Every David Lynch Film RANKED From Worst To Best
With rumours abounding that the auteur is returning to cinema, there's no better time to dive in.
2020 has been a less than ideal year, yet one bright spot has been David Lynch's typically up and offbeat weather updates from L.A., uploaded to the filmmaker's YouTube channel. Indeed, Lynch has been curiously active over this year, releasing a short film What Did Jack Do? to Netflix aside from his YouTube uploads, and even teased in a recent interview that, if it wasn't for lockdown interrupting, he would have been working on a new film.
Since his first feature in 1977 to Twin Peaks: The Return in 2018 and other projects since and beyond, Lynch has established himself as one of cinema's premier filmmakers, almost immediately developing a trademark style mixing retro 1950s vibes with the surreal and quotidian in oftentimes uncomfortable combinations. Lynch doesn't just make film and television, however, having started his career as a painter and thereafter branching out into everything from photography to furniture design and even having released two albums.
However, cinema always has and always will hold a special place in Lynch's heart. All in all, the signs are pointing to Lynch returning to our screens sometime soon.
This seems a perfect time then to look back over Lynch's idiosyncratic filmography, ranking all ten of his feature films from worst to best.
10. Inland Empire
Certainly Lynch's most challenging feature, this is one only for hardened fans; newcomers are liable to be turned off by the low resolution digital cinematography, nonlinear narrative structure, and all the usual Lynchisms turned right up to 11.
Starring Laura Dern, Jeremy Irons, and Justin Theroux, Inland Empire concerns, in the most basic description that can be mustered, an actress's life falling apart as she begins to absorb the personality of the role she is playing. That, however, is an admittedly inadequate description of what happens, though mainly because this is the Lynch film that most epitomises the notion that the plot is not as important as the mood.
Inland Empire also marked Lynch's transition from traditional photochemical film to digital cinematography, a decision that the filmmaker champions and that was featured in the Keanu Reeves-produced documentary Side by Side. Whilst the switch afforded Lynch a degree of creative freedom that he found to be truly liberating, the low resolution look of the film is liable to be off-putting to some. Add to that a three hour run time and nonlinear, indeed oftentimes seemingly incoherent narratives, the film is really for the hardcore Lynch fans looking to immerse themselves in the filmmaker's world - and assuredly not for newcomers.
9. Dune
With Denis Villeneuve's remake coming next year, now's the time to revisit Lynch's version which, despite studio interference resulting in a less than ideal adaption, is still not as bad as you have heard.
The first big screen iteration of Frank Herbert's genre-defining novel, the production was infamously troubled by studio interference, resulting in the picture being reedited and Lynch attempting to have his name removed from the credits.
And yet, despite that, Dune is not as bad as you may have heard. In fact, watching the film and then the trailer for Villeneuve's outing will reveal a good deal of visual similarities. Lynch's version still has scale and action and there is a lot to be said for production design and detail displayed on screen.
Kyle MacLachlan makes his debut and is a strong performer right out the gate. Indeed, everyone in the star-studded case - Patrick Stewart, Max Von Sydow, Sean Young, and Sting to name a few - either performs admirably if not excellently. Yes, it has aged and the weird whispering voice overs are plain disconcerting, but Dune is still a good sci-fi film, even if it doesn't quite live up to the novel.
Indeed, its main criticism for the purposes of this list is that it doesn't always feel particularly Lynchian.
8. The Straight Story
The last company you would imagining producing a Lynch film would be Disney, but that is exactly who backed this gentle, touching tale of one man's journey to reconnect with his brother with only a lawnmower for transport.
With an unforgettable and Oscar-nominated turn from Richard Farnsworth, who undertook the role of Alvin Straight despite suffering from terminal prostrate cancer which had spread to his bones, the film manages to be a true oddity in Lynch's filmography by virtue of not being surreal or nightmarish. Indeed, The Straight Story is just that; a straightforward, simple, yet undeniably affecting drama that carries you effortlessly from beginning to end.
