Exploring Existentialism In The Films Of Darren Aronofsky

Aronofsky Cover In existentialism, the most basic idea is that the individual is solely responsible for applying meaning in his or her own life, coming to terms with the material world, and living as authentically as possible. With this article, it's my intent to dissect five films by Darren Aronofsky in exploring theme and focusing on how each protagonist is responsible for both finding and applying meaning in their own lives. Very rarely in cinema are we allowed to truly explore the psyche of our protagonists, and that's part of what makes Aronofsky's films so honest. Regarding tone, all five films carry a certain gravitas about them that can feel suffocating. It's in these claustrophobic moments that the struggle for authenticity, for meaning, are traversed and analyzed. The five films I'll be analyzing are: Pi, Requiem For A Dream, The Fountain, The Wrestler, and Black Swan. Each of the films are similar thematically and are very much character studies in which these characters eventually reach a defining, self-determining moment, and find peace in their solace. By the end, I hope to have discussed not only the existential moments, but why these films are essential to the world of cinema, and what makes them that much more of a rewarding experience.

5. Pi (1998)

Pi In the film Pi, Max (Sean Gullette) is on the verge of discovering how number patterns function in the real world. He's obsessed with the notion that everything in nature can be explained through numbers and is dedicated to finding out how. His obsession leads to his reliance on painkillers and introversion. Seemingly the only two people who take notice to him are his neighbor, Devi, and a little girl who is quick to approach with a calculator in hand, asking him to solve random math problems. Most of his interaction takes place with his mentor, Sol. Sol was once in search of meaning through number, but became dangerously unnerved and burned out by the process. Their time is spent discussing number theory while playing the game of Go. Through his attempts and recklessness, Max is approached by Wall Street tycoons who take a sudden interest in his theories concerning numbers and patterns, as well as members of a sect of Judaism who firmly believe his mind is the key in restoring order in the world. Through all of his trials and tribulations, Max's moment of self realization comes in a hallucination. In this dream state, Max stares at himself in his bathroom mirror holding a power drill, desperate to rid himself of the headaches he'd been suffering up until that point. With only the slightest hint of hesitation, he takes the drill to his head as it burrows through a vein that had been protruding just above the right temple. Blood spurts outward and he awakens on the floor of his bathroom, unscathed, in complete silence. Though the vision is violent by nature, it is the representation of Max coming to terms with his surroundings. He finds peace in knowing that in trying to find the relation between number patterns and existence, he had been missing out on the most important connections in his own life. Moments later, Max is sitting outside on a park bench marveling at the sight of leaves swaying back and forth as the Fall wind passes through them. He's approached by the little girl with the calculator who asks him to solve another math problem, to which he smiles and claims not to know. This is not only a sweet gesture, but a self affirming notion that he has now applied meaning to his own life and is ready to move forward into the unknown.

4. Requiem For A Dream (2000)

Requiem Based on the novel by Hubert Selby Jr., Aronofsky's Requiem For A Dream is a story of addiction and how it transcends age and gender. It is an intricately told story following the lives of Sara and Harry Goldfarb (Ellen Burstyn and Jared Leto), Marion (Jennifer Connelly), and Tyrone (Marlon Wayans). Harry, Marion, and Tyrone are all friends who are all well-meaning people looking to become successes and live very much in the moment. Harry and Marion are not only friends, but lovers who are looking into starting their own business while Tyrone is simply trying to live up to expectations by hustling his way around town. Their addiction is in the form of heroin and they become engulfed in drug trafficking. Sara's addiction comes in the form of weight loss pills when she's asked to take part in a TV game show she watches on the regular. Realizing she no longer fits into her favorite red dress, she takes extreme measures in regaining her prime physical form. For as much as we want these people to succeed, the film takes on a life of its own as we watch the gradual degradation of each of these characters. Through the deconstruction of the film's protagonists, they find inherent value where they felt displaced by society. Sara Goldfarb develops a dependency on the weight loss pills and sedatives she's prescribed, thus forming an addiction. Because of this, she hallucinates at various points throughout the film and finally, takes the subway to Manhattan in search of the TV show executives responsible for her invite. Once she stumbles into the office, she's taken away and committed to a psychiatric ward where she undergoes various medical treatments and shock therapy, which leads to her losing her mind completely. Harry and Tyrone are en route to Florida to try and score some heroin, but an infection in Harry's arm spreads rapidly, forcing them to make a stop in South Carolina. There, Harry and Tyrone are arrested for skipping bail. In prison, Harry is taken to a hospital where his arm is amputated and Tyrone is forced to work hard labor amongst guards throwing racial slurs at him. Marion meets with a pimp to support her drug habit, but finds herself entangled in a world of degrading sexual activity as she becomes objectified at parties the pimp throws in his apartment. It's only through their mistakes that these characters find meaning in their own lives. For instance, Tyrone in his prison cell, curls into a fetal position and his first thought is of his mother and being held by her. He realizes the error of his ways and is at the beginning stages of repentance. The significance of Harry's amputation is that it serves as a physical reminder that his addiction cost him so much more than the loss of his arm. Sara is finally at some semblance of peace by the end, but her friends mourn her loss as they realize she's no longer the person she was. Though physically present, she's at a distance, mentally. Each of these characters' displacement comes from not living up to expectations, wanting to establish themselves, and the search for acceptance, all of whom are awarded such acceptance. They are very much aware of their existence and do what they can to improve upon their situations. However, it's the methods they employ that cost them dearly. The title of the film says it all, really, and in Sara's last dream that closes out the film, she has lost weight, and is on the TV show along with Harry and Marion (who are engaged and well off) as they celebrate her winning the grand prize as the crowd cheers them on. A requiem by definition, derives from the term Requiem Mass, which serves a celebration for dead souls at rest. I don't think the ending could've been more apropos.

