Evil Dead: The Best (and Worst) Horror Has To Offer

evil-dead-feat Even before its official opening in early April, horror flick The Evil Dead stirred a remarkable frenzy in the horror film community. Some hailed it as a terrifying masterpiece, while others derided it as sloppy, needlessly gory, and a weak, unnecessary remake of a film that wasn€™t all that great to begin with. The mixed reaction is no surprise at all. These days, horror films are at best a decidedly mixed bag, often eschewing classic models of horror filmmaking in favor of stereotypical characters, buckets of blood and gore, and plain old shock value. If you ask people what makes a good horror movie, you€™ll get all sorts of different answers. Personally, I skew much more towards the 70€™s and 80€™s stylings of directors like John Carpenter and Wes Craven, and I have a healthy dislike for the new wave of horror that consists of little more than excessive gore and extremely gratuitous violence. The question is, where does the new Evil Dead fall on the spectrum, and why? Evil Dead is a maddening amalgamation of fantastic moments of true horror and cringe-worthy mistakes and lost opportunities. The problems that exist in the film only stand out more because of how good some of the other elements are. For my money, The Evil Dead remake is a blending of the best and the worst that the current horror genre has to offer us as viewers and fans. evil-dead-2-ash-600x300 Let€™s start with the basics: 2013€™s The Evil Dead is a remake of the 1981 cult classic directed by Sam Raimi and starring Bruce Campbell as Ash. Now, this will probably lose me some readers right away, but I absolutely hated the original Evil Dead. It took me three tries to finish watching it (the first time I quit was after the tree-rape scene), and the dialogue and acting struck me as so bad throughout that it was almost a literally painful viewing experience. Being a fan of 70€™s and 80€™s horror, I was genuinely surprised at my serious dislike for the original film. Despite this, the buzz surrounding the remake caught my attention enough that I wanted to see it. In particular, director Fede Alvarez€™s insistence on using practical effects over CGI intrigued me as a viewer. What€™s interesting, and to me very positive, about Evil Dead 2013 is that it is more of a reinvention than a remake of that original. The reality that the film exists in does not limit it. There€™s a fresh spin on the classic story here, and the characters present turn out to be (at least at first) fresh and interesting rather than simple caricatures or replicas of those in the original. Things that carried over €“ for example, the basic plotline, the setup, setting, and level of horror-infused violence €“ did so for good reason, and were well executed. It seems fair to say that the starting strength of this movie comes from its embracing of the maniacal horror theme that drove the original, without being overly beholden to the particulars of it. It exists in the same world, for sure, but does so without becoming a dull retread of a story that€™s already been told.

evildeadfeature The characters are at once the most interesting and infuriating part of the film because of their immense amount of wasted potential. A cardinal sin of many contemporary horror movies (and one that Evil Dead commits in spades) is giving us characters who are flimsy sketches at best, and annoying caricatures at worst. The archetypes that have existed for so long in horror are not interesting enough to carry a film alone anymore, and they haven€™t been for decades €“ but Hollywood clearly hasn€™t gotten that message. What makes this all the more frustrating is that most of the five characters are actually pretty promising at the start, only to be undone by the abandonment of their development in favor of frenetic horror and violence from about 30 minutes into the film and beyond. It€™s a glaring mistake because (as we€™ll discuss later) Evil Dead impresses on a thematic level, but failing to give us interesting, multilayered characters to suffer through said thematics means the whole film is less impressive and less effective overall. David, the long-haired teacher, is the shoddiest character in the film. He€™s the very definition of a plot puppet €“ every last thing he does only happens as a literal machination of plot without any legitimate character dynamics behind it. This is especially frustrating since he is the one who unleashes the horror that€™s at the crux of the movie, and thanks to his puppet role, we€™re never given anything resembling an actual reason for his actions. The lack of characterization also comes back to bite the filmmakers most crucially in the case of Mia, who turns out to be not only the catalyst, but the heroine of the movie. Her shoddy characterization causes problems on two levels. First, we lose her to the demons before we really have an opportunity to understand and sympathize with how much her loss means to the other characters in the cabin. Thus, we€™re less engaged with them as they seek a solution to the problem €“ despite how viscerally frightening that problem is to begin with. Secondly, once she comes back and (in an admirably clever spin of roles) becomes the heroine and the last woman standing, we root for her mostly because we don€™t have any other choice. She€™s the last human being left at the cabin, and she€™s fighting what seems to be an impossible battle in a rain of blood. Sure, that situation in and of itself is compelling, but the downside is that we€™re more interested in seeing the evil vanquished than we are in seeing Mia triumph.