The film was nominated for the Palme D'Or and was universally acclaimed, with a number of outlets somewhat surprised by Lynch's uncharacteristic turn. Legendary critic Roger Ebert, no fan of Lynch at the best of times, gave the film four out of four, praising the realistic, Hemingway-esque dialogue, and the film's beauty. The main reason why The Straight Story appears so low on this list is simply because of how atypical it is for Lynch; suffice to say, the best Lynch film isn't the least Lynchian he has made. However, that doesn't detract from this excellent drama.
7. Lost Highway
This dark Neo-noir marks Lynch's turn towards more difficult narrative structures, the resulting picture being a certainly challenging yet still intriguing thriller about identity and authenticity.
The initial premise sees musician Fred Madison (Bill Pullman) receiving disconcerting VHS tapes of himself and his wife filmed from inside his house, before his wife is murdered and he is arrested. From there, the nonlinear elements become explicit and doppelgängers abound. Attempting to describe Lost Highway is to somewhat miss the point; the film is designed more as a cinematic experience than as a coherent narrative, though there's certainly enough there for you to piece everything together.
Whilst not as challenging as Inland Empire, Lost Highway will still test the patience of non-Lynch initiates. However, its blend of noir and surrealism makes for a truly fascinating motion picture, one which is at turns horrifying and humorous (a combination one comes to expect from Lynch). The three central performances from Pullman, Patricia Arquette, and Balthazar Getty manage to anchor the film even in its most disquietingly surreal sequences.
A favourite amongst aficionados, Lost Highway is an unforgettable if difficult film from Lynch.
6. Tne Elephant Man
Lynch's second feature is a typically unusual approach to the period drama and biopic, telling the tragic tale of John Merrick (John Hurt in a truly heartbreaking role). The film also managed to net eight academy award nominations, with the backlash to the lack of academy appreciation for the film's groundbreaking make up heralding the creation of the Best Make Up category thereafter.
Telling the true tale of Joseph Merrick (called John Merrick in the film), this late Victorian set piece centres on Merrick's (John Hurt) trials and tribulations in living with his severe deformations, as well as his relationship with Dr. Frederick Treves (Anthony Hopkins). Though the entire cast is exquisite, particularly Hopkins and John Gielgud, every scene is stolen by Hurt, who manages a performance of incredible strength, tenderness, and nuance, all the while filming under make up so heavy it took about eight hours to apply.
Though relatively subdued and realistic, unlike Dune or The Straight Story however, there's enough that is identifiably Lynchian in The Elephant Man. In particular, surrealistic fugues exploring Merrick's childhood and dreams seem to seep into the celluloid in places. Those sequences, as well as the stark black and white cinematography, combine to deliver an emotional and yet still recognisably Lynchian outing.
5. Wild at Heart
This sexually charged surrealistic road trip sees Laura Dern and Nicholas Cage as star-crossed lovers on the run from their pasts. Lynch's Palme D'Or winner is one of his most entertaining romps.
Adapted from a novel by Barry Gifford, the film sees Nicholas Cage's Sailor and Laura Dern's Lula hit the road, trying to escape Lula's domineering mother (Diane Ladd, in an Oscar nominated turn) and the various gangsters and underworld figures she's hired to hunt them down. With Elvis and The Wizard of Oz regularly cropping up, as well as surrealistic digressions (one particularly striking scene when Sailor and Lula happen upon the aftermath of a car crash comes to mind), Wild at Heart is an unforgettable ride.
And yet, despite all that, the story of Sailor and Lula was subject to rather lukewarm receptions upon release, with a number of critics finding the film a bit too disjointed and potentially pointless. Its reputation, however, has only improved since and the film is now rightfully considered a true original. Not only that, in your writer's estimation, it is Lynch's fifth best.
4. Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me
Unjustly maligned at the time of its release, this prequel/sequel feature to the seminal show Twin Peak deserves rediscovery and is being tentatively reappraised by critics as one of the director's greatest triumphs.
