Christopher Nolan Films: Worst To Best

A restrospective on the career of the finest director working today.

Is there a finer filmmaker working today than Christopher Nolan? From humble roots and some indie smash hits, the British director has conquered the world. His star has risen to the point his name carries with it the same expectations of Hitchcock or Kubrick. You may think that a bold claim, but has there ever been a director so consistent in quality yet so unique in approach? No one would ever say that the two aforementioned greats never did a bad film, but I submit to you that Nolan has yet to. Born in England and raised partially in the US, he is a director who can craft films that will entertain the masses while also providing layers of meaning for those who desire to discover it. Every one of his movies benefits from repeat viewings, presenting something intelligent and, in reference to his recent work, beyond the standard blockbuster. Thanks to his massive appeal, he has, over the past half decade, become one of the most influential current filmmakers; as will be discussed, the recent spate of super serious blockbusters stems from the success of his gritty re-imagining of Batman. There has been a recent (albeit small) backlash against Nolan, but that is the case with many artists who has grown from personal affection to the public€™s favourite. Unlike many, however, he€™s kept his integrity as his star has risen to astronomical levels. This is shown best through the fact that, throughout his career Memento onwards, he has kept the same Director of Photography, Wally Pfister, who has imbued all his films with sumptuous and memorable visuals. So, in honour of this consistently brilliant filmmaker and to kick-start what I hope to be an ongoing retrospective series on directors careers, here€™s a rundown of Nolan€™s work, from his weakest through to the very best. Spoilers obviously abound, so read with caution.

Honourable Mention: Doodlebug

Nolan€™s 1997 short film clocks in at a mere three minutes, so to include it proper in the list would be ludicrous. However, it is too brilliant to not to give a mention. It follows a man alone in a flat, hunting down his elusive tormentor; the titular doodlebug. To say anymore of the plot would be unnecessary; check it out in the video below. A Twilight Zone-esque short produced while Nolan was still studying at UCL, Doodlebug shows the spark that would later lead to great things. It conveys the festered nature of the flat and its owner well, along with music and sweeping camera shots that help instill a sense of unease. But the best moment has to be the look of satisfaction on the man€™s face after he completes his task; he€™s been so determined to wipe out the Doodlebug that he€™s been oblivious to the world around him. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-WhKt_CkXD0

8. Insomnia (2002)

It€™s telling of his greatness that Insomnia is Nolan€™s weakest film, yet is far from a bad one. Nolan€™s third feature, more obviously a crime thriller than his others, places bottom on this list purely because everything else is so damned perfect. A remake of a Norwegian thriller, Insomnia tells the story of an LAPD detective who heads up to an Alaskan town to investigate the murder of a teenage girl. With the small town setting, a visiting agent and a lot of logs about it€™s quite easy to draw parallels with Twin Peaks; the story is even kicked into motion by a teenager€™s murder. This comparison hurts the film as it does anything compared to David Lynch€™s surreal masterpiece, but the similarities are mainly superficial €“ Insomnia is more psychological than supernatural. The main conceit €“ Nightmute is so northern that there can be continuous daylight for days €“ is an interesting one and is explored well. The strongest elements of the film involve Pachino€™s struggle with insomnia and the eventual revelation it isn€™t the perpetual daylight forcing sleep from him, but the guilt from his previous actions comes as a proper shock thanks to the deftness with which Nolan has pushed us into his viewpoint. As an actual crime thriller, the film isn't as strong. Despite being driven by the dual threat of a revelation of corruption and Robin William€™s admittedly great performance as a psychotic killer it never fully amps up the tension. Nolan has gone on the make films that balance multiple elements perfectly, but here they don€™t quite gel. Yet it still remains worth seeing thanks to its stellar representation of the sleeping disorder.

7. Following (1998)

A director€™s first film is always interesting, showing their raw talent before outside influence takes hold. Following, Nolan€™s first feature, tells the story of a struggling writer who takes to stalking random members of the public for inspiration. It€™s a cracking film told in a surprisingly non-linear narrative, albeit rather short and with clearly inexperienced actors. What is probably Nolan€™s least seen work is definitely one that more people should check out, particularly for the Batman symbol on Bill€™s door; an accidental and humorous foreshadowing. It's easy to see the influence it has had on his later works. Inception may seem the obvious link, with a robber named Cobb and one scene having a character sneak through a kitchen to then go on and steal the contents of a safe. But it is Memento, which directly followed Following, that it shares the most with. Both films follow similar plot beats, with various threads running through and tying together well before the end, allowing room for a final twist. The non-linear narrative told through multiple different strands makes a lot more sense in Memento, as in Following it feels present just to give a sense of mystery to events. Similarities exist stylistically too, with the complete fade to black and pause between changes in time and the use of black and white film stock, used to keep costs down, which here gives the film a cold, unforgiving tone. The film emulates Film Noir in a modern setting very well, with some camera angles that would feel well at home in the forties, but also has its own distinct style; you can see the director€™s one to watch. From here on in, all the films are, in my opinion, worthy of a full five star rating. The next three are, to some degree interchangeable and have been placed in their order based on my current personal opinion.

