Every Halloween Movie (They Never Actually Made)
There's a long, long list of Michael Myers' that never made it to the big screen.
With 2018's latest movie in the Halloween franchise bringing Michael Myers surging back from the grave, many might not have realised quite how many bones of long dead films he had to pass on the way out.
Going strong since 1978, the Halloween franchise now boasts an impressive 11 movies under the banner, meaning it's the series that has everything from its own original storyline, to vastly different reimaginings, to straight up remakes - as well as having enough of a timeline to just throw almost all of it away and start again just because it feels like it.
Of course, with this much investment and effort gone into one of the staples of the horror genre, there's been many scrapped movies along the way. If you've always wanted to see Michael in space or an evil warlock toymaker make their way onto the screen, then you're in luck, as the scripts are out there somewhere.
Dust off your mask, sharpen your machete, and pull on your finest boiler suit, as we're going deep into the 30+ movies lurking under the bed of the Halloween franchise thanks to one avid redditor by the name of ImbecilicNoob. It's going to get weird.
23. Halloween II Pitches
We've already had an actual Halloween 2 in the form of Rick Rosenthal's continuation of 'the night he came home', setting up Laurie Strode in a hospital for the duration as she comes to terms with the events of the first movie.
The initial idea, however, credited to production designer Tommy Lee Wallace, was to have Halloween 2 play out in a high-rise building five years after the event. Laurie Strode is central to the plot, still understandably quite traumatised by her past, and is now attending college.
The Shape would return on Halloween night to do what he does best amidst high security and a decidedly urban backdrop - but Carpenter preferred the idea of going back to the same night more instead.
22. Halloween III: Season Of The Evil Toymaker
The Halloween 3 we got wasn't the one that was originally written, with Season of the Witch being a world away from 'Season of the Evil Toymaker' that the movie was billed as. This had to be rewritten to be gorier, darker, and less tongue in cheek to get to the standard we came to expect from the Halloween movies, with Nigel Kneale leaving his Toymaker script after Carpenter heftily adapted his offbeat ideas.
Tommy Lee Wallace said: “All in all, his tone and the way he wrote the script and ended it all conspired to be a downer ⏤ in a dark and depressing way that wasn’t all that much fun when you got right down to it. It needed help, but it was a pretty complete story. It was his idea to have a fiendish toymaker who is actually a warlock and is going to an international child sacrifice.”
21. Halloween IV Pitches
By far one of the strangest iterations of Michael Myers out there, the Halloween 4 that was originally billed was heavily supernatural, returning to its roots with characters from the original massacre such as Tommy, Lindsey, Gary Hunt, and Brackett.
At the end of the movie, The Shape has the powers of changing his size, meaning he turns himself into a 12ft tall behemoth after playing around with getting variably bigger, and then rampages through the Lover River Drive-In - a location mentioned in passing in the actual Halloween 2. He also regenerates his fingers that get shot off, because why the hell not at this point?
Sadly, it was rejected for being 'too cerebral', with a more human (read: less massive) Michael being the desired antagonist for the feature.
20. Halloween V Pitches
Pitches for Halloween V began a little differently to the niece-stalking, mental hospital themed Halloween 5 that was released, with Shem Bitterman's version having Jamie being far more evil whilst Michael hunted her, and a 35 person death toll dished out along the way.
Robert Harders suggested a Frankenstein story instead, however, where Myers was a sympathetic character brought back to light by lightning. No longer evil and vilified by Haddonfield, Loomis was out to protect him this time around.
And the director of Halloween 4 would have done it differently still, with Dwight H. Little stating: "I would have had Michael either dug up or crawled out of the hole and had an explanation on how long he was down there. I would have told the story going forward with Rachel and Jamie and watched her dark possession evolve. My version would have been a little more from a character point of view."
A POV Myers movie could have been really interesting, here.
19. Halloween: In Space
It happens to the best of villains. Jason ended up there in Jason X, the Leprechaun went there in his fourth movie, even Pinhead took a trip in Bloodlines - so of course, there were plans put in motion for Michael Myers to take a trip beyond the stars and go intergalactic in his franchise. How far we've strayed from god's light.
