Every DCEU Movie Ranked By Box Office Success
How does The Suicide Squad compare to the rest of DC's catalogue?
There are few movie franchises that have had the same ups and downs, and have a been as polarizing as the DC Extended Universe. Over the last eight years there have been shocking releases that could have killed any other franchise, but also some truly exceptional movies completely on the other end of the spectrum.
It has had its successes and its failures, but through everything has still managed to bring in over $5 billion in box office numbers, making it the eleventh highest grossing movie franchise ever. Despite the inevitable comparisons to the MCU, the DCEU has survived its rocky start, and the worst could be behind it.
One of the biggest hinderances has been the interference from Warner Bros. The studio overseeing the building of the DC universe has often handcuffed its creative talents and sacrificed much in the way of storytelling and quality for the potential of a bigger number on the bottom line.
This hasn’t always worked out particularly well for them, but as always, the box office has offered up some surprises in the DCEU, certainly not always fairly reflecting the quality of each movie. This list definitely makes for different reading than if these ten movies were to be ranked from worst to best.
10. The Suicide Squad - $162.5 Million
The DECU has been playing catch up with the MCU for years and, between trying to rush into a shared universe, producing nightmares, and studio interference, the franchise has been a mess for a while. There are, however, a few bright spots, one of which is The Suicide Squad.
The most recent addition to the DCEU, directed by James Gunn, is easily the best of the bunch. It’s loud, outrageous, and above all else, it’s fun. Though not perfect, it is everything you could want from a comic book movie.
Despite critical acclaim and minimal interference from Warner Bros., the movie comes in dead last in terms of ticket sales. There are lots of different factors that have gone into this, not least a worldwide pandemic that shut the entire world down for the best part of 18 months.
Pair this with a simultaneous release in both cinemas and on HBO Max, and the sour taste still left from David Ayer’s Suicide Squad five years earlier, what should have been a roaring franchise debut success for Gunn fizzled into a box office bomb. This hasn’t stopped WB reportedly eying the director for more projects in the future, though.
9. Wonder Woman 1984 - $166.5 Million
Throughout the eight years and ten DCEU movies (11 if you count the Snyder Cut), there has so far only been one true sequel. Wonder Woman 1984 followed the universally acclaimed Wonder Woman in 2020, and to say it didn’t live up to the hype would be a huge understatement.
For years since her debut in Batman v Superman, Gal Gadot’s Amazonian warrior was one of the only reasons to keep any interest in the franchise, and yet, her second solo movie was criminally underwhelming. Handicapped by poor villains, weak CGI, and a bizarre body swapping plot, WW84 was always going to struggle to live up to the undeniable success that preceded it.
Even without taking into consideration the quality of the movie itself, its release, just like The Suicide Squad, caused problems. While James Gunn’s movie released in 2021 when it seemed that much of the world was beginning to open back up, WW84 came out at the height of the pandemic in 2020.
It was pushed back several times, and was also released on HBO Max at the same time, leading to incredibly disappointing box office numbers. Though it failed to break even in terms of ticket sales, it did at least become the most watched straight-to-streaming movie of the year.
8. Harley Quinn: Birds Of Prey - $201.9 Million
There weren’t many positive things to come out of David Ayer’s Suicide Squad in 2016. In fact, in reality there was only one, and that was Harley Quinn. Margot Robbie’s character took pop culture by storm with the release of the movie, and suddenly became one of DC’s most marketable characters.
Warner Bros. ran with this and gave Harley her own spin-off in 2020, though it disappointed in terms of ticket sales. So much so, the movie that was originally marketed as Birds of Prey (and the Fantabulous Emancipation of One Harley Quinn) was changed to Harley Quinn: Birds of Prey in an attempt to bring in more sales.
Aside from the confusing title that put more emphasis on the relatively obscure Birds of Prey (in terms of the mainstream audience, at least) over that of Harley Quinn, it would appear that no one really wanted a spin-off or a sequel to Suicide Squad, and that Harley herself wasn’t quite as marketable as WB thought.
The back end of its theatrical release was somewhat affected by the coronavirus pandemic, although at this point the movie was already a certified flop. This is a shame as it is actually one of the DCEU’s better outings.
7. Shazam! - $365.9 Million
When Shazam! was released in March 2019, it appeared to be the dawn of a new direction for the DCEU. Zachary Levi’s character and the movie named for him moved away from the dark tone of the beginnings of the SnyderVerse, and instead opted for more of an unmistakable Marvel-esque feel.
This clear change in direction that was more in line with what mainstream audiences expected from the MCU automatically sold tickets, however it still fell some way short of the numbers some of the previous entries in the franchise achieved.
The timing of the movie’s release may have had a large impact on its performance at the box office as it was up against not one, but two $1 billion MCU outings. Sandwiched between Captain Marvel and Avengers: Endgame, Shazam! was always going to struggle to win over mainstream fans.
While these more casual cinema-goers were never likely to choose DC’s outing over either Marvel outing, some of the die-hard DC fans may have felt Shazam! betrayed the Snyder influence that made them fans of the franchise to begin with. This movie feels like it was between a rock and a hard place with its release, but at least it still managed to break even and make some profit.
6. Justice League - $657.9 Million
There is no greater example of the dysfunctional nature of Warner Bros. and the DC Extended Universe than Justice League. This was supposed to be their big 'Avengers moment', but it fell completely flat for a whole host of reasons, and while it still brought in over $650 million, it reportedly lost the studio money.
