Dredd 3D: 5 Reasons Why It Flopped At The Box Office

When Lionsgate took the decision to screen the as-then unreleased Dredd 3D in July at San Diego's Comic Con International, it played to collective cheers from the attendant fans. Early word was good... in fact, better than good. This was something special. A decidedly British vision of a US dystopia a century from now; grim and bloody, it featured hypnotic visuals by an Oscar-winning cinematographer, rendering visceral violence with a surreal beauty, and combined that with action movie-making the likes of which had not seen since the excesses of Paul Verhoeven's Sci-Fi holy trinity: Robocop, Total Recall and Starship Troopers. By Hollywood standards, this was a modestly budgeted movie (measured against Hollywood Sci Fi, it's actually low-budget). Conversely, for a British production, the supposed $45 million production (excluding marketing) represented the biggest independently produced Brit movie of all time. Writer/producer Alex Garland and fellow staff at DNA Films spent many years in pre-production, giving centre-stage to the much-loved UK comic character (Judge Dredd has appeared in the pages of weekly comic anthology 2000AD for the past 35 years). Regardless of budget being big or small, this had clearly been a labour of love for the creative talents involved. So, how confident must they have felt, directly following Comic Con, when those first reviews started to appear? The initial fan reaction was matched by an equally enthusiastic critical appraisal. Better yet, it seemed the American audience actually got the pitch black humour, that satirical edge so present in the pages of the source material. Tantalisingly, Karl Urban's performance of the central character was described by all as the definitive Dredd. It looked like the sleeper hit of the year, already in the bag. Even before release, there was talk of a sequel; then, that Dredd was the first of a possible trilogy of movies penned by Garland. Hardcore Dredd-heads salivated at talk of the Dark Judges, Dredd's pilgrimage into the Cursed Earth, the Angel Gang.... all this before the movie opened at the start of September for UK audiences (two weeks later in the US). Regardless of worldwide takings, a box-office pull of $50 million in US theatres was the mooted figure to guarantee a green light for the sequel. Word was already out - Dredd 3D was precisely what mature audiences wanted to see. Hard R-rated action. Something that didn't pander to the teen market. A concept that acted as calling card - here's just a taste of what's to come. This was going to be BIG. Only - it wasn't. At time of writing, it's the start of October, one month later, and the results are in. And Dredd has perfomed abysmally, both at home in the UK, then even worse in the US - falling out of the top ten movies there in only its second week. By any measure, it's a commercial wreck. Had the film been slated by the critics or hated by the fans, this might not matter. Lousy films tank all the time, and rightly so. But here is a movie deemed not only worthy of merit - it also offered something a little different within its own genre trappings. It should have played to a much bigger audience than it did, even if it didn't reach that magic $50 million line in the sand. And at current standing €“ the film has barely reached a fifth of that amount €“ it looks like a sequel is never going to happen. When I saw Dredd 3D on that opening weekend, I left the cinema feeling I'd seen something pretty remarkable. I decided before I'd even got home that I needed to see it again. Even before the terrible box office results were calculated, though, I'd had my own concerns. Why was there only a dozen people in the same screening, or even less the next time I went back? I know a lot of people who go to the movies - yet none of them paid money to see Dredd. So. What went wrong?

Theory 1: Irksome Concepts and the Shadow of Sly

From the off, Dredd was always going to be a tough sell, at least in terms of the all-important US market. The Dredd strip depicted a wry, British view of America gone to hell; inspired by Clint Eastwood in Dirty Harry, but set in the future, Dredd is the logical extreme of hard-line policing. Was it a tall order expecting American audiences to be interested in an outsider's half satirical idea of a post-holocaust metropolis, governed by an army of state executioners? It isn't like we hadn't been there before. As much as Dredd fans want to forget the Sylvester Stallone movie of '95, it casts a very long shadow. Judge Dredd was a previous attempt to bring the character to the big screen; with a far greater budget and an over plotted storyline it also failed miserably on release. At least that one made $20 million on its opening weekend (peanuts next to its $100 million-plus budget) - and that was in 1995. In 2012, Dredd 3D made a tenth of that figure on opening. Stallone's version infamously shed Dredd of the iconic helmet - absolutely forbidden in the comic - and even added a love interest. DNA Films said from the start they weren't going to make the same compromises. As much as the production remained true to those cornerstones of the comic, they made changes in other areas - specifically with the design of Mega-City One, Dredd's stomping ground and very much a character in its own right. In Dredd, Mega-City One is seen as an exaggerated version of a large urban sprawl, shot through a murky miasma of pollution and decay. This is in contrast to the city of the comics, where the dazzling organic architecture is shown alongside crass billboards and a population of bored, unpredictable citizens. Flying vehicles, robots and banal entertainments are very much part of the fabric of Mega-City One on the page. Dredd opted for a more realistic world - but maybe a colourful, eccentric metropolis might have offered an interesting counterpoint to the bleak setting. After all, it works that way in the printed stories...

