Charlize Theron: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

Furious, occasionally frightening, but never, ever expected.

Charlize Theron The Huntsman Winters War.png
Universal Pictures

Hollywood has a nasty habit of pigeon-holing actors. If you want charismatic, delightfully haired action heroes you call Tom Cruise, everyman, easy charm? Mr Hanks. An Oscar nomination? Meryl Streep. That's just how the great circle of cinema works.

Attempting to add any kind of reductive label on Charlize Theron has so far been nigh impossible. Not content with showing the kind of range that makes categorisation redundant, the actress seems to have a provocative defiance about some of her professional decisions.

This is she who chose to pursue playing Aileen Wuornos, and then followed it up with an anime-inspired action film. Who seems - and rightly so - to dare anyone to limit her appeal to aesthetics by chasing wounded, morally murky and occasionally downright nasty characters. And who stunningly accepted George Miller's call to play the real hero of his Mad Max: Fury Road project. But then, of course she did.

This week the sequel to The Huntman - Winter's War - sees Theron return to cinemas as Ravenna, despite the fact that the first film made hardly any money and nobody liking it. A real triumph of will from whoever REALLY wanted to see it at studio level, but then Theron was the best thing about the original, so at least we get a chance to see more of that.

Whether it will break into her best or worst performances remains to be seen...


5 Awesome Performances

5. Det. Emily Sanders - In The Valley Of Elah (2007)

Warner Bros.
Warner Bros.

While Tommy Lee Jones' performance as Hank Deerfield inevitably draws the most attention in retrospect thanks to his Oscar nomination, Theron's performance alongside him is just as effective and just as impressive without the same intense beats. Without both of them there could have been some potential for Paul Haggis' Crash follow up to disappear under the weight of its own self-importance, but they are the elements that ground the plot, which occasionally threatens to stomp on the rest of the film's pillars.

As Detective Sanders, Theron is as measured as Jones is wounded. She's drawn to his situation, with the anchor of her own bullying by male colleagues who are fully aware of the open secret of her former affair with her boss (Josh Brolin). Just as Jones is an island, so too is she; perhaps less far gone, but just as driven by emotion.

There were some accusations that Theron's character was added to the mix as some sort of feminist gambit, but the reality is that she is the right actor for the job, bringing honesty and depth that flies in the face of the director's notorious penchant for hyperbole and heavy-handed symbolism.


4. Mary Ann Lomax - The Devil's Advocate (1997)

Warner Bros.
Warner Bros.

Just two years after her screen debut as the decidedly unglamorous "Young Woman" in the woeful Children of the Corn III: Urban Harvest, Theron made a step up to the big time opposite an atypically excellent Keanu Reeves and a scene-chewing Al Pacino.

To be frank, any performance that manages to steal any of the limelight when Pacino - generously shorn of all restraint by the chance to play Lucifer in a $10,000 suit - is in full flow deserves to be handed an Oscar on the spot.

But it's not only that balance that counts towards the success of the role. Theron plays a picture book wife of a high-flying lawyer, frustrated and isolated and robbed of her own identity. Her eventual spiral into despair and trauma is inherently linked to Reeves' rise to power under his Devil father, and without her raw-nerve emotional performance, his typically deadpan reactions wouldn't have landed at all. Instead, there is a curious clash in their extremes, which adds the perfect otherwordly note to Reeves.

And when she ultimately takes her life, it's an astonishingly provocative moment that remains difficult to watch.


3. Mavis Gary - Young Adult (2011)

Paramount Pictures
Paramount Pictures

Young Adult represented the moment when Theron's particular brand of woundedness came to full fruition, and she is completely captivating in it. It feels very much like Theron was hand-picked for the role - or even more that the character was written with her firmly in mind.

That's not to say that she is a stagnant, self-involved 30-something suffering an existential panic, but there's just something right about the fit of her persona and Diablo Cody's distinctly nasty script. Perhaps because of the writer, there is also something tangibly personal about both the material and the performance, and that is testament to the authenticity of it.

Impressively, despite being invited to "ruin" her own image in conventional terms, with a nasty role (something the likes of Will Smith never really sought), Theron doesn't do so cheaply by making herself "ugly". She's just broken, stuck on a loop like the casette mix tape she hangs on to as a symbol of her former relationship with Patrick Wilson. The prom queen who peaked in that moment and hasn't left it, and it's spell-binding.


2. Imperator Furiosa - Mad Max: Fury Road (2015)

Warner Bros.
Warner Bros.

George Miller clearly has a thing for the provocative. Long after Mad Max "ended", the director with the singularly dusty vision of Dystopia was trying to get a fourth in the franchise made, even after Mel Gibson past his Use By date. The reward - for Miller and for fans - is the stunning, and it has to be said entirely disarming Fury Road.

The film is unrestrained and nostalgic, a career killer for anyone involved had it not gone to plan, and the fact that stars as big as Charlize Theron and Tom Hardy signed on is not so much brave as it is defiant. Their enthusiasm for the project, which has screened in Cannes of all places and promises to very probably be this year's Dredd, shows in the finish product, which is delightfully vulgar, and as provocative as a punch to the face.