3. The Fountain (2006)

the fountain 2006's The Fountain is a disjointed narrative that is spread among three stories running parallel to one another. It spans three time periods and places. One of narratives being told is set in the twenty-first century and is focused on Thomas Creo (Hugh Jackman), a doctor frantically trying to find a cure for his wife, Izzi (Rachel Weisz), who has been stricken with cancer. The second follows a conquistador named Tomás who is seeking the tree of life for his Queen Isabel set against the backdrop of the inquisition. The third follows Thomas many years in the future, hurtling through space inside a biosphere that also houses the dying tree of life, towards a dying star in hopes to be reunited with Izzi after it burns out based on a notion mentioned by her earlier in the film that implies the star was representative of Xibalba (also referred to as the Underworld in Mayan culture). All of these parallel timelines could be construed as one narrative being told at various intervals, with the same characters. Having the conquistador and Queen Isabel portrayed by Jackman and Weisz certainly hints at the possibility, but ultimately it's up to the audience to decide just how much they would like to suspend their disbeliefs. The film is essentially a meditation on death, and the acceptance of. Thomas refuses to accept the fact that his wife has a limited amount of time left, and while in this state of denial, he's missing out on what Izzi needs more than anything. While he's researching a cure, she is writing a book titled, The Fountain, in which it's revealed that the conquistador narrative is actually what's being written by her (or at least, one could assume). She not only wants Thomas to read her book, but to finish it. Again, Thomas refuses and is swallowed whole by his work. His moment of clarity comes after Izzi has passed and he's sitting on his bedside alone. He takes a fountain pen she had given him as a gift and pierces his finger with the sharp end. Blood clumps up on the tip and he pokes at his wound a second time. His hand recoils and that is perhaps the first time he truly realizes what he has lost and the guilt of not having spent as much time with Izzi as he could have sets in. From here, we are taken back to the future narrative and the biosphere has reached its destination. The star is dying and in its passing, a rebirth will take place. Thomas sits in the lotus position and floats towards the star and accepts his fate. In an instant, light burns through and bends him like a twig, creating a sort of star dust that falls over the tree, giving it life anew. Snow has fallen and Thomas walks over to Izzi's gravestone, drops a seed just above it. The expression on his face is that of acceptance and tranquility. The act of inflicting physical pain on himself was of Thomas' own necessitation. Much like Pi, the character of Thomas reaches a point where he's faced with his own mortality and decides he wants to salvage what is left before he loses himself. He then makes a conscious decision to relinquish himself of his fears, doubts, and frustrations, despite the loss.

