Every Marvel Comic Book Movie Ranked From Worst To Best
Earth's mightiest defenders. And some really quite bad ones.
Although it was DC who struck the first blow for comic book movies with 1978's Superman and Tim Burton's Batman in 1989 (it's still astonishing that took more than a decade to happen), it wasn't until Marvel got their house in order (albeit with several rights-sharing partners) at the turn of the millennium that funny book films really became a genre.
Whether DC fans care to acknowledge it or not, Marvel Studios are the current top dogs in the genre that Sony, Fox and New Line Cinema helped make or them. They're masters of spectacle and ceremony, diversifying a lot more than their critics give them credit for and justifiably dominating the box office come blockbuster season.
Throughout the years, the rights to Marvel's biggest and best heroes have been shared across multiple studios with lots of different ideas and contradictory voices, so it's not surprising that the results have been a mess of different tones fuelled by wildly contrasting agendas. Or that there was lots of variation in quality before Kevin Feige unveiled his grand-plan for cinematic domination for the brand Stan Lee built.
And even as suggestions of over-saturation sneak in, Marvel (and their partners) continue to explore brave new worlds, hiring the world's best talent to make crowd-pleasing costumed movies at an unprecedented frequency. Looking back at some of their more infamous and more flat-out terrible projects, it's amazing we ever got here.
But which Marvel movie deserves to be crowned the greatest? And which would they prefer we all forgot? After all, it hasn't all been a bump-free road to money town...
50. Captain America (1990)
The First Avenger didn't have the best modern day announcement on the silver screen. Instead he was lumped into a Yugoslavian produced plotless atrocity that limped out of development hell and straight-to-TV, minus the hilarious sounding stolen Statue Of Liberty sub-plot it originally boasted.
It shouldn't really come as any surprise that it is the worst ever Marvel movie release: it's shoddily made, badly written and poorly cast, leaving Cap without any charisma, and it was made by exploitation film-maker Menahem Golan, which was just asking for trouble. He duly obliged by making Red Skull an Italian gangster...
Saying all that, the film did beat The Winter Soldier to the plot idea that an enemy super soldier could be used to remove political opponents like Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., President John F. Kennedy, and Robert Kennedy in the 1960s. So the MCU does owe it.
49. Howard The Duck
And the winner for Creepiest Sex Scene in a comic book movie goes to...
Marvel started their foray into big screen film-making with a Duck that was also a turkey long before that monstrosity was a Christmas staple in some homes. Quite why anyone thought Howard The Duck deserved more of a chance to shine on the silver screen than the comic book prime time players remains to be seen, but the 80s were a difficult time for a lot of people and George Lucas was the man behind the project.
Had it been an animated movie as originally intended, it might not have been so bad, but even that probably wouldn't have solved the problems with the tone and the script. And while there is some pleasure to be had in this as a terrible curio, nostalgia has added precisely no room for appreciation here.
The best you can say about the Duck these days is that his appearance as an Easter Egg at the end of the first Guardians Of The Galaxy is basically the biggest indication that Marvel can now do absolutely no wrong.
48. Nick Fury: Agent Of SHIELD
Strictly speaking, the David Hasselhoff-starring first attempt to bring Nick Fury to screens was actually a pilot movie for a TV show that inevitably didn't get made. But you really have to feel for the former champion of sucking his tummy in on Baywatch: he tried to do a superhero movie before it was cool, starring as a bad-ass character before he was cool, and now he's all but been wiped out of the history books.
Or you could, until you actually watch Nick Fury, which is the weird, bastard sibling of mainline Marvel movies that is justifiably kept locked away in a cupboard. Incredibly, this was written by David S Goyer (though on reflection, he's far from a sure-thing in this genre), and though it sort of looks the part, it's horrible when you get into its substance. It's cliched and fatally dull, and it's no wonder Hasselhoff appears to be so bitter about the whole thing.
47. Captain America (1944)
Just as some will say it's unfair to judge a made-for-TV movie/pilot in the same breath as the MCU, there's some argument that you shouldn't consider the early serials that saw Captain America (and Marvel's) debut on the big screen in the same terms. But all cruelty aside, it's not like 1944 was a bad year for films, so it's still fair game.