Theory 2: It's Another Comic-Book Movie/It's An Obscure Hero

The sheer weight of comic-book adaptations hitting cinema screens presented an undeniable problem for Dredd. The current cycle of superhero movies has thrown up so many characters and concepts that it€™s easy to imagine audience fatigue, at least when it comes to this genre. Unfamiliarity with the character would invariably draw unfavourable comparisons - some people dismissed the movie as a cheap Batman knockoff thanks to misreading the apparent the dark vigilante feel of the trailers. Efforts to educate the masses to the unique properties of a property hadn€™t worked earlier in the year for John Carter or Green Lantern - and it sure as hell didn't work for Dredd. Then there's the matter of that uniform. And although the gritty redesign of the original outfit worked perfectly for the film (and won fan approval), word is that US audiences didn't like that they never got to see the main guy's face - some were disappointed at the lack of reveal - which of course misses the fact that we're not supposed to see his face, but that's beside the point. With the success of The Avengers, the bar was raised for all comic book adaptations - at least, those made in that mould. Dredd chose to be different and eschew it's comic trappings, presenting a very grounded, CGI-lite interpretation of the source material. So it's a bitter irony that, for a film trying to not be a comic book movie, it may have ended up being dismissed as one anyway.

Theory 3: Difficult Demographics

'I'll just wait for it to come out on DVD'. How many times do you hear people say that about a film when they look for what€™s showing? In the case of Dredd, it's probably many times. Dredd dared to stick to its R-rated guns, making it clear from the outset that punches were not being pulled. This one was going to be bloody. Aiming for a distinctly adult audience, DNA Films believed there was a healthy market out there; a section of the population that enjoyed a certain vintage when it came to action pictures. And while they were right in this assumption, they may have overestimated the punters' desire to hand over money when it came to the experience. Dredd knows what market it's pitched at. It's the same generation who grew up watching Eastwood growl the words 'do you feel lucky, punk?' They get the black humour inherent in one man's grim determination when passing judgement without emotion. Dredd perfectly distils that down-the-barrel-of-a-gun moment, providing many of the money-shots in the film. Sadly, those same people who would 'get' it are the same ones who've given up paying for a cinema ticket. Ironically, that€™s due in part to the prevalence of teen-friendly event movies, which in turn has led to lots of annoyed adults turning their backs on cinema attendance €“ mostly because they don't want to sit in a dark room full of chattering kids. Combine that with the perceived cost element, made worse by the extra sting of 3D hiking the ticket price (more on that later), the reluctance to hand over hard-earned cash for a movie that doesn't quite say what it is (more on that later, too). Many didn€™t get past some basic questions. Was it a sequel? A reboot? Another comic-book character? Would Dredd have benefitted from two edits - one release for the PG-13 crowd, another for the R certificate? It's hard to know how toothless such an edit might render the movie, but there's no denying, it would have put more backsides on seats.

Theory 4: 2D - Or Not 2D

The current trend for 3D pictures in many ways allowed Dredd to happen. Sold on the back of Avatar's success, 3D was essential to the pitch made by DNA; without it, the film could not be made. From the outset, this became a design consideration when shooting the film. Trouble is, people have been burned by poor, retrofitted 3D, plus the additional cost (ramped up further if you forgot to hold onto the glasses from last time). Most people won't know about the artistic decisions made during the creative process of the production. All they know is the inflated ticket price and the relative lack of return from many 3D experiences. Once bitten... This wouldn't be so bad if there was still the option for a 2D screening. Regardless of how essential the 3D experience is to a film, there are people who will abjectly refuse to pay extra. Some just don't like the sensation. Others hate wearing the glasses. Add into that those who actually can't see 3D images and you've got a fair chunk of people who wouldn't even consider it. For a sizeable number of moviegoers, 3D is never an option. There was a paltry number of 2D screenings available in both the UK and the US - which may have had a significant effect on audience numbers.

