Fantastic Beasts: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best
From No-Majs to MACUSAs and monsters...
Warner Bros and JK Rowling were always facing a difficult task when it was clear they'd have to introduce a whole new cast of characters for Fantastic Beasts. They'd inevitably face questions of which veteran characters could appear (and seriously, kudos for not going for cheap cameos), and the unspoken rule of legacy films also means all fans would inevitably compare them to the Potter cast.
To do so is reductive and not to be encouraged, but remarkably, Newt Scamander and his American friends (and foes) actually do mostly stack up against the better Harry Potter characters. They're not quite in a position to have earned the same kind of iconic appeal, but there are stand-outs in the packed cast who could well go down as some of the most memorable and most loved characters in the entire Wizarding World franchise.
But which one comes out on top of this new pile?
Here's how all of the major characters in Fantastic Beasts rank in terms of awesomeness (including some of the cuddlier, scalier and hornier variety)...
19. Henry Shaw
Unfortunately, it very much feels like the Shaws were added to Fantastic Beasts to reflect a growing awareness (or suspicion) in the No--Maj community around magical characters and the "threat" they represent.
As such, Henry Shaw - a surface-level pantomime villain who is introduced only so he can call the Second Salemers freaks and to help feed the deception that Modesty is the real Obscurial - is no more than a narrative device. His death is used for effect, and while it's a cool little sequence, he's so undeveloped that it's almost impossible to feel anything but mild amusement that he's killed.
It works as misdirection though, which says nothing about the quality of the character.
18. Shaw Snr
As qualified already, the Shaw clan are clearly designed to be the family closest to pulling down the veil of the magical world. Sadly, it's such an undernourished plot that it feels entirely superfluous, and Shaw Sr in particular feels like a total passenger. Sure, he watches his son die and then witnesses the climax, but none of that information is ever used.
Unfortunately, the end of the film is pretty clear in saying that the rising friction between No-Majs and wizards is done thanks to the Obliviate mass spell, so the build-up of Shaw potentially becoming a leader of a group of Aware No-Majs is entirely undone.
It all makes you wonder why the hell someone as big as Jon Voight was ever cast.
17. Langdon Shaw
Again, he's problematically saddled with a poor narrative arc, but Langdon Shaw gets a little more of a chance to shine than his other family members.
You can almost see that there was an idea to have his father's newspaper empire eventually be the mouthpiece for an anti-wizarding movement (and maybe that can still happen), but the idea is almost immediately dropped after he tries to lead an awareness campaign in the fact of his father and brother's ignorance.
His American accent is a little ropey too, which is a shame as actor Ronan Raftery (who is Irish) is brilliant in the hilarious Moone Boy.
16. Seraphina Picquery
There's a strange epidemic in Harry Potter universe movies that dictates that Minister of Magic types have to be slightly bumbling and completely unlikeable. Cornelius Fudge was the most charming example, Rufus Scrimgeour had promise but tanked quickly and now Seraphina Picquery is just boring.
She's vaguely morally grey - ordering the execution of a child and having a literal execution chamber in the Magical Congress - but she's not actually interesting because she's only involved pretty vaguely too. Probably because Graves is the Congress' man, he represents the authoritative picture, and it might be reasonable to assume that Picquery will become involved more in sequels.
Hopefully they'll add some more texture to her too.
15. Modesty Barebone
The brilliantly named Modesty Barebone does everything she's asked for in the film, but she's rathe saddled by the fact that she's not supposed to be considered a fully fleshed-out character. That much is necessary because the whole point of the film's big twist is that we're supposed to initially believe that she is the Obscurial, and adding any detail to her other than making her a little bit detached and creepy would ruin the effect.
But the youngster does sell the misdirection well: her fury at Henry Shaw before he dies works well and her reaction when Mary Lou punishes Credence one too many times does too.
Ultimately, she's another narrative device, so it's impossible to really get attached to her, but she definitely wouldn't feel out of place in a horror film.
14. Frank The Thunderbird
The first main Fantastic Beast who actually affects the plot - in a fairly convoluted, frankly weird way in the end - Frank is the least charismatic of the big creatures. He's a regal sort of figure, aesthetically based on Fawkes the Phoenix from the Harry Potter books, and the idea of him is pretty cool (based on the North American mythological symbol), but he doesn't get much chance to shine.
