Every Halloween Series Timeline Ranked From Worst To Best

Michael Myers: Curse of Continuity Confusion.

Michael Myers Halloween
Aquarius Releasing

There can be few film franchises with a more torturous timeline than Halloween. Or should that be timelines?

The latest in the series - released this month in time for its eponymous holiday on the fortieth anniversary of the night Michael Myers first came home - is the eleventh in the franchise, kicking off the series' fifth new timeline, and confusingly is the third of those simply to be titled Halloween.

But which of these multiple continuities is worth your own time? If you're only just coming to the series fresh and don't know your Jamie Lloyd from your John Tate or your Shatner mask from your Silver Shamrock mask, what should be your Halloween viewing order of choice?

Let's take a trip back to Haddonfield and find out. Going through the pros and cons of every one of the different mini-franchises that exist under the Halloween name, we'll see whether it's better to be enjoying the Season Of The Witch or suffering the Curse Of Michael Myers.

6. The Reboot Series

Halloween 2007
Dimension

Which Movies? Halloween (2007) and Halloween II (2009)

Why would you bother with this one? The only timeline to replace the original 1978 classic with an unsubtle reimagining that replaces tension with graphic violence, it's only really for audiences raised on torture porn gore with no patience for 1970s slow burn pacing.

To be fair to director Rob Zombie, he's obviously a fan of classic horror in general and the original Halloween series in particular and this is, for him, a labour of love. The White Zombie frontman has always been a better horror enthusiast, though, than he has been a horror filmmaker.

Halloween has always been at its best when not trying to over-explain Michael Myers, a creature of pure evil instinct and an almost literal boogeyman. Zombie's films take the opposite tack, far more interested in Myers' psychology and his familial connection to sister-cum-perennial-victim Laurie than any film before.

To its credit, Zombie's first Halloween, awkwardly half-prequel, half-remake, handles giving Myers more backstory and personality relatively reasonably. The prequel half, in which Malcolm McDowell (no Donald Pleasance, but a decent choice for a psychiatrist with an obsessive streak barely more sane than his patients) attempts to treat and connect with Michael, works well enough. The second half, a lightweight retread of the original completely disinterested in making us engage with any of the victims, is much worse.

Zombie's Halloween II, meanwhile, is completely disposable, doubling down on the Michael-Laurie family stuff to suggest that she might be prone to the same streak of madness (hardly an original direction to go, as we'll see). It's not worth your time and, to be honest, neither is the reboot timeline as a whole.


5. The Curse Series

halloween curse of michael myers.jpg
Dimension Films

Which Movies? Halloween (1978), Halloween II (1981), Halloween 4: The Return Of Michael Myers, Halloween 5: The Revenge Of Michael Myers, Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers

For many old school Halloween fans, this is the definitive series (and it's certainly the Halloween timeline that went on the longest). That does also mean that it inevitably suffers in the way that any other long-running horror series does: it starts strong, becomes formulaic, and ends terribly.

The switch from Roman to Arabic numerals for the fourth instalment marks the point at which series creators John Carpenter and Debra Hill tapped out, along with lead actress Jamie Lee Curtis. So, in some ways, The Return Of Michael Myers represents a soft reboot to the series, a sequel with none of the original participants, all of whom felt that they'd taken Halloween as far as they wanted.

As a result, the later films wrote an offscreen death for Curtis' Laurie in a car accident and centred the story instead on her young daughter Jamie. Danielle Harris does a decent job as the new child protagonist, never entirely clear whether Jamie is a victim of Michael, his potential anchor to become more human, or is about to take after him and become a psychotic killer herself.

Nevertheless, Halloween 4 and 5 are never anything more than generic, workmanlike slasher flicks with their extra flourishes (Jamie develops a psychic connection with her murderous uncle) only serving to make them sillier rather than more interesting.

Things take a sharp turn for the worse in the final part, The Curse Of Michael Myers, which eliminates Jamie and switches attention to a pre-fame Paul Rudd as Tommy Doyle (the kid Laurie babysat in the first movie) and attempts to retcon the whole series as a story of druidic black magic. It doesn't work.


4. The Resurrection Series

Halloween: Resurrection Jamie Lee Curtis
Dimension Films

Which Movies? Halloween (1978), Halloween II (1981), Halloween H20: Twenty Years Later, Halloween: Resurrection

Two decades before the new forty year reunion, H20 brought Curtis back as Laurie Strode for the first reboot of the Michael Myers timeline. Originally planned as "Halloween 7: The Revenge Of Laurie Strode", the seventh film instead decided to capitalise on Curtis' return by ditching most of what had come before and bring the focus back to Laurie instead.

Since The Curse Of Michael Myers, Scream had been released and revitalised flagging interest in the slasher genre with its postmodern take. H20 emerged from a pitch from Scream writer Kevin Williamson and, while he doesn't have a credit on the final screenplay, his rewrites as script doctor give this reboot some of the same knowing tone as his earlier hit.

Halloween, Halloween II, and H20 make for a fairly satisfying Halloween trilogy which seems quite neatly wrapped up at the end. Laurie survives her first confrontation with Michael, he comes back after her specifically, revealing that they are brother and sister, then twenty years later Michael tracks her and her son down again and she finally kills him.

