Every Sequel To Best Picture Oscar Winners - Ranked
Did any of them live up to the original?
Sequel spawning isn't necessarily an indication that a movie is any good. Even the likes of Ghost Rider and Deuce Bigalow: Male Gigolo went on to ride again, but there are times when follow-ups are made for all of the right reasons.
Some stories are so compelling that the next chapter simply cannot go untold, regardless of whether that leaves the sequel with massive shoes to fill and lofty box office expectations to live up to. Case in point, a number of the Best Picture winners at the Oscars have been followed by sequels, and their fortunes tend to be mixed.
Although most of the movies that have claimed to top prize are standalone offerings, from Ordinary People to Titanic, plenty have served as a starting point for a franchise, and in rare instances, the sequel has even surpassed the original.
At a time when virtually every movie exists within the confines of a blockbuster franchise or a cinematic universe, it's easy to come down with a bad case of sequel snobbery, but at least the Best Picture winners earned their follow-ups on merit.
10. Scarlett
Pitting Scarlet against the other films on this list is a trifle unfair, since Gone With the Wind's belated follow-up is a six-part TV feature and the rest are blockbuster sequels, but the CBS miniseries didn't exactly set the small screen alight.
After the original swept the Academy Awards in 1939, MGM asked Margaret Mitchell, who penned the novel it was based on, to provide a script for a big-budget sequel, only to have their offer declined. It wasn't until more than two decades after the author's death that her estate gave the go-ahead for a continuation of the story.
By this point, MGM was no longer interested in making Gone With the Wind 2, so a sequel didn't arrive until 1994 when Scarlet hit television, with Joanne Whalley and Timothy Dalton stepping into the roles made famous by Vivien Leigh and Clark Gable.
The only thing Scarlet will ever be remembered for is the film it's a sequel to. That, and Dalton's rather striking moustache.
9. The Evening Star
James L Brooks’s comedy-drama Terms Of Endearment was a surprise package at the Oscars in 1983, picking up five gongs from 11 nominations and edging out critics' favourites like The Right Stuff and The Big Chill along the way.
Its sequel The Evening Star didn't arrive until 13 years later, and that was part of the problem. Did anyone really care that Shirley Maclaine and Jack Nicholson were revisiting these roles by the time the follow-up actually happened?
Brooks did not return to helm the sequel, with that honour falling to Steel Magnolia writer Robert Harling, though he failed to get the most out of Larry McMurtry's screenplay and fell flat at every turn in his efforts to recapture former glory.
Evening Star was critically panned and recouped little over half of its $20m budget.
8. The Sting II
Paul Newman and Robert Redford can claimed to have starred in one of the finest caper movies of the 1970s, George Roy Hill's The Sting, the quality of which was reflected in its seven Oscar wins and $159.6m in box office takings.
The fact it spawned a sequel wasn't especially surprising, but the follow-up's cast and crew list was. Few people involved in the award-winning original return for The Sting II, which cast Jackie Gleason and Oliver Reed in the lead roles.
Rather than a sequel, this was a lazy retread of the original that did a poor job of copying it from start to finish. The film holds a 0% score on Rotten Tomatoes, and that pretty much sums up how uncalled for this movie really was.
Despite its many shortcomings, The Sting II did actually earn an Oscar nomination of its own for Lalo Schifrin’s original music, but lost out to Michel Legrand, Alan Bergman and Marilyn Bergman's score for Barbra Streisand's Yentl.
7. The Road Back
Sequel mania is by no means a new trend in Hollywood. It's been churning them out since films were first committed to celluloid, and 1937's The Road Back - the belated follow-up to All Quiet on the Western Front - is an early blockbuster example.
Bride of Frankenstein's James Whale replaced Lewis Milestone on the director's chair and the work of author Erich Maria Remarque once again served as the film's inspiration. The story revisited the Second Company from the original and followed their struggles to return to civilian life in Germany after World War I.
The Road Back should have been Whale's crowing directorial achievement. A powerful, controversial indictment of armed conflict which warned the world about the impending dangers of the Nazi regime in Germany during the late 1930s, but studio meddling left it a shadow of the movie it could have been.
The German government threatened to boycott all of Universal's movies unless the anti-Nazi messages were removed from the film. Recently under new management, the studio bowed to these demands, much to Whale's chagrin.
Even though The Road Back was cut to pieces in the editing suite, the battle scenes remain powerful, shot using a special type of crane that was developed specifically for the movie. Whale's vision shines through on occasions like these. It's just shame Universal was only too happy to suppress it the rest of the time.
6. Hannibal
The Silence Of The Lambs is a dark masterpiece that introduced the world to Anthony Hopkins's eloquent psychopath Hannibal Lector, who instantly established himself as one of the most memorable movie villains of his generation.
