Cate Blanchett: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

The Curious Case Of Why She Was In Benjamin Button.

Cate Blanchett breaths rarefied acting air as one of the most well-respected, most-decorated and just plain best performers of this or maybe any generation. Unlike a lot of her peers, too, she's managed to build up that reputation by picking and choosing what jobs she takes on. There's barely any total duffers in her back catalogue. She has discerning tastes. Which means that, on the whole, when you watch a Cate Blanchett film you're pretty much guaranteed both a brilliant, multi-layered and believable performance, but also a decent movie to match. A film that's deserving of her mad acting skills. Plus she's in How to Train Your Dragon 2, which was a nice surprise. This weekend sees the release of Disney's live action remake of Cinderella, from Shakespearean actor/Thor director Kenneth Branagh and starring Blanchett as Lady Tremaine €“ better known as Cindy's Wicked Stepmother. What she does with that part remains to be seen. In the meantime, whilst we wait on just how passive-aggressive and chore-happy she gets in that role, it's time to remember not only some of her best acting parts...but also the few times she's let us down. These are Cate Blanchett's five awesome performances, and five that sucked.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Magdalena €œMaggie€ Gilkeson €“ The Missing (2003)

For the most part, Ron Howard is not in the business of making badass action films. He may have started his career with car chase thriller Grand Theft Auto, but since then the former Happy Days star has plied his trade with more family-friendly affairs like How the Grinch Stole Christmas and prestige dramas like A Beautiful Mind. But for one shining moment in 2003, he figured he should give a revisionist Western a crack, and it's probably the best thing he's ever done. Helped in no small part by the source material (Thomas Eidson's 1996 The Last Ride), Tommy Lee Jones and Cate Blanchett. Really it's Blanchett's show, as Jones's estranged daughter forced to team up with her absent father to track down her own child when she's kidnapped. Blanchett's Maggie is not always a sympathetic heroine, but she's one of the most interesting women characters in the history of Westerns.

4. Jude Quinn (Bob Dylan) €“ I'm Not There (2007)

Technically it was €œJude Quinn€ Cate Blanchett was playing in I'm Not There, but the frizzy wig, skinny-fit suit and harmonica were a dead give away. Todd Haynes' unorthodox biopic of folk music legend Bob Dylan cast six different actors to portray different facets of the mercurial singer-songwriter's personality and history, including Heath Ledger, Ben Whishaw and Richard Gere. There was also 11-year old African American boy Marcus Carl Franklin as the young Dylan obsessed with Woody Guthrie, and Christian Bale as the protest singer who gets held up as the voice of the revolution. But Blanchett gets the real plumb role, made up as the electric Dylan who earned accusations of €œJudas!€ This was the Dylan €“ or €œQuinn€ €“ who lead interviewers through dizzying linguistic gymnastics with oblique answers and equally obtuse lyrics. It's not an easy part of Dylan's career to capture, which is probably why Haynes went for Blanchett. Within five minutes of her on screen she's totally absorbed into the character. Despite being, well, a lady.

3. Sheba Hart €“ Notes On A Scandal (2006)

Patrick Marber, the new Shakespeare and writer of stilted sex drama Closer, adapted Zoë Heller's best-selling psychological drama for the screen. The scandalous premise is what first draws attention to the film €“ Sheba Hart (Cate Blanchett) is a history teacher who enters into an affair with a fifteen-year-old student, and is subsequently blackmailed by a colleague (Judi Dench). But it's the character drama, rather than the movement of the plot, that makes Notes On A Scandal such a great film. Dench's retirement-age spinster Barbara Covett is not just threatening to tell all about Sheba's transgression for the fun of it, but because she has her own attraction to the younger woman, setting up a uniquely dark love triangle. Blanchett as Sheba is the triumph, of course, with the actor not only managing to dress down to a dowdy teacher but convincingly put together a sympathetic performance as a paedophile. The panic and terror as she tries desperately to cover her tracks and avoid the advances of Dench's character are brilliantly wrought and never tumble into TV movie histrionics, as the premise so closely flirts with.

2. Queen Elizabeth I €“ Elizabeth (1998)

It only makes sense that an actor with the sort of regal presence and commanding power of Cate Blanchett would one day find herself playing royalty. In fact in this case it happened twice, as she reprised the part of Queen Elizabeth I in 2007's Elizabeth: The Golden Age, re-teaming with director Shekhar Kapur and some fabulous costumes to dispel all memories of Miranda Richardson in Blackadder. Costume dramas are the sort of bread-and-butter of your prestige actor, a chance to show off how good you are at talking all old-timey whilst also putting across a sense of gravitas. Despite not knowing what you're going on about. Kapur's films were far from your average historical dress-up game in a country house, however. For one thing, both Elizabeth films are only loosely based on true events, with Kapur opting to look more into the Queen as a character, rather than a pawn in grand political games. Which, again, is why Blanchett was on board as the titular monarch, bringing a dignity, grace and hidden depths. And great wigs.

