Every Modern Disney Live Action Remake (So Far) Ranked
The good, the bad, and the unnecessary.
Disney isn't going to slow down with its live action (and, with the release of The Lion King, photorealistic) remakes, with a handful on the way and certainly more unannounced to come later.
It's becoming very quickly apparent, however, that many of these features need to perform double duty to compare to their animated predecessors, and while some have worked as fairly faithful remakes to their original source material, others have turned out to be boring retreads of better works. Those that do differently than the original vary from inspired genius to hit and miss time wasters with extremely high budgets.
While it could be argued that remakes are unnecessary if the source material is great, some of these films do surprisingly well to justify their remake status.
Here's a list of all of Disney's modern live action and CG remakes, not including sequels (such as Alice: Through the Looking Glass). Not included on this list are films made before the 2010s (such as 101 Dalmatians).
10. Alice In Wonderland (2010)
Between this and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, audiences get to see Tim Burton at his worst, his visuals becoming inexplicably soulless and losing their charm to what seems more like a 3D cashgrab flaunting the Disney logo like branded clothing - the quality isn't much better than other works in the same field, but they have enough money to make themselves look appealing.
Alice In Wonderland was the opposite of charming, a little menacing (but not enough to be interesting), and with another pale Johnny Depp character that didn't do much beyond act weird and prove to anyone still doubting that this was a Burton film. The visuals, while the film's highlight, are dreary, and the characters are not very likeable, even if Mia Wasikowska does a fine enough job as an Alice who isn't particularly well-written.
The most fun one can get from this film come from Helena Bonham-Carter as the big headed villain, Crispin Glover's Knave of Hearts being entertainingly nasty, and the Hathaway's White Queen being just plain hilarious. And, being a Disney joint, the visuals still hold up after 9 years.
9. The Lion King (2019)
A lot of the hype surrounding this film focused on how real its CGI lions looked, but to have a far superior 2D film and Broadway Musical - both of which are juggernauts in their own fields - to compare to, it felt unnecessary in comparison. On its own, the Lion King films have nothing new to offer beyond its visuals.
Overall, the film is visually stunning and fun, with a star-studded cast that performed their voices well. It just couldn't find more charm than what it copied shot for shot from its predecessor, however, so judging it on its own merit would ignore how it does nothing different from the original, but adds just enough to pad time to make the difference between a 2D animated film and a "live action" (photorealistic) blockbuster.
It's... fine. The visuals are high quality, and indeed a masterclass in CGI realism. It unfortunately not only has to contend with comparisons to the original and the Broadway run, however; it also has to compare to Favreau's other CGI animal film - The Jungle Book - whose photorealistic animals still emoted better.
8. Dumbo (2019)
One of the more "different" adaptations of classic stories not quite following the original script, Dumbo was in some ways enjoyable, but in many ways still missed the mark when it came to putting together a solid movie.
The story is mainly framed around the human characters rather than Dumbo himself, and while the cast is star-studded, the CGI elephant remains the movie's emotional core, making a lot of the added plot feel just a little superfluous. The performances of the characters themselves ranged from okay to great.
What this film did well, however, was push the emotion that the original Dumbo film pushed, with a baby animal missing his mother making for heartbreakingly sweet moments, and Dumbo's relationship with his human caretakers does a lot right.
Another Tim Burton live action CGI Disney joint, this one is at least lot more charming than its Wonderland predecessor, and enjoyable enough to be worth the viewing.
7. Maleficent (2014)
Maleficent is a mixed bag, but ranks just a little higher for being both memorable and so different that it's difficult to call it a remake so much as a spinoff. Angelina Jolie does a fantastic job in her role as a much more sympathetic and fun character, with her relationship with the film's Sleeping Beauty a charming highlight.
Far from the most solid film in the Disney remake lineup, with some elements that don't feel completely fleshed out, Maleficent is carried on the fantasy concepts that work, and the character that is compelling as both a protagonist and a complex villain-slash-anti-hero. The relationships in this film are surprisingly mature, with dark elements of violence and betrayal that seem to skirt past its low PG rating.
As with all Disney remakes, the visuals are stunning, and the costume design and VFX behind Maleficent herself are brilliant to watch. Though a lot of it doesn't work as well as it should, it's still a memorable and unique and fun film, with a great emotional centre that deserves praise.
Not to mention how perfect Angelina Jolie is in this role.
6. Christopher Robin (2018)
Another one of the more different adaptations that feel more like a spinoff than any sort of "remake", Christopher Robin has a lot of heart and a great lesson about retaining childhood wonder that really resonate in darker times.
Winnie The Pooh (along with the rest of the residents of the Hundred Acre Woods) is endlessly charming, with Jim Cummings keeping the magic alive and the CG providing a sweet real-world interpretation that hearken back to the original Milne art. Ewan McGregor plays a fine Christopher Robin, just world-weary enough but also just hopeful enough to pull off the character.
