Ewan McGregor: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
In nearly 20 years as a Hollywood star, Ewan McGregor has been a prominent figure in the world of mainstream and independent cinema. He has successfully accomplished the daunting task of moving between genres without his fanbase or stock levels diminishing greatly, while crafting roles that are masterful, engaging and thrilling. Of course not everything the Scottish actor has done has been critically or commercially successful, but more often than not he has produced acting performances that allow his films to become more than what it should, extending his abilities and enthusing them with a vigour and passion that wouldnt of been possible in anybody elses hands. His latest film Jack The Giant Slayer, based on the fairy tales Jack and The Beanstalk & Jack The Giant Killer, is released in UK cinemas today and while it has gathered average reviews from critics and has been underwhelmed at the US box office, heres hoping that it finds success here and across Europe in the coming weeks. Due to the films release here in the UK today, Ewan McGregor is the latest actor for a close examination of his career as we remember 5 Awesome Performances and 5 That Sucked...
5 Awesome Performances...
5. Big Fish Young Edward Bloom
Tim Burton's most restrained film Big Fish tells the story of Edward Bloom, an enthused storyteller who likes to recount tales that have happened to him over the years that vary from those of generosity, to to those of love. The story begins with an older Edward Bloom, played brilliantly by Albert Finney, recounting the tale of the day he caught the uncatchable fish, leading us to meet Edward Bloom in his youth played by Ewan McGregor. This begins the magical journey that Burton and screenwriter John August take us on for two hours of glorious cinema. Big Fish really is a movie that has to be sat through multiple times in order to fully appreciate. It blends reality and fantasy wonderfully and has a pure heart at its core. McGregor is enigmatic and charming in the lead role, possessing the ability for audiences to feel sympathy and engage with Edward, something particularly crucial when spending so much time in a characters' presence. If youre familiar with Burtons previous work but have missed out on this, give it a try, you may be pleasantly surprised.
4. Moulin Rogue - Christian
On paper, Moulin Rogue shouldnt have worked. By the start of the 21st century, musicals were simply not mainstream anymore and were declared dated. However Baz Lurhmann had other ideas and did his best to bring musicals back and in a big way! He cast Ewan McGregor and Nicole Kidman as the romantic pair Christian and Santine that fell in love in Paris in the early 20th century. The chemistry between McGregor and Kidman is off the charts and there can be no denying that McGregors performance is pure brilliance, excelling in the dramatic scenes but also showcasing his versatility with his vocal talent. Blending modern music to its historical setting, Moulin Rouge is a brash, bold and ultimately joyous musical that captures the trials and tribulations that love can have over a person and the risks they are willing to take to get it. McGregor was Golden Globe nominated for his performance.
3. Beginners - Oliver
Written and directed by Mike Mills and seen by far few people, Beginners is a quirky, eccentric and incredibly charming drama. Ewan McGregor plays Oliver, a man dealing with the death of his father who sparks chemistry with Anna (Melanie Laurent) at a party. The strength of the film lies with the performances provided by the whole cast but in particular it is McGregors chemistry with his gay father Hal, played by Christopher Plummer, that truly shows what a talent both actors are, blending wit and heart effortlessly. Beginners was a critical and commercial success and provided Christopher Plummer with a deserved Oscar win for Best Supporting Actor. However, it is clear that without McGregor by his side, that award may not have come so easily, each actor needing the other to drive the message that Mills screenplay conveys with realism and feeling. Beginners can definitely be seen as the beginning of McGregors 2nd phase as an actor. After the promising start he had to his career, the mid to late 00s had seen him make some very awkward choices when picking roles, seemingly stuck by his youth and the type casting the Star Wars may have provided. However, with other success such as Salmon Fishing In The Yemen and I Love You Philip Morris there definitely seems to be mini-renaissance and that hopefully his slump is over.
2. The Impossible Henry Bennett
The Impossible, directed by Juan Antonia Buyona, depicts the real life tragedy of the 2004 tsunami through the eyes of Maria Belon and her family and the struggles they endured throughout the disaster. For the purposes of the film, the names of the characters were changed but the Belon family were there on set, allowing them to converse with the actors, providing a 1st hand account of the emotions, movements and thought processes that each scene in the movie depicts, adding an added dimension of realism. McGregor plays family man Henry Bennett, who alongside his wife, played by Naomi Watts, are taking a vacation with their sons when disaster strikes and tsunami change the course of their lives forever. This strangely is McGregors first role as a father figure, allowing for a differing style that hasnt been seen from him before. He conveys compassion and feeling brilliantly and portrays the human conflicts that any of us would experience with incredible realism. One particular scene in which McGregor is taking a phone call is particularly striking and watching a man break down in fear and anguish was incredibly powerful and once again confirmed the range of emotive talent that McGregor possesses.
