Fantastic Beasts 2 Trailer Reactions: 8 Ups & 3 Downs
Dumbledore got HOT!
It's time to get extremely hyped for your return to the Wizarding World - now an official shared universe brand, thanks to the brand new logo introduced by Warner Bros - with the arrival of the new Fantastic Beasts 2 trailer. And it's a very good example of how to market to an established audience.
The trailer hits almost every beat that returning Harry Potter fans would want to see: there's familiarity, nostalgia and the return of beloved characters and ideas from the main-line series as well as the continuation of the Fantastic Beasts story, which was charming enough to bring in more than $800m. Adding a new Dumbledore to that mix is probably good enough for an assault on the billion dollar mark.
The production road hasn't been without its hitches - mostly to do with allegations against Johnny Depp and the film's presumed reluctance to explicitly explore the LGBT elements of the story - but this trailer will be enough to wash some of the concerns away. If you're already a fan of the Wizarding World, it's like being welcomed home again, and you just can't buy that sort of popularity.
Having said that, it's not a flawless trailer, and its good and bad elements warrant inspection in equal measure.
Firstly, the negatives...
Downs
3. APPARATING INTO HOGWARTS?!
Given that this is written by JK Rowling and will be scrutinised by every very knowledgable Harry Potter fan in the world, it's slightly weird to see something as potentially problematic as Ministry officials apparating into Hogwarts grounds in almost the first scene of the trailer.
We know that there is a restriction on Apparating within the grounds in Harry Potter, which was presumably brought in as a means to protect from threats. And while you could say that it was brought in later, why would the school not be hyper-vigilant about its defences with a Dark Wizard of Grindelwald's prowess active (and escaped from Ministry custody by the time they visit Hogwarts since Newt has already been sent to Paris)? Especially when Dumbledore is BOUND to be a target for the villain...
And while some might say it might be an exception for Ministry employees, that would be idiotic since Grindelwald literally infiltrated the Ministry in the last movie pretty easily (and has LOTS of followers all over). Allowing apparation into the school at all at this point is just careless.
At the very least, this needs to be explained very clearly in the movie.
2. The Fan-Baiting Makes It Too Easy For Cynics
For most fans of the Wizarding World, the opportunity to see Hogwarts again as the first image in the trailer should be cause for whooping and air-punching - and likewise the familiar theme music at the end of the trailer, but, objectively, you can see why there might be some cynicism aimed at the decision.
Anyone who wants to knock these films down will see that as a cynical cash-grab and an attempt to make this a Harry Potter film by another name. It's ridiculous logic (mostly because this IS a Harry Potter film by another name), but you can see it all over the Internet reactions already. There are accusations of Warner Bros' "reappropriating" key elements from Potter to make sure this film does huge financial numbers.
And though it's silly, maybe not starting with Hogwarts and actually focusing on the star of this series - Eddie Redmayne's Newt Scamander - might have attracted less cynicism.
1. The Kowalski & Credence Spoilers
There's a mostly commendable commitment to remaining as spoiler-free as possible while also teasing the story elements here (though really we all know the shape of this story thanks to the mainline Potter stories anyway), but it's a shame that two of the film's most valuable shocks have been so blatantly undermined. And also that two of the story elements from the end of the first movie have been undone as early as the first trailer for the sequel.
At the end of Fantastic Beasts, Jacob Kowalski has had his memory wiped and while there are hints some remain, it's done for his own safety. Sure, those remaining memory fragments and the romantic attachment to Queenie means he was always going to come back, but it should have been left to the actual film to reveal it. The trailer showing that he's just back to normal robs us of that small surprise.
And then there's the return of Credence, who was apparently disintegrated in the first movie when it was revealed he was an Obscurial to protect the magical community. A bit of the Obscurus escaped so, again, there was a big hint he was coming back, but the flippant reveal of him TWICE in the trailer (and the revelation that he's probably part of a magical circus) was just unnecessary. And it takes away some of the magic.
Now the positives...
Ups
8. Powering Up Newt
Looking at the story teases from this trailer purely objectively, there is a SLIGHT gap in logic around why Newt Scamander of all people would be chosen as the right person to take down Grindelwald. He is, after all, a bit bumbling, was kicked out of Hogwarts and almost caused a major magical disaster not so long ago.
You can, of course, see why Dumbledore would trust him - he's basically the prototype for his affection for Harry Potter decades later - but while Harry was protected by the love shield, the first film's Newt really doesn't seem up to the job.
But this trailer does a sterling job of addressing that concern directly by giving us the shot of Newt working with his brother Theseus to conjure the earthquake-like magic we see at one point. This isn't just a mere zoologist anymore - Newt is a magical badass now, and he's bamg up to the task of bringing Grindelwald down.
Well, he's not (because we know what happens), but still, it's good to see that he's been powered up to make it seem more believable.
7. The Sign Of The Deathly Hallows
With Grindelwald's story coming to the fore, the Fantastic Beasts franchise can now rely on one of the most easily marketable brands in the entire Wizarding World - the Deathly Hallows and though it's simple, the way the trailer uses them is really bloody good.
