Fantastic Beasts: 10 Potential Harry Potter Spinoffs We'd Rather See

Because sometimes JK Rowling can be her own worst enemy, and this is one of those times.

Harry Potter Spin Offs
Warner Bros.

For a really long time, most people would have said that JK Rowling was one of the few super successful authors who consistently had her finger on the pulse of her fanbase. Then The Cursed Child happened. So sorry JK, but now you're on notice.

When the news of a new franchise revolving around Newt Scamander, a character we'd only fleetingly been introduced to through his seminal work Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, was announced, it was terribly exciting.

But I couldn't shake the niggling feeling that there were so many other HP stories I wanted told before this one. Then JK announced that, in true Douglas Adams fashion, the Newt Scamander film coming out next month is going to be the first in an increasingly inaccurately named trilogy (in this case, five films).

Now, I'm a big Star Wars fan, and I'm excited about their idea to release a series of standalone films that are only tangentially related to the main Star Wars story. It allows us to explore the expanded universe, but doesn't force casual audiences into a multi-film commitment to characters they don't even know.

That's what I would rather see with the Harry Potter world. It's such a rich universe that it seems a shame to devote so much time to just one character when there are so many other stories to tell.

With that in mind, here are just a few of the stories that should have been given the spin-off franchise treatment.

10. Neville Longbottom

Neville Longbottom
Warner Bros.

I'm going into this entry knowing full well that I am very likely one of the few people who is particularly eager to see a Neville Longbottom spinoff film. But hear me out. Neville is the most noble, painfully awesome character in all of the wizarding world.

He has all of the hero's journey that Harry Potter experienced (arguably more so, because he didn't benefit from the same levels of fame and natural talent), but gets none of the credit. To be totally honest, Neville deserves his own standalone film. I always think of him as sort of the Rosencratz and Guildenstern of Harry Potter, and you know he had some crazy adventures after the Battle of Hogwarts, but before he settled down to become professor of Herbology.

That's what I want to see. Mid-20s Neville exploring the world and finding himself as he fights the forces of darkness. Is part of this out of a desire to see Matt Lewis reprise his role as Neville Longbottom? I can neither confirm nor deny that. But you can't argue that it wouldn't be a great story.


9. Dumbledore

Dumbledore Pensieve
Warner Bros.

So one of the main goals of Deathly Hallows was to give all these tantalizing little hints about Dumbledore's past, only to drop them like your dead little sister that you may or may not have killed (sorry).

Notably, the whole Dumbledore youth subplot was almost completely dropped from the film adaptation. Which is a shame, because those little snippets are incredibly cinematic and would only benefit from being seen on the big screen.

I want the wizarding version of a biopic, an homage to one of their greatest heroes. I think most Harry Potter fans would agree that there is absolutely no such thing as too much Dumbledore - he's always operated on the periphery of the action (and rightly so, as the story needs to have its focus be on the main trio of children), but every glimpse we get of his inner life and controversial past hint at an irresistibly compelling character.


8. Dudley Dursley

dudley dursley
Warner Bros.

In one of the many interviews JK Rowling has given since completing the book series, she casually mentioned that she had considered including a scene at the end of the seventh book where Dudley Dursley is at Platform 9 3/4, sending his own magical offspring to Hogwarts. As though you can casually bring up such an awesome idea and expect Harry Potter fans not to run with it.

So I'm going to go ahead and accept this intriguing little plotlet as canon (yes, I know JK's stance is that any contact with Vernon Dursley's muggle blood would prevent any magical inclinations from taking root, but I won't hear it and I won't respond to it.) Because how adorable would it be to have a tiny little Dursley running around with magic?

It would give Dudley (who I for some reason imagine as a fiercely loyal father) a chance to right the wrongs of his childhood abuse of his cousin, and provides us with the comedic value of hearing the Dursley's reaction to having a magical grandchild. Potential downer: they couldn't actually show Vernon Dursley, because we no longer have Richard Griffiths with us and I refuse to allow re-casting.


7. Regulus Black

Regulus Black Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

In the books, Regulus Black serves two very simple purposes: to thwart Voldemort by helping to destroy one of his horcruxes, and to provide contrast between Sirius and the rest of his Death Eater family. We know that Regulus joined the cause, and then abandoned Voldemort in a major no-turning-back sort of way that ended up costing him his life.

But this noble act is only dealt with at a very shallow level, and the implications of Regulus's sacrifice are left unexplored. This is a young man who follows the family line to the point of actually becoming a Death Eater, but then something happens somewhere along the way to give him a crisis of faith where he is driven not only to leave Voldemort's service, but to go to extreme length to bring his former boss down.

And then there's the little matter of the dynamic between him and his Gryffindor big brother Sirius, a situation that is barely touched upon in the book, but is immensely fascinating.

As much as people like to think of James and Sirius as brothers, we often forget that Sirius actually had a brother already. And what must that relationship have been like for the both of them?


6. The Next Generation

Harry Potter Cursed Child Albus Scorpius
Twitter

Let me be crystal clear when I discuss this idea: I am not for one tiny second advocating for a film adaptation of The Cursed Child. But I do want to see what the wizarding world looks like twenty years down the line, casually populated by older versions of the characters we know and love and, perhaps more importantly, their children.