When he does burst out into the plot (after an initial appearance that shows off his powers a little), he's hamstrung slightly by the fact that his method of obliviation is just plain stupid. Are we not supposed to believe that there will be some humans who aren't either in the rain or drinking water or showering at that exact moment? That's a fairly big plot hole, but you can't really hold it against Frank.
And he's an impressive looking beast all the same. Just hasn't got a personality like the others.
13. Mary Lou Barebone
For what we see of Mary Lou Barebone, she's an effective character: she's the typical militant pious figure, quick to violent punishment, all too hard on children and generally a bit of a one-dimensional sub-villain cliche.
She's enjoyable enough to watch, but it would have been perhaps better to discover she had links to the the historical Scourers that JK Rowling introduced in the run up to release. That would have given her more complexity, though it perhaps wasn't needed.
In another world, Barebone would have been the villain of a straight origin story for Credence Barebone but this isn't really his story, and it's certainly not hers, so it's simple enough to forgive the lack of depth.
12. Grindelwald
To complain that Johnny Depp is playing the major villain in a franchise this big is beyond ludicrous. He might make back decisions sometimes these days, but he's still a good actor and without the creative influence of Tim Burton we might actually get a good performance out of him.
Equally, it's hard to really call this a good performance, because he's not in it very much. His brief appearances that bookend the plot are good for mythology building and he looks interesting enough, but when you consider how needlessly complex his plot is and the fact that he is overwhelmed by a wizrd expelled from Hogwarts DESPITE HAVING THE ELDER WAND, he loses considerable credibility.
Yes, I want to see more of him, and that's pretty much what his appearance needed to establish.
11. Swooping Evil
Swooping Evil is basically Newt Scamander's Swiss Army Knife, protecting him in open battle, representing a sort of danger yo-yo when needed (because of course no magical police would remove dangerous creatures from the person of a criminal known to be carrying dangerous creatures), and providing a ready made McGuffin.
The creature doesn't have any real personality, it's not cute in any tangible sort of way, but it's a resilient, useful little figure and it does look the part. That name is a little iffy though - particularly as Newt gives all the rest of his creatures nice sanitising names.
10. Gnarlack
If you didn't know Ron Perlman was playing the American goblin gangster Gnarlack before the film's release, you needed only look at his face for confirmation. The facial capture work has done wonders to recapture his immediately recognisable face.
Gnarlack could well have been a much more interesting character, but he's limited to a few minutes of screen-time in a short sequence that accelerates his arc from mysterious to turncoat in a matter of moments. And it's not like you don't see it coming: he's not exactly presented as a particularly trustworthy element.
It's nice to see that America has such murky figures on its magical underbelly too, and that the goblins who run the banks have inverted versions who put the same skills to work for more nefarious reasons.
9. The Erumpent
It might not look as it "should" after the appearance of the Erumpent horn in The Deathly Hallows (in Xenophilius Lovegood's house), but the big gelatinous rhino slug is the star of one of the film's most memorable moments. That tends to be the effect when you see a gigantic creature attempting to have sex with a comedy sidekick after being fluffed by Eddie Redmayne doing a sex dance.
The creature isn't on screen for a long time, but it's basically a personification of that old favourite joke when the girl cat accidentally gets striped in white paint and the skunk falls in love. Who could ever get sick of that?
And as gags go, the decision to literally have the Erumpent's sexual aggression (its horn) be volatile given what we know of it is pretty damn funny.
8. Credence Barebone
Like his sister, Credence Barebone is a consciously guarded character, not really his extra dimensions until the very end of the film after his big secret is revealed. He's sort of the anti-Tom Riddle, who has suppressed his powers purposefully only to see them explode out, and in retrospect, Ezra Miller's twitching, pained performance makes a lot more sense when you realise he's basically trying to suppress his puberty.
He's very much like a Carrie sort of figure, taught to believe that his natural urges - in this case to magic - are dirty and evil and deserve serious physical punishment. And of course he'd be socially broken as a result, which is why the performance isn't the most verbal or showy.
And Miller definitely has good chemistry acting alongside more powerful characters.
7. Picket
Who would have thought that a glorified stick insect would rank so highly?
Picket is a Bowtruckle (what Hagrid told Harry he was "no bigger than" when he dropped him at Privet Drive, which is clearly inaccurate), with attachment and abandonment issues, a cute little personlity and instant selling appeal.
