Every MCU Villain Plot Ranked From Worst To Best
They can't all be Thanos hunting down the infinity stones.
There is a lot that goes into making a compelling villain. While a great portrayal from a strong actor is a must, this can only take an antagonist so far. An interesting backstory, a strong motivation and reason for doing what they're doing is vital, and they must give the audience a reason to care.
If we can't feel something for an antagonist, whether it is empathy, fear, or both, or if said bad guy doesn't pose a real threat to the hero, what is the point of investing in the story?
The plot surrounding any villain is vital, and the MCU is no different. There have been some great portrayals of villains throughout the franchise's ten plus years that have been let down by a poor plot. On the other hand, there have been some strong plots and stories that have made up for less than brilliant performances.
While phase three saw a rapid increase in the quality of villains facing Earth's Mightiest Heroes, that doesn't necessarily mean that there is a similar correlation with the story telling element. Not all villain plots are created equal, and some are simply far better than others.
23. Plunging The Universe Into Darkness - Malekith (Thor: The Dark World)
The Dark World is strongly considered to be the worst movie in the history of the MCU’s ten plus years, and with that also comes the title of worst villain. It’s not even close really.
Christopher Ecclestone’s acting talents were wasted behind a mask of make-up, lack of any emotion whatsoever, and frankly boring dialogue. The movie missed on every level with its antagonist, including the story.
The leader of the Dark Elves wanted to defeat Thor and plunge the Nine Realms into darkness because of reasons. It was a forgettable motive without any logic or any reason to feel empathy towards him. He wanted to wage war for the sake of waging war, and it couldn’t have been more boring.
Somehow, Marvel Studios managed to take one of the six infinity stones and put it in the centre of a story line that nobody cared about. Though there are some poor villains throughout the franchise, none come even close to Malekith in terms of lack of excitement or intrigue.
22. The Total Destruction Of His Enemies - Ronan (Guardians Of The Galaxy)
The MCU's second team were introduced in phase two, and gave us more information about Thanos and the infinity stones than ever before. While The Mad Titan was ultimately behind the plot to take the power stone, it was Ronan that acted upon it.
As a Kree radical, Ronan hated Xandar and the planet's entire culture. In exchange for delivering the Orb to Thanos, the Accuser was promised the destruction of his enemies. It was only half way through that the Kree realised with the Orb in his possession, he would have no further need of Thanos.
There was little more to the villain than a largely unexplained xenophobic feeling towards Xandar, however he did provide Drax's motive for teaming up with Quill and company. The villain murdered the Destroyer's family, forcing him to join the Guardians in an effort to see justice done.
Ronan's weakness was retrospectively shown at the beginning of Infinity War, when Thanos obtained the Orb off screen, with seemingly little trouble. There really was no need for the Accuser to be sent after the Guardians at all.
21. Selling The Yellowjacket Suit And Proving Hank Pym Wrong - Darren Cross (Ant-Man)
Ant-Man is the first of a few movies on this list that revolve around money. A lot of the Marvel Cinematic Universe's heroes either have a lot of money, or have friends with lots of money. In the case of Scott Lang, his friend was Hank Pym.
This is also the first on this list where one of the villain's main motivations is jealousy. Darren Cross, former associate of Pym, became wildly jealous of Scott's relationship with his former mentor, and the fact that he never got let into the world of Ant-Man.
Cross eventually figured out a way to recreate the Pym Particles that made the Ant-Man suit shrink, and developed them into the Yellowjacket suit. The threat here came with the fact that Cross was willing to sell his suits to the highest bidder, including terrorist organisations like HYDRA and The Ten Rings.
A lot of this was for the money, but a lot was also to rub it in Hank Pym's face that he could be a success without him. He would have done anything to prove it, regardless of the amount of killing machines he would have created, and deaths that ultimately would have come from his business deal.
20. Getting Rich (And Back At Tony Stark) - Aldrich Killian (Iron Man 3)
In what is easily the most divisive plot in all of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Iron Man 3 took the Mandarin, one of the most iconic villains of Iron Man's past, and reduced him to a joke. It was brave of Marvel Studios to attempt something so different, though it is easy to see why many were unhappy.
Every time one of Killian's Extremis experiments went wrong, he would pass it off as a terrorist attack orchestrated by the 'fictional' Mandarin. It was something of an insult to a great character from the comics, but actually quite a genius cover up by the real villain.
If only the rest of the plot could have been that smart. Killian's ultimate goal was to the kill the President and replace him with a loyal pawn, allowing him to control supply and demand on both sides of the war on terror with his Extremis soldiers. So ultimately, Killian Aldrich's plan came down to a blind want for money and power.
What began as a plot revolving around a personal grudge against Tony Stark, and a resentment toward the world thanks to his disability, ended up as something actually quite generic, and could have been far better. Maybe Marvel Studios would have been better going with the real Mandarin after all.
19. Handing Over Power To Dormammu - Kaecilius (Doctor Strange)
In 2016, Doctor Strange included one of the character's classic villains, though in this iteration Mordo didn't turn heel until after the end credits. Instead, the movie's antagonist for the most part was Kaecilius, a character even the die hard comics fans had trouble remembering.
Though Marvel Studios managed to secure the brilliant Mads Mikkelsen for the role, the Hannibal actor's talents were wasted on a character that saw minimal development throughout the movie. Everything he did was out of a blind devotion to Dormammu, the ruler of the Dark Dimension. This was really as shallow as the plot went in terms of Kaecilius.
Dormammu himself appeared once Mikkelsen's character had been defeated, but with just the ambition to take the Earth to his home, seemingly for the sake of it. Doctor Strange was ultimately able to utilise the time stone in a creative and different final battle, but Dormammu wasn't truly defeated.