1. Trainspotting Mark Renton
It was never going to be anything else. After the success of his first collaboration with Oscar winning director Danny Boyle in Shallow Grave, the pair moved on to the Irvine Welsh novel Trainspotting. The book depicts the gritty, realistic abyss that drug addiction can send a person and set against the backdrop of a bleak, grey Edinburgh in the the 1980s. The novel created controversy but garnered critical acclaim for highlighting the themes set throughout the narrative. Naturally, after the success of the novel, the inevitable film adaptation came in 1996 and with a cast that includes Johnny Lee Miller and Robert Carlisle, Ewan McGregor stood out as the films protagonist Renton. Possessing the required charm and wit to carry that grim narrative along, the performance from McGregor almost seemed effortless and exuded everything that was cool about Britain in the mid 90s. Having a great soundtrack and comedic wit, Trainspotting was critically and commercially successful and has gone onto to appear on many best ever lists, while at the same time new fans are being introduced to the films unique feel. It still today is seen as McGreogr zenith but with the speculated Trainspotting 2 apparently on its way, it will be intriguing to see if McGregor produces a similarly stunning performance.
And 5 Performances That Sucked...
5. Deception Jonathan McQuarry
Released in 2008, Deception stars Ewan McGregor as the nervous and timid Jonathan McQuarry who befriends Hugh Jackman's incredibly charismatic and arrogant lawyer named Wyatt Bose, and starts to gain some of the self-confidence that Bose possesses. The plot focuses on both being part of an exclusive sex club while both falling in love with the woman simply known as S, played by Michelle Williams. The problem with the film is that its just far too predictable and could easily have been a straight to DVD release had it not had an A-list cast. McGregor in particular just doesnt seem to be interested in finding the intricacies of the character and when the shift in tone changes within the film the contrast in personality on McQuarry is far too obvious and two dimensional. The performance needed a more gradual shift in personality but instead it all happens very suddenly as his love S is placed in danger. Admittedly Jackman as the pretentious Bose does provide some enjoyment as a very serious threat to McGregors McQuarry, but in the end the film is merely a standard thriller that was critically and commercially unsuccessful.
4. Angels & Demons Camerlengo Patrick McKenna
3. Cassandras Dream Ian Blane
In one of my previous articles I named Cassandras Dream as one of the worst Woody Allen movies he has ever made. The plot for this insignificant film is far too similar to Crimes & Misdemeanours and the script see Woody on auto pilot. However, for all the flaws the film does have, it is not helped by the performances that the cast give, most notably the brothers in the film Ewan McGregor and Colin Farrell. The film being set in London, has for some reason meant that each actor must have a cockney accent in order to distinguish this to the audience. The problem is that the cockney accents that are produced are incredibly poor and provide nothing but slight sniggering and embarrassment on part of the actors. McGregors performance in particular is sub-standard and again like the script McGregor just seems to be on auto pilot rather than attempting to salvage the problems of the film with energy and charisma. Throughout the film you just get the sense the circumstances of the script and its setting just do not suit McGregor and the lack of chemistry with Colin Farrell doesnt help the performances of either. The less said the better.
2. Emma Frank Churchill
Directed by Douglas McGrath, Emma is the 1996 film based on the novel of the same name by Jane Austen. The films stars Gwyneth Paltrow as the aforementioned Emma who sees herself as a romantic matchmaker after apparently matching a newly married couple attempts to prove her abilities, while unaware that she herself would be meeting the love of her life. One person she has feelings for is that of Ewan McGregor's Frank Churchill who despite looking incredibly ridiculous in period attire, gives a performance that shows that this role was far too much at such an early period in his career. Coming fresh off the success of Trainspotting, McGregor clearly felt that a differing change of genre and style of acting role was necessary but his performance is extremely awkward, with the chemistry between himself and Paltrow seeming forced and line delivery feeling strained. Incidentally, Ewan McGregor has stated that Emma is the one film in his career that he regrets doing, simply because he just wasnt very good. It seems that at this early point in his career he didnt quite possess the depth required to play the role and credit where credit is due, it is refreshingly honest to get such a candid opinion from a Hollywood star. Still, he was pretty bad. No excuses there.
1. Eye of the Beholder The Eye
Stephen Elliott, director of The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of The Desert, decides to indulge in noir with horrible results. Featuring Ewan McGregor as the protagonist simply stated as The Eye, he is an intelligence agent who while searching for a socialites son witnesses his murder by Eris, played by Ashley Judd and thus begins a tale of obsession, desire and loss. The film, a remake of the 1983 French film Deadly Circuit would certainly work under the hands of someone who knows and understands the intricacies of noir, for example Hitchcock. The problem is Elliott mashes together various pieces of differing visual styles into what is ultimately an incredibly boring and dreary film that produces terrible performances One the problems with McGregors performance is that he is so incredibly monotone throughout; any traces of emotion that the script begs for are merely uttered back in a bored, un-enthused way. It really does seem that McGregor just felt no passion for the film and the admittedly decent premise of the film is wasted under poor direction, a woeful script and easily one of the worst acting performances McGregor has given. The contrast in how a performance full of wit, charm and charisma such as McGregor gives as Renton in Trainspotting compared to this really is startling. Here is hoping he never gives a performance this underwhelming again.