The film's sequel Hannibal was years in the making since author Thomas Harris took his sweet time delivering the book it would be based on. It finally arrived in 2006 and was adapted for the big screen by Ridley Scott the following year.
Hannibal exceeded the box office feats of its predecessor but fell short of garnering the same critical acclaim. It's easy to see why this was the case. For all of the movie's visual splendour and unsettling depravity, at times it's just plain dull.
Hopkins is once again outstanding in the lead role, backed by a strong supporting cast headed up by Julianne Moore and Gary Oldman, but it's the flaws carried over from the novel which prevented Hannibal from hitting the heights of its predecessor, namely its pacing issues and a botched final act that plumetted into distaste.
5. They Call Me Mister Tibbs!
Few films reflect US zeitgeist at the time of the Civil Rights movement like In the Heat of the Night, in which the great Sidney Poitier debuted as Detective Virgil Tibbs.
It won five Oscars in 1968, including Best Picture, and Poitier would go on to reprise the lead role in two sequels. First up was They Call Me Mister Tibbs in 1970.
Although Poitier was once again roundly praised for his performance in the follow-up, and the second sequel The Organization, director Norman Jewison did not return to the series, nor did his writing team and the dip in quality was plain to see.
They Call Me Mister Tibbs is a solid, well-acted detective story but it fell far short of the standards set by In the Heat of the Night.
4. The French Connection II
William Friedkin delivered one of the best action-thrillers of the 1970s with The French Connection, a hardboiled cop movie that spawned countless imitators and swept the Academy Awards in 1972, pipping A Clockwork Orange, Fiddler On The Roof and The Last Picture Show to the Best Picture accolade that year.
Friedkin did not return for the sequel three years later, but his replacement John Frankenheimer did manage to convince Gene Hackman to reprise his role as Popeye Doyle, which earned him an Oscar the first time around.
Unlike the first film, which was partly based on a true story, The French Connection II is entirely the work of fiction, following Doyle on a fabricated adventure. The sequel satisfied, though nowhere near on the same level as the original.
It's a cut above the wave of cop thrillers The French Connection paved the way for, but like most movies on this list, it couldn't match the feats of its predecessor.
3. Ziegfeld Girl
Robert Z Leonard's all-singing, all-dancing The Great Ziegfeld was a runaway success when it pranced on the scene in 1936, winning three Oscars, including Best Picture and Best Dance Direction, that year and netting MGM a tidy profit.
Ziegfeld Girl was one of two sequels to follow in the ensuing years and, unlike most items on this list, it did recapture the hokey magic of the original thanks to stellar casting. Jimmy Stewart, Judy Garland and Hedy Lamarr took on the lead roles.
Sure, it's melodramatic at times and cheaply recycled footage from the original, but Ziegfeld Girl should be weighed and measured on its production numbers and they're never less than lavishly entertaining, particularly Garland's renditions of I'm Always Chasing Rainbows and Minnie the Moocher.
2. Rocky II
It's apt that one of the greatest underdog movies of all time pulled off a string of unlikely feats at the 1977 Academy Awards, knocking out such heavyweights as All The Presidents Men and Taxi Driver to claim the Best Picture gong.
If there's one thing Rocky has attracted more of than critical acclaim over the years, it's sequels, starting with Rocky II in 1979. The second instalment did a decent job convincing the audience to root for the underdog once again, even though the original made it clear the outcome of his showdown with Apollo was unimportant.
Although the sequel was more concerned with setting up an epic showdown in the ring than meaningful character development, Rocky II during its best moments is nothing less than raucous entertainment, from its training montage to its final fight.
As was the case with most Rocky sequels, this one was never going to emulate the Oscar feats of the original, but it's a hugely enjoyable popcorn flick nonetheless.
1. The Godfather Part II
The Godfather Part II is an easy pick for the top spot on this list, since it's the only sequel on it that truly lived up to, and in some ways surpassed, the original.
To date, The Godfather is the only movie series to deliver two Best Picture winners, and consistency was the key to its success. Francis Ford Coppola returned to the director's chair for the sequel, much of the main cast was retained along with shrewd additions, and the story was based on unused material from Mario Puzo’s novel.
The follow-up showed no shortage of ambition by attempting to be a prequel and a sequel in one package. Not only did it a achieve that, it connected to its predecessor seamlessly, turning the first two Godfather movies into a cohesive whole.
Nobody needs reminding that The Godfather Part II has always been a frontrunner for the title of greatest sequel ever made, or that it includes a career-best performance from Al Pacino, who was robbed of a Best Actor gong the year it came out when the Academy wrongly handed it to Art Carney for his role in Harry and Tonto.