The biggest problem with the serials - aside from the use of a villainous MacGuffin hilariously (and childishly) called the "Dynamic Vibrator" - is the fact that it has such ridiculous disregard for the comics. Captain America is reimagined as a crime fighting District Attorney called Grant Gardner and played by the very much not super-soldier-bodied Dick Purcell.
Inevitably, Marvel comics were unhappy with the liberties taken, which goes some way to explaining why this is basically any crime noir serial that just so happens to have a guy wearing Cap cosplay in it.
46. Man -Thing
Given how terrible it is, it's pretty charitable of all Marvel fans to have forgotten that there was a Man-Thing movie released right at the height of Marvel's first successful movie period. In 2005, we already had two X-Men and Spider-Man movies and each of their sequels proved it wasn't hard to make astonishing comic book movies, so the fact that this mess landed then is just baffling.
The film was helmed by The Lawnmower Man's Brett Leonard, who was commended for his computer animation work on that horror so much that he clearly never thought to update it 13 years later. He then suffered the ignominy of his feature not getting a US theatrical release at all, which is the best thing for everyone given how badly it fudged the character and how awful the whole thing looks.
45. Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer

When the not-very-good Fantastic Four made an unfeasible amount of money at the box office, it was inevitable a sequel would follow, and Fox were so buoyed by that success that they sought to go bigger and bolder. And how much bigger could you go then introducing Galactus, the eater of worlds?
The studio, rather unfortunately, also combined that good idea with a director who just wasn't up to the project, in Tim Story, who singularly failed to stamp any style or authority on the sequel. Not that he had a good script to work from in the first place or a good cast (okay, Chris Evans was there but even he wasn't the same actor who would later play Cap) to try and save it.
Apparently, nobody working on the sequel got the memo that there are absolutely no circumstances in which having superheroes dance is a good idea. Perhaps they were all too busy congratulating themselves on turning one of the most striking looking villains in comic book history into a bloody great cloud...?
44. Ghost Rider
Who could ever have guessed that a film starring Nic Cage as a flame-headed instrument of the devil riding a motorbike wouldn't work? Even more shocking, though, is the revelation that the film is actually boring.
That's right, a film starring Nic Cage with a skull head that is literally on fire is as dull as dishwater.
Despite failing with Daredevil, director Mark Steven Johnson was handed the opportunity to ruin another beloved Marvel property by sucking out all of the fun and watering everything down for a PG-13 rating the studio presumably thought would help them sell more toys.
For his part, Nic Cage is fine... Well, he's just Nic Cage. But he's hampered by a guinea pig-like hairpiece and a script so bad that everyone seems to have tried to over-compensate by going full ham.
43. Punisher (1989)
Perhaps because of the presence of moody Euro-trash Dolph Lundgren in the title role, the first attempt to make a Punisher movie has something of a cult following, but that ignores the fact that in every single typical metric, it's a very bad film.
Putting aside the fact that it's nowhere near an adaptation of the comic (even the curious decision to paint stubble on Lundgren's face didn't make him look right), it's nothing more than a cliched, bloody action movie. Director Mark Goldblatt has some seriously impressive credits as an editor, but it seems the step up to editing just wasn't for him.
Were it to come out today (minus the lead star), it might have done better, but there's no escaping the script issues or the general lack of substance between the punchy bits.
42. The Fantastic Four (2015)
Considering it was supposed to be the confidence building reboot of the Fantastic Four franchise that would wipe out the bitter aftertaste of the two cartoonish messes that came before it, Josh Trank's take on the Fantastic Four probably couldn't have gone worse.
It's not quite the unadulterated disaster many will lead you to believe, but there are very few positives to take from it beyond the charisma and chemistry of the central cast. If the rumours of a sequel are to be believed, let's hope they get a better script, a better director and a better sense of what these movies should be. Or, you know, just hand the rights back to Marvel and have done with it.
The biggest problem is the film's lack of imagination or real creative thrust: it's a reboot without a better idea, and that's absolutely criminal.