Bright Review: 3 Ups & 6 Downs

Netflix's first blockbuster is a sure disappointment.

Bright Will Smith Joel Edgerton
Netflix

It's been in the works for a damn long time, but Netflix's first card-carrying blockbuster movie, Bright, is finally now available to stream, and...it's not very good.

It sucks to say it, as with a cast this great and a premise this peculiar, Bright could've earmarked Netflix as the home for left-field, big-budget movies that traditional studios won't gamble on.

That may still be the case depending on how many people watch the film, but it's a shame that Netflix's first high-priced, star-studded movie is being mostly skewered by critics.

Is it the worst film of 2017 as some critics have hyperbolically dubbed it? Absolutely not, but it squanders a good deal of its potential and ultimately ends up a watchable, mediocre effort most people will stream while eating their dinner and quickly forget about soon after.

Though the movie's success or failure will ultimately just be a drop in the ocean for Netflix, one hopes that low-rent offerings like this don't discourage other A-list stars from taking the leap...


Downs...

6. Max Landis' Script Is A Hot Mess

Bright Will Smith Joel Edgerton
Netflix

Bright was written by Max Landis, so it's little surprise that the end product is a muddled mess of ideas, as was especially apparent in his screenplays for American Ultra and Victor Frankenstein back in 2015.

Landis' script for this movie is ambitious to a point, but it also fails to reconcile its various different genres - gritty cop thriller, fantasy adventure film and buddy cop comedy - into a coherent whole, resulting in a sloppy mash-up that just feels totally all over the place.

From the tone, which fleets from goofy to grimdark at the turn of a heel, to the total lack of character development for some of the film's more pivotal characters and its checklist of concepts cribbed from other, better movies, it feels like a film trying to please about half a dozen different types of audiences, but ultimately not fully satisfying any of them.


5. The Action Sequences Are Unremarkable

Bright Will Smith Joel Edgerton
Netflix

Perhaps the most disappointing thing about this movie is that the action sequences are oddly benign for the most part, failing to make good use of the reported $90 million budget to deliver any remotely memorable set-pieces.

Ayer largely settles for monotonous, repetitive shootouts and a forgettable car chase, with the only vaguely notable action involving Noomi Rapace's villain Leilah stylishly annihilating some humans who get in her way.

Considering that Ayer has pulled off some stunning action in his career before (namely Fury's climactic battle), it's a shame he plays things so safe despite the huge sandbox of toys and actors he's given to play with here.

Rather than use the fantasy twist to heighten the usual cop thriller shootouts and chases, it all feels weirdly ordinary.


4. Noomi Rapace & Edgar Ramirez Are Totally Wasted

Bright Noomi Rapace
Netflix

Bright benefits from a terrific ensemble cast...that it does absolutely nothing with. Especially given the short shrift is Noomi Rapace, who plays the dark elf Leilah, yet barely any glimpse is given into her motivations or reasoning beyond "she's evil, just because".

Apart from a few fun action beats, she deserves so much better. Then there's the talented Edgar Ramirez, who appears as an FBI elf named Kandomere, but apart from getting to wear a snazzy-looking suit, he gets almost nothing to do.

That's without even mentioning Suicide Squad's Jay Hernandez, who briefly appears as one of Will Smith's cop pals, but again, there's nothing to his character so it's easy to forget he's even in it.

In fact, of the film's supporting cast, the only actor used even remotely well is Ike Barinholtz, who just as he did in Suicide Squad, plays a skeezy scumbag cop to mildly entertaining effect.


3. The Social Commentary Is Lazy & Ham-Fisted

Bright Will Smith
Netflix

There's a vaguely satirical element to this film that was hinted at in the marketing, that in a world where fairies, Orcs and humans live together, the prejudices that already exist in real life are massively exaggerated.

Joel Edgerton's Orc cop Nick Jakoby, for instance, is viewed with pure disdain by his human cop colleagues, and there's a prevailing "cops are scumbags" commentary that feels undeniably pointed towards the recent Black Lives Matter protests. In fact, in one of the film's first scenes, Will Smith's cop Daryl Ward kills a fairy that's bothering him, before telling some onlookers, "Fairy lives don't matter today."

