Death On The Nile Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs
Poirot's long-delayed sequel is a rock solid whodunnit.
For a while there it truly seemed like Kenneth Branagh's Death on the Nile - the sequel to 2017's box office smash Murder on the Orient Express - wasn't ever going to be released, or rather, might just get sent straight to streaming.
Yet despite the pandemic causing the film's release to be pushed back numerous times - it wrapped shooting way back in December 2019 - and stars Armie Hammer, Letitia Wright, and Gal Gadot having to weather their own personal controversies, Death on the Nile is now finally out on the big screen.
And though audiences might've tired of seeing the trailer over the last 18 months, on its own merits this is a solidly enjoyable murder-mystery that's lavishly well-made while demanding little from its audience beyond their desire to have a good time.
Adapting Agatha Christie's beloved source text with a fair degree of faithfulness, Branagh's take won't erase anyone's fond memories of the acclaimed prior 1978 adaptation, but largely delivers on its glossy, star-studded expectations.
Whether audiences will show up for it in enough numbers to secure a third Poirot romp remains to be seen, but as a standalone, old-fashioned mystery yarn that's lighter than air, it mostly brings the goods.
But first, here's what doesn't quite work...
Downs...
4. The Wildly Uneven Pacing
One of the chief complaints about Branagh's Murder on the Orient Express was that it took a little too long to get going, and that too is true here.
So much time is spent on the preambles of the story and introducing us to this admittedly massive cast of characters - or rather, future suspects - that the movie is well over the half-way mark before the focal murder has even been committed.
As fun as it is to simply drink in the titular cruise down the Nile with this diverse cast, viewers couldn't be blamed for getting fidgety long before the instigating death occurs.
By comparison, the second half of the film is a more frantic sprint to the finish, breathlessly ripping through melodramatic subplots, deaths, bait-and-switch twists, and so on, some of which could've benefitted from having a little more time to sit.
Ultimately this isn't to the film's fatal detriment, but a little editorial reshuffling might've served the story better.
3. Gal Gadot's Weak Performance
Though the ensemble cast serves as the movie's primary appeal and largely delivers the wink-wink fun audiences will be hoping for, there is one weak link among the bunch, and that's unfortunately an actor playing a most pivotal part in the story - Gal Gadot.
While Gadot recently proved in Red Notice that she can be a charming and appealing presence in the right role, there's a distracting woodenness to her performance here as wealthy heiress Linnet Ridgeway-Doyle.
She effortlessly fits the glamourous requirements for the part of course - she's Gal Gadot, for Christ's sake - but she struggles to make the dialogue feel naturalistic and believable coming out of her mouth.
It's distracting at times, and though she by no means sinks the film, her flat performance means you might well appreciate the mercifully plentiful times she isn't on screen.
It's far from Razzie-worthy work, but often you might find yourself thinking about a line reading, "That really the best take you had?"
2. The Inconsistent Visual Effects
Generally speaking this is a very well-produced film that makes the most of its exotic setting to heighten the sexy intrigue of its central whodunnit, but despite a mighty $90 million budget it's often clear we're watching a film produced with a lot of digital trickery.
For starters, the film's otherwise spectacular prologue sequence features a digitally de-aged Kenneth Branagh playing a younger Poirot during the First World War, but the effect never even remotely convinces.
Unlike the Marvel Cinematic Universe's mind-boggling VFX wizardry to de-age their cast members, here Branagh's face has a plastic, overly smooth sheen to it that distracts from the words actually coming out of his mouth.
As for the bulk of the movie, though there are some fantastic establishing shots of the cruise ship chugging along the bank of the Nile, too often it's made abundantly clear we're watching something filmed on a green screen soundstage in London.
The almost too-perfect magic hour lighting of the skyline doesn't always convincingly match with how the actors are lit, giving the film an artificial aesthetic some may find overly garish.
This is particularly apparent during a shot where the jealous Jacqueline de Bellefort (Emma Mackey) first boards the ship in slow-motion.
Again this isn't a fatal flaw but it does demonstrate the limitations of a mid-budget blockbuster such as this.
1. Some May Find It Too Obvious
Without getting into spoilers or hinting at anything, even those who know absolutely nothing about Christie's novel will probably be able to figure out where it's going if they put their thinking cap on.
The outcome can be predicted easily enough if you're paying attention, which really means this is a movie best enjoyed if you simply dim your senses a little, glug a big glass of your poison of choice, and simply give yourself over to its slushy vibe.
If you're hoping for an all-timer genius rug-pull this doesn't have it, but the ride getting there is enough of a good laugh that most probably won't mind all that much.
