Captain Marvel Trailer Review: 9 Ups & 2 Downs
A new era of the MCU begins with a bang...
Ladies, gentlemen and green-skinned aliens masquerading as humans, the dawn of a new era is here. The second age of the MCU - in which female superheroes will lead the charge and we visit brave new worlds, new times and new characters - is here with the long-awaited arrival of the first Captain Marvel trailer.
And after a marketing campaign that has consciously fed off silence, it's truly wonderful to see that the first trailer seems to be living up to the hype. It shouldn't come as any surprise, given the studio's flare for marketing, but this was still something of an unknown quantity and they've knocked it out of the park.
Here's the trailer...
Now that really is something. It gets a lot of things right without anything too negative sticking out (though there are some slight reservations on a couple of things) and more than anything, it really draws you in. If you weren't already hyped, there's no way you aren't now.
So what works and what maybe doesn't so much? First the negatives. And trust me, there's not a lot of bad to say about this.
Downs
2. Agent Coulson's De-Aging
Look, this is not a major negative at all but Clark Gregg's one shot in the trailer suggests that it might have been better to digitally de-age him than just relying on make-up and a hair-piece.
When this film is set (and we can assume it's the mid-1990s (judging by the pager used, which appears to be a Motorola Advisor, but not the Gold, which was released in 1997, so presumably sometime before then), Coulson should be around 30 a most. Unfortunately, no amount of make-up can make Clark Gregg look 30, because Clark Gregg looked 50 when he was 30. So it sticks out a little.
Again, it's not ruinous, but it's a bit of a shame, considering Snapchat can make you look 10 years younger in a matter of seconds and that's a free app.
1. There's Some Michael Bay Shooting Going On
Perhaps it's because the film is consciously trying to get a 90s aesthetic and vibe about it, but there's an awful lot of shots in this trailer that feel a little like a Michael Bay action movie. His approach to shot choice has always leaned heavily on his "peak work" in the 1990s and the slanted images and slightly over-zealous use of slow-motion are VERY reminiscent of his work.
That won't be a major problem for a lot of people who actually like what Michael Bay does - and to a certain extent it is a clever comment on 90s action films to mimic their style a little (if it's a conscious thing) - but Bay's work is so much of a divisive thing these days that it's heavily parodied and that's not really a great thing to ape seriously.
Again, though, it's a minor negative more than anything, but it's certainly a consideration.
And now to the positives...
Ups
9. How They Establish The 90s Vibe
There were MANY ways Marvel could have established that the film is set in the 90s. We could have had a title screen overtly stating as much, just as Captain America: Civil War revealed the Peter Parker sequence to a huge audience reaction, but instead they do something a lot better and a lot funnier.
The trailer opening with Captain Marvel landing with a thud on top of a Blockbuster is one of the most ingenious things ever done in a Marvel trailer. It's incredible, succinct establishing work that sells the message far, far better than anything else could and it's likely to give fans a laugh in the process.
If that's a reflection of how the directors have put the rest of the film together, we're in for a treat.
8. The Effects Look Great
Given Marvel's powers, it was always inevitable that we'd see a lot of effects work in here and it looks like the studio are using all of their financial might and technical prowess to make sure it's all very glossy.
There's no hint of the CGI rag-doll effect even the likes of Black Panther was a victim of in its first trailer and there's nothing here that suggests that the trailer has been pushed out unfinished in that department. It even feels like the effects will be held back for a sort of investiagtive road movie that sees Marvel hunting her alien enemy and only going big on her powers in the final act.
On top of that, what little action we've got in there looks pretty great. But it's very much only designed to show how much of a big deal Marvel is at this stage so there's not a huge amount of detail just yet.
7. The Hero Shot
Marvel know how to do hero shots like nothing else. That spinning shot of The Avengers from the start of the Battle Of New York set the bar pretty high but it wasn't the first example and it certainly wasn't the last.
Hero shots are effectively Marvel Studios' answer to comic book splash pages: it's where they get to build up the iconography of their characters and trumpet their importance and heroism in a single, easily marketable shot that will stick with the audience. The fact that the trailer for Captain Marvel ends on her effectively going Super Saiyan (to steal from another fandom) in one of the best hero shots so far in the MCU is nothing short of ingenious.
After the slow build of not showing off her iconic red and blue suit, to get that powering up shot right at the end is the real money shot and it lands a hell of a haymaker.
6. The Clever New Origin
When it was revealed that Marvel were making Captain Marvel and that we'd be getting to see how she gets her powers, some fans would have immediately been drawn to the problem presented by that awful Green Lantern film that Ryan Reynolds wishes had been struck from the record.
Unfortunately, that film starts with an origin story that is almost identical to the most famous Captain Marvel origin and nobody wants that sort of parallel being drawn. So instead, it appears we're getting something else: it appears we're going to meet Captain Marvel fully formed, arriving to 1990s Earth and then finding herself reminded of a human origin that she might have been initially unaware of.
