Every Single MCU Film Ranked From Worst To Best

How does Ragnarok shake things up?

MCU Films Ranked
Marvel Studios

After almost a decade and over 16 years, the MCU has become a continuous brand that has eclipsed most of the industry's biggest series, sitting alongside the Pixar universe, Star Wars and the Disney Classics as a bona-fide behemoth.

It would be easy to suggest that it's all been flawless along the way - that the ship that Kevin Feige steers like a juggernaut through the box office waters towards billion dollar catches every time has never gone off course - but that would be incorrect. So too would the accusation that there have been few boundaries tested and few innovations encouraged, in the name of creating one mega-successful but ultimately homogenous flavour profile.

Saying silly things like that shows off biases and ignorances either way. There have been rocky patches, just as there have been surprising successes, and there have been stunningly inventive, utterly unique movies just as there have been those steeped in nostalgia. And for all that talk of bubbles bursting, the fact that every single release seems to closely flirt with billion dollar box office takes is testament to the MCU's boom time.

So far, in 2017, we've had two great new additions in the shape of Guardians of The Galaxy Vol 2 and Spider-Man: Homecoming, but the question now is how Thor: Ragnarok stacks up against the rest of the pile...


17. Thor: The Dark World (2013)

Thor The Dark World
Marvel Studios

The biggest problem for Thor: The Dark World was how badly a great decision played out. The hiring of Game Of Thrones director Alan Taylor should have been perfect to replace Kenneth Branagh; he should have brought the right blend of theatricality and fantasy with that typical Westeros eye for drama.

Sadly, his film was a boring misfire that took its good ideas - like pretty much everything it does with Loki - and buried them in drabness. There are other good flash-points - but there's too much focus on villains who simply aren't interesting enough to warrant it. Again, they have their moments - like the idea of a select few "evolving" into The Kursed - but in Taylor's hands they become no more than Doctor Who monster of the week types.

It also doesn't help that there is an awful, distracting attempt to alleviate the tension by having too many comic relief characters - like Kat Dennings' Darcy and Stellan Skarsgard's utterly disrespected Selvig who are very close to unwatchable.


16. Iron Man 2 (2010)

Iron Man 2 Robert Downey Jr Tony Stark
Marvel Studios

Considering all the talk about Iron Man being the keystone for the MCU, it's still a wonder that the first sequel was so badly undercooked.

There's a shell of a really good story in there, with interesting pillars focused on Tony Stark's addiction behaviour and the introduction of a dark mirror villain (and his monster side-kick), but it's all curiously misguided and you can almost tangibly feel Jon Favreau losing his grip on it.

Obviously Robert Downey Jr is great, and Sam Rockwell is good (though he's underused), but the decision to cut most of Mickey Rourke's character made him look entirely disposable, and there's way too much focus on empty spectacle without the right balance of heart. And there's a fundamental lack of chemistry between Downey Jr and his co-stars.


15. The Incredible Hulk (2008)

The Incredible Hulk
Marvel Studios

You can complain about the fact that we've not seen a stand-alone Hulk movie for almost a decade because of the movie rights issue all you like, but the reason Marvel have never worked as hard to get the issue ironed out is thanks to Ang Lee's Hulk and Louis Leterrier's problematic follow-up sequelboot.

The film - which actually has its merits (like General Ross, and the idea of having Hulk and the Abomination clash) - was something of a mess, beset by issues on set that saw star Edward Norton apparently take a little too much control. The result was a thick soup of imbalanced flavours that stinks to high heaven of too many cooks.

It actually improves as it gets older (or as we do), and it's some way better than Lee's interpretative dance of an adaptation, but all of the things that would make later MCU movies so effective - the blend of heart and spectacle and the character builds - wasn't quite refined enough. And it's ultimately the lack of heart that really does for it (not to mention the fatal lack of restraint shown by Tim Roth in his having-way-too-much-fun pantomime villain performance as Blonksy.


14. Thor (2011)

Thor And Loki
Marvel Studios

It's pretty stunning that a movie as good - and as well-measured - as Thor can only come in at 13th in such a ranking, but that's the sort of quality you're looking at at the top of the MCU ladder. But make no mistake, Thor is a very good film and the gap in quality between it and The Incredible Hulk is chasmic.

The film works mostly because of Kenneth Branagh's eyes for theatrical staging and the casting of his two most important characters. Tom Hiddleston in particular is excellent (and actually much better than a Chris Hemsworth still wearing his character a little uncomfortably - before the humour later introduced added gloss) and it's no accident that he's been an MCU mainstay ever since. Even Natalie Portman is good, as this very much came before Marvel stopped caring about its female characters.

