Cruella Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs
Emma Stone shines in this muddled, uneven origin story.
After Disney took a theatrical hiatus for most of 2020, the latest in their spate of live-action remakes is now in cinemas and on Disney+ worldwide.
Cruella is of course a prequel-slash-reimagining for 101 Dalmatians' iconic villain Cruella de Vil, a project which invited immediate skepticism from many for one simple reason - does anyone really want a sympathetic origin story for a woman who kills dogs for fur?
Regardless, Cruella is finally here armed with a titanic $200 million budget, talented director Craig Gillespie (I, Tonya), and an all-star cast led by Emma Stone, Emma Thompson, and Mark Strong.
The results, predictably, are all over the place. Though broadly well-received by critics so far - with most reviews landing in the three-star region - Cruella matches its style and creativity at every step with frustrating excess while succumbing to many of the most cliched problems that plague so many prequels.
It certainly doesn't want for acting talent or filmmaking skill, but by the end of its 134 minutes, Cruella is more an exhausting, fitfully entertaining sit than a genuinely worthwhile origin story that fully justifies its own existence...
Downs...
5. It's WAY Too Long
First and foremost, Cruella is a film sorely in need of a few more passes in the editing room - it clocks in at a beefy 134 minutes, a runtime it doesn't nearly begin to earn.
From its overbaked prologue sequence onward, the film is packed with indulgent, prolonged sequences which, while often slick and well-crafted, quickly become repetitive as Cruella (Stone) continually attempts to one-up the object of her ire, fashion designer Baroness von Hellman (Emma Thompson).
A skilled editor could've easily trimmed 30 minutes from this without affecting the overall narrative throughline, and while executive meddling is rarely a good thing, in this case Gillespie was seemingly given too much free rein to craft an undisciplined, bloated story.
4. It Suffers From Chronic "Prequelitis"
Of all the Disney characters to give their own prequel movie, Cruella de Vil has to be one of the toughest to crack, and it shows. For starters, how do you endear a character to audiences who murders cute animals for her own gain?
Gillespie answers this by reconfiguring the character in a number of ways to make her more palatable for modern audiences, effectively neutering her hostility toward dalmatians and piling a tragic, twist-filled backstory on top.
Overall, the film clings so, so eagerly to the prequel movie formula, most criminally resulting in a customary, cringe-worthy scene where we learn the ham-fisted origin of Cruella's surname.
Through and through, it is a film that strains itself to explain why Cruella needs her own movie at all, or why we should care much about her.
If this new take needs to alter the character so thoroughly in order to make her appealing to audiences, isn't that better proof that this was the wrong route all along?
3. The Excessive Needle-Drops
Not since Suicide Squad has a film so shamelessly used popular music as a crutch, because Cruella is absolutely jam-packed with killer songs, each and every one of them slotted into the film in the most obvious, groan-worthy way possible.
With all the efficiency of a pub jukebox, viewers can barely go more than a few minutes without another on-the-nose hit song double-underlining the meaning of whatever we're seeing on screen.
Occasionally the musical choices rouse a smirk - namely a car chase set to Queen's "Stone Cold Crazy" and head-banging use of The Stooges' "I Wanna Be Your Dog" - but by the time The Rolling Stones' "Sympathy for the Devil" is trotted out as Cruella makes a badass girlboss entrance, it's tough not to feel a strong twinge of second-hand embarrassment.
Many of the musical selections feel like they were shoehorned into the movie late in post-production to help less-interesting scenes "pop" a little better. It's pretty much the laziest thing a filmmaker can do to elevate their work.
2. The Messy, Lazy Storytelling
Without going into too much detail, this thing is a mess as an attempt at telling a coherent and dramatically compelling origin story for Cruella.
The script is so desperate to wrap itself up in narrative sleights of hand and devious plot twists, but most of the film's big reveals end up feeling like totally stock Disney melodrama.
Otherwise they're fundamentally silly and the rob the film of any earnest attempt to make Cruella a statuesque anti-hero in her own right. By the time Gillespie fully reveals his hand at film's end, it's more-or-less devolved into stakes-free schlock.