Though Max Landis has written the film with a socially conscious bent, unfortunately it's about as deep as a puddle and laughably lacking in subtlety, to the point that it ultimately feels shoehorned into a story that didn't really need it.

There was absolutely a way to pull this off, but Landis doesn't seem interested in anything more than a cheeky, simplistic nod to real world events.


2. It's Not Weird Enough

Bright Will Smith Joel Edgerton
Netflix

This might seem like a weird complaint to make about a movie where a human and an Orc team up to stop an evil dark elf from using a magic wand to summon an ancient evil that will destroy the world...but Bright just isn't weird enough.

When you break it down, the film's throughline is actually very simple: the main plot is pure fantasy nonsense everyone's seen dozens of times before, the action is fairly grounded and subdued for the most part, and it doesn't get truly bonkers in the way it should have.

Clearly Netflix felt that the shell premise was enough of a gamble, and making things any more strange or surreal could've turned off the casual crowd. While it wouldn't be fair to call the film boring or bland, there are times, especially during lengthy exposition dumps, where it feels practically ordinary.


1. A Sequel Is Already On The Way

Bright Will Smith Joel Edgerton
Netflix

Before Bright even became available for streaming, Netflix confirmed that a sequel has been given the greenlight, with Will Smith already attached to return.

It's a bit of a gamble considering the film's generally mixed-negative critical response, though for the streaming platform it will ultimately come down to how many people watch the movie.

To that end, if Adam Sandler's Netflix movies always open to #1 viewership in every worldwide territory, it seems likely that Bright will be deemed a "success" for the platform, and the sequel will definitely go ahead.

Such is one of the drawbacks of Netflix's model: they're swimming in so much cash right now and don't need audiences to fork over cash specifically to watch a particular movie, so we're going to get a sea of mediocre projects like this that people watch hungover, as well as their wildly unnecessary sequels that are probably even worse.

Though Bright is undeniably a disappointing first blockbuster for Netflix, it's not a total, irredeemable trainwreck, so here's what actually worked...


Ups...

3. Will Smith & Joel Edgerton's Solid Performances

Bright Will Smith Joel Edgerton
Netflix

There are two constants in this film that are consistently entertaining, and that's Will Smith and Joel Edgerton in the lead roles. For all of the film's flaws, they absolutely give it their all and make for a fun double act, not remotely embarrassing themselves or just lazily phoning their work in.

Smith is, well, exactly what everyone expects from him here, and that's not a bad thing, while Edgerton is his more sympathetic and intriguing foil, and together they make for a compelling duo who clearly deserve a much better script.

Basically, if Edgerton and Smith aren't paired up again in the sequel, there's no point even bothering.


2. The Superb Makeup Effects

Bright Joel Edgerton
Netflix

Much like Ayer's previous film Suicide Squad, which controversially won an Oscar for its makeup effects, Bright benefits hugely from its fantastic makeup work.

As much as you might dislike the film in other areas, the fantastically lifelike Orc makeup allows Edgerton and other actors to completely disappear into their characters, while also blending into the aesthetic enough to not look totally ridiculous.

The elf characters also look great, especially those played by Noomi Rapace and Edgar Ramirez, so it's ultimately just a shame that this excellent crafts work didn't end up in a better film.

On the flip side, Bright has qualified into the final seven movies eligible for the Best Makeup and Hairstyling Oscar, so it could very well end up nominated for an Academy Award in a few short weeks.


1. The Banter Is Sometimes Enjoyable

Bright Will Smith
Netflix

Though the script is totally all over the place, it does at least manage to intermittently hit the mark when it comes down to the quick-fire banter between Smith and Edgerton's characters.

Though David Ayer didn't write the film, he's proven in films like Training Day, End of Watch and Fury that he has a real knack for directing entertaining chit-chat, and some of that clearly rubs off here.

The back-and-forth between the cop protagonists is generally played for laughs, but there are even occasional moments where it hits home on a dramatic level, specifically a heart-to-heart between the pair at the end of the second act.

When the film isn't busy trying to drown the audience in excess exposition, it actually stops to take a breather and teases out something approaching real character development.

What did you think of Bright? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Will Smith
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.