He promised to leave Earth alone in exchange for being released from Strange's infinite time loop, but are we supposed to accept that the giant, powerful cosmic being wouldn't regroup and launch another attack on the planet or another world at some point? It seems strange to call it a victory when Dormammu is still out there potentially terrorising worlds all over the galaxy.
18. Purging The Earth Of Mankind - Ultron (Age Of Ultron)
So much of Tony Stark's past has come back to haunt him throughout the MCU. Whether it was what his company did years ago, what his father did before he was even born, or a misguided attempt at putting a suit of armour around the world.
While Ultron's origin was quite unique, the end game of his plan was quite generic. Essentially world domination for world domination's sake, he wanted to end the world and rebuild it again in his own image. The majority of the robot's plan actually went to count for nothing.
He recruited Wanda and Pietro, only for them to ultimately fall on the side of the Avengers, and he spent much of the movie shifting pieces into place to build his new body. The vibranium from Wakanda and the stone from Loki's sceptre all went into this body, only for it to be hijacked by the Avengers and turned into Vision, the being that ultimately delivered the final blow.
For an artificially intelligent robot that could occupy thousands of bodies at once, Ultron failed at putting together a strong plan. Throughout the movie, on multiple occasions the villain changed the scope of his plan, from destroying the Avengers to destroying Earth's entire population before settling on the idea of manufacturing a meteor out of Sokovia.
Surely he could have come up with something better than lifting a country into the sky and dropping it again with the resources he had?
17. Revenge - Zemo (Captain America: Civil War)
The third installment in the Captain America trilogy is an excellent movie, helped by Zemo, a great villain. Daniel Brühl portrays the broken hearted Sokovian, whose grudge against the Avengers came after the death of his family during the events of Age of Ultron. This is an example of how a great character has been let down by a poor plot.
The performance of the villain is captivating, and the motive is both strong and intelligent, but Zemo's actual plan is simply ridiculous. After stealing the book with Bucky's trigger words (that he knew exactly where to find), Zemo steals Barnes' face to frame him for blowing up the UN. He then breaks into the CIA himself to activate Barnes and get information on the night of Howard and Maria Stark's death.
Zemo then travels to Siberia to obtain footage of the murder of Tony's parents, and shows it to Cap and Tony who happen to have followed him. He may have known that Steve and Tony would have come to blows over the truth of the Starks' death, but he had no way of knowing that Iron Man would also follow him to Siberia. It is an incredibly intricate plan with far too many variables to ever be considered a good one, yet somehow, against all odds, it still managed to work.
Then there is the question of the secondary villain, and why Brock Rumlow was even in Lagos in the first place. He was there to steal a biological weapon, sure, but what actually was it? Who was his buyer? These are questions that we will likely never get real answers to.
16. Capturing The Hulk - General Ross (The Incredible Hulk)
The black sheep of the MCU family was largely ignored by the wider MCU aside from Bruce Banner, until Thaddeus Ross reappeared eight years later in Civil War. The then General Ross acted as one of the antagonists in The Incredible Hulk, with a borderline unhealthy obsession with catching Banner.
For this, you really can't blame Ross, after Banner hulked out and nearly killed his daughter. Since Bruce was such a threat, and technically on the run from the law, Ross was only doing his job in trying to apprehend him. It was when he played god with Emil Blonsky that he crossed the line.
With the Abomination, Ross became part of the problem, creating another version the very thing he was trying to destroy. One the one hand, this plot offered a father that would do anything to protect his daughter, but it also reduced the ultimate villain, Blonsky, to a carbon copy of the hero. Something that happens far too often in the MCU.
Seemingly General Ross wasn't punished for his experiments on Blonsky, rising up to the rank of Secretary of State in the coming years, which just raises further questions.
15. Revenge Against The Starks - Ivan Vanko (Iron Man 2)
After the incredible success of Iron Man, the sequel two years later couldn't live up to the expectation set. In terms of villains, the movie was a mixed bag, with Mickey Rourke's Ivan Vanko juxtaposed against Sam Rockwell's brilliant Justin Hammer.
Many of the MCU's villains, and of Tony Stark in particular, either have some connection to the hero through family, stretching back to the past, or end up battling against them with the same technology. Ivan Vanko falls under all three. Resentful of the Stark family ever since Howard had his father deported after they worked together on the arc reactor, Ivan built his own and came back to haunt Tony as Whiplash.
Hammer on the other hand, is simply jealous of Tony, and willing to do anything to get Hammer Industries ahead of Stark. The two teamed up to take down Iron Man, but were simply no match.
Before the end of the movie, Vanko takes to a bigger version of the Iron Man suit in a similar fashion to Stane from the first movie. There was potential in this villainous story line, but in the end it came off as generic, too similar to the first Iron Man movie, and even a little bit boring.
14. Taking Over Stark Industries - Obadiah Stane (Iron Man)
The first ever Marvel Cinematic Universe movie is still to this day one of its finest, as it introduced the titular hero, and teased the huge shared universe that would be coming over the next decade. Iron Man also introduced the first ever villain of the franchise, Obadiah Stane.
Kicking off the MCU's long list of father figures/mentors that turn evil, Stane betrayed Tony, his business partner and best friend's son, for money. Even before Stark became Iron Man, before he even thought about designing the suit and getting the business out of weapons manufacture, Stane planned on killing him.
Eventually, the arc reactor and the Iron Man suit itself became the focus of Stane's plan, but the man known in the comics as Ironmonger hired the Ten Rings to kill Stark far earlier than that. The shock and emotional value of Stane's villainous change was big, but the fact that it was just for money is slightly shallow.
With regards to the Ten Rings, though the organisation ultimately played a relatively minor role in the movie, this laid the groundwork for further appearances in the franchise, including of course, the upcoming Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings.