Chris Evans: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked
Which side does Cap fall on?

Once unfairly described by film critic Camilla Long as "the world's least charismatic actor," Chris Evans has been notoriously hard on himself over the span of his career. "I've made about 20 movies and Im probably proud of three," he once stated, highlighting a filmography packed with flops, misfires and ill-judged failures.
It's true that, to date, Evans' time in Hollywood has only really been defined by his on-going stint as Captain America, a role he has played down on a number of occasions... and yet one he has returned to six times in the space of five years.
Here's an actor who admittedly does not care for acting, and would largely prefer to move behind the camera. There is a sense of that in all of Evans' work - the feeling that he'd rather be somewhere else. On screen, his characters tend to fall into two categories: stoic, brooding and very, very serious, or plainly wacky. His good looks have enabled him to play the jock, but he can also do piercing intelligence and wounded pain - there just haven't been all that many opportunities to show it.
Ultimately, Evans makes for a curious case; it's difficult to imagine anyone else as Captain America, but - as an actor outside of those Marvel films - he has little box office draw. Perhaps that's why he ultimately signed the contract - it gave him a guarantee of success. And yet it's hard to escape the feeling that, deep down, there's a great artist waiting to burst free... it's just that the people want Steve Rogers.
To celebrate the release of Captain America: Civil War, here are 5 awesome Chris Evans performances and 5 that sucked...
5 Awesome Performances...
5. Jake Wyler - Not Another Teen Movie (2001)

It makes sense that Chris Evans' career started here; his handsome looks and cheesy grin made him ripe for the role of a high school jock, and it's a part that he pulls off with a surprising amount of likeability.
Not Another Teen Movie isn't the best spoof flick in the world, of course, but it is consistently funny and does manage to parody classic teen movies of the 80s.
As Jake Wyler, "The Popular Jock" tasked with turning unattractive nerd Janey Briggs into Prom Queen in order to seek revenge on his cheating girlfriend, Evans is without question the best thing in the film, injecting Jake with an underlying innocence and goofiness that somehow makes a strictly one-dimensional character into a human being (sort of); he also shows brilliant comic timing in his line delivery.
It was here that Hollywood first sat up and took notice of Evans, not knowing how hard it would be to find appropriate roles for this guy in the future - or that Evans aspired to playing more interesting and complex characters than "the jock."
4. Mike Weiss - Puncture (2011)

"No one sees my good little movies," mourned Evans, referring to Puncture, a good little movie featuring one of his best performances. To put Evans' comment into perspective, Puncture made just $68,94 at the box office. When you throw your heart and soul into a project like he did with this one... well, that's gotta hurt.
In the film, which is based on a true story - Evans plays a drug-addicted lawyer named Mike Weiss, who take on a controversial case regarding a nurse who contracted HIV at work... and find himself caught up in a pharmaceutical scandal. The film both admirable and flawed, but is ultimately essential due to Evans.
This flick was a real passion project for the actor, and it shows: playing Weiss offered him the rare opportunity to show the world what he could do, and he delivers a subversive performance as a young, hotshot lawyer who isn't anywhere near as cool as he appears on the surface (i.e. he loves that cocaine).
The film is essentially all about Evans' performance; he lights up the screen at every opportunity and - best of all - makes us believe in a guy who could've ended up as a caricature. His work here deserved way more attention than it received.
3. Mace - Sunshine (2007)

For their second collaboration, director Danny Boyle and novelist-turned-screenwriter Alex Garland made Sunshine, a sci-fi thriller in the Solaris vein.
The plot concerns a team of scientists who are sent on a dangerous mission to "reignite the sun" in the not-too-distant future, after it begins to die and life on Earth is threatened with extinction. The first two thirds of the film are masterful; the last act... well, it all goes a little crazy, but - for the most part - this is a stunning stuff.
Chris Evans isn't the lead in the movie, nor does he have a particularly large role. As Mace, the engineer, he plays second fiddle to Cillian Murphy's physicist hero Robert Capa, and the two characters find themselves at odds throughout. This is Evans at his most understated, and yet he's riveting to watch in the wake of the countless hyped-up performances he'd committed to at this point in his career.
It's easy to see why this is the actor's favourite of his own films; creating a cool, interesting character in the background, he quietly steals the entire movie.
2. Curtis Everett - Snowpiercer (2013)

In Snowpiercer, Korean filmmaker Bong Joon-ho's daftly underrated adaptation of a French graphic novel, Chris Evans offers up his most angst-ridden performance.
As one of a handful of survivors who live on board a never-stopping train in the wake of the freezing apocalypse, Evans plays Curtis Everett, a man confined to the slums of the tail end. Resourceful, stoic and forever battling the demons of a shocking past, Curtis ultimately comes to lead a rebellion as he battles his way to the front of the train to meet the architect of the titular "Snowpiercer."
Bong Joon-ho originally disliked the idea of casting Evans, deeming him too all-American for the part. The two met, however, and the director saw that there was more to Evans than Steve Rogers; he's the relentless, violent force that keeps the narrative driving forwards, but there's also sad, wary side to the character - a sense of pain and remorse that Evans manages to brilliantly convey using just his eyes.
Hopefully this is one of the three films that Evans is actually proud of, because it's exactly the kind of weird and original film that he should continue to make.
1. Steve Rogers - Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2013)