Because Harry Potter is first and foremost a story designed to capture the imagination of children, and is at its best when shown through the eyes of a child. Also, I think that this would make an incredible television show,. All of the superhero programs and HBO dramas prove that you can tell a compelling story on TV without sacrificing quality in a way that wouldn't have been possible ten or fifteen years ago.

I'm picturing an anthology show where each episode focuses on a different character, but they're all integrated seamlessly into a cohesive view of the future wizarding community. Like Skins, but at the same time nothing like Skins.


5. Young McGonagall

McGonagall Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

We all know that Professor McGonagall is ten shades of awesome - common knowledge, right? But not everyone is aware of the backstory that JK Rowling has lovingly crafted for the Hogwarts matriarch. They just see her as the strict but caring head of Gryffindor house, a woman capable of shaming you into obedience with the mere raise of an eyebrow, and a genuinely badass witch in her own right.

But I'm here to tell you, she's so much more than that. Go investigate McGonagall's backstory, then try to tell me that it doesn't deserve to be a major motion picture.

She's one of those characters who seems to have come out of the womb crotchety and middle-aged (much like her namesake, actually, who sprouted out of her father's head one day, fully grown). So it's interesting to think about what she would have been like as a young woman, or even as a child.


4. Argus Filch

David Bradley Harry Potter Game of THrones
Warner Bros. / HBO

How about an Argus Filch prequel that casts him in a more sympathetic light, a la the string of recent Disney films that show the classic villains before they were beaten down by time and circumstance into the malevolent creatures they eventually become.

Basically, I want to learn more about Squibs and how they fit into the larger wizarding community. Because for all their high and mighty talk about how Muggles are just as good as witches and wizards, there is definitely a huge stigma against Squibs.

Let's be real, it must have royally sucked to grow up in the wizarding world without any magical powers. It's one thing for Muggles - ignorance is bliss. But to be fully aware of magic but at the same time not be able to access it? That's just cruel.

So imagine little Argus Filch, maybe with a couple of magical siblings, always on the outside looking in. I would love to see Film young and optimistic, getting dragged into a series of adventures where everyone else has magic but he has to rely on his wits alone.

Then somewhere along the line, something happens to turn him into the rules-obsessed human garbage that he is in the books. Argus Filch, man - there's so much more than meets the eye(s). #GreekMythJokes


3. Draco Malfoy

draco malfoy
Warner Bros.

Dramione forever, y'all. OK, but even if Draco doesn't get the girl, there's a whole lot of his story left untold. In a lot of ways, Draco is a much more complex character than Harry, but we don't really get to explore the nuances because we're hampered by our narrator, his biggest grade school enemy.

But what do we really know about him? We know that despite growing up in a cesspool of hate and bigotry, he still wasn't quite willing to kill for his parents' cause. And in one version of the eighth film's finale (filmed but ultimately not used in the movie), it is Draco who throws Harry his wand so that he can have his last climactic battle with Voldemort. And Draco's characterization in A Cursed Child is far from villainous, so it seems as though this is a direction JK has considered for him. I

t's clear to me, at any rate, that he is a classic example of nature vs nurture -- had he not been raised by Lucius Malfoy, he would have likely turned out drastically different. So what I want is a post Battle of Hogwarts redemption story for him. How does a Malfoy who doesn't really believe the party line anymore deal with being a social pariah?

And what can he do as an adult to prove to everyone that no matter how big of a dick he was in high school, he's not a terrible person. Um, maybe a road trip adventure with the Golden Trio? You know you want it.


2. Hogwarts Founders

Harry Potter Hogwarts
Warner Bros. Pictures

A group of four friends work together to build a school so that children with special abilities can learn in a community of their peers, rather than being forced to hide in the shadows. And things are great, for a while anyway. But slowly the friends are faced with a disagreement: how special do children need to be to attend, and should children whose abilities have developed seemingly out of nowhere be treated any differently than those with a long pedigree of witches and wizards in their family?

Rowena Ravenclaw, Godric Gryffindor, Helena Hufflepuff, and Salazar Slytherin: only alliterative names need apply. But seriously, how awesome would it be to see an origin story of Hogwarts itself on the big screen? The medieval wizarding world, the constant fear of discovery by Muggles, and most importantly, the sheer dynamics of four incredibly powerful and intelligent witches and wizards.

What I like most of all about this is that at its heart, it's the story of a great friendship gone sour, and if there's one thing that really spices up an historical drama, it's a little bit of relationship drama.


1. The Marauders

Marauders Map Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

The sheer number of fanvids that exist on tumblr telling the story of the young Marauders is enough to let me know that I am not alone in desperately wanting to see their story on the big screen. I don't know why JK is so resistant to developing more content about arguably the most interesting group of characters she's ever created, but it's really starting to negatively impact my day to day life.

Imagine it. An ill-fated circle of friends and lovers who launch a noble rebellion against a growing evil in the wizarding community. I have always said that one of the biggest mistakes of the Harry Potter films was their decision to cast forty-somethings as James and Lily, rather than the kids in their early 20s they actually would have been. It undermines the tragedy of their deaths if you are able to forget how very young they were when they were murdered.

Here, I can do it properly right now. Aaron Taylor-Johnson as James, Ben Barnes as Sirius, Karen Gillian as Lily, Andrew Garfield as Remus. All set, let's go.

I imagine this as a magical spy thriller with liberal dashes of comedy and romance, and yes, cameos from Frank and Alice Longbottom, because I am apparently a horrible masochist.


Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.