6. Batman Begins (2005)

Batman had been left for dead after the painful Schumacher pun-fests Batman Forever and Batman and Robin. Warner needed to do something drastic to bring the franchise back to acclaim, so they gave the reigns of one of their biggest licenses to indie wonder Nolan. He took a genre that, even with its best entries (X-Men 2 and Rami€™s Spider-Man films), maintained an air of camp unbelievability and brought it down to Earth. He took the approach that had gifted him with success previously and applied it to Hollywood€™s blockbuster machine. But while Batman Begin€™s has Nolan€™s fingerprints all over it, the film still has some typical blockbuster elements, likely stemming from studio requirements. The film was incredibly revolutionary; origin stories went from a quick ten minutes at the beginning to get the film going (see Rami€™s Spider-man) to dominating the first film in a series. Although with The Avengers Marvel have stepped away from this, when they were starting their cinematic universe, a lot of their films used Begins as a template. Iron Man may not be dark, but it maintains the realism that Nolan breathed into the genre. What a lot of these films don€™t understand is that it wasn't just the lengthened origin that made Begins great; it was how the entirety of the plot ties directly into the character. Many other directors appear too afraid to gamble the entire film on their character€™s beginnings; this summer€™s The Amazing Spider-Man attempted to ape this method, but gave up after the one hour mark, spiralling down into an anticlimactic showdown that related little to the character and his origins.

5. The Dark Knight Rises (2012)

As their career goes on, you€™ll see many directors begin to stagnate, choosing to stick with the familiar over pushing themselves (Burton and Tarantino are two high profile examples). With Nolan, however, you can see his films develop over time. His decision to punctuate each of his Batman films with a more personal project not only allowed him a holiday from Gotham, but also gave him an opportunity to develop himself outside of the confines of the franchise. The Dark Knight Rises is testament to his ability to grow; without practice with the dreamscapes of Inception, Nolan and Pfister wouldn't have had the same mastery over the epic scale of destruction Bane reaps in Rises. Watching his films back you get to sense how he€™s honed the art of filmmaking to suit his style and give the audience the best experience possible. In the pre-release hype, a lot of stock was put in whether Bruce Wayne would make it to the end credits and in the end it was only the Batman half of him that perished; as with Inception and its spinning top, it was less about the physical side of things and more about the emotional. There has been a small backlash against Rises, particularly on this website, that has escalated into dissatisfaction with Nolan€™s entire trilogy. It€™s a mixture of high expectations but more importantly stiff commitment to the source material. We get countless adaptations of novels that update and alter the source material to make it more relevant, but, with Nolan being the first to do it properly with comic books, it has proven a hard pill to initially swallow.

4. The Prestige (2006)

Back in 2006, within a couple of months of each other, two very similar films appeared. Often films will arrive around the same time that are comparable on the surface, but the similarities end when you delve deeper; Antz and A Bug€™s Life, Finding Nemo and Shark Tale, The Raid and Dredd. What was odd about these two is just how similar they did appear; both were about magicians in the 19th century, both used real and fictional characters and most important of all, both had a big twist at the end. The Illusionist, starring Edward Norton, followed a simple linear plot of a magician and his confrontation with the law, with a final twist that (shock horror) all his magic was in fact smoke and mirrors. And then there was The Prestige. It had a brilliant cast led by Christian Bale and Hugh Jackman and through a non-linear narrative provided by numerous diaries and flashbacks it told the story of two warring magicians and their desire the learn the other€™s secret of the signature trick, The Transporting Man. There was twist after twist in the story of double crossing with a final reveal €“ both men were sacrificing more than the other could ever have imagined €“ that left the audience€™s jaw firmly planted on the floor. The Illusionist went the simple, obvious route, whereas The Prestige was daring and used its twists to muse on the obsession of men. With similar ideas, a less worthy director (Neil Burger would go on the make Limitless) stumbled while Christopher Nolan crafted a deep and superior thriller.