Theory 5: Poor Marketing

Finally, there's the way the movie was marketed to the public - and when it was released. Historically, September is a lousy month by any measure in the world of film; ticket sales are always at their lowest. Add to that an overall downturn in cinema attendance this year - some say by as much as a 30% dip from last year in the US - and you're looking at possibly the worst release window in a long time. Principal photography finished on Dredd almost two years ago; what followed was a lengthy post-production period that, by some accounts, marked an especially difficult phase for the film. This undoubtedly held the release back, maybe to its detriment. Unfortunate comparisons to the similarly plotted Indonesian flick The Raid would have been groundless - and it would have got in there before Nolan's final Batman instalment hit the screens, and it would have preceded the spectacle of The Avengers. Scheduling aside, there's the matter of the strangely unengaging trailer. Tantalising as it was to existing fans, it left everyone else underwhelmed - although later variants and TV spots improved on this start. And although some vaguely interesting pre-launch posters appeared, the final movie poster was horribly similar to Ben Affleck's Daredevil dud - further enhancing the films also-ran status, before it was even out of the gate. Instead of focusing on its comic book roots, maybe a campaign embracing the grindhouse vibe of the piece would have worked better, playing up the exploitation elements. An impactful poster encapsulating both the lurid comic vibe and the violence in one hit could have worked in much the same way it did for Hobo with a Shotgun, where that image brilliantly telegraphed an era that harked back to VHS. The very 80s action films that informed and inspired Dredd - Escape from New York, Assault on Precinct 13, Die Hard - all had names that said what they did, and used the confines of the scenario almost as a character in itself. Think how the tower block in Die Hard is the central image for that poster, not Bruce Willis - would Dredd have been better pitched for the concept, rather than the character? In fact, why call it Dredd at all? That surely suggested a sequel to the Stallone movie to all but devoted fans. There were token attempts at viral marketing: a graffiti teaser poster, a lifeless pastiche of the Drudge Report website (www.dreddreport.com €“ see what they did there?) and even a booth to create your own slo-mo sequence (try searching €˜slow mo booth€™ on youtube). At a reputed $10-15 million additional marketing spend on Dredd, is this the best they could do? Click "next" to read the final part, "The End of Dredd - And Violent Movies?"...

The End of Dredd - And Violent Movies?

Inevitably, this is all very bad news for DNA Films and Lionsgate (to say nothing of Reliance Entertainment, who€™d coughed up most of the film€™s finance). Looking beyond Dredd, does this spell bad news for the future of all action movies? Some say the failure of Dredd at the box office is a damning indicator of the public€™s lack of appetite for violent adult content €“ that there's only a small audience for that kind of thing; the message seems to be that the public generally prefers their action without impact wounds and collateral damage. Studios will argue that it€™s far better to hit the wider market, even if that means toning down the intensity. Whatever the reasons, Dredd became another of this years disappointments - if only from a fiscal viewpoint. Perhaps it was always going to be that way. The simple view is that, when it came down to it, nobody much cared for a Dredd film in the first place. With that in mind, those Dredd fans glum because of the terrible box office should maybe rejoice that the film exists at all. What we're left with is a brilliantly bold and ambitious film that will without doubt become the cult classic it set out to be. Time will be kind to Dredd. And despite the current total showing on box office registers, we may yet see a return for Mega-City One's toughest lawman. It just might take the long walk to get there.

Contributor
Contributor

Ian Terry is a designer, writer and artist living somewhere in the leafy outskirts of North London. He'd previously worked in the games business, from humble 8-bit beginnings on to PC and console titles. Ian is the author of two novels and is currently employed as a writer for the designer menswear industry. Since the age of ten, he's been strangely preoccupied with the movies and enjoys writing about them.