It's essentially a Crocodile Dundee remake with Norse mythology, frost giants and lashings of Oedipal conflict, and that's absolutely not a problem.

It struggles at times with the weight of exposition, but the balance is mostly right and there's a personality in there that was fatally absent from the follow-up.


13. Iron Man (2008)

Iron Man Explosion
Marvel Studios

Without Iron Man, there wouldn't be an MCU. Without Robert Downey Jr there would probably be no Iron Man. And without Jon Favreau, there would definitely be no RDJ as Stark. Back before he was the MCU's lynch-pin, Downey Jr was still classed as a perpetual enfant terrible in Hollywood terms. He had lots of red in his ledger, and Marvel reportedly struggled with the idea of casting him.

Just imagine the alternative. This is the same Hollywood that tried to cast Tom Hanks as Tony Stark for a long time, missing the fact that Stark absolutely isn't a clean cut Ethan Hunt-style hero. He's a douche-bag, inflated by money and charm, who skirts the line between likeability and the opposite as a calling card. He's basically the fictional living embodiment of Downey Jr, with his baggage included.

The film, ultimately, is all about Downey Jr's fit: there's a reasonably good story in there, with his conflict with Obediah Stane and his own shifting moral compass playing central roles, but this was mostly an opportunity for the star to see how well his feet fit Stark's boots, while setting up future plot threads.


12. Captain America: The First Avenger (2011)

Captain America The First Avenger
Marvel Studios

It's a real shame that Captain America had to be the man out of time he's always been in the comics, because the historical setting of The First Avenger - and the chance to see him and The Howling Commandoes teaming up to kick Nazi tail - was a great diversion from the rest of the MCU.

Thanks to Steve McFeely and Chris Markus, the script is excellent and the central performances of Chris Evans and Hugo Weaving as Cap and Red Skull were incredibly good. So good, in fact, that it's a travesty that the angry-faced villain hasn't returned yet.

Cap is easily the most human of the Avengers (unlike Scott Lang turns up anyway) and this was the first movie in the franchise to really nail the idea of heart (because all three of the others already established were looking for it as part of their narrative). In that respect it has bags of charm, and it's impossible not to be taken in completely by the propaganda.

Perhaps you could say that it's a little understated, but vulgarity never suited the period setting, and the slightly different tone actually suited the culture clash at the character's centre.


11. Ant-Man (2015)

Ant Man Movie
Marvel Studios

There's an army of Edgar Wright fans who will no doubt argue until they're blue in the face that his version of Ant-Man would have been superior, but given how long the project was stuck in "development hell", it's incredible how good Peyton Reed's replacement version ended up being.

As with Robert Downey Jr, Tom Hiddleston and Chris Evans, the success of the film really comes down to the casting of Paul Rudd. He might have been a slightly unexpected hire, but he guarantees everyman spirit and his particular brand of humour proved to be perfect for the grown-up Honey I Shrunk The Kids caper.

He's not the only smart casting - Michael Pena is enormously charming as Luis (even with some iffiness around racial stereotypes), Evangeline Lily is acerbic and precise as, Michael Douglas is his usual effervescent self and even Corey Stoll works well as the imbalanced villain. There are slight issues with the logic of his motivation, but the accusations that he's just another generic Marvel villain are misplaced.


10. Doctor Strange (2016)

Doctor Strange The ancient One
Marvel Studios

It may have taken way too long to happen, but Kevin Feige was finally able to open the doors on the Cosmic MCU in stunning fashion with the belated origin story for Doctor Strange. And if anything, it helped that the film was delayed so that it could find its perfect fitting director in the shape of horror maestro Scott Derrickson. Oh, and its perfect star in Benedict Cumberbatch, who almost missed the gig thanks to Sherlock's schedule.

As it always should have, Doctor Strange feels like a technology-stretching movie, which comes with unprecedented effects (at least for the MCU - those folding landscapes scream Inception) and is so transformative that it feels like it opens up far more opportunities in the MCU than any other film to date.

Cumberbatch is typically excellent - slightly aloof, brilliant geniuses are his wheelhouse after all - and he has a very capable supporting cast, even if some of them are more unfairly underused than others. The villains lack something, but the casting of Mads Mikkelsen is a genius move because he's so effortlessly menacing that it almost doesn't matter that he has little to do.

That Dormammu scene left a lot to be desired, though, but the rest is a great start for Strange and for the Cosmic MCU. More please.


9. Avengers: Age Of Ultron (2015)

Avengers Ultron
Marvel Studios

Joss Whedon probably doesn't enjoy Age Of Ultron half as much as its fans, but there's no way the sequel is the failure he has publicly seemed to call it at times. It is an assured escalation of the first Avengers, pushing important elements - like Tony Stark's growing anxiety and the idea of superhero accountability and introducing a delightfully over-the-top villain in the shape of James Spader's Ultron.

The political messages might be about as subtle as a sledge-hammer, but considering the MCU's irresistible trajectory towards Civil War and all of the ramifications of the accords, it shouldn't really come as a surprise.

Even with Spader's pantomime villain - a performance he is clearly deeply enjoying - Ultron is a more grown-up, sombre affair that crams in huge crowd-pleasing moments like the Hulkbuster/Hulk fight and isn't afraid of killing. Sure, the character chosen isn't all that important, but at least there's some incredible Deadmeat Hawkeye headf*ckery along the way to enjoy.

Robert Downey Jr's Tony Stark is excellent, there's interesting ideas established for Bruce Banner and the balance of spectacle works well, even if it doesn't QUITE live up to its predecessor.


8. Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 (2017)

Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 Groot Hi
Marvel Studios

Some will tell you that Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 is high on its own supply, and they'll probably try and have you believe that this is somehow a bad thing. As if removing the training wheels from James Gunn's gleeful, cocky first movie for one that pushes all of the most charming elements further could be.

Vol 2 is even more heartfelt than the original, with emotional punches at the end that will genuinely leave you sobbing, despite how obvious the twists are. Thanks to exceptional scripting and characterisation - helped hugely by excellent casting - the story is really king, even with lots of very silly new elements, and it's impossible not to be utterly intoxicated by Peter's hunt for a father.

It's hilarious at the same time - which has been a problem for cynics - and Gunn once more proves he has an eye for the kind of spectacle most other directors wouldn't even consider. And while the effects work on the Planet Ego sequence aren't all 100%, it still manages to look great.

As with any sequel, the new additions have to be judged in special terms, and everything from Baby Groot to Kurt Russell's duplicitous Ego are worthy bolt-ons.


7. Iron Man 3

Iron Man 3 Extremis Aldrich Killian
Marvel Studios

When Marvel had a second rocky bump in their MCU plans with Iron Man 2, you could have been forgiven for thinking Iron Man would be shunted into a lesser veteran role in the Avengers movies and taken away from solo movie duty. But then Marvel hired Shane Black - rather ingeniously - and combined him with an exceptional script from Drew Pearce to create a charming, intelligent film that dealt with the fall-out of The Avengers and expanded on key Tony Stark issues organically.

Sure, there's temptation to reduce the entire thing to a single twisty story decision, but Iron Man 3 is far more than its Mandarin conceit. It has heart, threat and spectacle in perfect measures, and it even gives Pepper Potts something to do, which is something Jon Favreau and Joss Whedon had failed to do.

The film takes in buddy cop movie dynamics, humour and Black's usual nostalgic eye for action movie tropes, adds a great villain (and yes that does include the idea of The Mandarin as a false front), and while Marvel were compelled to apologise for the twist, they really didn't need to.


6. Thor: Ragnarok

Thor Ragnarok Hulk
Marvel Studios

There will be some cynical people who complain that Thor: Ragnarok is both too funny and too frivolous to really be considered good, but there is a far more organic feel to the tone - thanks to Taika Waititi directing - that marks a stark contrast with how the MCU traditionally does comedy.

Instead of shoe-horned gags that can be distracting, Ragnarok is a comedy at its heart with dramatic moments on top. It almost feels like a coming-of-age comedy (in that it follows Thor's journey to discovering what it really means to be "worthy") with nods in its genetics to the likes of Withnail & I and Planes, Trains & Automobiles.

It's nothing like any other MCU movie, thanks to how much scope Taika Waititi has to explore his own sense of humour and taste (though he is kept slightly on a leash by the wider agenda of the franchise). And it's hysterical, with good stakes, great new characters and a joyful sense of fun that seemed impossible given its proximity to Infinity War. Perhaps because of the decision to avoid that narrative, the stand-alone stands apart as en energetic, enjoyable frolic with meaningful drama.


5. Spider-Man: Homecoming

Spiderman Homecoming
Sony Pictures

Spider-Man: Homecoming had the potential to cause Marvel a lot of heart problems. Not only did it have the usual burdens associated with kick-starting a new property in the established MCU, but it also came with the huge caveat that whatever they achieved had to also be measured against the deal they cut with Sony. There would always be that question of whether it had all been worth the negotiations.

Luckily, the film is both an exceptional MCU movie and the perfect answer to any cynicism. It's not as good as Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 2 (though, actually no Marvel film is), but it's definitely up there in the top 3 Spider-Man movies (including the exceptional cameo in Civil War).

Building on that first appearance, Homecoming goes hard on Tom Holland's excellent, enormously charming performance, adds a great villain with complexity in Michael Keaton's Vulture and offers the best Spider-Man of any film. And incredibly, it didn't even try and lean heavily on Robert Downey Jr's role, which ended up being no more than an extended cameo.


4. The Avengers

The Avengers
Marvel Studios

Even with Iron Man and Captain America: The First Avenger's successes, The Avengers was still a pretty big gamble for Marvel. It would require not only uncharacteristic restraint (for the genre at least) to balance all of the moving parts as well as the necessary space to build a self-contained narrative that justified the team's existence.

It would probably have been tempting to go too big too early, introducing a monstrous villain like Thanos too prematurely in order to guarantee the draw, but instead Joss Whedon - an inspired directing choice - turned to Tom Hiddleston's Loki and dialled him up beautifully. While the heroes are forced to be juggled (leading to great chemistry that continues into all new MCU films), he is given precious space to breathe and the result is a tour de force performance.

Okay, so the Chitauri were no more than cannon fodder in the end, and their invasion feels a little unearned, but the Avengers did need something to fit in the climax, so it's a worthwhile compromise on quality. Just about.


3. Captain America: The Winter Soldier

Captain America The Winter Soldier Bucky
Marvel Studios

Who would have thought that the closest thing in the MCU to a 1970s political intrigue movie would end up being one of the most beloved of the entire franchise?

The Winter Soldier is basically the perfect answer to the cynicism that swarmed around the Russos' hiring. They went from being the weirdest choice in comic book movies, having been most notable for You, Me & Dupree previously, to being the steady hands entrusted with both Civil War and Infinity War. That's a hell of an achievement.

The sequel is anchored by another great script that takes in both world-ending connotations and gigantic sky machines, and is somehow claustrophobically personal (just as Civil War was), which managed to be compelling even in its most political moments (a retrospective lesson for The Phantom Menace) and which added a world-changing SHIELD twist without it ever feeling like any sharks were jumped.


2. Guardians Of The Galaxy

Guardians Of The Galaxy Destroy Ronan
Marvel Studios

For a long time, James Gunn's brilliant, shocking sci-fi was the run-away winner of the coveted best in show prize for the MCU, and while it's definitely still a thing of genius, it has been robbed of top stop by an incredible film, and there's no shame in that.

Guardians' cast is incredibly well put together, with great individual performances combining to make effortless, charming chemistry. The characters are your typically amiable rag-tag bunch of space pirates - all in some way based on Han Solo when you think about it - and watching them find themselves and their places on the team without surrendering their characteristic quirks is where Guardians is at its best.

The incredible soundtrack obviously plays into the success too, and while Ronan the Accuser is sneered at somewhat as a villain, Lee Pace's performance is great (even if he's defeated partly thanks to a bloody dance off).

Guardians is an easy film to love, like a roguish younger brother with behaviour problems but a heart of gold, and everything Gunn built was all the more remarkable given how obscure and weird the property is in the first place.


1. Captain America: Civil War

Captain America Civil War Giant Man Black Panther
Marvel Studios

Let's be real, Captain America: Civil War is nothing like the comic book, aside from in a very spiritual way. Both story arcs deal with superhero registration and control, and both have two teams of superheroes fighting each other. But that's all there was to it - a framework that the Russos took and built something else entirely on.

In fact, the whole decision to use the Civil War title and story elements was no more than a remarkably clever step in the misdirection that turned a global scale exploration of huge ideas and ramifications into one broken man's act of vengeance. And it was that smaller scale personal twist that really succeeded more than anything else.

In the end, the things that mattered most were small relationships rather than huge ideological differences: Tony's to his parents, Cap's to Bucky, Zemo's to his dead family. And while all the spectacle and the amazing set pieces played into the overall success of the film brilliantly, it's ultimately that narrative deception that lasts. And it's that depth that makes Civil War the most rewatchable MCU movie released so far (hence it's jump up in the charts since its year of release).

How would you rank the MCU films released so far? Share your ranking below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.