He's a useful figure - helping Scamander escape the execution chamber (though we only find out the creatures are famed for picking locks AFTER the escape weirdly), and then going in a delightful little huff when Newt pretends to agree to swap him for information from Gnarlack. If there are many toys released in the wake of any Fantastic Beasts films, expect him to rank highly on the sales charts.
6. Percival Graves
As villains go, Percival Graves is one of the more under-stated and complex in the Harry Potter franchise as a whole. His intentions are never entirely clear (he appears at first simply to be a misguided cog in the Congress machine), but as he develops he gains significantly more interest. He's darkly charismatic, venomous when necessary and a similar sort of figure to Dolores Umbridge, without the pink.
The problem with Graves is that he's rather badly undone by the twist ending that reveals he's actually Grindelwald. Perhaps it's because Colin Farrell does so well with the character, but the revelation feels almost like it's been tagged on for an added punch (which isn't necessary).
Narratively, it would have been better for Graves to just be one of Grindelwald's fanatics (mentioned early in the film but entirely invisible beyond that), and the twist does take away some of the lustre of the performance.
5. Tina Goldstein
The central four characters in Fantastic Beasts are probably the most interesting human characters by some distance, and it's almost a shame that their story and the focus on the plot around the creatures isn't pushed more in this first film.
Of the four, Tina is definitely the least interesting (though that's not a bad reflection of her at all): she has a good heart and wants to be a good Auror, but it might have perhaps been better if both of those things were developed a little more.
Because of the way the plot is weighted we don't get to see much more than flashes of that, but she builds enough good will that when she's threatened with execution you do genuinely feel the threat.
4. Queenie Goldstein
Slightly edging out her sister, legilimens Queenie scores more points because she's given more of a developmental arc. She's also aided by the fact that she's genuinely funny, using her powers not only to reflect out other character's emotions (which is a very handy tool for directors to call on).
But it's her relationship with Kowalski that really elevates her - her wide-eyed, flirty exoticness is genuinely irresistible when seen through his eyes, and the way she is disarmed by his scruffy charm is enchanting.
It's a shame that some will say she's just another female character relegated to a romantic element, but nobody should be complaining when the romance is that compelling. And in truth she has a lot more to her bow than just being an object of his affection: she's resourceful, dependable and a very charming figure.
3. Niffler
Like Picket, Niffler will be one of the most hotly sought toys that come out of this film (particularly as he's available as a Funko Pop Vinyl and is gorgeous) and it's for good reason.
The little shiny-thing-stealing rascal is a wonderful addition to the film - nonchalant, almost provocatively annoying and deeply charming. He's already better than all of the Harry Potter magical creatures (including Buckbeak), and he's not even on screen all that much.
Obviously, Warner Bros now have a struggle on their hands to make sure they catch the right balance to take advantage of the inevitable Niffler love-in. Because nobody wants Minion fever all over again.
2. Newt Scamander
If you're not a fan of Eddie Redmayne (fie on you), then you're probably not going to be a fan of Newt Scamander, but the new lead of JK Rowlings' franchise will be adored by some fans for exactly that reason.
He wonderfully captures the blend of self-effacing charisma and roguishness that Redmayne brought to his performance in The Theory Of Everything, and he's definitely like the walking embodiment of all three of the Golden Trio of leads from the Potter films.
He also has that tangible, bumbling charm of Hollywood's ideal vision of Englishness too (see also High Grant and Colin Firth), which cuts through the more swaggering Americana and gives Rowling and Yates something to hang the old Potter spirit on.
Hopefully the promise of him being involved all the way through the franchise prove to be true.
1. Kowalski
It was always an oversight in the Harry Potter books and films that the magical community's relatonship with the Muggle world was underplayed so much. It was hinted at here and there, but it would have been nice to see some sort of cross-pollination (not least because there was always the question of magical characters having Muggle friends at home).
In Fantastic Beasts that itch is well and truly scratched with the lovingly crafted, never victimising portrayal of "everyman" figure Kowalski. He's basically this franchise's version of Boo from Monsters Inc - unwittingly thrust into a world not his and the focus of panic as a result.
And rather ingeniously, he's also the personification of an old desire among all Wizarding World fans - he's not only our way into the plot, he also offers a sympathetic vision of our fears that we'll never be magical realised. That's exactly why the tragedy of him having to return to his old life is so pronounced, and why the return of Queenie and his knowing smile at the end are so beautifully poignant.
Let's just hope they find a way to bring him back.
How would you rank the major characters in Fantastic Beasts? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.