Eternals Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs
The MCU's first Rotten movie is an ambitious disappointment.
The third of four MCU movies due to release this year is finally here: the massively anticipated Eternals.
With recent Best Director Oscar winner ChloƩ Zhao at the helm and buzz suggesting it could pull a Black Panther to become the second Best Picture-nominated MCU movie, it's absolutely shocking that Eternals is the franchise's first Rotten movie on Rotten Tomatoes.
Currently wavering around the 50% mark - about 40% below what most surely expected - Eternals undeniably falls far short of the lofty expectations from fans and critics alike.
That's not to say this is a terrible or worthless film, but that given the cast and crew involved it totally misses the expected mark.
For a movie touted as the next big step forward for the MCU, it's a bafflingly messy, often boring piece of work that doesn't really convince on a conceptual level.
It's still sure to please many MCU fans enough to get a passing grade, but audiences equally couldn't be blamed for feeling utterly fatigued and exhausted by what it has to offer.
And so firstly, here's what Eternals just doesn't get right...
Downs...
5. The Brutal Pacing & Runtime
While it goes without saying that Eternals has to cram a lot into its runtime - namely over a dozen prominent new characters and its own dense mythology - that doesn't mean the film's bladder-busting 157 minutes are all well spent.
The pacing is frustratingly all over the place: the first half darts violently between time periods and settings enough to cause potential viewer whiplash, while the back-end of the movie slows down to a stamina-sapping halt.
As such, audiences may well find themselves clock-watching long before the story reaches its prolonged climax.
The adage goes that no good movie is too long nor no bad movie short enough, yet it's certainly easy to see how a film like Eternals could have earned its expansive length.
Yet due to the leaden writing and some questionable editorial choices, this is far more of a slog than any MCU movie ever has been. All in all, Eternals might've been a story better told in a six-part Disney+ series.
4. The Disappointingly Dull Action Sequences
It's always a roll of the dice when an indie filmmaker inexperienced in huge-scale action joins the MCU - sometimes we get James Gunn's gloriously colourful and exciting set-pieces in Guardians of the Galaxy, and other times we end up with the anonymous, forgettable action of Cate Shortland's Black Widow.
Eternals director ChloƩ Zhao is an especially interesting case given that her prior three films are not only extremely low-budget but also meditative mood and character pieces - almost the exact opposite of what's expected in an MCU movie.
Sadly Zhao doesn't bring much to the table for the action sequences, which lack any sort of distinct aesthetic personality and instead feel more like they were pumped out by a committee at Marvel Studios.
The superhero fisticuffs with the Deviants and others are bafflingly lacking in imagination, sometimes evoking the overly glossy, floaty vibe of a mediocre video game cutscene, or in one of its final set-pieces the blurry muddiness of Zack Snyder's worst fight scenes.
There's not a single action scene here that can hold a handle to the first few from Shang-Chi, for instance. Despite having so many super-powered individuals at its disposal, the fantasy carnage here feels totally boilerplate.
3. The Shockingly Generic Script
Though Eternals certainly has some intriguing and provocative ideas on its mind, you'd barely know it from the script.
Co-written by Zhao and three other screenwriters, this may simply be a case of too many cooks compromising their disparate ideas into a more palatable, digestible whole.
And yet, in order to make sense of the many new characters and concepts we're introduced to, the script so often relies on lazy exposition to get the job done.
By the time the fourth of fifth exposition dump is hurled at the viewer, they can't really be blamed for feeling a bit tired of it.
Characterisation is also a major issue, as while these heroes seem interesting enough on paper, the script makes a shockingly meagre effort to flesh them out.
In the case of Sersi (Gemma Chan) and Ikaris (Richard Madden), far too much of a focus is placed on their tedious, predictable romance.
This all adds up to a screenplay that's a mess of conflicting tones and ideas, and so only sporadically manages to engage.
2. The Mixed Bag Of Villains
If you thought the Deviants looked like generic CGI dog-monsters you've fought in at least a dozen different video games over the years, the final film won't much dissuade from that belief.
The MCU villain problem abounds once again in Eternals, for though the Deviants are slightly more complex than they first seem, for the most part they're presented as generic fantasy baddies.
The Celestial Arishem (David Kaye) proves a little more interesting, though naturally lacks much of a presence throughout the film for reasons that will be clear to anyone watching it.
Other villains can't really be discussed in any depth for the sake of spoilers, though the major third-act villain has such a painfully predictable and by-the-numbers arc that few are likely to be left fully satisfied.
Eternals' villains aren't nearly the worst the MCU has ever offered up, and there are definitely kernels of intrigue here, but due to the film's aforementioned scripting issues they don't feel utilised to anywhere near their full potential.