ed The overall plot and themes explored in the story are a close second to the characters themselves in terms of infuriatingly lost potential. Evil Dead starts very promisingly by conquering the age old problem of horror films: what on earth would make people go to that creepy cabin in the woods or the abandoned house or the dark basement (and no, €˜because the plot says so€™ is not an acceptable answer here). Evil Dead gives us an interesting setup and a compelling reason for said setup: Mia is a drug addict who has overdosed, and her friends are bringing her to the out-of-the-way cabin so that she can detox cold turkey. One of her friends is even a registered nurse, giving more credence to what might otherwise seem like a juvenile, not to mention dangerous, plan to help Mia. This plot setup also provides an opportunity for an interesting €œdrugs as monsters€ metaphor to be played out over the course of the film. This isn€™t an argument for moralizing in a horror film like Evil Dead €“ just an observation that there is potential for layered, more complex storytelling thanks to the basic conceit of the movie. But here again, we run into the film€™s greatest flaw: abandonment of deeper storytelling in favor of blood and frenetic terror. The two concepts are not mutually exclusive, but this movie chooses to look at them in that way, which only hurts its overall resonance. evil2 There€™s no denying that The Evil Dead is a hard-R horror movie, and it earns that rating at every turn. There€™s nothing wrong with that. A major plus, and one of the more interesting production elements in the film, is its use of almost 100% practical effects. Rather than cheap-looking CGI, prosthetics, squibs, plain old buckets of fake blood, and other practical effects were used to maximum effect, recalling the glory days of practical filmmaking. Frankly, if the filmmakers€™ claims about practical effects work on the film are true, I€™d pay to see an in-depth documentary about the making of the movie. There€™s no denying that these production choices allowed for some fantastic, unflinching filmmaking on the part of director Fede Alvarez. In particular, the constant rain of blood in the penultimate scenes, the onscreen amputations, and demon makeup all served to draw the audience deeper into the world of the film. The question, though, is: how good is that, really? The pacing of the movie is frenetic and almost nonstop after the first possession occurs, but peel away the layers and it€™s at least partially hollow €“ because, going back to what was discussed earlier, we don€™t care about the people these things are happening to in-film. We€™re impressed, sure, but are we really invested? Probably not. I know I wasn€™t €“ and I really, genuinely wanted to be. I wanted to be terrified not only by what was happening, but for the people it was happening to.


evil-dead-feat (1) The second part of this element is the John Carpenter (Halloween) question. Carpenter always said that part of his filmmaking philosophy was that showing explicit violence onscreen actually might be unnecessary in horror. He argued that our minds can do much worse on their own. We don€™t have to see someone€™s limbs cut off to be able to envision it happening and have a reaction to that. This, then, might be one of the most important questions for modern horror audiences to answer, especially in the wake of the €˜torture porn€™ fad of films in the last decade. Where do we land on it, and where should we land? Is Evil Dead true to the spirit of horror filmmaking, or is it missing the point entirely? Evil Dead is certainly an improvement on the original film, but it is far from a perfect movie. The amalgamation of elements present in the film makes it rich fodder for discussion amid horror fans. Really, it prompts us as the audience to ask what we think makes a truly great horror film. Is it enough to have impressive levels of jump scares and violence, even if the characters onscreen are poorly drawn and don€™t truly engage us? Or do we need something more? Personally, I say the latter. Horror and terror only truly get under your skin when you can identify with the characters who are suffering from it. Otherwise, you might be justifiably impressed by the filmmaking, but it isn€™t a truly great expression of horror itself without the balance between characterization and action. In some ways, it is a retreat from the gory, vicious, and exploitative trend of torture-porn films €“ but it is also a step up from the jump-scare-a-minute horror of franchises like Paranormal Activity. Even with its particular flaws, Evil Dead is exciting because it tries to be something fresh and viscerally terrifying while still paying homage to the classic form of horror filmmaking that inspired it. What do you think? Was Evil Dead 2013 great, terrible, or something in between? And what is it that makes a truly great horror movie? Sound off in the comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

Matt is a freelance writer and aspiring TV and film scriptwriter. He has a bizarrely eclectic skillset, and the interests to match. Find more of his work and ramblings over at the Breakwater Industries page on Facebook. He is a regular contributor to WhatCulture.com, and his work has also appeared in the essay collection "Joss Whedon: The Complete Companion", published by Titan Books.