These issues accepted, then, here's what makes Death on the Nile well worth a watch...
Ups...
6. The Fantastic Origin Story For Poirot's Mustache
Yes, you read that right. Death on the Nile includes the most inexplicable of things upfront - an origin story for detective Hercule Poirot's (Branagh) iconic, gigantic mustache.
The film's amusingly self-serious prologue introduces us to a younger Poirot simply trying to survive the First World War, and in turn provides an explanation for how the detective's legendary lip-caterpillar came into existence.
It's not something anyone needed to see and is undeniably indulgent on Branagh's part, and yet the punchline is strangely meaningful in adding shade and even sadness to Poirot as a character.
It shouldn't work, but it totally does.
5. Poirot Steals The Show (Again)
Kenneth Branagh's campy rendition of Poirot was easily the best thing about Murder on the Orient Express and too it's the definitive highlight this time around.
Branagh is totally dialled into the character and knows how to make him both amusingly witty and attention-grabbingly severe as the material requires.
As mentioned above, there's more of an attempt to develop Poirit as a person beyond being a mere monolith this time around, and for the most part it pays off.
It's clear that Branagh is having a total blast reprising the role, and so we can only hope he'll get at least one more opportunity to don the oversized lip-foliage for our sure amusement.
4. The Game Ensemble Cast
Branagh may be the best of show, but he's supported by quite the excellent ensemble indeed.
Surely taking second place behind Branagh is Sex Education's Emma Mackey, who is delightfully charming and dangerously sultry as Simon Doyle's (Armie Hammer) jilted former lover Jacqueline de Bellefort.
Hammer, for all of his alleged personal failings, is meanwhile perfectly cast as the fair-weather newlywed Doyle, bringing a pleasant amount of ambiguity to the role - perhaps unavoidably informed by his recent headlines - that we're never quite sure which way the character will go.
Elsewhere Game of Thrones' Rose Leslie is a hoot as Linnet's french maid Louise, Sophie Okonedo is a seductive blast as jazz singer Salome Otterbourne, and Letitia Wright, antivax controversy be-damned, turns in fine work as Salome's niece Rosalie.
This is without getting into smaller but enjoyable parts for the likes of Annette Bening, Tom Bateman, Russell Brand, Ali Fazal, Dawn French, and Jennifer Saunders.
It all adds up to a can't-miss concoction, and Branagh is smart enough to keep mixing up the configurations of actors he pairs together.
3. Kenneth Branagh's Slick, Stylish Direction
The aforementioned VFX gripes aside, this is a handsome, well-mounted movie for the most part, and one that warmly embraces the old-school tenor of its source material.
Granted, BAFTA-winning production designer Jim Clay does a lot of the heavy lifting here with the gorgeously ornate ship design, as do the beautiful stylings of Oscar-nominated costume designer Paco Delgado.
This is a frequently ravishing looking movie by those standards alone, but Branagh's smoothly controlled filmmaking also shouldn't be denied.
The slick, roving, dynamic camerawork makes the most of the ship's enclosed spaces, capturing much of the monologuing and high-drama through fluid lengthy takes for maximum impact.
It may not be one of Branagh's finest works as a director, but it's never in doubt that we're watching a highly skilled artist at work.
2. The Satisfyingly Ridiculous Third Act
Easily the best part of the movie is the finale, when the buildup is done with and Branagh plunges headlong into the frothy murder-mystery silliness everyone paid their money to see play out.
The corpses quickly pile up as the central enigma becomes increasingly twisted, leading to a resolution which, while again perhaps predictable to some attentive viewers, is appropriately absurd all the same.
Beyond that, Branagh also circles back to Poirot's own personal arc in a gratifying way that even threatens to be unexpectedly moving.
And so, while the journey getting there occasionally feels a little too long and has a few undeniable hiccups, the payoff is satisfyingly over-the-top while paying firm tribute to Christie's sacrosanct source material.
1. It's A Solid Improvement Over Murder On The Orient Express
Though Death on the Nile is hardly a great film, it is a fair improvement over the more uneven Murder on the Orient Express.
By focusing on a dishy melodramatic love story usurped by death and beefing up the budget considerably, this is a more fun, less-rigorous exercise that shows Branagh in more confident control of both his resources and his own lead character.
Basically if you enjoyed Orient you'll have a breezy fun time with this, which while hardly a definitive adaptation exploits its all-star cast and big budget for every drop they're worth.
Hopefully this won't be the last we see of the franchise, because Branagh's made it abundantly clear he's up for more, and he's clearly found himself a refreshingly modest blockbuster niche.