Not only are the Elder Wand and the Cloak Of Invisibility featured in the new title font (the Resurrection Stone is missing, presumably it's still in the possession of the Gaunt family and hidden), but we get a smokey emblem of the sign of the Hallows at the end of the trailer. And honestly, it's the perfect example of how to use symbols.
If this film doesn't inspire a whole new raft of Hallows tattoos, there's something wrong with the world.
6. Stupid Sexy Dumbledore
Though there was some consternation when he was cast to play young Dumbledore, Jude Law looks the part as the charismatic Transfiguration professor who is already an important enough figure for the Ministry Of Magic to be suspicious of him and his influence.
This Dumbledore is a sharp-suited, bedazzling charmer with the same twinkle in his eye that Richard Harris wore as part of his costume and a sort of casual cool that Law's casting was always going to guarantee. And while it's silly to reduce him to his looks, the reaction to his appearance seems to suggest that the future headmaster has a lot of "stans" online already.
So far, there's not many hints that he'll be drawing from either Harris or Michael Gambon's performances to influence his own (there is in fact a distinctly Law edge to his performance), but the immediate impact actually suggests that might not be all that necessary.
5. The Hinted Past
Naturally, when it was revealed that The Crimes Of Grindelwald wouldn't explicitly deal with the relationship between the villain and Dumbledore that JK Rowling retrospectively revealed after the publication of the Harry Potter books there was huge outrage. This was an opportunity for a progressive LGBT storyline in a mainstream movie that would be seen by lots of families - this was a major chance for normalisation and they seemed to be passing it up.
But as Rowling subsequently reiterated, this is a series and there's no need to reveal all cards in the first installment of a multi-film arc. And, rather cleverly, the trailer does hint of the history between the two men as a means of appeasement.
Though there are multiple reasons why Dumbledore is unable to intervene with Grindelwald (politics and his own guilt at helping foster his dangerous ideas, primarily), there's also the suggestion that their closeness would make it difficult. And even implicitly hinting at that is a good move to suggest that the films WILL explore their relationship in some form.
4. The Production Design
Though it will have fierce competition from Black Panther (and hopefully Han Solo), if The Crimes Of Grindelwald isn't up for consideration when it comes to deciding next year's Production Design Oscar winner, it will be a travesty.
Following on from the gorgeous first film, the sequel's portraits of Paris, London and, of course, Hogwarts already look absolutely stunning. The shot of the Parisien Department Of Fantastic Beasts (to assume its name somewhat) in particular is glorious, with an incredible amount of detail in the domed ceiling's artwork.
And the magical circus that we see glimpses of looks just as incredible. This was what all Harry Potter fans wanted from the moment we were told we'd be getting to see more of the Wizarding World and it's wonderful to see that they aren't going to fail us.
3. Very Little Johnny Depp (And he Looks Better)
No matter how secretly enthusiastic you might be to see Johnny Depp play Grindelwald properly (especially after his brilliant turn in Murder On The Orient Express), Warner Bros have faced something of a backlash for casting him after his well-publicised personal life controversies. It has quickly got to the point where fans have called for him to be replaced, though that's clearly not happening.
In that respect, it's been a smart decision to limit how much he's in this first trailer, even with his name above the door. Pushing him too hard would have been fuel to the fire and that's the last thing they want.
And mercifully, Depp actually looks a lot better this time out as the villain than he did last time. He looked a little ridiculous as the Peaker Blinders style wizard in the first movie and this more shaggy look is a lot more Wizarding World appropriate.
2. Hedwig's Theme
All those accusations of fan-baiting aside, there is no magic in the cinematic world quite like hearing the fanfare from Hedwig's Theme that greets the end of the trailer. It ranks up there with the Star Wars opening bars and the James Bond fanfare in terms of conjuring up the magic of the brand instantly.
And though it might have been nice for Fantastic Beasts to have its own theme, this Wizarding World adopting Hedwig's Theme as its official music is not a bad thing by any means. Just try and resist the hairs all over your body standing on end when it plays at the end of that trailer.
1. Actual Fantastic Beasts
When it was announced that the second Fantastic Beasts movie was going to be focused on the rise of Grindelwald, you could have been forgiven for wondering how much room there was actually going to be of fantastic beasts to be involved. It even looked a little unlikely that Newt Scamander could be as much of a key figure, given that Grindelwald's story was very much Dumbledore's starring vehicle.
So it's good to see that the trailer has gone out of its way to show off the beasts - including a new underwater variety and a group of Thestrals powering a Hogwarts coach (presumably someone involved there has been touched by death). There's also a bowtruckle, some sort of bird and other creatures to keep all magizoologists' interests peaked.
It's a tiny shame that Niffler didn't get a chance to appear, but it's smart not to overdo it. Nobody wants a Porgs situation again.
What did you think of the Crimes Of Grindelwald trailer? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.