Though most Disney movies do adhere to a template, here the formula is put to shockingly transparent use while not even having the good sense to do it in a concise, to-the-point way.
1. Mark Strong Is Totally Wasted
Mark Strong improves pretty much any movie he's in, so it was encouraging to see him show up in Cruella as Baroness von Hellman's valet and henchman, known simply as John.
Sadly Strong gets shockingly little to do throughout the film, relegated to an extended cameo for the movie's first half before getting a fraction more screen time in the second.
Despite the potential-rich nature of Strong playing a stoic, dignified lackey, the script largely just tasks him with dumping exposition in the audience's lap.
Though Emma Stone and Emma Thompson get substantial parts befitting their talents, Strong feels stranded with a mostly-nothing role here. At least he hopefully got paid handsomely for the part.
Cruella is a deeply sloppy prequel, then, but it's also far from being a bad film. Here's what it gets right...
Ups...
5. Emma Stone's Devilishly Good Performance
What just about everyone can agree on is the strength of Emma Stone's turn as Cruella.
Even in the film's very weakest moments, she gives a fully committed performance as both the downtrodden Estella and her more outgoing, vengeful alter-ego.
Stone does everything within her considerable abilities to sell the character's transformation from outcast to aggressor, wrapped in a thick layer of playful camp throughout.
Comparisons to Glenn Close's prior iteration are inevitable, but Stone acquits herself well as a rather different take on the character. In fact, she's good enough to make one wish she was given a stronger script to match her chops.
4. The Oscar-Worthy Costume Design
Similarly, few will likely find themselves complaining about the film's eye-popping couture on offer, courtesy of legendary, Oscar-winning costume designer Jenny Beavan.
Seeing Cruella interrupt Baroness von Hellman's various galas and parties in her increasingly ostentatious get-ups helps fend off the otherwise repetitive nature of these scenes.
True to the film's punk-rock sensibilities, there's a scuzzy, off-the-wall feel to the costume design, which not only makes it a guaranteed Best Costume Design nominee at next year's Oscars - it could help it stand out enough to win the award outright.
Costumes are an uncommonly important part of the movie's aesthetic, and here Beavan absolutely knocked it out of the park. Gorgeous isn't even the word.
3. Emma Thompson (Almost) Steals The Show
Though there are a number of solid supporting performances in the movie - namely Joel Fry and Paul Walter Hauser as Cruella's childhood pals Jasper and Horace - the show is very nearly stolen entirely by a brilliantly cast Emma Thompson.
As the snobby Baroness who plays a pivotal role in Cruella's transformation, Thompson is deliciously obnoxious yet also refuses to let the character descend into pure hammy farce.
It's clear that Thompson's having an absolute blast throughout, and nails a character who is both hilariously conceited and genuinely quite fearsome - while looking spectacular in her many ornate outfits, of course.
2. The Slick Visuals
Though it isn't always easy to see how Cruella ended up costing Disney a reported $200 million, it is nevertheless an incredibly stylish film from a visual standpoint.
Impressively elaborate sets and sharp production design capture the aesthetic of 1970s London well, while Gillespie's creative camerawork - occasionally employing long, Scorsese-esque tracking shots to explore buildings - is some of the most inspired from any recent live-action Disney film.
Aside from some admittedly not great dalmatian CGI, Cruella is quite the visual feast indeed, and pops off the screen whether you're catching it in cinemas or at home.
If the recent likes of Dumbo and Aladdin felt like fairly plastic, artificial productions, the world of Cruella at least feels believably lived-in.
1. It's The Most Unique Live-Action Disney "Remake"
Beyond its visuals, Cruella is by far the most unique of Disney's recent glut of live-action remake - or in this case, remake-adjacent - projects.
Though obviously indebted heavily to its inspiration, this doesn't seem quite so desperate to just rake over the same style and narrative touchstones.
Its spiky feminist themes prove far more persuasive than the factory-assembled just-play-the-hits nature of Beauty and the Beast, Dumbo, Aladdin, and The Lion King.
It's certainly not the best of the bunch - that crown goes effortlessly to Jon Favreau's The Jungle Book remake - but it at least has the bravery to forge a bold path for itself that isn't resting entirely on what came before, flaws be-damned.