While the MCU treated The Avengers as an exciting crossover and milestone in the franchise’s storytelling, Warner Bros. treated Justice League like a cash cow. Zack Snyder was handcuffed and constantly hamstrung, with the studio giving the audacious demand that the film clock in at less than two hours.
When Snyder had to step away from the project due to tragic circumstances, Warner Bros. inexplicably brought in Joss Whedon to finish the movie to try and reach a more mainstream audience. This resulted in a reported $25 million worth of reshoots, and a movie that was at war with itself in terms of tone, pleasing nobody.
Warner Bros. needed Justice League to bring in a ton of money in order to break even, but it fell short thanks to a combination of studio interference, alienated audiences, and the fact that the movie just simply wasn’t that good.
5. Man Of Steel - $668 Million
Eight years ago, before the DCEU was an established franchise, and before there was ever any controversial meddling from Warner Bros., Man of Steel was the new take on one of the most instantly recognizable characters in the history of comic books and larger pop culture.
Seven years after the release of Superman Returns, Henry Cavill took on the cape, though his first outing was met with mixed responses, to say the least. The action was a strong point of the movie, however many were turned off by the unexpected dark tone for the character.
Yet still, the intrigue surrounding a new Superman and how he would be handled filled seats in cinemas at least for the opening weekend. The MCU had reinvented the comic book genre in Hollywood, and the hype around superheroes extended from Marvel to DC in 2013.
While the $668 million Man of Steel pulled in is more than any other solo Superman movie before it, after an impressive opening weekend of $116.6 million, it reportdely saw a decline of 65-68% for its second weekend. Clearly the pull of a new Superman movie couldn’t outweigh reviews of the movie itself.
4. Suicide Squad - $746.8 Million
The marketing department of Suicide Squad did a simply phenomenal job back in 2016. The trailers made it look as though the movie would be a fun-filled, exciting superhero blockbuster, not unlike James Gunn’s reimagining of the franchise five years later. However, what was actually brought to screen couldn’t have been further from what was promised.
In spite of early reviews, and following the disappointing Dawn of Justice, fans still flocked to the cinemas to see what could have been a Guardians of the Galaxy-esque outing for the DCEU, and to see the latest iteration of the Joker eight years after Heath Ledger’s iconic role in The Dark Knight.
As this simply wasn’t what was given to cinema-goers, like with Man of Steel, the movie saw a significant drop in its second weekend sales. This was even worse than Henry Cavill’s Superman movie, as it reportedly achieved the second highest second weekend drop off in summer history.
Despite the ticket sales falling off a cliff, thanks to the success of its opening week, there is no doubt that Suicide Squad was a box office success. This is unequivocal proof that box office gross and a movie’s quality are not necessarily correlated.
3. Wonder Woman - $822.8 Million
One of the biggest problems with the DCEU, and in particular the theatrical release of Justice League, was that the studio tried to rush things into a big crossover without taking the time to develop their characters properly. Aquaman, Cyborg, and the Flash all suffered for not having their own solo movies before joining the Justice League, but the same can’t be said of Wonder Woman.
Gal Gadot’s character made her first appearance in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice and absolutely stole the entire show. When her own solo movie was released a year later, there was a buzz like never before.
The superhero genre has grown exponentially over the last two decades, in particular since Iron Man released in 2008, yet until Wonder Woman in 2017, there hadn’t been a female-led movie in the genre. Patty Jenkins and Gal Gadot were on the first wave of changing the game and, rightly so, audiences flocked to the cinema.
The success of this movie may have subsequently affected the expectations and success of its sequel, but Wonder Woman still deservedly claims a place towards the top of this list.
2. Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice - $873.6 Million
In 2012, the Marvel Cinematic Universe opened the door to incredible comic book movie crossovers. Since The Avengers, there has been Age of Ultron, Civil War, Infinity War and Endgame, with countless characters jumping from franchise to franchise in between.
In the same year most of the Avengers joined the Captain America franchise, DC joined the fun. Despite all of Marvel’s success in Hollywood over the years, it’s possible they will never enjoy the star power afforded DC by the names Batman and Superman, and bringing both superhero heavyweights to the screen in the same movie essentially gave Warner Bros. and DC a license to print money.
After the insane popularity of Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy, and with Superman’s longevity, both characters clashed on the big screen for the first time ever.
The movie itself was a crushing disappointment, for a whole laundry list of reasons, and suffered what has been described as an historic box office drop of 81% from its first weekend. However, that didn’t stop this particular train wreck from almost reaching the coveted $1 billion dollar mark. There has been just one DCEU movie to better these numbers since…
1. Aquaman - $1.148 Billion
In a similar way to Harley Quinn rising as a huge asset to DC and Warner Bros. from the woeful Suicide Squad, Arthur Curry was one of the few shining lights to come from the theatrical release of Justice League. Jason Momoa is one of the most likeable personalities in all of Hollywood, and his new, edgy take on Aquaman was a hit with just about everyone who went to see Justice League.
The character may have been wasted in the DCEU’s biggest team-up to date, and Warner Bros. may have done it the wrong way round, but at the very least it managed to hype up his solo movie.
Directed by James Wan, and starring Momoa in the leading role, Aquaman released the following year after Justice League and enjoyed box office success the DCEU has enjoyed neither before or since. Not only was this the DCEU’s biggest hit financially, it is the second highest grossing movie WB have ever released - behind only Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2.
Though not a bad movie by any stretch, Aquaman isn’t the strongest movie in the DCEU’s catalogue, and like Wonder Woman, its success at the box office may ultimately lead to a disappointing figure when Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom is released next year.