Envisioned by John Carpenter himself, the idea was literally just to put him in a space station at some point. However, executive producer Moustapha Akkad had none of it, and the world was saved from Michael going boldly where no man has gone before.
18. Halloween VI Concepts
Offering up even more insane leeways before settling down into the movie we got, one concept for Halloween VI had Dr Loomis turning out to be Michael Myers father, and another his mother rendered a sex slave to the Man in Black, aka Dr Terrence Wynn from Halloween V that turned Myers into the serial killer we know and love.
The Man in Black was a feature of other pitches too, set up as a relative of Michael Myers, a replacement for Dr Loomis, and as a simple Bobba Fett style bounty hunter. All of these were scrapped in the end, but it's interesting to see how much of a sticking point the character was in the run up to the early Halloween sequels.
17. Halloween 666: The Origin & Halloween 666: The Curse Of Michael Myers
Two snappy titles that made use of the good old 666 trope for the sixth entry into the series, the first movie pitched - titled The Origin - was another trippy look at Michael Myers in a way he hadn't been seen before.
Incorporating virtual reality into its vision of a homeless Michael Myers, The Origin brings in another Myers sister by the name of Dana and brings in a load of old cameos: but was deemed 'crummy' by its own writer, Scott Spiegel, and tossed for being unfocused.
666: The Curse was a two hour feature that was riddled with alternate endings, and functioned as the early draft for Halloween 6. It was super intense and scary, stopping on executive from sleeping the night he read it and serving as the reason Donald Pleasance signed back on, but ended up being chopped and changed to fit a more mainstream audience in its final form.
16. Helloween: Pinhead Vs. Michael Myers
Introducing the infamous Pinhead from Clive Barker's Hellraiser, there was talk of a movie crossing over the staple franchises in an absolutely batsh*t manner, incorporating the two big bads into a world where they'd fight it out respectably via their demonic powers.
David Parker explained the pitch in detail in Fangoria: "So, the story takes place when people try to destroy the Myers house and they find the box hidden between the walls. Of course, they open it and Pinhead shows up, and it's Halloween and it's the Myers house, so Michael shows up because there are people there and Pinhead recognizes that Michael is Samhain because he can feel it—which begins this whole battle in the real world. And of course, the third act takes them all to hell."
It's strange that this one never made it to light in a world of crossovers and horror monster showdowns, especially considering the attention paid to linking Pinhead into the Halloween lore, but there's time yet.
15. Halloween VII: Two Faces Of Evil
Alongside one mysterious script treatment by Daniel Farrands titled Michael Myers: Lord of the Dead, a version of Halloween 7 that never saw the cold hard daylight, there was a Robert Zappia pitch by the name of Two Faces of Evil.
Working as a sequel to Halloween 6, this movie would see Michael dead in prison, then taken to the morgue. It's there that he miraculously comes back to life somehow, escapes, and starts working through the local boarding school to teach the students a lesson or two about his big horrible knife.
Another relative would've been introduced, as well as a copycat killer that turned the script into a Silence of the Lambs rip off. Unfortunately the whole thing was canned with rewrites, changing first to the title of 'Blood Ties' with Laurie Strode added in - and then dropped altogether. The opening scene was the only part that remained from Zappia's original ideas.
14. Halloween H20 Concepts
The main change that took us away from the original concept of H20 is that Kevin Williamson originally wrote in Michael getting killed with a helicopter propellor. Why they axed that will forever remain a mystery, but there we go.
As for other versions of the 7th Halloween movie, there was one that was written with the title of 'The Revenge of Laurie Strode', complete with far more deaths and a subplot that involved the police force of Haddonfield working on tracking down Myers. Again, the ending was toyed with to varying degrees of success, with this iteration having Michael killed in a pool with a javelin - not quite sure the link between the two, but we'll go with it - after begging for his life.
Whilst satisfyingly gruesome, hearing Myers not only talk, but beg, would've been a bit of a mood killer.