If you were to choose just to watch those three then you can probably bump this entry up one place on the list. But this reboot timeline doesn't, unfortunately, end there. Producers Dimension couldn't just leave it alone, which meant that four years later Michael came back from his decapitation with Halloween: Resurrection.

Resurrection is perhaps the worst movie in any of the various Halloween series. It clumsily retcons Michael's death and then has him bump off Laurie almost immediately to instead go after some complete non-entity victims and only gets worse from there. Even more than the Curse series, this mini-series suffers immensely from the quality of its final instalment.


3. The Anthology Series

Halloween 3 - TV
Universal Pictures

Which Movies? Halloween (1978), Halloween II (1981) and Halloween III: Season Of The Witch

It was never supposed to all be about Michael Myers. Once Carpenter and Hill had a hit on their hands and were asked to spin it into a franchise, their plan was to turn Halloween into an anthology series in which each new movie was a completely new story only linked by how they all took place on Halloween night.

Ultimately, however, the relatively muted box office and critical response to the third movie, often from people who were expecting more Michael Myers after having spent two previous episodes following "The Shape" on his killing sprees, put paid to any future Halloween films with any non-Michael focus.

This is a shame because, even though the one separate anthology installment that did get made (1982's Season Of The Witch) is more of a mixed bag than a total success, it would undoubtedly have kept the series interesting going forward, avoiding the repetitive storytelling that we were given from The Return Of Michael Myers onwards.

Adapted from a story pitch by British sci-fi horror icon Nigel Kneale (the man behind Quatermass and The Stone Tape), Season Of The Witch was produced by Carpenter and Hill and directed by Tommy Lee Wallace, who had worked on the design and editing of the original film. Although Kneale disavowed the project, its story of cursed jack o' lantern masks, television hypnosis and microchips that harness the power of Stonehenge is straight out of his playbook of sci-fi explanations for horror tropes. The story's a mess, but an interesting one.

You don't have to watch Halloween II for this viewing order to work (just the first one and Season Of The Witch would give you the anthology feel), but I, II and III are the films made by the original production team so still feel in some ways like a coherent whole when taken together.

More of a missed opportunity, then, than genuine brilliance, but this Halloween series is still worth watching.


2. The Reflective Series

Halloween Jamie Lee Curtis
Universal Pictures

Which Movies? Halloween (1978) and Halloween (2018)

This brings us to today and the latest attempt to reboot the Halloween timeline.

David Gordon Green and Danny McBride, the talents behind mediocre medieval stoner comedy Your Highness, weren't exactly the obvious choice to direct a reflective reboot of Halloween that ignored every different sequel permutation to make a movie that considers in a new light Michael, Laurie and Haddonfield and all that might have happened in the forty intervening years.

This was, however, the first Halloween movie in decades to have Carpenter's creative involvement, not just as producer but also as a "creative consultant" as well as composing a new variant on his classic score. And, indeed, with Carpenter on board, Green and McBride have made a Halloween film that really feels like a true successor of the original.

Initially pitched, like H20, as a story that would ignore the Jamie Lloyd-era (and H20 itself) but pick up from Halloween II, the 2018 Halloween ultimately did well to go one further and also ignore the revelations of the second part (specifically the idea of the Michael and Laurie sibling relationship that provided so much fuel for the earlier sequels and reboots, but doesn't make much sense in the context of the original movie).

Halloween 2018 is not perfect, its horror is often more efficient than tense or shocking, but it does return its series and its killer to their simpler, clearer roots, while giving Curtis' Laurie - now around 60 and having lived her whole life in the shadow of the events of the original movie - her most interesting characterisation and storyline of any film in the series.

Taken together Halloween 1978 and Halloween 2018 make an appealing pair of companion pieces, the latter reflecting effectively on the former. Now, let's just hope that they don't screw it up Resurrection-style with another sequel.


1. The Classic

Halloween Michael Myers
Compass International Pictures

Which Movies? Just Halloween (1978)

The best Halloween series timeline and continuity, however, may just be the simplest: a viewing order of only one movie.

When they sat down to write their "Babysitter Murders" script, Carpenter and Hill didn't have their eyes on a franchise at all, whether of Halloween-based anthology stories or further stories of Michael Myers. They just wanted to write the best, boldest, scariest standalone babysitter murdering movie that they could.

There was no sequel-bait, no seeding of plot elements to be picked up in a future part (which is why Halloween II's sibling revelation comes out of nowhere), it was just a single exercise in ramping up the tension toward its conclusion. In that sense, it can be considered its own timeline separate from any of those established by the rival sequels.

The original Halloween, as much a stalker film as a slasher, takes its time establishing atmosphere and character. It's a masterpiece of the slow-build and then release of tension, a model of great horror filmmaking.

Since then there's been good Halloweens, bad Halloweens and utterly forgettable Halloweens, but none of the ten later movies have come close to being utterly genius Halloweens like the first. Each of the sequel sequences has their pros and cons, but to be honest after watching the original, any of the follow-ups are going to feel a little disappointing.

That's why this October 31st you should maybe consider making your Halloween movie marathon just 101 minutes long.


In this post: 
Halloween
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Loves ghost stories, mysteries and giant ape movies