare this offering to modern Pitt fare, it's much like a lion riding a bicycle. You could conceive of the prospect and you might even find it hilarious, but deep down you'd know that it could never really happen. Getting a lion's paws on those stirrups would be just as far-fetched a prospect as Brad Pitt starring in a Who Framed Roger Rabbit ripoff. An entertaining thought, but an impossible one.

Well, it turns out it wasn't. Whilst lions have yet to master two-wheeled transport, Brad Pitt has starred in one of the worst films ever to hit the world at large. But much like us all, he made mistakes in his formative years; he was young and dumb, just starting out, willing to put his name to anything that looked like it had potential.

To be fair to him, for a time it did actually look like Cool World would've been an interesting idea. Director and writer Ralph Bakshi pitched a film to Hollywood about a hybrid being born to adult and cartoon parents, who travels into the real world to kill her absentee father. It was going to be the world's first horror cartoon, a sleazy, colourful romp that left you feeling dirty all over, in that classic film noir style. Again, maybe it wasn't a good idea, but damn, that's pretty interesting.

But then came a studio-mandated rewrite where Gabriel Byrne's cartoonist effectively bones one of his creations into flesh-and-blood existence. Digest that last sentence, if you will. Read it again. Yes, the actual premise of this film was that Byrne's character had a magic penis, and he just had to get his freak on with his own Jessica Rabbit-aping cartoon. It's essentially most of deviantART's wet dream, minus the Hippogriffs.

The job of Pitt's 1940s gumshoe (again, why?) job was to stop this unholy union from taking place, probably the very definition of a thankless task. It's just that the script is that special combination of wooden, fantastical and awful. As a result, it's hard for Pitt to come across as anything but awful. His motivation seemed to go something like this; I'm deadly serious, and so's my cartoon spider. When a cartoon spider's involved, the very premise of a film noir is invalidated by sheer lunacy. But the worst thing here is that he's not even on autopilot, he's just confused about his role in this mess. He, along with Byrne, are trying really hard to make this shocking material work. But much like you can't build an ice sculpture out of shit, you couldn't get a good performance out of Cool World. It was just a disaster zone.

It didn't help that the animation was so poor, especially for a Bakshi film. Whilst the film it was aping, Who Framed Roger Rabbit, managed to make it look like Bob Hoskins and Roger Rabbit were living on the same plane of existence, the film gives Pitt no favours, distracting away from an already troubled performance through a series of glitching errors and unnatural positions between the 'doodles' and humans. You ended up just wishing it would stop.

To put it lightly, the animation made him awful to watch, and the dialogue/premise made him awful to listen to, and this was compounded by real-life scenes so bad that they resembled one of those budget films you found on the mediocre film channels. For all intents and purposes, it looked as though Brad had stumbled onto that set by accident wearing a preposterous zoot suit he'd just fished out of a charity shop bin. It just seemed as if the film embodied the very thing that would become a common criticism of Pitt; that as an actor, he's all style, no substance. I don't often like to say it, but if you ever needed evidence for this claim, you didn't need to look any further than Cool World, a film so bad it dragged Pitt's considerable efforts down with it.


Contributor
Contributor

Durham University graduate and qualified sports journalist. Very good at sitting down and watching things. Can multi-task this with playing computer games. Football Manager addict who has taken Shrewsbury Town to the summit of the Premier League. You can follow me at @Ed_OwenUK, if you like ramblings about Newcastle United and A Place in the Sun. If you don't, I don't know what I can do for you.