It might have ranked higher if it wasn't for the plot running just a bit longer than it felt like it should have, and the fact that the toys turn out to be real to everyone rather than it being more ambiguous just feels a bit... unusual, even if not an outright bad choice.
It's a heartening film that's largely well-made, and even if it's far from the best Disney's remakes-slash-spinoffs have to offer, it's certainly worth the watch.
5. Beauty And The Beast (2017)
Beauty and The Beast counts among Disney's more exact retreads of old source material, rather than remakes that do anything different. The most notable changes made to this film were, in fact, largely negative, such as the dress (which didn't actually need updating). Not that the film changed much.
The film brings nothing truly new to the table, but the way it adapts 2D to live action is vibrant and well done, with the songs just as enjoyable and the performances just as compelling and fun.
The cast does a fine job, with some highlights being Josh Gad as the over the top LeFou, and Emma Watson and Dan Stevens having great chemistry.
The only downside is that this film has nothing else to offer, and compared to the original, nothing is much better - the music, is in fact, overall just not as good.
It's a fun experience, and vibrant visually, and the performances are solid, but it does absolutely nothing else with the source material. And while it works, there are other films that just work better.
4. Aladdin (2019)
While Beauty And The Beast was a relatively more solid movie, Aladdin does a lot more with its source material that deserves praise as an adaptation.
While the main story remains intact, details are tweaked in a way that works in favour of the cast, who perform very different versions of their characters from the original film (apart from Aladdin, who's mostly the same character).
Will Smith in particular is a vast departure from the late great Robin Williams's Genie, but he adds his own unique spin to it that feels appropriately respectful rather than making any attempt to copy what Williams did perfectly.
The energy in this film is what really carries it, however. The songs and dance numbers are fantastically dynamic and well-choreographed, performed well in a style just different enough from the original without sacrificing quality.
While not all of the changes worked (with the added Jasmine song feeling out of place in amongst the adapted soundtrack), Aladdin, unlike some of the other Disney remakes, actually did enough different to justify the film being remade. Add to that visually stunning sets and costume designs and VFX, and you have a great musical film worth experiencing.
3. Pete's Dragon (2016)
The original Pete's Dragon is not too well-known to many modern audiences, and appropriately, if sadly, this adaptation of an older Disney property also flew under the radar when it came to brand-faithful Disney audiences.
Pete's Dragon feels very... eighties, in a strange way, with the young boy and his dragon friend feeling wilder and freer than any modern child has been in a while. The design of the dragon Elliott is unique in its cartoonish furriness, but it works for how soft and sentimental and fantastical the film feels, while retaining the very eighties melancholy mixed with wonder of childhood innocence.
There's a remarkable sadness and an equally remarkable hopefulness in this film that feels very different from most of Disney's blockbuster offerings, and it feels like this movie needs to be on an entirely separate list for how far its tone feels from the rest. Still - it's an excellent modern remake that deserves praise, even if it doesn't at all feel like its more mainstream siblings.
2. Cinderella (2015)
Cinderella did a lot of things right, though it has to be stated that it came before Disney live action remakes became a trend that many people in 2019 have become since tired of.
On its own, however, Cinderella is a solid and beautiful fairy tale, one that doesn't copy the original Disney film so much as actually adapt the story and make it into its own - something other films in the lineup have barely done, or failed to do well.
Cinderella's costume design and visuals are vibrant and appealing, with fantastic and charming performances that all worked well within the plot. While it was not a musical, it had enough music in it to give it whimsy, and the music from the original film is adapted into its soundtrack.
The film is a feast for the eyes, with Lily James as a wonderful Cinderella and Cate Blanchett as a wonderfully sinister Lady Tremaine. It's an earlier remake definitely worth revisiting, and one Disney needs to strive towards - different, but still recognisable.
1. The Jungle Book (2016)
With how perfectly Favreau captured the magic of CG animals in The Jungle Book, it's a wonder how Lion King's animal characters didn't have the emotional capacity and presence that this film's did.
The Jungle Book is a remarkable mix of great elements in a Disney adaptation, with a plot close to the original cartoon while adding details that make the story feel much more serious and the stakes feel much higher.
It's action-packed, emotionally charged, visually stunning, and the plot feels more like an adult fantasy prestige series than a Disney children's cartoon. There's very real menace and intriguing motivation from Idris Elba's Shere Khan, and the film takes itself seriously in a way that really works, without losing the whimsy of a child raised by talking animals, or the songs that, while they didn't completely mesh like other musical films, didn't feel entirely out of place, either.
The voice acting is memorable, and the CGI animals emote fantastically well without feeling too cartoonish. The film goes to dark places while retaining its solid emotional core, and it's one of Disney's most solid blockbusters not of their lucrative Marvel universe to date - surprisingly improving upon its original.