2. The Wrestler (2008)

Wrestler Shot in a style that mimics cinéma vérité, The Wrestler tells the story of Randy 'The Ram' Robinson (Mickey Rourke), a pro wrestler on his way to retirement. His heyday was in the 80's when he worked for a bigger wrestling promotion and fought the big names for top dollar. Now, he barely makes ends meet, lives in a trailer park, is divorced, hasn't spoken to his estranged daughter (Evan Rachel Wood) in years, and is working the indie circuit for a few hundred dollars a week while working at a supermarket. Running parallel to his story is that of a stripper named Cassidy. She is good friends with Randy and is his link to the real world. Her career mirrors Randy's in that she's also a bit older than her peers and is affected by the passage of time. She's seen as irreverent among her clientele and strives to make ends meet. A heart attack after a grueling hardcore match is what forces Randy to be shelved and into retirement. Soon after, he decides to conform to everyday, mundanity and try to rebuild relationships and start new ones. This of course, involves trying to make contact with his daughter, Stephanie and win the heart of Cassidy. When everything goes awry, Randy finds that a return to the ring (against doctor's orders) is his only means to salvation. His moment of self awareness comes after the fallout while working the deli counter. Unable to deal with the constant stream of customers, he thrusts his thumb into the meat slicer and quits his day job. He smears his own blood across his face and mocks the customers, causing a ruckus and exiting with the bravado that only a charismatic pro wrestler could get away with. In his return match against The Ayatollah, Cassidy makes a last ditch effort and quits her job to be in attendance. Backstage, she confides in Randy and offers her full attention and friendship to which Randy is appreciative, but admits to feeling most at home with his fans. Despite the physicality of the sport, the only place he's truly hurt is outside the ring. Though heartbreaking, it's a beautiful sentiment that directly reflects The Ram's acceptance of his true nature. He's come to terms with the material world, but chooses to live a life more authentic and true to his persona.

1. Black Swan (2010)

black-swan Also shot using documentary style techniques was 2010's Black Swan. With the intent to win the lead in Swan Lake, Nina Sayers (Natalie Portman) becomes consumed by an almost perfectionist mentality. Her overbearing mother, Erica (Barbara Hershey) only attributes to her compulsion and anxiety. When the director of the production, Thomas Leroy (Vincent Cassel) forces the principle dancer, Beth (Winona Ryder) to retire, Nina urges Thomas to reconsider her audition as she proved to lack the emotion the Black Swan required. He forcibly kisses her and she instinctually bites his lip which has him taken aback. He notices he had provoked that reaction and sees that she's capable of channeling that drive to become the Black Swan. Nina wins the role, but at a great cost. Her anxiety driven up the wall, she builds a protective barrier between her and a new dancer in Lily (Mila Kunis). Lily is the personification of the Black Swan and naturally, this causes Nina to question Lily's intent and friendship. Thoughts of Lily begin to envelope her everyday commutes to and from work, and Nina finds that getting in tune with her dark side has suddenly become easier as she becomes filled with jealousy and at times, rage. The theme of seduction is heavy throughout as Nina sprouts wings and feathers in hallucinations and dreams. The kiss from Thomas was intended to put her in a certain mindset to force a reaction, and as Nina becomes more comfortable in her duality, the Black Swan wins out and she is seduced by its sway. Nina's moment of keen awareness comes in the form of a perceived struggle between her and Lily in her dressing room. She smashes Lily into a mirror and leaves her for dead during the show. During intermission, she realizes that it was merely a hallucination and that in her momentary lapse, had shattered the mirror and stabbed herself with a shard of glass. With only moments until the beginning of the final act, Nina gathers herself and puts on a performance that is worthy of a standing ovation. In the final moment of the production, she throws herself from high atop a set piece onto a mattress as planned. Her peers gather around her to congratulate only to find her bleeding profusely through her costume. Medics are called and all Nina can focus on was how perfect her performance was. To conclude, all of these films are similar in theme and they share a correlation in their acts of violence and awareness. In each of these films, our protagonists either inflict pain upon themselves or are met with violent actions committed against them by their own decisive existential moments. All of these characters exist in a world that is so reminiscent to our own, that we forget they are purely fictitious. These characters live, breathe, consume, hurt, question, and authenticate. They accept the world they inhabit and come to terms with it, but they also go to great lengths to apply meaning to their lives no matter the cost. All of these characters take sole responsibility in choosing the course of their actions in the search for meaning through perseverance. They aren't easy films to watch, but that's what makes these films so unique. They are transcendent in ways film probably shouldn't be, but they're all the more rewarding for providing a challenge where most films would rather hold your hand. Sharing in the pain and struggles of these characters only reflects our own search for meaning, and for living a life more authentic.

Contributor
Contributor

Graduate of UTEP with a degree in Creative Writing and a minor in Film, Sergio also runs his own blog, Utterances Of The Mundane. Lover of all things geek including film, comics, tv, and music. He can be followed on twitter: @SergioBravoJr