1. Jeanette €œJasmine€ Francis €“ Blue Jasmine (2013)

Blanchett's most recent awards success €“ netting her the Academy Award, BAFTA, Golden Globe and Screen Actors Guild Award For Best Lead Actress €“ was, obviously, well deserved. A shame one of her all-time best performances had to come in a Woody Allen film, which seems a bit like one of those monkey paw wishes that comes with a terrible price. Anyway, despite working with a scumbag's script she made gold. Manhattan socialite Jasmine is not an easy character to make sympathetic. Even less so when she's forced to leave her life of leisure, following her businessman husband's arrest for dodgy dealing and death, and is forced to shack up with her working-class sister and her husband. Which she doesn't take well. Throughout Blue Jasmine the film makes it intensely difficult to sympathise with Jasmine, but Blanchett's portrayal is so well-rounded and real and human that even when she's being an awful sh*t to everyone around her, she still feels like a real person. One who's much more complex than simply an entitled nasty lady. It's a combination of script and actor that's made Cate Blanchett's best roles just that. But then there are the times when it's not quite up to snuff...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Kate Wheeler €“ Bandits (2001)

Blanchett actually earned Best Actress nominations at the Golden Globes Screen Actors Guild Awards for her supporting role in this Barry Levinson-directed crime caper, but that seems more in spite of the film than because of it. Being a woman of discerning tastes (and genuine talents), Cate Blanchett hasn't appeared in a whole lot of films you could categorise as uniformly bad. But when you stumble across a thoroughly average movie in her otherwise glittering filmography, it stands out like a sore thumb. And that's exactly what this clumsy crime-rom-com thing is. Bandits is by no means a bad film, but the amount of talent involved should really have come up with something better. Bruce Willis and Billy Bob Thornton take the lead as a couple of hapless bank robbers known as the €œSleepover Bandits€ because they kidnap the manager of a target bank the night before a planned robbery. Then Blanchett's bored housewife, literally running away from her marriage, bumps into them and a weird love triangle between her and the two convicts begins. That's a lot of set up, but without much pay off, the film never quite deciding on its tone and collapsing into a needlessly convoluted ending. Levinson not deciding on what film he was making means the actors can only do so much.

4. Lady Marian €“ Robin Hood (2010)

There's nobody who's going to defend this, is there? The outcry at a Blade Runner sequel without original director Ridley Scott might have been tempered somewhat if people remembered how long it had been since he made a good film. Before he returned to his other big sci-fi franchise with Alien prequel Prometheus, his last big blockbuster effort was yet another missed target. Who knows why you'd even bother making another Robin Hood film when Disney's animated one from the sixties is the best one, but maybe Sir Scott likes a challenge. Not that he's up to them if this turgid, po-faced and just plain tedious new take on the Nottinghamshire legend is anything to go by. Russell Crowe does his usually scowly, indeterminate accent thing as Robin Of Loxley, refusing to give his character any sort of personality besides €œgrrr€. Blanchett lost a bet or something so she was contractually obliged to play Maid Marian, and commits as much as original actress Sienna Miller was probably going to.

3. Lola €“ The Man Who Cried (2000)

If you've never heard of this Anglo-French historical drama, well, good for you. But rest assured it is terrible and an early sign of Johnny Depp's slow descent into career apathy. Which is kind of a shame, because director Sally Potter had previously managed to bash Virginia Woolf's book Orlando into a serviceable screenplay with Tilda Swinton in a decade before. But that was then, and this is a slightly more recent then, and instead of adapting a work of literature by one of history's greatest writers Potter penned her own screenplay. It did not go down well. The Man Who Cried is a sort of sweeping drama where a young Jewish girl is seperated from her father in Russia, is raised in England, and then moves to Paris for the outbreak of World War II. It's a series of unfortunate events, with too many coincidences to take seriously and not enough levity to make the drama really work. Blanchett plays Lola, an older Russian woman that the young woman (Christina Ricci) lives with for a bit. That's about as much character development as she gets. Just boring and flat.

2. Daisy Fuller €“ The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button (2008)

Every director has his low points. Steven Spielberg has failed war-comedy 1941, Quentin Tarantino mucked up Death Proof, and M Night Shyamalan has his entire career. In the curious case of David Fincher, it was an uncharacteristically sentimental, drawn-out Forrest Gump rip-off masquerading as an adaptation of an F Scott Fitzgerald short story. And, yes, the screenplay was actually by the Forrest Gump guy. Who has apparently only ever had one idea his whole life, since The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button is another picaresque tale of a man's life that takes in every major historical event of his lifetime, ending with Hurricane Katrina for some reason. Except here the man in question ages backwards! It's a three hour long tech demo of the special effects that let Brad Pitt age backwards, essentially, with more time spent on that and making everything else look authentically old-timey without bothering with, y'know, writing good characters. Blanchett is Pitt's love interest, and that's as far as her character gets. A waste.

1. Colonel-Doctor Irina Spalko €“ Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull (2008)

2008 was a banner year for bad decisions for Cate Blanchett, as she indulged in another talented director's worst first. Oh sure, 1941 was a colossal failure, but at least it had noble intentions. Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull was a cynical cash-in of a beloved, long-dead franchise which somehow managed to forget about everything that made people love the films in the first place. It's too painful to recount everything that sucked about the fourth Indiana Jones films, and everyone already knows that the ants, the monkeys, the gophers and the fridge are amongst the worst screenwriting decisions this decade. But the true crime of The Kingdom of The Crystal Skull might be its wholesale waste of acting talent. Ray Winstone does his cockney wide boy thing as Indiana's old mucker-turned-enemy...but is never anything more than a caricature. Ditto for Shia LaBeouf as Rebel Without A Cause greaser Mutt. And then there's Blanchett, sporting a goofy wig and Russian accent as the big bad. It's pantomime stuff, and not in a good way. All Indiana Jones villains are broad and silly, but at least they're usually...well, characters.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/