It's a little like her host - Carol Danvers - was body-snatched and then her return to Earth (on the trail of the Skrulls who land there) awakens those feelings. Essentially, the film appears to be doing something different in their approach here, with Marvel actually investigating her own origin and finding out the origin of Carol Danvers rather than the other way round. It's a cool distinction and difference is definitely a hugely marketable commodity for this release.
5. There's No Infinity War Coat-Tail Riding
How easy would it have been for Marvel to use the huge selling power of Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers 4 to market Captain Marvel? After all, that post-credits scene with the intergalactic pager was one of the lasting images of that movie (alongside all of that unfortunate death) and raised some pretty big questions about Captain Marvel's involvement in Avengers 4 as the saviour.
But it's great to see that Marvel haven't gone with that approach, which would have been pretty reductive, in all honesty. It would have suggested that they didn't have enough faith in the character to market her as her own thing and that would have been terrible for perceptions of the film.
The only real allusion to that film is the loaded shot of Nick Fury's Motorola pager, which would later be augmented to communicate with Captain Marvel in the Infinity War stinger. And that's JUST enough of a reminder that she's going to be a big part of Avengers 4 without anyone's toes being trodden on unnecessarily.
4. De-Aged Nick Fury
Samuel L Jackson is a pretty ever-green guy and he's looked pretty much the same for the past two decades, but even he would struggle to look like he'd stepped out of the 90s without a little assistance. And honestly, there were some concerns when the film's setting was announced and it seemed we might have to see him digitally de-aged in the vein of Rogue One's... unfortunateness.
But Jackson looks incredible.
Whoever has worked their magic on him deserves an Oscar because he doesn't even look like he's been de-aged - which is always a bit of a thing when it comes to this approach that you just have to subconsciously accept. He looks like he's genuinely 20 plus years younger. In fact, he looks about 35, which is astonishing for a man who is 69 years old.
He's clearly been getting his vitamins and considering how much he's going to be involved in this film (by the look of it anyway), his look being that organically convincing is definitely a good thing.
3. It Doesn't Ruin The Entire Plot
The two worst things about trailers these days are that they have those awful pre-trailer teases for no reason (as if the audience need a TL:DR version before they can commit to watching a couple of minutes) and that they give away way too much. Trailer studios are given way too much power to get the shots in there that will sell the trailer, without any consideration for how much it ruins of the final film. And yes, Marvel have been guilty of it themselves in the past.
But here, the agenda is more akin to a mood board. We get world building and character hints (some of which, like the Skrull, Jude Law's Mar-Vell and Coulson) are limited to single shots and a rough idea of Captain Marvel coming to Earth and discovering a mysterious connection to the place and to her former identity as Carol Danvers.
Other than that, if you didn't know about the Skrull story, you'd be forgiven for not really knowing the main thrust of the story. And that's a brave thing to do, but it also allows the trailer more space to really show off Captain Marvel herself.
2. Girl Power!
The biggest positive for Marvel making this movie is the effect it's going to have on a generation of young girls who will now have someone who they could really aspire to be as one of the MCU's titular heroes. That was one of the biggest things to have come out of Wonder Woman's success (and of Black Panthers in terms of that film's representation of black identities) and it's going to be a major deal for Captain Marvel.
And the film absolutely nails its Girl Power message. It's hard to recall any of the MCU's leads whose powers have been this heavily shown off in a first trailer, but that's only part of it. The narrative of the trailer is very much focused on Carol Danver's strength and coolness while making her gender an incidental thing, rather than a marketing opportunity. There's no sexualised imagery, there's no insidious "but she's JUST a girl" imagery, it's all brilliantly balanced.
There's very much a vibe that we're going to see Marvel hunting Skrulls in disguise on Earth (hence her punching the old woman) and that should provide lots of opportunity for us to see more of the complexities of her character rather than just her punching things and shooting energy beams out of her hands.
Also, nothing says girl power like punching an old lady on a train. Please do not try this yourself. The outcome will be vastly different.
1. Mythology Building (But With Subtlety)
If you hadn't already caught it in the marketing, Kevin Feige wants us all to know that Captain Marvel is the most powerful hero who has ever come to the MCU. He's even stated that much pretty overtly in the past and this trailer might as well have been made with his mantra at the top of all of the editors' screens.
As such, the trailer does a magnificent job of building up her instant mythology without giving too much away. We see flashes of her powers and there's definitely a look at Carol Danver's already impressive physical strength even before she "levels up" and the whole thing screams Big Deal.
And crucially, this is all without ever really showing who she's fighting (aside from the old lady), which is a remarkably clever creative choice because all we have to compare her to is herself and the other human characters. Without showing her in open combat with an imposing alien enemy, but while also hinting heavily at them through atmospheric building and a general ominous tone, she looks like a total bad-ass.
It's the difference between watching a boxing match and watching a hype video of each boxer working out and sparring with a hobbled opponent. This is how you do hype for a comic book movie character you want everyone to know is the real deal.
What did you think of this trailer? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.