Nobody expected Captain America: The Winter Soldier to be quite as brilliant as it was; though the first flick was entertaining enough, it didn't leave much of a lasting impression, whilst Evans - as the titular superhero - didn't feel quite as fitting in the role of Steve Rogers as, say, Robert Downey Jr. did with Tony Stark.
His performance as the Captain picked up slightly in The Avengers, of course, and he managed to make an impression with a few in-jokes and a couple of badass action moments, despite not being the film's main focus. When The Winter Soldier landed, though, so did Chris Evans - here was an actor finally commanding a role that had managed to elude him somewhat previously.
It was almost as if Evans, accepting of his fate as the lead in a major superhero franchise, stop lamenting and decided to just give it his all; here Captain America became an interesting character in his own right, partly down to the clever scripting (which pegged him as a "man out of time"), but mostly due to the way that Evans effortlessly switched between moments of po-faced seriousness, comic self-awareness, awkward romance and genuine anguish.
With The Winter Soldier, Captain America finally felt like a "person" - and that's down to Evans' decision to commit entirely to the character. He's never been better.
And 5 Performances That Sucked...
5. Johnny Storm - Fantastic Four (2005)

It isn't really Chris Evans' fault that his take on Johnny Storm turned out so naff; the entire film is a clumsy affair, and one in which - giving how bad it is - Evans just manages to walk away from with the remnants of his dignity still in tact. Just.
Still, it absolutely stands as one of his worst performances because it asks nothing substantial of the actor, except to play a one-dimensional frat boy. Evans isn't allowed to do anything with his Johnny Storm other than read his lines in the same repetitive, smug voice, so naturally it feels like a half-assed effort on his part.
It must be considered that Fantastic Four was intended for family audiences, which explains the goofy tone and Disney Channel aesthetics - we were never going to get a deep and thoughtful take on The Human Torch, were we? And despite the relatively one-note nature of his performance, Marvel clearly saw something in the actor because they feverishly pursued him to play Captain America thereafter.
Doesn't stop this character's self-satisfied schtick from driving you crazy, though.
4. Me - Playing It Cool (2014)

At first glance, Playing It Cool looks like a joke. Everything about it, from the plot to the marketing material, has "parody!" written all over it. It's a film about a screenwriter who wants to write action movies, but - for contrived story purposes - the screenwriter's agent wants him to write a romantic comedy first. Of course, Evans' character doesn't believe in love, and - wham! - there's your premise.
More annoyingly, his character is only referred to as "Me" in the film, whilst co-star Michelle Monaghan (who deserves way, way better) is branded as "Her." Clearly not interested, Evans offers up a performance that is almost impressive in its genericness. He sits back, he reads his lines... it might as well be a rehearsal.
Also: Chris Evans as a screenwriter? No, not buying that. Not one bit.
3. Hayden "Harvard Hottie" - The Nanny Diaries (2007)

Here's a movie that you know isn't going to be very good from the title alone, and sadly it also contains one of Chris Evans' least notable turns. He plays a love interest to Scarlett Johansson's sort-of nanny, Annie, who accidentally gets the job when somebody mishears her name (really). She nicknames Evans' character, who lives upstairs, the "Harvard Hottie," for reasons that are somewhat self-explanatory.
Evans pretty much serves as eye candy here, and - like the film - is about as dull and uninspired as generic rom-com love interests get. He's so well-groomed that he almost looks fake, as though he's been cut right out of a glossy magazine.
The only remotely interesting thing about his being here is that it gives you the chance to see Captain America and Black Widow interacting pre-Avengers.
2. Syd - London (2006)

London is, at its most basic level, a film in which a group of incredibly unlikeable people get together for a party one evening and - having done a bunch of coke - proceed to shout at and belittle one another for the sum of 90 minutes.
Chris Evans plays one of these people, and - as the lead - is automatically rendered as the most insufferable of the lot... which is really saying something, considering the conveyer belt of terrible human beings on show here. Nobody comes out of this flick looking good - Jason Statham, what were you thinking? - and it's hard to know what drew Evans to the project, save for the fact that it was 2006 and, hey, why not?
His Syd is a sleazy, unlikeable hipster and the actor fails to make us root for him in any way at all, though it's never made clear whether we're supposed to want to. He also has zero chemistry with love interest Jessica Biel, which is even more shocking when you consider that they were a real couple at the time (?).
1. Jimmy Dobyne - The Loss Of A Teardrop Diamond (2008)

There's probably a good reason that the Tennessee Williams play that this movie was based on had been long-forgotten by the time the filmmakers got around to adapting it; it's just not up to the standard of the great writer's other works.
The plot centres on an heiress, played by Bryce Dallas Howard, who enlists the son of her father's caretaker - our man Chris Evans - to accompany her to a bunch of Memphis parties in the 1950s (it's strictly a business arrangement, you understand).
Everything about the film is off, though, from the tone to the way the narrative unfolds in awkward, melodramatic chunks; the actors didn't have a chance, given the material, but Evans has never felt more out of place than he does here. Once again, he's lumbered with a generic hunk of a character with little to express. And Evans really goes to town on the "not expressing" stuff. His face barely changes shape.
He's never been charismatic in the way that he's supposed to be here, playing a James Dean-type character. Somebody seems to have just assumed that, because he's handsome, he was right for the part. Instead, he looks like Evans has been brought in from the wrong time period, and the bad Southern accent he adopts for the length of the film doesn't help matters. Miscast and flat, it's a career-killing turn.