Disney+ Vs Netflix: Which Is Better?
Has Disney+ dethroned Netflix as the king of streaming services? Let's break it down!
When Disney+ was announced, everyone was prepared for the proper Netflix killer to arrive. After all, this is Disney we're talking about, the king of Hollywood and the global box office, as well as the owner of the films that made many people's childhoods. Add on the recent acquisition of Twentieth Century Fox, and suddenly Netflix had a worthy challenger.
Well, that's what everyone thought initially, but has this come true? While The Mandalorian was a great hit, the service hasn't really taken off like expected.
There's a considerable wealth of family-friendly animated classics and a promising array of future exclusive shows within the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but there are still question marks about the platform. Between several instances of censorship, the complete botch job with porting over The Simpsons (due to be amended later this year), and many Disney products not being available until 2021 at the earliest, Disney+ has given many subscribers some cause for concern.
Does that mean Netflix is doing leagues better? Not exactly, but with Disney+ nearing the completion of its full international roll out, it seems right that we analyze the king of streaming services against the platform that would supposedly unseat it.
How do the two compare at this stage of the game? Let's break it down.
6. The Price
When deciding on which streaming service you're dishing out monthly payments to, price is the first thing to address. As many are acutely aware, Netflix has raised its monthly subscription fee recently. This has led to some division amongst subscribers, causing some to threaten cancellations if the price increases continue. Disney+, on the other hand, launched at an extremely competitive price, bringing plenty of interested parties on board and even some previously on the fence.
So to quote everybody's dad after getting the dinner bill, 'What's the damage?'
Disney+ can be yours for a once a month payment of $6.99 or $69.99 for the year. That plan gives you simultaneous viewing on four separate screens with 4K and UHD support at no extra charge. In comparison, Netflix has three separate plans: Basic, Standard, and Premium. Basic is $8.99 and limits you to one screen with no HD. The Standard plan at $12.99 gives you two usable screens with HD. Finally, Premium gives you four screens playing at the same time with 4K and UHD options for $15.99.
If there's any category Disney+ is crushing compared to Netflix, it's the cost. Four screens + 4K at $7 with no ads (currently) can't be beaten.
Winner: Disney+
5. The Content
Now that the payment's been taken care of, the most important question comes: what are we watching? All streaming services are defined by their content and Netflix's obnoxious abundance of viewing options is what earned its spot at the very top of the streaming hierarchy. However, the sheer amount of movies and shows Disney has produced throughout the years cannot be underplayed. Is it enough to challenge the king?
Honestly, if you're a super-fan of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Star Wars, and all of Disney's animated catalog, then you've got plenty of content to keep you busy for a while. Beyond that though, there's little variety beyond family-friendly comedies like Home Alone. Compare that to Netflix, where your preferences are covered no matter what they may be, and the difference is palpable.
Of course, the platform has been around much longer, but the sheer amount of content Netflix has amassed is simply unbeatable. The variety of movies and shows are more than sufficient enough to keep any subscriber entertained.
Winner: Netflix
4. The User Experience
The User Interface of a streaming service is such an essential, but mostly underrated, quality of a platform. Most don't even think about it, although they know a bad one when they see one. Ideally, a U.I should be efficient in relaying what your viewing options are and minimizing the delay between signing in and watching.
Disney+ has a U.I fairly similar to Amazon Prime's, albeit a little more cleanly laid out with most things categorized by their respective series or franchise. Scrolling is a bit jumpy, like clicking the far side of a taskbar. Nothing game-breaking, but not very smooth.
Netflix, by comparison, is an increasingly-smooth and efficient process where you know what's available to you and how long it takes to get the show started depends solely on your household's decision-making skills. Scrolling is buttery smooth, everything is laid out, and everything is laid out based on its genre and even budget-level. Figuring out what you want to watch has never been easier (well, in a design sense).
There's a clear sense of progression compared to where the Netflix menus began and where they are now. With years of customer feedback and increased customization options, Netflix's U.I is second to none.
Winner: Netflix
3. The Future
Regardless of how long your service has been around or how great things are at the moment, the next step is always essential. Where is your platform going?
Disney+ has only recently joined the ever growing list of stream services, whereas Netflix is a long-time veteran, and yet the future of each platform is equally as important. Disney's developing a brand, a platform in which they can promote their own products AND ensure millions of monthly subscriptions. At the same time, Netflix is trying to further its influence within the entertainment world, both in reputation and when it comes to awards consideration.
Right now, all of Disney+'s major exclusive shows take place in either the Star Wars or Marvel Cinematic Universe. A solid pair of franchises to invest in, but once again, the lack of variety does hamper some of that excitement, especially when the company has a wealth of potential IPs to use. Netflix, meanwhile, has enjoyed something of a resurgence as of late, putting out massive successes like The Witcher and Tiger King.
They're not resting either, further continuing to produce extremely promising projects that could be built upon for years.
With the likes of the Resident Evil series, Witcher's second season, and Space Force (created by The Office showrunner Greg Daniels and Steve Carrell), the future for Netflix remains the most expansive and wide-reaching - at least for now.
Winner: Netflix
2. The Management
While everything preceding this section focused on content, this entry delves more into the quality of management put out by those in charge of each brand. Are they listening to their subscribers, utilizing their feedback? Are they supporting the right projects? Simply put, are they earning your monthly payment?
Both brands have dealt with some controversy, but Disney+'s track record has had several controversies in a severely limited time to put customers off. Whether it was the terrible Simpsons port that saw early seasons become unwatchable or the recent cancellation of the pro-LGBT+ 'Love, Simon' show due to 'adult content,' their judgment has been questionable. Add in the censorship of classic films and they've portrayed themselves as overeager micromanagers.
In comparison, Netflix had gotten into trouble with fans due to their random cancellation of quality exclusives like One Day at a Time and the Marvel shows, but they've been on better behavior recently. While their promotion skills of intriguing low-profile projects need serious retooling, they seem to be working towards a pro-artist reputation and continue seeking interesting, unique projects that aren't just adaptations.
For their ability to seek original projects and allowing artistic freedom for the creatives in charge of said titles, Netflix comes out on top once again.
Winner: Netflix
1. Conclusion
Upon breaking down all of the essential components of a streaming service and comparing the two, it's clear that Netflix hasn't lost its crown yet. Disney has a very promising service that will continue to have a steady stream of subscribers just for the MCU/Star Wars content. However, until they add some desperately-needed variety in their library, it'll remain a contender rather than a champion.
Netflix has ensured its supremacy for years now because of constant investment across all corners of entertainment, including exclusive anime, movies and various adaptations - and that's without including the impeccable library of much-beloved pre-existing titles. They've been (mostly) incredibly smart in knowing when to invest in something or to cut their losses.
That doesn't mean they can rest on their laurels though. If Disney learns from the issues they've had in their debut year, they could begin regathering that momentum they had pre-release. Also, with HBO Max on the horizon, armed with a dense library of critically-acclaimed titles and phenomenal exclusive projects already confirmed, Netflix could finally meet its match come May.
How Well Do You Know Netflix TV Shows?