1. It's The Most Disappointing MCU Movie BY FAR
Is Eternals the worst ever MCU movie? That's totally debatable - for many it will be of considerably greater interest than the indisputable franchise punching bag, Thor: The Dark World.
This isn't nearly as disposable plot-wise as the second Thor movie or even Black Widow, but it is almost inarguably the most disappointing MCU movie to date.
Expectations were enormously high from the moment the cast and director Zhao had their involvement confirmed, and so for this much talent to end up delivering the worst-reviewed MCU film to date is absolutely inexplicable.
It just goes to show that, as ever, script is king, and without the fundamentals being nailed down on such a massive project, no amount of star power or directorial prowess can paper over it.
The best thing you can do is lower your expectations going in and appreciate that what you're about to see is a deeply flawed piece of work, albeit not without its merits.
Speaking of which, here's where Eternals actually succeeds...
Ups...
5. The Entertaining Ensemble Cast
The script may not give them enough, but Eternals' large ensemble cast of heroes absolutely deserves credit for keeping the film as watchable as it ultimately is.
As de facto protagonist Sersi, Gemma Chan is especially solid here, while Barry Keoghan is an easy dramatic highlight as the tortured Druig, and Kumail Nanjiani brings well-placed comic relief as superhero-Bollywood star Kingo.
As by far the youngest member of the cast, Lia McHugh brings as much dimension as possible to the thinly-written part of ever-young-looking Sprite, Richard Madden is steely-good as the Superman-like Ikaris, and Brian Tyree Henry delivers the sardonic goods as the MCU's first openly gay superhero, Phastos.
There's no denying that some characters are better-served than others - Angelina Jolie's Thena makes a strangely soft impression, and Kit Harington's role as Dane Whitman is much smaller than expected - but overall the cast absolutely delivers all you could expect from the material.
4. It Has Game-Changing Implications For The MCU
The moment-to-moment writing may be disappointing, but there's little denying that Eternals is one of the most ambitious MCU movies to date in terms of pure concept and scope.
The film has much to say about the creation of Earth, the future fate of humanity, and the general packing order of the universe, and while these considerations are often wrapped around more typical fantasy shenanigans, they're still the best part of the movie.
By rewriting the history of the world in a bold and inventive way, the MCU has received a substantial update to its mythos which has potentially tectonic implications for the future of the franchise.
It of course remains to be seen whether or not subsequent MCU movies will dig deeper into this (especially given the divisive response so far), but the seeds have most certainly been sewn for future stories and conflicts.
Perhaps most bravely of all, the film also re-contextualises Thanos' (Josh Brolin) most tyrannical actions in a fascinating and surprising way - albeit one not all fans are likely to agree with.
3. The Stunning Cinematography
Much was written pre-release about Eternals relying far more on natural locations and lighting than basically all other MCU films, which typically use bespoke sets and heaps of green screen compositing.
And while Eternals certainly does feature a lot of VFX, it is massively refreshing that so many scenes were clearly filmed in real locations with minimal digital embellishments.
As such, despite its flaws Zhao's film has a tactile, lived-in quality to it that most other MCU films simply don't.
It doesn't hurt that veteran MCU cinematographer Ben Davis - who previously lensed Guardians of the Galaxy, Avengers: Age of Ultron, Doctor Strange, and Captain Marvel - shoots the absolute hell out of the various gorgeous sunsets and sweeping vistas, ensuring Eternals feels epic in a way quite unlike any other MCU film.
2. The Lack Of "MCU Humour"
As much as we've all grown tired of that "Fall Collection, IKEA" joke from the film's trailers, that's really as typical as the film's "MCU humour" actually gets.
For the most part Eternals does a respectable job of toeing the tonal line - taking itself and its mythology seriously and not punctuating each and every serious moment with a goofy one-liner.
Sure, there is still enough humour - largely by way of the wise-cracking Kingo - but one suspects Zhao's more serious-minded filmmaking sensibilities were instrumental in ensuring the dramatic moments were given room to breathe here.
It's funny enough when it needs to be, but clearly doesn't feel the urge to accompany its more straight-laced moments with a slew of daft gags to lighten the mood.
1. The Surprising (And Weird) Credits Scenes
No spoilers here of course, but whatever you make of the movie proper, you'll absolutely want to stick around for both of the movie's surprising, even crowd-pleasing, and very strange credits scenes.
The mid-credits scene is sure to be the most headline-grabbing and, per the many leaks about it online, possibly the one you're already aware of.
It's sure to invite plenty of discussion about its implications for the MCU's future, and particularly the presence of a certain actor in it.
The post-credits scene is a little more modest but nevertheless teases a majorly anticipated upcoming MCU project in a more overt way than many were likely expecting.
Needless to say, it's worth sitting through almost 15 (!) minutes of credits to experience these two scenes.