In the void left by Hardy's "restrained" performance as Max - he's hardly the most loquacious of fellows - Theron takes up the reigns as the real protagonist. This is her story, which Max joins as the force of nature muscle, and once more she's at her best as the wounded heart of the plot. She is a terrier, with her back against a wall that probably isn't fit for purpose, and the scars really do show.


1. Aileen Wuornos - Monster (2003)

Newmarket Films
Newmarket Films

If you couldn't have guess where this ranking was headed from the frequent allusions to broken characters and wounds, then you probably haven't been paying enough attention.

Theron's performance in Monster might well be most memorable for the physical transformation she underwent to portray the fractured serial killer, but to concentrate solely on that aspect is to do a disservice to the substance of the performance.

She channels the same morbid fascination - the irresistible draw of rubber-necking - that Wuornos managed in her infamous documentary film opposite Nick Broomfield. It's arguably her most showy performance of all, but that is no bad thing, and the true power of the film is that she makes the story entirely gripping without an ounce of glamourising.


5 That Sucked

5. Meredith Vickers - Prometheus (2012)

20th Century Fox
20th Century Fox

It is perhaps somewhat cruel to say that Theron's performance as Vickers was flat-out terrible, but never has any performance been so completely over-shadowed by a face-slappingly stupid moment by the character.

That's sort of true of the entire film: it is vapid but incredibly beautiful, the best-looking idiot of 2012's crowd of movies.

The real issue for Theron's performance, and indeed most of the characters in the film is that in its attempt to definitely not be an Alien film (yeah, good one) Prometheus threw the baby out with the bath-water. The atmosphere isn't there, the fear isn't as authentic and for some reason - catastrophically - the characters are as far away from the weirdos and reprobates of the "main" Alien series, which costs it horribly.

That means Theron - who should be a goose-stepping business Nazi - has precious little to do. Ridley Scott tried so hard to avoid the archetypes he needed for his genre film that he ended up hamstringing his talent almost unforgivably.


4. Candy Kirkendall - Waking Up In Reno (2002)

Miramax
Miramax

Considering the ability of the four lead actors in the Brady Brothers' hill-billy romantic comedy, it's astounding how much of a festival of awfulness it is.

Clearly built on the idea - espoused by Krusty The Clown no less - that the funniest thing about clown comedy is the destroyed dignity of the victim, Waking Up In Reno took its classy cast - Theron, Billy Bob Thornton, Natasha Richardson and Patrick Swayze - and pushed them through a mangle.

The film apparently gestated first in Billy Bob Thornton's mind - which perhaps explains his self-charitable decision to turn Theron's character into a convenience-slut (she has literally no reason to cheat on her husband) - and the fact it was written by five people says all you need to know.

It's just a distasteful affair from start to finish: a comedy that seems to have Jerry Springer as its benchmark for laughs and morality, and Theron - thankfully - has come a long way since.


3. Mary Embrey - Hancock (2008)

Columbia Pictures
Columbia Pictures

Hancock shares something with Theron's lead character in Young Adult in that it peaks way too early. Unlike its temporary bedfellow, there's no going back (not even a similar pretence of change and evolution) because there's no epiphany moment.

What started as a deliciously dark sounding post-superhero movie ended up being robbed of its teeth by a total switch in direction that reimagined Hancock's anti-hero as a love sick immortal puppy pining for his other half (Theron).

Again, perhaps it's cruel to lay the blame for the entire thing at Theron's feet, but her performance, which goes from authentically human to believably villainous to annoyingly sappy in the space of about 40 minutes, is very much endemic of the problems. Everything just ends up feeling inadequate, and the shift in Theron's character is so ridiculous and so out of nowhere that it's hard not to dislike the entire performance.


2. Anna - A Million Ways To Die In The West (2014)

Universal Pictures
Universal Pictures

There's a very distinct possibility that A Million Ways To Die In The West was the most disappointing film of 2014. Yes it made money - twice its budget in fact (though hopefulyl that's not enough to make 2 Million Ways To Die In The West) - but the entire thing felt like a silly manchild remake of Blazing Saddles without any of the comic nuance or subtlety.

But then, Seth MacFarlane's name was above the saloon doors front and centre.

Theron is actually probably the best thing about the film, but it's mostly only because she doesn't get overly involved in the back-slapping smut or stupidity. She is restrained but you get the nagging sense that it's more down to boredom and not entirely feeling like she belongs than any conscious acting decision.

And unfortunately, her willingness to go along with MacFarlane's "side-splitting" dick, dumps and death jokes is just bad publicity.


1. Aeon Flux - Aeon Flux (2005)

Paramount Pictures
Paramount Pictures

Only the most ardent of fans of the original anime would have anything positive to say about Aeon Flux. Having just won Best Actress for Monster, Theron pulled a Halle Berry by pulling on lycra and high-kicking boots and making an entirely underwhelming adaptation that went way too serious and missed the point.

Aeon Flux seemingly ignored the fact that the original source was delightfully, self-consciously daft and went instead for a more solemn approach. Obviously it scores points for not overtly sexualising Theron's lead, but they could have at least spent some time on the characterisation and substance to go with the style.

It takes a lot to make a film in which Theron is actually less likeable than she was as Aileen Wuornos, but this wayward dystopian sci-fi (nowhere near as good as 2002's Equilibrium) manages it effortlessly.

Which Charlize Theron performances do you think deserve to be on either end of this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.