3. Memento (2000)

Memento is an incredibly easy sell of an idea. The narrative device €“ telling the story of an amnesiac through short vignettes shown in reverse order €“ is brilliantly simple to grasp but difficult to fully crack, giving you a view of how Leonard sees the world. Unlike Stan Smith in the pilot of American Dad, you definitely can only get more out of it with repeat viewings. The first time you see it, the film forces you to be confused; there€™s so much manipulation and the film is so open ended that you can€™t quite be certain what you€™ve seen. With each rewatch, the chronological, black and white, scenes that punctuate the reverse order action become increasingly important, telling us more about Leonard€™s mentality, as well as putting increasing weight on Sammy Jankis. Natalie€™s actions, using Leonard to deal with her problems, motivated by his killing of Jimmy, are the big shock of first viewing, but upon rewatching it€™s Teddy who becomes even more mysterious. Even after seeing the film countless times, it's hard to grasp what exactly is motivating Teddy; the ending presents us with a logical explanation, but the fact he has been calling Leonard anonymously plants doubt. Nolan is still reluctant to truly divulge his interpretation of events, making Memento a film that, while it can be cracked, is still a headscratcher. There€™s an optional edit available on certain versions of the DVD that presents the story in chronological order. It initially sounds cool, but is poorly edited and if anything makes events more confusing as it distances you from Leonard after the first, orignally chronological anyway, half. There€™s little that can be gleaned from this that you won€™t get from multiple viewings of the original cut.

2. The Dark Knight (2008)

While there has always been a lot of talk around Heath Ledger€™s Oscar winning performance, this is just one element of what makes The Dark Knight brilliant. The best entry in Nolan€™s Batman trilogy is at its heart a thrilling crime drama that just happens to have these two superheroes at the centre of it. The film has a myriad of plots flying around at once and Nolan, the master plate-spinner he is, keeps each moving toward their final goal. With destruction as chaotic as its villain and grounded by a great cast the film never tests its length, although it did test certification; some scenes, such as the disappearing pencil, caused uproar from parents unhappy the 12A rating let their kids be exposed to such horrors, despite children's ability to see it being in their hands. When it was made, Nolan gave no inclination that he would do a third part, meaning The Dark Knight could quite easily have been the last entry set in the his realistic Batverse. We know it wasn't and having witnessed the explosive finale it€™s safe to say the film still works. Now the middle entry in a trilogy, The Dark Knight makes for an interesting watch. Nolan plays with the preconception of sequels going darker by having a brighter city and setting more of the film in the daylight in contrast to the increasingly dark plot. The ending works on a dual-purpose. While it definitely ties directly into The Dark Knight Rises, thanks to Nolan€™s insistence of not planning more than one film ahead makes the ending feel final, tying up all the major plot threads. Can any other major trilogy boast a middle that does that?

1. Inception (2010)

Now we get to Nolan€™s masterpiece. After the incredible critical and financial success of The Dark Knight, Nolan was given free reign by Warner to do what he wanted. What he delivered was his long gestating dream-inspired sci-fi, Inception. The film was a surprise hit. For an original, smart film to do so well around the world is testament to Nolan€™s ability to craft startling images and approachable stories. A film with incredibly wide appeal, it was often praised (and in some cases criticised) for its overly complex nature. Now that isn€™t entirely true. Inception adopts a complex plot and through the timey-wimey workings of the world there€™s many events happening within the other, but in itself it€™s not complicated; it just requires you to pay attention. The first half sets up all the key mechanics of the dream world and then wreaks havoc with them in the second half, readily assuming you've taken everything in. This leaves a good hour for the film to craft spectacular sequences without needless exposition; the brilliant scene with Joseph Gordon Levitt€™s Arthur fighting militarised projections in a rotating corridor is one of the best film sequences of the decade so far. But amongst all the spectacle, the film is emotionally carried by Leonardo Di Caprio, playing the grieving Cobb. Like all great sci-fi, we can relate to the character, even though his situation is nothing like ours. His fractured mind visually bleeding into the heist through the form of trains and his deceased wife along with the shocking discovery of the original inception provide a great psychological backdrop to events, turning the action into tragedy. It is because we are so invested in him that we put so much weight on the often debated spinning top at the end. Ultimately, the reality of the ending doesn€™t matter; like Cobb with his children, we can accept the world as where he wants to be. Inception showed that there was an audience for brainy films that forced you to work to enjoy them, but more importantly it placed Nolan in the public consciousness as a great director.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.