Fantastic Beasts 2 Trailer 2 Reactions: 6 Ups & 2 Downs

More beasts, more badass...

Fantastic Beasts 2
Warner Bros.

It might not be out until the end of the year, but Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindelwald is increasingly looking like one of the most exciting movies currently heading towards release. We'd already had one trailer for the forthcoming sequel, which promised a trip back to Hogwarts and lots of cool young Dumbledore and now, thanks to Comic Con, we have even more reason to be excited.

The trailer was part of Warner Bros' excellent Comic Con presentation (which also had the excellent Shazam! and Aquaman trailers) and it might well be the best of the bunch (which is saying a lot). The world-building is great, there's lots of new elements in there to get excited about and the look at Johnny Depp's Grindelwald goes some way to establishing that he is genuinely a threat to stand alongside Voldemort.

Yes, there will be controversy around his casting, but you really get the sense that Fantastic Beasts 2 would survive any sort of mooted boycott. It's what Harry Potter and Wizarding World fans continue to live for, and it's great to see Warner Bros appear to be delivering.

Here's the trailer:

It's not entirely unblemished, of course, so let's look first at the negatives...

Downs

2. The Shoe-Horned Romantic Tease

Fantastic Beasts Dumbledore Grindelwald
Warner Bros

Despite the firm confirmation from several sources involved in the film that we WON'T be getting any explicit exploration of Dumbledore and Grindelwald's romantic relationship, there is a slight allusion to it in the trailer thanks to the Mirror Of Erised sequence.

Unfortunately, it feels like it's been shoe-horned in retroactively (because of the reaction to the news that it wouldn't be in there, perhaps?). It also makes no sense in the context of the Mirror itself - the mirror is supposed to show the user's deepest desires, not just a projection of someone they like. What he sees should be he and Grindelwald fully rendered side by side, not a floating head and shoulders.

Anyway, it feels slightly disingenuous.


1. The Dumbledore Plot-Hole

Fantastic Beasts Dumbledore Newt
Warner Bros

For any Harry Potter fan who knows their lore - and that's a significant number given the interest in Pottermore and the wider texts (which Fantastic Beasts actually counts as too, of course) - the idea of Dumbledore ever being the Defence Against The Dark Arts teacher simply makes no sense.

It's the sort of thing we would absolutely have found out by now (especially considering the mythology around the role and its importance to Voldemort). And we already know which teachers were in the position when Dumbledore was teaching. So either this is a change to Hogwarts history or we're going to have to just accept that Rowling apparently chose to leave key information out of the existing Wizarding World texts and companion materials.

Now the positives...


Ups

6. It Feels MORE Like The Wizarding World

Fantastic Beasts Nicolas Flamel
Warner Bros

While the first Fantastic Beasts film was great and the world building and production design were brilliant (and well worthy of awards recognition), it still felt a little removed from the Harry Potter texts.

But now that we're heading back to Hogwarts and there's more pure magic on show (and less focus on magizoology), the sequel feels a lot closer to the original books and movies. It also helps that there's fan service in there, of course - even when it's slightly confusing (as with the appearance of Nicolas Flamel, which appears to serve very little actual purpose).

It definitely seems more like we're back in the home of Harry Potter, and that's definitely not a bad thing for selling the movie even more.


5. More Beasts

Fantastic Beasts Cat
Warner Bros.

When it was revealed that the second Fantastic Beasts movie was going to focus on the rise of Grindelwald, the decision to keep the FB title convention became immediately confusing. Fans were always going to struggle with the relevance of Newt Scamander's little zoo when the greatest ever Dark Wizard was straight-up murdering people and seeking to take over the world.

So it's good to see that there is an attempt to make Newt's importance to the plot to take down Grindelwald stand out in the trailer. Not only do we see Dumbledore telling him he has to count on him, but we also get to see new Fantastic Beasts. That at least delivers on the title, and it's always good to see Rowlings' imaginative beasts realised in "real life" on the big screen.

Let's hope they continue to be genuinely relevant to the plot...


4. The Effects

Fantastic Beasts Circus
Warner Bros.

As you'd probably expect with a movie this size - and with a budget so inflated - there's a lot of effects work in The Crimes Of Grindelwald, with David Yates clearly seeking to push the envelope on the magical front.

We're going to see more magical warfare, more of Credence's Obscurial powers, an array of magical oddities at the Arcanus circus and a new menagerie of beasts for Newt to catalogue - and potentially use against Grindelwald and his followers.

And from the trailer, all of the effects work looks great (and complete, thankfully), with no compromise on the immersive impact of the world because there's too much obvious CGI.


3. Grindelwald Is Truly Incredible

Fantastic Beasts Grindelwald
Warner Bros

There will inevitably always be complaints about Johnny Depp's casting as Grindelwald in the Fantastic Beasts movies because of his personal life and revelations about his relationship with Amber Heard, but it's hard to argue that the character isn't coming across very well in the marketing.

With the franchise already somewhat over-shadowed by the excellence of Ralph Fiennes' Voldemort, it needed a towering villain. Grindelwald arguably has to be more darkly charismatic than Voldemort; more terrifying; more appealing to followers and more deeply unnerving. And for all of his issues, Depp does deliver on all of those fronts.

He seems a lot more restrained than he has done more recently and he certainly looks the part - it seems we might have the right villain for the movie, even as there are suggestions we don't have the right actor.


2. The Emotional Heft

Fantastic Beasts Kowalski
Warner Bros.

While it would be a shock for any of the main characters to die in this movie (they might not be safe forever given Rowlings' penchant for killing off characters), it definitely looks like death could be a presence here.

There's definitely an ominous feel - particularly around Queenie and Jacob (who fits as a target since he's a Muggle and everything Grindelwald hates) - and you shouldn't get too close to some of the characters. At this stage, those two, some of Grindelwald's followers, Credence and Theseus Scamander are probably at the top of the list for possible deaths.

Whoever it ends up being, it seems inevitable that the Grim Reaper will have work to do, because Grindelwald needs some Crimes to commit and we need his mythology to be built upon before the next movies.


1. The Action Sequences (And The Escalation)

Fantastic Beasts Grindelwald Prison Break
Warner Bros.

After the RELATIVELY gentle action of the first Fantastic Beasts movie, this definitely feels like an escalation and there are some pretty big action sequences hinted at in the trailer that suggest the pace here is going to be significantly dialled up.

We're going to see Grindelwald's prison break and escape, a probable attack on the circus to retrieve Credence (though that might happen in the sequel), one underwater sequence, a monster attack, a fiery dragon attack and a climactic showdown between the Scamander brothers and Grindelwald (ominously for Theseus, unfortunately).

That's a lot to fit into around two hours, so it's probably right to think of this as more Deathly Hallows Part II than Part I. Which nobody should be able to complain about.

What do you think of this trailer? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.