Fire Walk With Me is primarily concerned with the events leading up to Twin Peaks' first series, though time is a great deal more fluid here. In particular, the film follows the investigation into the murder of Teresa Banks (Pamela Gidley) as well as the last seven days of Laura Palmer (Sheryl Lee). Most of the original series cast reprise their roles, though a number were left on the cutting room floor, and the film also features small roles and cameos from Kiefer Sutherland, Harry Dean Stanton, and musicians Chris Isaak and David Bowie. Essentially, Fire Walk With Me distills the horror and mystery elements from the show and leaves most of its quirky humour out, layering dread into a masterpiece of trauma and suffering.
And that explains for the most part the initial backlash to the film: Fire Walk With Me is profoundly distressing, one that refuses to sugar coat the heart of the story of Twin Peaks in the entertaining eccentricities which are part of the show's charm; for all its surrealism, this is a story about one girl's abuse and murder. Despite being a horrific film, Fire Walk With Me has been unjustly ruled a bad one, which is most certainly is not.
3. Eraserhead
Lynch's debut was a staple of midnight movie screenings and remains one of cinema's most surreal horror films.
Written, directed, produced, edited, and with score and sound design all by Lynch, this low-budget experimental work essentially presents a nightmare, one in which a man (Jack Nance) is left to care for a peculiar, almost alien baby in a desolate industrial landscape. From dancing and bleeding poussin chickens to the woman in the radiator stamping sperm-like flesh deposits to the titular sequence in which the man's head is taken to a factory and turned into eraser heads for pencils, there's no shortage of striking and disturbing imagery in the film.
Surprising, however, is how cohesive the film feels despite its narrative disruptions and surrealistic segues. Eraserhead is a complete cinematic experience and one you are unlikely to forget. Perhaps the finest praise Lynch could have hoped for came when he heard that not only was legendary auteur Stanley Kubrick reportedly showing the film to the cast and crew of The Shining to get them in the right mood, but that Kubrick told Lynch directly that Eraserhead was his favourite film. It's hard to ignore the praise of such a filmmaker.
2. Blue Velvet
Lynch's return to a smaller scale after his big studio experiences with Dune and Elephant Man was the film that arguably established him as the unique filmmaker he is today. If you're looking for your first Lynch experience, or simply just a distillation of every element that constitutes 'Lynchian,' then Blue Velvet is the film for you.
When Jeffrey Beaumont (Kyle MacLachlan) comes home from college to look after his father's store after the latter has a stroke, he finds a severed human ear in a field one day, leading him into the seedy underbelly of his town he never knew was there.
Featuring one of cinema's most frightening villains in Dennis Hopper's Frank Booth, Blue Velvet is justly considered one of the best mystery films ever made. From those first technicolour shots of red roses against blue skies and white picket fence as Bobby Vinton sings to the squirming beetles underneath greener than green grass, you find yourself transported to an uneasy dreamworld of Americana and erotica.
It should come as no surprise that the film initially met with mixed critical response, something consistent through Lynch's career. However, it is now considered one of cinema's triumphs.
1. Mulholland Drive
Lynch salvaged what was to be a new TV pilot and managed to pull together his outstanding feature film achievement; a moody, melancholy Hollywood nightmare.
Telling a nonlinear narrative of L.A., film directors, mysterious studio heads, wannabe actresses, gangsters, lowlifes, and all sorts, the film's initial premise follows Betty (Naomi Watts) and Rita (Laura Harring), the latter an amnesiac, as they try to uncover Rita's identity. Originally, the film was to be a pilot for a new TV series, but when that project fell through, Lynch rewrote and reworked his material, restarted filming, and produced Mulholland Drive.
Though Blue Velvet is the Lynch film for some, Mulholland Drive has the feeling of a culmination, bringing together all those characteristic elements evident in even Lynch's earlier work, his developments in writing Twin Peaks, as well as the nonlinearity he played with in Lost Highway. The result is a breathtaking piece of cinema, rightly considered one of the 21st century's finest. In the end, though it is close, Mulholland Drive has to take the top spot; it has more heart than Blue Velvet, even if it sets out to break it.